This is a very difficult question. Normally, if you go to a surgeon and you want surgery done, you come away with the problem cured or not. In federal science policy and in regulatory science policy, the results are seldom that quick to emerge.
I think one has to have a multipronged criterion. Emergency response cannot be held to the same standards as whether or not cancer research policy delivers the goods. This morning we've already talked about different kinds of criteria, and there was a question raised: Is research getting from bench to bedside? It is one kind of indicator, but it would not be the right kind of indicator for measuring whether emergency responses are working or whether climate change policies are working. I think one has to settle for a somewhat sector-specific approach to accountability issues. These are continually being revisited.
This is a point that I would make: It's not that in a thriving democracy like Canada the research policies have been sitting still, with no attention to these matters. One should pay attention to the historicity of these processes and what is being learned along the way.
