You're absolutely right; the terms “excellence” and “inclusion” don't belong in the same sentence.
Again, some people on this panel have said that there is unequivocal evidence that supports the idea that diverse research teams lead to better outcomes. It depends how you measure diversity.
As I mentioned earlier, if you measure diversity as, for example, interdisciplinarity, then that form of diversity does improve scientific outcomes, because you're getting people who have different areas of expertise joining together to solve a common problem. However, I would challenge anybody on this committee to tell me how whether I am queer or not will help me improve quantum computing. I'm open to hearing that explanation, but until you show me how my sexual orientation affects my understanding of the distribution of prime numbers, I don't think those metrics affect research excellence, and they should be made null and void.
