Madam Chair, thank you for allowing me to open the discussion on the importance of considering the chief science adviser's scientific recommendations. You mentioned that it's important to consider the possibility of her appearing before the committee this Thursday. I would therefore like to remind you of the important points she raised with us in November. According to what she told us, the government is currently not acting appropriately and isn't taking her scientific expertise into account when it comes to major projects of national interest. I remember her saying that the situation was a nightmare. Those were her words. So I would still like to continue my important presentation on the consequences of not having access to data when we want to be able to establish the best possible public policies.
As I mentioned, an economics researcher who is part of the U15 group and is based in Quebec said that faculty members at major universities tend to have a bit more influence. Let me remind you, for example, that the University of British Columbia competes every year for the best new doctoral students on the job market. When they recruit one, the candidate is excellent from the start. The projects coming from there and the calibre of the candidates are quite high. Obviously, when you have a better chance of securing financial support, you're able to develop better and have the necessary tools.
Compared to history and economics, certain disciplines such as sociology and political science place a more balanced emphasis on CVs and research proposals in their evaluations. The nature of their evaluations also differs when assessing CVs. Many sociologists and political scientists adopt a more diverse view of publications, emphasizing that journal articles or academic works aren't the only valuable outputs. Public outreach publications, such as reports intended for government or community groups, are considered relevant. They also emphasize elements deemed less important by historians and economists, such as supervision of students.
One of them says that, for established colleagues, they pay a lot of attention to their efforts to mentor and supervise students. If someone has had a career as a nurse and has only supervised two people, you could say that they lack experience, that it's not enough, especially since the division of workload and supervision in the departments can be a problem. So he thinks there is a challenge in this area. It is possible to be extremely productive if there is no supervision. It was a Quebec-based sociologist at a university that is not part of the U15 group who said that.
Researchers say that this can be a decisive factor for candidates from smaller universities that don't offer master's or doctoral programs. Although sociologists and political scientists generally reject the hierarchical views of scientific excellence promoted by economists, they do take into account how university affiliation may influence the ability to recruit and train students, and consequently, the feasibility of a project. While respondents in both disciplines generally express some tolerance for alternative training plans, such as involving undergraduate rather than graduate students, it is considered the candidate's responsibility to explain how their working conditions won't hinder the completion of the project. In the absence of clear and convincing justifications, candidates from smaller universities may receive lower scores.
An Ontario-based political scientist who works for a university that isn't part of the U15 even says that this can be detrimental to candidates from smaller universities, because it's not always straightforward. For example, if they say they plan to hire a research assistant but are at a university that doesn't have master's or doctoral students, that can work against their application. He thinks this is simply the reality of being at a smaller university in general.
That's sad to hear, isn't it? Researchers say that's just the way things are for them, that they are at a small university, and that they recognize that the system is more powerful than they are.
Researchers note that university affiliations are also important in determining the type of support that proposals can get before they are even reviewed by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council committees. As a result, even in disciplines such as sociology, where there seems to be a broad consensus that institutional prestige doesn't influence outcomes, reviewers sometimes give more weight to candidates who have secured resources within their university, as this demonstrates the feasibility of their proposal.
According to a sociologist at a non-U15 university in British Columbia, it is quite clear that the university's ranking and reputation can be used to judge the value of a candidate. He can't say for sure if there's an implicit bias on that, but he says it really helps when universities put money on the table to support applications. According to him, when you receive an application and all the support is in kind, such as available rooms and printing services, I think that can hinder a candidacy compared to a university that provides four graduate scholarships of $15,000 each to graduate students to support the project.
That's sad to hear, isn't it? It's the researchers themselves who recognize that they're not on a level playing field with other universities and that the government isn't doing anything in that regard to help them.
In this example, we see that the impact of academic inequalities on funding success manifests itself in various ways in the work of Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council committees. Sometimes, affiliation to a prestigious institution is used as a mere indicator of quality and status, particularly in disciplines such as economics, where rankings are clear and reproduced. At other times, it plays a role in assessing the feasibility of projects. As a result, the ability of professors to obtain financial support within their university may be the decisive factor between a successful application and one that is rejected.
Again, awareness and acceptance of the role of academic affiliation varies across disciplines, with these dynamics more or less aligned with the cultural frameworks and categories specific to each discipline. This is consistent with quantitative observations that the prestige and size of universities matter more in some disciplines than in others. Nevertheless, despite these variations, many committee members interviewed cited situations where affiliation to a prestigious institution was a net benefit in funding competitions.
I'm getting to the conclusion.
This study shows a close link between university hierarchies and the success of grant applications in the humanities and social sciences. Data from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council indicates that applications from researchers affiliated with U3 universities—McGill University, the University of British Columbia and the University of Toronto—accounted for 19.2% of all submissions, but 24.6% of funded projects.
To recap, there's an imbalance here, and it's noted in the observations of the findings of this important study.
On the other hand, applications from candidates outside the U15 constitute 46.4%, of the submissions, but only 39.3%, of the grants awarded. The logistical regression shows that the effect of academic hierarchies persists, even in the face of other factors. In fact, the prestige of the university is, after previous funding, the most influential factor.
Compared to professors affiliated with universities affiliated with U3, McGill University, the University of Toronto and the University of British Columbia, this predicted probability is 43.60%. Candidates from U12 universities have a lower probability of success than 37.7%, while those from non-U15 universities face an even greater disadvantage of 32.7%.
When they do secure funding, candidates from less prestigious institutions also receive less money than their colleagues from top-tier universities. Under the insight grants program, candidates affiliated with U3 universities receive an average of $67,286, nearly $20,000 more than the average funding received by their colleagues at non-U15 institutions, which is $48,488. For candidates at U12 institutions, which exclude the three largest universities, the figure is $55,817. These patterns contribute to the process of cumulative advantage or disadvantage in the sciences.
The initial argument put forward was that grant reviewers used university affiliation as a judgment tool to mitigate the uncertainty inherent in evaluating applications. However, the correlation between academic prestige and outcomes is not as strong across all disciplines. While in economics and management, candidates from outside the U15 are respectively about half as likely and one-third as likely to secure funding, no statistically significant advantage is observed in anthropology or geography. That's quite interesting. Anthropology and geography are important disciplines, and they aren't affected by these issues.
Also in the study's conclusion, the researchers note that interviews with members of evaluation committees helped them understand these intertwined mechanisms. As demonstrated, the varying weight given to university affiliation across disciplines reflects a tension in evaluation practices: while disciplines such as economics focus more on CVs, others such as history prioritize the research proposal. Other disciplines, including sociology and political science, fall somewhere between these two extremes.
When evaluating CVs, sociologists and political scientists also take a broader view of scientific contributions, valuing not only journal articles and books, but also popular science publications and activities such as government reports and community engagement. They also prioritize elements, such as supervising students, that are less highly valued by historians and economists. That's interesting.
Although the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council issues formal, standardized evaluation criteria, the rules established by the agency, that is, the government, are then interpreted and applied differently by the committees, which operate as decentralized and semi-autonomous entities. This is a serious matter. You understand that this means that people could have biases, and this is confirmed here by independent researchers, funded by the government, once again, and accredited by ethics committees. I therefore believe there is cause to explore this topic further.
It is crucial to distinguish between the general standards adopted by funding agencies and the situated standards that reviewers rely on to evaluate and rank applications. This underscores the importance of a discipline-based approach to science that, above all, acknowledges the normative dimension of evaluation. By highlighting the fact that review practices are inherently localized and limited, the findings underscore the need to take disciplinary cultures into account, both in research and in efforts to reform scientific institutions. This is interesting, since that is precisely our role here: the reform of scientific institutions.
The findings also highlight the importance of the evaluation context in perpetuating social inequalities in science. Given the competitive nature of funding applications, evaluators must find a way to assess proposals fairly and make them comparable so that they can be ranked by relative merit. Relying on generic criteria, such as academic prestige or publications in reputable journals, allows committees to rank candidates while reducing uncertainty. It's important to note that these signals of value are largely qualitative in nature and don't need to rely on controversial bibliometrics. As such, it is doubtful that a shift to narrative-style CVs would significantly mitigate this phenomenon.
I'm going to repeat this passage, Madam Chair, so that it's clearly understood, because there are people who have come here—even members of the government—and told us that narrative CVs would solve everything. We have a group of researchers here telling us the opposite: they think it's doubtful that a shift to narrative‑style CVs would significantly mitigate this phenomenon, which we've been talking about since the beginning of this meeting, namely, the hierarchy of universities and the related funding.
Given the potentially negative consequences and the diminishing marginal returns associated with the concentration of funding, it's important to understand the processes at play. While symbolic capital alone can influence outcomes, it is likely that the concentration of funding within a small group of universities is not the result of evaluation practices within committees. This adds an important nuance to the discussion.
University affiliations provide access to various forms of capital that shape candidates' prospects: symbolic capital linked to academic prestige, economic capital linked to internal funding and material support, and social capital linked to privileged access to networks of experts and disciplinary knowledge. Since disciplinary evaluation rules are partly informal and unwritten, access to insider knowledge is essential for crafting an application that meets the committee's expectations. Several members of committees from less prestigious institutions reported that they shared the knowledge gained from their experience on the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council with their colleagues, with the aim of improving their chances of securing grants.
So you can see the pattern: researchers who have gone through the system, which is imperfect and unequal, tell other researchers not to do the same thing as they did because they could be penalized.
The patterns observed could also be a direct result of the structure of the Canadian academic market. That's really interesting. Some interviewees suggested that researchers with the most valued characteristics were concentrated in the largest and most prestigious universities, and that unequal chances of success were therefore already built into the system by the time applications were reviewed. This is important. There is an unequal structure in place, and another one is being added in terms of access to research funding.
Furthermore, disparate working conditions from one university to another, particularly with regard to teaching load, administrative workload, research support and internal funding, could widen the gap even further. However, this explanation is not entirely convincing. The concentration of high-performing researchers in a small group of universities cannot be separated from the fact that prestigious affiliations can increase scientific productivity and rewards for researchers throughout their careers.
Assuming that scholars who are in the U3 have more merit, as the representatives of some disciplines do, is in effect a self-fulfilling prophecy. This is particularly clear in disciplines where university hierarchies are closely linked to valued publication patterns, which in turn serve as a key criterion for allocating funding. For instance, if review committees in economics placed less emphasis on CVs, specifically on past publications in a restricted list of English-speaking journals—the “tyranny of the top five”—applicants from less prestigious institutions would likely exhibit higher success rates. This is exactly what we observe in history, where the importance given to research projects during SSHRC evaluations mitigates the correlation between university prestige and success rates. Not that historians do not gauge applicants' CVs as well. Scholars who have published one or multiple monographs, depending on their career stage, are clearly valued by the committees. Yet, because historians do not abide by a clear ranking of publications and publishing houses, diverse research profiles can be valued and regarded as equally respectable. These disciplinary contrasts show that the greater success of researchers from the most prestigious universities does not reflect inherently greater merit, but rather the way merit is defined and assessed within the scientific field—a social construct that varies across disciplines and depends on the alignment between institutional positions, publication patterns, and the prevailing scientific hierarchies within each discipline.
This important study was carried out by Professor Julien Larregue and Professor Alice Pavie in 2025 with Government of Canada funding through the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council. The title is “Prestige at Play: University Hierarchies and the Reproduction of Funding Inequalities”, and it appeared in the Canadian Review of Sociology.
I also want to discuss another important response we received from the government during our study on the distribution of research funding. That response highlighted the inequities in the federal research funding system.
Madam Chair, in a letter addressed to you, the government responded to a study we did on the distribution of federal funding among Canada's post-secondary institutions. That study was presented to the House of Commons on September 15, 2025.
With regard to the first recommendation regarding the modernization of the federal research support system, which we've been talking about since the beginning of the study, the government says the following:
The Government agrees in principle with the Committee’s recommendation to implement the recommendations of the report from the Advisory Panel on the Federal Research Support System, and ensure that the composition of the future advisory council on science and industry is representative of the entire research ecosystem.
This report, which we commonly refer to as the Bouchard report, was published in 2023, which was three years ago. The letter goes on to say:
The Government recognizes that an effective research support system is critical to Canada’s prosperity. We know that science is increasingly key to addressing the complex challenges facing Canada and the world.
That's interesting because, in the last budget, the federal government reduced its investments. This is the first inconsistency I'd like to point out. When we say that something is increasingly key, we don't usually reduce the support we provide. The letter goes on to say:
As emerging technologies transform societies and economies, Canada must seize the moment. Our future success depends on our ability to mobilize science and research across disciplines and sectors to develop transformative solutions to pressing challenges, nurture talent, plug into global science networks, and effectively commercialize homegrown ideas.
It's good to commercialize homegrown ideas, but, in the last federal budget, the government cut funding for the granting agencies by 2% and invested $1.7 billion to attract foreign researchers. We can't commercialize homegrown ideas because we're not adequately supporting the scientific researchers who are already here, on Canadian soil. The letter goes on to say:
The Advisory Panel on the Federal Research Support System (the Advisory Panel) was launched in October 2022 to provide independent expert advice to the Government to modernize the system. The Panel’s report, released in March 2023, provided 21 recommendations to enhance research excellence while enabling greater agility, flexibility, and responsiveness to support transformative research and innovation. This included structural change to enhance strategic coordination and agility; strategic direction and advice to orient the system in a common direction; modernized, streamlined programming to enhance effectiveness and reduce the burden on researchers; a new paradigm to support Canada’s major research facilities (MRFs); and, re-investment in research and talent to bolster success.
However, I can tell you that that is not what the government did. Consider this: The government commissioned people to do an analysis, but it's not following the recommendations of that analysis. This is the second inconsistency. I'll continue:
Budget 2024 announced the government’s intent to create a new capstone research funding organization….
That was a recommendation in the Bouchard report, which came out three years ago, but there's still nothing on the horizon. The third inconsistency is that the government says it's doing things, but doesn't actually do things. There are several measures that the government says it has taken, but that it has not actually taken. I'll continue to read the government's response to the study on the distribution of federal funding among Canada's post-secondary institutions:
The federal granting agencies led engagement with the research community in summer 2024 to seek feedback on the proposed capstone organization, which was synthesized in a “What We Heard” report, released in October 2024.
I don't know what the government heard, but it must not have heard much, because it hasn't implemented the recommendations in that report. I'll continue:
The Government’s commitment to work to implement the capstone research funding organization was reaffirmed in Budget 2025.
It's hard not to laugh at the government's ad hockery. Let's recap. In 2023, a report was published. In 2024, the government said it would implement the report's recommendations. In 2025, it said it was still thinking about implementing the recommendations. For three years now, the government has been thinking about setting up an organization it said it might set up. We know what the government members are saying: They want to be world leaders in science. However, it has taken then more than three years to decide whether or not to create a new capstone organization that was talked about in a report they themselves requested. That's truly unbelievable. I'm trying not to laugh. I'm laughing, but not because it's funny. I'm sure folks will understand, because we witness ad hockery here every day. I'll continue reading the government's response:
Significant investments have also been made to [deliver] on the Advisory Panel’s recommendations to boost the budgets of the granting agencies and increase levels of support for talent.
This is another thing I'd like the government people to explain to me. In the last budget, budget 2025, the government announced a 2% reduction in funding for the granting agencies, yet it seems awfully proud of its plan to invest $1.7 billion to attract 1,000 new researchers. I look forward to seeing the results, but I have my doubts. When those researchers see the quality of our infrastructure, I'm guessing they'll take pictures to share with their friends and have a few laughs. I don't want that to happen. However, there's no guarantee these researchers will come or be persuaded to stay. The government seems to be saying that applications are being accepted until the end of March and that researchers need only publish and they'll have an opportunity to come to Canada.
I'll continue reading the government's response, in which it announced an investment of “$1 billion over 13 years to the federal granting agencies to launch an accelerated research Chairs initiative to recruit exceptional international researchers to Canadian universities”.
I think it would still be useful to continue this study and analyze the possibility of having access to the essential data.
In response to our study, the government did an inventory of its somewhat scattered investments, but it says, “Budget 2025 also noted that the government will examine whether Canada’s research ecosystem requires further support to retain talent.”
This committee did a study and found that scholarships had not been indexed at all in 20 years. The government thinks it has the right conditions to retain this talent because it indexed graduate scholarships for the first time in 20 years. According to the data we have, some 40% of postdoctoral students are thinking of going to other countries because conditions here aren't favourable. I think it's worth reconsidering what the government says in this response, or speeding things up, because what it's saying conflicts with what it's doing. I'll go on:
Addressing the Advisory Panel’s recommendation to simplify the suite of talent-focused programs, the Canada Research Training Awards Suite (CRTAS) was launched in March 2025.
That's interesting, because there was an election in March. I'll go on:
The CRTAS consolidates eleven scholarship and fellowship programs across the three granting agencies into a single streamlined program suite, streamlining the way Canada supports the next generation of research talent and making it easier for students and fellows to access support.
This still doesn't make sense. The government says that students don't need more money or more financial support. They don't need to go abroad to do more research. The government says it's going to streamline things and simplify administrative standards. Apparently it wants to do more with less. If someone from the government can explain to me how that's possible, I'll gladly accept the explanation, but I haven't heard an explanation yet.
There are more responses to the other recommendations, including the one on support for research at smaller institutions, colleges, polytechnics and CEGEPs. I will read from the government's response again:
Three of the Committee’s recommendations focus on enhancing support provided to smaller institutions, colleges, polytechnics, and CEGEPs. This includes college centres for the transfer of technology (CCTTs, known in Quebec as centres collégiaux de transfert de technologie) and Technology Access Centres (TACs), which are organizations affiliated with colleges and CEGEPs that provide applied research and innovation services to local organizations and businesses, particularly small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs).
Madam Chair—
