Thank you, Madam Chair.
Good afternoon, members of the committee.
I'm Karine Morin, president and chief executive officer of the Federation for the Humanities and Social Sciences.
The federation promotes scholarship and leadership in the humanities and social sciences through advocacy, capacity building and knowledge exchange. Our membership spans 76 post-secondary institutions and 66 scholarly associations, representing a diverse community of 90,000 researchers and graduate students in Canada.
I'm pleased to appear before the committee to contribute to its work on the capstone organization and research excellence.
Today I wish to once again share my observations regarding our disciplines, as well as my previous experience within the granting agencies.
To begin, I want to note that for intramural and extramural research and innovation to be well governed and accountable, the science policy ecosystem must be guided by fundamental principles. In Canada, these principles are well established and are a core strength of our system.
Research is conducted ethically and with integrity. I note that the relevant tri-council policies uphold international best practices and undergo periodic reviews.
Assessment of research proposals should be carried out fairly and by experts and it is. Our peer reviewers act neutrally and they disclose their conflicts of interest. They are trained to avoid unconscious biases, and, again, these are the practices that are put forward by the research councils.
Furthermore, our agencies are at the forefront of assessing questions, such as whether the pool of applicants is representative of the population and whether certain groups perform better than others within given applicant pools.
For example, the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council, SSHRC, produces detailed and publicly available dashboards, because the federal government made it a policy.
Assessment of funding programs should be transparent, accountable to government and the public, and it is. Research councils' funding programs undergo rigorous public evaluations that assess relevance, efficiency in delivery and fulfillment of objectives. I would cite, as an example, a very comprehensive 2024 review of support for research training and talent development.
Let me turn to opportunities for improvements, which we must seize as we mobilize research and expand our understanding of its value. I first want to note the rapidly evolving field of metascience, which heavily relies on data. As you heard previously, the research councils' legacy systems currently present challenges; however, a new grant management system is being implemented and should eliminate some of these difficulties. Nevertheless, researchers are able to make data requests and to obtain such data to answer some research questions.
Nevertheless, clearer mechanisms could be implemented to support data requests from researchers and to make these data requests publicly listed, including the relevant findings or related publications. These improvements should be an important part of a capstone organization.
Furthermore, what is most needed is a clear mandate to assess strengths and gaps in our science policy. This should be embedded in the long-awaited advisory council on science and innovation and in the national strategy that is called for by the chief science adviser.
Finally, the key question is whether we are measuring the full benefits of federally funded research or relying on narrow assessments that value only certain types of research that mostly benefit private firms rather than communities. Measures need to extend beyond tech transfer, patents or spinoffs. Personally, I'm not convinced that I need another app on my phone.
To broaden the assessment of the value and impact of research is to establish a new contract between science and society, one that recognizes social innovation; supports research to be spread and scaled to benefit health, social resilience, adaptability and cohesion across our communities; restores greater trust in our institutions; and preserves our sovereignty. As we anticipate policies that will set mission-driven research, we must ensure that they will be human-centred.
To sum up, I would say that the federation believes that the government already has a number of mechanisms at its disposal to identify needed improvements. At this time, the federation doesn't believe it's necessary to create another body or another independent monitoring, analysis and accountability function. However, we do need to broaden our assessments of the value and impact of research to improve Canadian science policy for the benefit of everyone.
Thank you for your attention. I will be pleased to answer your questions.
