Evidence of meeting #32 for Science and Research in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was china.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Kingston  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Vehicle Manufacturers' Association
Burton  Senior Fellow, Sinopsis, As an Individual
Adams  President & Chief Executive Officer, Global Automakers of Canada
McKinnon  Interim Chief Executive Officer, Accelerate: Canada's ZEV Supply Chain Alliance
Breton  President and Chief Executive Officer, Electric Mobility Canada
Kabbara  Chief Executive Officer, The Transition Accelerator

Aslam Rana Liberal Hamilton Centre, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Mr. Adams, why are you fully against this policy on Chinese EVs, while most of your members are pursuing partnerships with Chinese companies?

4:25 p.m.

President & Chief Executive Officer, Global Automakers of Canada

David Adams

I didn't say I that was against the.... What I did say was that we need to cultivate a fair, rules-based environment by which any new entrant, Chinese or otherwise, comes to the Canadian market. Right now, as I think the other witnesses and I have outlined, we don't have that. In terms of other importers, everybody who is distributing vehicles in Canada is an importer, per se, as I outlined in my testimony. I think we are all unafraid to compete, but we need to compete from a level playing field.

Aslam Rana Liberal Hamilton Centre, ON

Could you please speak to the joint ventures and the partnerships that your member companies have with the Chinese car companies?

4:25 p.m.

President & Chief Executive Officer, Global Automakers of Canada

David Adams

As Mr. Kingston mentioned, pretty much every automaker has a joint venture established with the Chinese.

This is not to repeat Mr. Kingston's testimony, but the only way that the western auto companies were allowed into the Chinese market was to establish a joint venture with an existing Chinese automaker. That was the IP transfer, the technology transfer—all those things occurred. That's the way they entered the Chinese market. It was on the premise that it was going to be a growing and huge market, which it certainly is at this point.

Aslam Rana Liberal Hamilton Centre, ON

Thank you.

The government has set fairly ambitious EV sales targets. What needs to be in place in terms of infrastructure, incentives and supply chains for those targets to be achievable?

April 20th, 2026 / 4:25 p.m.

President & Chief Executive Officer, Global Automakers of Canada

David Adams

The initiative that the Prime Minister announced on February 5 about removing the EVAS, the zero-emission vehicle mandate, was important because it was challenging in terms of actually being able to achieve those targets, and that's been replaced by a greenhouse gas emissions target. That will allow automakers, regardless of who they are, to achieve emissions targets in a much more flexible way while still driving the same level of electrification. We do need more infrastructure. There's no question about that. The incentives have certainly helped as well.

Aslam Rana Liberal Hamilton Centre, ON

Mr. Kingston, global EV adoption has been growing steadily. How are the manufacturers that you represent thinking about their positioning in Canada relative to that broader trend?

4:25 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Vehicle Manufacturers' Association

Brian Kingston

Thank you. I'm sorry. My Internet was cutting in and out there.

The manufacturers that CVMA represents are very well positioned. As I noted, they're the first and second EV sales leaders in Canada right now, and they're actually building EVs in this country. The challenge that we've had recently has been a lack of demand. Now we're hopeful that with the return of the EVAP program and more investments into infrastructure, you will start to see an increase in demand. The February sales figures looked encouraging.

That's been the fundamental challenge that we face. Canadians just aren't interested in large-scale electrification at this stage.

Aslam Rana Liberal Hamilton Centre, ON

The uptake of EVs in Canada has been uneven. What do you think are the main factors driving that, and what would meaningfully move the needle?

4:25 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Vehicle Manufacturers' Association

Brian Kingston

The most important thing is charging infrastructure. We see it again and again in surveys of Canadians that they are concerned about their ability to charge their vehicle at home and to access fast charging infrastructure when they are taking road trips. As you see more EVs on the road, the throughput at these stations increases and actually can make the charging situation more problematic for drivers, so we need to address that. We have to give drivers the confidence that if you switch to an EV, it will be just as convenient if not more convenient than owning a gas-powered vehicle. We're not there yet.

Aslam Rana Liberal Hamilton Centre, ON

Thank you very much.

Thank you, Madam Chair.

The Chair Liberal Salma Zahid

Thank you.

With that, this panel comes to an end. I really want to thank all three witnesses for appearing before the committee.

I will suspend the committee for a few minutes so that the witnesses for the next panel can take their seats.

The meeting is suspended.

The Chair Liberal Salma Zahid

I call this meeting back to order. Welcome back.

I would like to make a few comments for the benefit of the new witnesses and the members.

Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by video conference, click on the microphone icon to activate your mic, and please mute yourself when you are not speaking. For those on Zoom, at the bottom of your screen, you can select the appropriate channel for interpretation: floor, English or French. As a reminder, all comments should be addressed through the chair.

With that, I would like to welcome our three witnesses for this panel.

We are joined by video conference by Andrew McKinnon, interim chief executive officer, representing Accelerate: Canada's ZEV Supply Chain Alliance. We are joined in person by Daniel Breton, president and chief executive officer of Electric Mobility Canada. Our third witness, also in person, is Moe Kabbara, chief executive officer of the Transition Accelerator.

Welcome to all three witnesses. Each of you will have five minutes for your opening remarks. After that, we will go to rounds of questioning.

We will begin with Mr. McKinnon.

Please go ahead. You have five minutes.

Andrew McKinnon Interim Chief Executive Officer, Accelerate: Canada's ZEV Supply Chain Alliance

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Thank you to the members of the committee for inviting me to speak on this important study.

Accelerate is an industrial alliance of key actors in Canada's emerging zero-emission vehicle supply chain. Our network of partners and collaborators includes critical minerals miners, battery producers, battery materials producers, vehicle parts makers, vehicle manufacturers, researchers and labour interests. Since 2021, we have been working across traditional industrial segments in Canada to develop the strategies that will support more Canadian content in EVs built here in North America and sold around the world.

Our research shows that building an EV supply chain and industry requires supporting the production of critical minerals and materials, as well as supporting the EV market through demand-side measures like predictable adoption targets, infrastructure build-out and the EV affordability program.

Today, it is widely recognized in Canada and by our allies that highly concentrated global supply chains for critical materials, including battery materials used in EVs, present a significant economic and security risk. For some of the key material inputs used in an EV battery or motor, greater than 90% of the world's supply is produced in China. This means that even though Canada has the raw materials needed and the final manufacturing prowess, we are missing control over critical segments of this value chain.

The economic opportunity to develop our EV industry and create jobs for Canadians must be considered with this context. It is essential that a strong EV industry in Canada, including a strong EV market, drives the demand to produce and process critical minerals and materials here. These are the same minerals and materials used to support our defence needs in advanced applications like power storage and drones.

A limited allowance of Chinese EVs into the Canadian market must be paired with continued and effective supports for Canada's own EV industry. In particular, this means support for critical minerals and materials production. This approach would build the EV market, support public access to and understanding of EV technology, and build up the materials supply side of our EV industry. Also, with the right instruments in place, it could facilitate technology transfer from the world's leading jurisdiction for EV and battery production.

We are pleased to see that the government, since the announcement of the new automotive strategy in February, has made multiple commitments to support key actors in Canada's emerging EV supply chains. This includes over $162 million for 22 Canadian projects announced by the Minister of Energy and Natural Resources at this year's PDAC conference in Toronto on March 3. Other critical measures include guidance in the strategic response fund on preserving intellectual property ownership in Canada, and budget 2025's addition of $22 million to renew support for the patent collective.

This diversified approach of trade and EV industry development must also continue to ensure that future deals to secure foreign direct investment from Canadian trading partners in the production of batteries and EVs include provisions that require investors to work with Canadian critical materials producers and clear timelines for the attainment of levels of Canadian content.

We want to see an assurance that future agreements on joint ventures in Canada for the production of batteries or EVs include safeguards that support the protection of Canadian IP, requirements for Canadian materials supplied at prices aligned with Canadian labour and environmental standards, and provisions to facilitate technology transfer to Canadian firms. Any future deal must aim to increase Canada's strategic independence and economic resilience.

We should develop a strategy to amplify and expand Canada's battery materials sector by coordinating with Canada's peers to share best practices, to co-develop IP and to create market access for Canadian battery materials.

We should deploy a national IP strategy for Canada's critical materials producers that would fast-track patents in this space, especially those related to battery materials and materials production.

Finally, this approach must continue to support Canadian firms in maintaining access to U.S. markets and consider long-term U.S. trading partnerships in the battery and EV supply chain.

Thank you for your time. I look forward to your questions.

The Chair Liberal Salma Zahid

Thank you.

With that, we will proceed to Mr. Daniel Breton for five minutes.

Please go ahead.

Daniel Breton President and Chief Executive Officer, Electric Mobility Canada

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Good morning, everyone.

My name is Daniel Breton. I am the president and CEO of Electric Mobility Canada. Our association has represented the transportation electrification industry in Canada for 20 years. We have nearly 200 members, ranging from small and medium-sized enterprises, SMEs, to multinational corporations.

Twenty years ago, only a few dozen people worked in the sector, and fewer than 20 electric vehicles were on the road across the country. Today, more than 130,000 Canadians work in the sector, and there are over 1 million electric vehicles. By 2035, between 360,000 and 600,000 people will be working in the sector. We therefore represent the future of Canada’s transportation industry.

Here are some facts. The Trump administration is trying to kill the Canadian automotive industry. In January 2026, he said, “We don't need cars made in Canada.” An auto plan that counts on Canada signing a free trade agreement where we will have no automotive tariff with the current U.S. administration is wishful thinking at best. No country in the world has no automotive tariff with the current U.S. administration.

I recently heard the CEO of CVMA say that diversification is not an option. Well, CVMA only represents three members, two of which would have been bankrupt without $80 billion in Canadian and U.S. taxpayer support 15 years ago, yet these three carmakers have decreased their Canadian car production by more than 80% in the past 20 years. It has nothing to do with Trump. It has nothing to do with China. That's why industry diversification is not only an option; it's the only option.

While approximately 5,000 jobs have been recently lost in the Canadian automotive industry, 130,000 jobs have been created in the Canadian EV industry. OEMs such as Rivian, Lucid and Tesla now employ thousands of Canadians in manufacturing and/or supply chain sectors here in Canada, yet they pay countertariffs while other OEMs that are currently laying off workers still get tariff remission. This is unfair, especially since these OEMs are the North American OEMs of the future.

Because Canada followed very lax U.S. regulations for decades, Canada was ranked dead last in the world by the International Energy Agency in a 2019 report for the average fuel economy of its light-duty vehicle fleet. By rolling back regulations on EVs, GHG emissions, fuel economy and even science, the current administration in the U.S. is creating the perfect conditions to slowly but surely kill its own auto industry. Trying to stop innovation is not an option.

Forty years ago—that's how old I am—the automotive enemy was Japan. At that time the Reagan administration imposed quotas on Japanese imports. My uncle worked at Ford and GM, and I worked at GM. He didn't want any of us in the family to buy a Japanese or German car, saying we couldn't buy from a country we had gone to war against. Today, the auto enemy is China. I sometimes hear the same undertones now towards the Chinese that I heard towards the Japanese 40 years ago.

Just over a month ago, I went to China to see the Chinese EV world with my own eyes. Chinese electric cars are very technologically advanced cars, much more so than many cars from most traditional automakers. If Canada had decided to follow the U.S. in trying to go back in time with cars and trucks with old technology, our industry would have been doomed.

The most laughable thing that I recently heard from an auto industry representative was the fear that Chinese automakers would come and copy our technology. We have a lot of catching up to do. Canadians want affordable cars, yet according to AutoTrader, the average selling price of a new car has increased by a whopping 57% between 2019 and Q4 of 2025, making buying a new car or truck very costly for Canadians.

Traditional carmakers stopped offering Canadians subcompact entry-level gas cars years ago. I recently went to Mexico, France and China. Carmakers in these countries offer affordable electric cars, starting at a little more than $20,000, some of them made in China, but also made in Europe, South Korea or even Mexico. Why can't Canadians get them? The most affordable EVs offered here start at around $40,000.

Today, Ford and GM import Chinese-made gas cars in Canada. The Lincoln Nautilus used to be made in Ontario. It's now imported from China and it's price has increased.

Tomorrow is Earth Day. I’m taking the time to point this out because the Standing Committee on Science and Research should keep in mind that the science of climate change is clear. Indeed, we must significantly reduce our greenhouse gas emissions, and Canada has a lot of work to do. Chinese vehicles are a small part of the solution, but we must work with everyone to create jobs here while we reduce our greenhouse gas emissions.

The Chair Liberal Salma Zahid

Thank you.

We will now go to Mr. Kabbara for five minutes.

Please go ahead.

Moe Kabbara Chief Executive Officer, The Transition Accelerator

Thank you, Madam Chair and committee, for inviting me.

I'm with the Transition Accelerator. We are an independent, non-partisan organization focused on helping Canada win economically and geopolitically within the energy transition.

I'm going to start with a simple statistic that I actually found really difficult to believe at first. In 2020, China exported one million vehicles, and not just EVs but everything. Last year, they exported more than seven million vehicles. One-third of these were electric. That is the fastest automotive expansion in history. At that scale, I think the question is not whether Chinese autos reach North American consumers. It's a question of when and how they do it, how much Canada can control that direction and outcome, and how much it benefits us.

The auto sector has lost more than half of its production since 1999. We peaked at around three million vehicles. Last year, it was about 1.3 million vehicles, and the EV transition is the opportunity, I believe, to potentially reverse that trend. We probably won't make three million cars again, but we can capture value that's potentially equivalent to that economic activity because Canada has the assets to help us win and compete in this EV transition. We have the critical minerals. We have access to talent when it comes to battery technology and battery innovation. We also have access to trade agreements that go beyond the U.S., even though the U.S. has been an anchor for the auto sector.

When the tariff question on EVs came up in 2024, we generally wrestled with this question because, given how deeply integrated the Canadian and the American auto production has been for decades, Canada couldn't afford to diverge too far from the U.S. position. However, we were actually very clear. We released a paper on this, in September 2024, in which we said that staying behind tariff walls indefinitely wasn't a strategy either. Tariffs can buy you time, but they don't build competitive advantage. Something like the agreement we are here to discuss today was going to happen eventually, and the question that we now face is how to maximize the benefits and manage the risks.

Earlier this year, the CEO of Ford in the U.S. was in discussion with the Trump administration about joint ventures with Chinese manufacturers. This is the world's most protectionist automotive market, and it is also exploring its options. Canada's engaging now on this is a head start, and I think it's a smart thing to do because, otherwise, we're going to be left out of the conversation.

The model of a structured joint venture is not new. It's actually how China built its own auto sector. It went from producing almost no vehicles to now having the capacity to produce half of the world's total vehicle demand. China used that model deliberately to absorb that manufacturing knowledge and to build its own capability. That is how you go from almost nothing to where they are today. We're seeing that logic used by global automakers. We're seeing it from Volkswagen, Toyota, General Motors, Ford and Stellantis. They are partnering and doing joint ventures with the Chinese automakers.

The question for Canada is whether we use that same arrangement, the same way China did, not just to let vehicles in but to actually get something durable in return. That is what we call “selective exposure”. It means that you don't just let the floodgates open, but you have selective exposure so that you can actually build and control. You have to admit that—as Daniel was saying—they are the world-leading manufacturers of EVs. With conditions that ensure that learning and investment can stay here, Canada can actually benefit as well.

We've seen this with Thailand as well, where they opened their markets, they removed tariffs on Chinese EVs and they're now building vehicles and battery plants on their soil.

Preferential market access is potentially a way to have that real investment happen in Canada. However, we should be careful about what we are defining as “investment”, because it's not just the assembly of the vehicle that can add value but also the batteries and the processing. Therefore, those joint ventures don't necessarily need to be at the assembly plant. They can be more upstream from that.

The second piece is that we're hearing a lot about the security concerns when it comes to Chinese vehicles. I don't think we should be completely dismissive. However, we should be really careful. It's not like you're going to plug a Chinese vehicle into the grid, and now China has access to a Canadian grid. Some of the things we were hearing are laughable, but we really should be careful as well.

There are solutions. There are models that the Europeans are using. Access to Canadian software on Chinese hardware made in Canada.... There are creative ways we can do this to make sure we're dealing with legitimate concerns because, obviously, China is not necessarily the best-faith actor or a good-faith actor, such that we shouldn't be careful on this.

Right now, with this opportunity, I think we can get the design of this agreement and the conditionality of the investment right. This is not just a trade concession, which is why I think this is very important for this committee to consider.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Salma Zahid

Thank you.

Now we will start our first round of questioning with MP DeRidder for six minutes.

Please go ahead.

4:50 p.m.

Conservative

Kelly DeRidder Conservative Kitchener Centre, ON

Mr. McKinnon, I'm going to start with you because you focused quite a bit on critical minerals.

It's a really critical time, knowing that the long-term value is either captured or lost with our critical minerals right now. In February, your letter to the industry minister emphasized the need for safeguards around IP and tech tied to Canada's critical minerals. If that IP, whether it's in processing, refining or battery innovation, is developed or controlled outside of Canada, do we risk losing long-term value of our own resources?

4:50 p.m.

Interim Chief Executive Officer, Accelerate: Canada's ZEV Supply Chain Alliance

Andrew McKinnon

Yes, I believe we would lose some control over long-term value should we lose that IP control. It's important in all joint venture agreements or any new trade partnerships around critical minerals to ensure that we protect homegrown Canadian IP and reap the most commercial benefit here.

4:50 p.m.

Conservative

Kelly DeRidder Conservative Kitchener Centre, ON

Last week we had a previous ambassador to China tell us that we need to allow Chinese investment into Canada for extracting our minerals. A part of that would be to then have the intellectual property to extract those minerals and, potentially, the ability to sell us back our own resources at retail. What are your thoughts on that?

4:50 p.m.

Interim Chief Executive Officer, Accelerate: Canada's ZEV Supply Chain Alliance

Andrew McKinnon

That's a model we should avoid. We need to work with the production agreements to protect Canadian IP, to ensure that we are adding value to minerals here in these complex value chains for batteries and electric vehicles.

4:50 p.m.

Conservative

Kelly DeRidder Conservative Kitchener Centre, ON

Thank you very much.

Mr. Breton, do you think that the Canadian manufacturers here in Canada are operating on a level playing field with Chinese EV producers?

4:50 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Electric Mobility Canada

Daniel Breton

Honestly, what I find concerning is when some people say that the Chinese manufacturers have been significantly subsidizing their auto manufacturing facilities and their capacities. The truth is that if you go back years ago, Japan was significantly subsidizing the auto manufacturing in Japan to help them come into Canada and the U.S. The U.S. has been significantly subsidizing its auto industry for decades. To me, when I see a country like China significantly subsidizing its auto industry, it's just doing what the Japanese, the Europeans, the South Koreans and the Americans have done.