Thank you, Chair.
Members of the committee, thank you for having me here. This is my second time testifying before a House of Commons committee on this issue. It's really a great honour.
I'm coming here with my experience of more than 25 years with the federal ministry of finance in the international trade and finance branch. I also currently teach at McGill, and I have my own advisory firm. Coming here, I represent no private interests or interests of any kind. I'm affiliated with no party. My interest, after having been invited here, is Canada's prosperity and Canada's sovereignty in the long term.
I'll make five or six points about that in the context of the government's agreement with the People's Republic of China to import, in the first instance, 49,000 electric vehicles for the next three years.
My first point is that this tariff relief agreement for EVs, canola and other foodstuffs, through which we have very substantial tariff relief on both sides, must be seen in the context of a larger trade agreement that's going to benefit both countries. I think this will actually benefit Canada more. China represents more of our trade than Chinese trade represents for Canada. They have a much more diversified export base than we do. That's one point.
The general point here is that tariff relief agreements, trade agreements and strategic partnerships require a quid pro quo and should allow countries to play to their comparative advantage. Our comparative advantage, whether we like it or not, is in energy, agri-food and other related exports.
I would never want to give up on our skilled manufacturing workers. That's my primary concern. You cannot be a rich country without a manufacturing sector, and a significant one, but when our economic model is based in large part on deep trade integration with the United States, we cannot have trade agreements with other countries unless there's a quid pro quo, so we have to accept imports. In this case, they're from China. It's a manufacturing superpower. It has one-third of global manufacturing, so there has to be give-and-take. We cannot only export.
This leads to my second point, which is what we can do with our automotive manufacturing sector, which we've had for more than 100 years. For the 500,000 workers, primarily in Ontario, who depend on this sector for their prosperity—middle-class families that require good incomes from good jobs—what can we do?
I think we have two broad choices, and maybe, with a mix of good policy and luck, we have three choices.
One is to go deeper into North American integration and to a kind of “fortress North America”. We haven't been in a fortress North America, but we've been in free trade agreements, NAFTA and then CUSMA, which came at the request of the Trump administration. Since the turn of the century, when our automobile production peaked at three million vehicles, we've seen the sector in long-term decline. Last year, we produced only 1.2 million vehicles, compared to the three million 25 years ago. In the context of the NAFTA platform, we have seen a migration of over 60% of our automobile production to Mexico and the United States.
We could stay in this platform, where Mexico has emerged as one of the six largest automobile producers in the world. We can try our luck there, or we can go global. We can take a page out of Australia's book. I'm not saying we should do this. I think there's a third way.
Australia ceased, as a result of a very strong currency and as a result of heavy government subsidies, to produce automobiles on a large basis about two to three years before COVID. More than its entire auto manufacturing population has been absorbed into the defence sector, which is growing rapidly in the context of a defence industrial policy aimed at defence sovereignty in Australia. In this new and enlarged defence sector in Australia, the wages and the earnings are higher.
I think there's a third Canadian option, which is to admit or to accept willingly and happily that the United States will always be our largest trading partner, but we can take a page out of Australia's book and have a mix of an automobile industry where we're producing EVs in a global sector where 70% of EVs are—
