In a sense, you've answered your own question. I mean, we are paying tax dollars to fund the public till. We're doing that because we have entrusted the government to look after the public good. If, for instance, we're devoting $40 billion to biomedical research and it's not producing improvements across the board, then what are we doing with that funding?
Now, that said, one has to be extremely careful in how one calculates the benefits of scientific research, partly because of questions of time—research results are not immediate—but also partly because the focus may be erroneous. In the U.S. there has been an ongoing debate about whether we're funding researchers or research. That is, are we actually funding frontier knowledge that will be distributed across the board? Are we even funding the right sorts of things? If we have an overemphasis on silver bullet science, we are not investing in palliative care, but it may be that in the health care system, palliative care is the more important set of goals.
The solution to that is that the public has to have a role, because they often see things that the scientists themselves are too targeted and too tunnel-visioned to see.
