Evidence of meeting #51 for Status of Women in the 39th Parliament, 1st Session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was inuit.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

MPs speaking

Also speaking

Melanie Omeniho  National Board Member, Women of the Métis Nation, Métis National Council
Jennifer Dickson  Executive Director, Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada
Ulrike Komaksiutiksak  Director of Programs, Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada

3:30 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Yasmin Ratansi

Committee members, we are ready to begin.

We have before us Melanie Omeniho of the Métis National Council, and Jennifer Dickson and Ulrike Komaksiutiksak of the Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada.

Each witness has 10 minutes to present, and after that we will go into a Q and A, with committee members being given an opportunity to ask questions.

If you have provided us with briefs, then enhance your brief. If you haven't provided us with a brief and your 10 minutes are up, take the opportunity under the Q and A to enhance your presentation.

I would like to start with Melanie.

3:30 p.m.

Melanie Omeniho National Board Member, Women of the Métis Nation, Métis National Council

Good day, ladies and gentlemen. Thank you for inviting us here. My name is Melanie Omeniho, and I'm one of the national representatives of Women of the Métis Nation. I would also like to bring greetings from our spokesperson, Rosemarie McPherson, who was unable to be here today, and from the rest of our national board.

We appreciate the opportunity we have to make this presentation to you today. We believe it's important that we are given these opportunities so we can make recommendations and help be part of the solutions for improving the lives of Métis women in Canada.

Through the empowerment of Métis women, we believe our nation is stronger, and the mosaic of Canada itself is also strengthened.

First, it is important that we give you brief details about who we are. The Women of the Métis Nation is a Métis women's collective body representing Métis women from the governing members of the Métis Nation and it's officially mandated by the government of the Métis Nation to speak and represent Métis women's agendas and perspective nationally.

The Women of the Métis Nation serves as an advisory body with the Métis Nation governance structures and within the Métis homeland. The Women of the Métis Nation retain a seat on our board of governors and within our cabinet at the Métis Nation. They are the only recognized representative body that meets and addresses the needs of Métis women specifically.

Women of the Métis Nation partners and works with the provincial Métis women's organizations in British Columbia, Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, and Ontario, which makes up our Métis homeland, and through these relationships we believe we're able to maintain the capacity and ability to identify the priorities that have been established by Métis women from across that homeland.

Women of the Métis Nation has worked to strengthen our capacity by building from the community level. We address issues by working through consensus. We have developed a set of principles and protocols that guide us when addressing the issues faced by Métis women, and we believe our strength lies in working as a collective by using our cultural and traditional values to effect change that is important to Métis women and to the Métis Nation as a whole.

Historically, Métis communities were matriarchal in nature and women were equal partners in the development of their communities--politically, socially, and economically. As women of the fur trade era prior to colonization, they worked beside the men in building the buffalo pounds and scouting during the hunts, interpreting and teaching, hauling and skinning meat, and in addition they prepared the hides, made products, raised their children, and provided economically and socially for their families in communities.

Métis women played key roles in relationship building and survival of the community through many challenging times. Through oral history passed on by our grandmothers, we were taught a sense of pride, accomplishment, and stubbornness that assisted us in forging forward in spite of the environmental and economic situations we sometimes faced.

We were taught that Métis women are the inspiration and the heart of our nation, allowing our Métis leaders to move forward. The reality is, in today's economy, Métis women live multi-barriered lives that affect our economic security and advancement. Several issues must be considered in the development of economic security for us.

Métis women face issues related to employment and underemployment. Factors affecting Métis women that we can readily identify in addition to employment are racism, health care, child care, marginalization of our priorities, child and family services, housing, poverty, education and training, safety, access to entrepreneurial business ventures, and our lack of political empowerment to change the policies that relate to our overall well-being.

Women of the Métis Nation is committed to creating awareness of the issues our women face and to encouraging and supporting their participation in the social, cultural, and economic development of the communities--regionally, provincially, and nationally.

We understand that our economic security will rely on our ability to identify the barriers, recognize our strengths, and find solutions to overcome our challenges. Some of the priorities we are currently addressing relate to family violence, education, retention of our Métis cultural and traditional knowledge, and Métis women's health and wellness.

We know the majority of Métis women live in large urban settings, with 69% of our women living in cities and towns. Of these, 42% of the Métis women who have children are lone parents. We should note that Métis women are often the working poor and are challenged to provide their families with housing by inflation and the costs that are added to the family units by fees and levies.

In 2001, 56% of Métis women 15 and over reported that they were in paid employment; however, 30% of Métis women have incomes below the low-income cut-off. The Canadian public lives under the misconception that we have free education, free health care, and free housing, but there is no free anything.

Métis people pay taxes, and for education and housing, just like all other Canadian citizens. For Métis women to identify and develop economic security, we need to address the lack of social mechanisms that affect the working poor. Our women often work in areas where their contributions are undervalued.

Métis women in the contemporary world have not always been engaged in creating solutions to change our life circumstances or conditions in which we live because we were marginalized. As a result, there is a gap in statistical data on issues facing Métis women.

The research that has been conducted has focused on the barriers facing first nations women. Métis women's oppression is not just due to a lack of resources from government but often can be identified as the lack of statistical information that is available.

In order that we address the many issues facing Métis women, we need to work in partnership with the government to address the area of data collection for Métis women. It is a priority for women of the Métis nation to seek the resources that we require to build on statistical information that exists so that we can stop being the forgotten segment of society and our issues will be better understood.

Métis people are a part of the proud, independent culture where we seek to find solutions to better our way of life by building on our strengths. As Métis women, we recognize that a part of our economic security will be accomplished by attempting to create mechanisms to empower Métis women by taking back our traditional role within society. One of our priorities is bringing together our older Métis women and young Métis women and creating a system of passing on their traditional knowledge.

These types of strategies will once again strengthen the role of our women for generations to come. As part of this work, we have recently undertaken small initiatives to assist our women in networking through the teaching of our traditional crafts. It is the cultural exchange that brings the older women together with the younger women, so that they are able to share their stories and teachings. In addition, we are able to assist young Métis women in developing their skills in traditional trades and build on the opportunities to engage in entrepreneurial programming so they can be self-sufficient.

It is our belief that through our work in traditional knowledge, our young women will be active leaders in the future. We will have them working beside the leaders of today so that they are stronger leaders for tomorrow.

In closing, I'd like to thank the committee for giving women of the Métis Nation the opportunity to have our voices heard, and I want to leave you with a Cheyenne proverb: “A nation is not conquered until the hearts of its women are on the ground. Then it is done, no matter how brave its warriors and how strong its weapons.”

Thank you.

3:40 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Yasmin Ratansi

Thank you very much.

We will now go on to Ulrike. Are you sharing your presentation?

3:40 p.m.

Jennifer Dickson Executive Director, Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada

No, I'll give it.

3:40 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Yasmin Ratansi

Okay, fair enough.

Jennifer.

3:40 p.m.

Executive Director, Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada

Jennifer Dickson

I have printed some copies of this with some nice pictures on it, if people want it. Unfortunately, it's English and Inuktitut, not English and French, and I don't know what the process is, but would you like to have it?

3:40 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Yasmin Ratansi

Committee members, would you like it distributed?

Pas de problème, madame? You don't want it. Fair enough.

It's normal for us to have English and French, but if anybody else wants to pick it up themselves, that's their prerogative.

3:40 p.m.

Executive Director, Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada

Jennifer Dickson

Thank you, Committee Chair Yasmin Ratansi, for including the voice of Canada's Inuit women in the Standing Committee on Status of Women deliberations today. We're pleased to be with you.

Your agenda discussing the economic security of Canada's women is dear to the hearts of Inuit women and their families and communities. It is timely and relevant to everyone in the north, and particularly to the people Pauktuutit represents, the Inuit women of Canada.

The message I wish to stress today, the message I want you to take away from this presentation, is that the success of Canada's businesses, environmental activities, and investments in the north rests upon the social and economic well-being of the inhabitants of Canada's northern communities. The full participation of Inuit women in the northern economy is crucial, and this participation both depends on and results in healthy and viable communities. Commitment to engagement of and with Inuit women in all business and policy strategies is the strongest possible assurance of success in Canada's north.

Pauktuutit is committed to and engaged in Inuit women's economic development on several fronts. This afternoon I'll touch on traditional knowledge and intellectual property rights and our work to improve Inuit women's economic self-sufficiency, two initiatives that demonstrate the link between social cohesion and economic success in Canada's north.

First, though, in case this is your first introduction to Pauktuutit, let me tell you a little bit about our work. Inuit women are the vessels of culture, health, language, traditions, teaching, caregiving, and child rearing, factors of the basis of the Inuit culture. As such, Inuit women play an integral role in the economic life of northern communities and society.

Pauktuutit is the national voice for Inuit women in Canada, guided by a highly motivated board of directors of Inuit women elected from 10 clusters of communities across Canada's Arctic, as well as youth and urban representatives. Pauktuutit fosters awareness of Inuit women, works for equity and social improvements, and encourages their participation in the national life of Canada.

Pauktuutit leads and supports Canadian Inuit women in policy development in community projects in all areas of interest to them. Our mandate...you'll see more of that in this document, too, but I'm going to go fast because I'm told I'm going to be cut off at 10 minutes.

What have social conditions to do with economic success? Well, everything. Here's one example. For over 20 years Pauktuutit has been a leader in breaking the silence on the difficult topics of family violence and child sexual abuse in Inuit communities. There's a slide in this presentation from a recent report by Statistics Canada showing some disturbing figures.

In Nunavut, women are 10 times more likely to need to go to a shelter as a result of abuse than women anywhere else in Canada. Sexual offences are equally high, and domestic violence is at least twice the rate in Nunavut than elsewhere. It dramatically illustrates the extent of the violence a lot of Inuit women face today.

Violence contributes to the high rates of homelessness in Inuit communities. There are few safe shelters and little in the way of alternate housing. Inuit women who flee violence must often depend upon relatives and friends for short-term shelter. As such, homelessness is largely hidden in the north. It is found in the severely overcrowded homes where couch surfers sleep in shifts.

A substantial proportion of Inuit households contain more than one family. Although we do not have reliable current estimates on the number of homeless in the north, we do know that a large proportion of these are women and children. We urgently need more homeless shelters and more and better supported Inuit community social workers and mental health workers.

This overcrowding is a major problem in the north. We are often told that commitments and investments to build new and affordable homes will keep pace with growth, but the Inuit population is young and growing rapidly, and this is putting increasing pressure on the current stock of houses.

In 2001--that's almost eight years ago--close to 70% of houses in northern Quebec and about 55% of houses in Nunavut were considered extremely overcrowded. About one-quarter of all Inuit are living in dwellings that are in need of major repair as well.

With regard to education, income, and employment, we have both discouraging and encouraging numbers. For example, the 2001 census showed that almost 58% of adult Inuit had not completed high school compared with 31% of all adult Canadians. Currently, it's estimated that for every 100 students entering kindergarten in Nunavut, only 25 will graduate from grade 12.

I could go on and on. Unemployment rates are high, and the cost of living can be unbearable. For example, in Nunavik, the Inuit region in northern Quebec, food and basic retail items can cost between 44% and 100% more than in Montreal. This last winter in Pond Inlet, Nunavut, one litre of orange juice sold for $22, and Ocean Spray cranberry cocktail was selling for $42.

Quality food can be very expensive. Junk food is cheaper because it is often lighter and less expensive to ship. The shelf life for manufactured processed food is longer. In one small community in the western Arctic, food prices have been calculated to be 470% higher than in Ottawa.

Costs like these contribute to a poor diet, which in turn contributes to heart disease, diabetes, and tooth decay. Inuit women and children often bear the brunt of the impact of poverty and the concomitant health and social problems that occur. Pauktuutit firmly believes that encouraging Inuit women to become self-employed will improve not only their lives but the lives of their families and communities as well.

Where and how can economic development contribute? How can government and business provide leadership that can truly improve the social fabric and therefore the economic stability so important to their business interests in the north?

Inuit women have the ideas, creativity, commitment, and tenacity to succeed in business for themselves. What they may lack are business skills, technical information, and marketing contacts. Networking, mentoring, business partners, and access to funding opportunities would help in all these areas.

Intellectual property rights are a potential barrier to the economic self-sufficiency of Inuit women. In the fall of 1999, these concerns became pressing when the New York City fashion designer, Donna Karan, sent a buyer to the western Arctic to collect older, traditional Inuit clothing for inspection for her new fashion line. Pauktuutit was concerned that the amauti.... Do people know what an amauti is? It's a parka you pull on over your head with a great big hood in the back for your baby. You see Inuit women with their very special amauti. All the women across the north make them their own way, so when you see an Inuit woman wearing an amauti, you can tell where she's from, and it's a treasured garment. Come over to our office on Sparks Street and we'll show you some.

Pauktuutit was concerned that the amauti was destined to be another element of Inuit cultural heritage to be misappropriated. Without legal protection, the small-scale economic activities of Inuit seamstresses in remote communities would be undermined by mass production in the south. The amauti could go the way of the kayak, the parka, and the kamik.

Protecting the intellectual property of indigenous peoples is problematic. The current legal regimes are geared for commercial or economic rights over privately owned economic property. So if you own something, you can protect it, but if your community owns something, it's almost impossible.

Pauktuutit is keenly aware of the challenges of starting a business in remote Arctic communities, particularly for Inuit women. High costs of transportation, small markets, and high business operating costs all have an impact on northern business. Inuit women face additional challenges, because many of the programs and services available do not reflect our needs and priorities.

In partnership with INAC, Pauktuutit has developed a handbook and a three-day workshop that helps walk Inuit women through the business planning process. I would go on and on and tell you a little bit more about that, but I want to skip to the key thing.

The huge economic potential of the north can only be realized in the context of the social and economic strengths of the Inuit inhabitants. From resource extraction to mega-development pipeline construction projects, the success of northern industrial development will be judged by how it contributes to the social and economic well-being of the Inuit communities in its path.

Together, I know we can be creative and seek novel solutions to the issues I've outlined here today.

For small entrepreneurs in isolated communities, practical access to banking services and financial credit can be a barrier. Microcredit is a tool particularly well suited to tiny, one-person enterprises, especially those initiated by women. We're seeing that all across the world right now. The only place it isn't is in Canada. It is gaining attention worldwide and is worthy of assessment in a northern context. Cooperative banking is another alternative to be explored.

I'm so glad to see someone from Justice here today too. Intellectual property rights beg a solution. As I mentioned earlier, for Pauktuutit, this is an important matter. But all our work on this issue is pro bono at the moment. We lack the resources to pursue it to the degree that is warranted at the national and international levels. We have consulted on its status at WIPO, which is the World Intellectual Property Organization, which meets in Geneva three times a year and invites us all the time, but we either can't go or they send us a ticket at the last minute and we can't go prepared. It's ridiculous.

To date, with two or three notable exceptions, support for our work has come on a project-by-project basis from several Government of Canada departments. We applaud these funders and thank them. However, the urgency of the crises facing Inuit in remote northern communities cannot and will not be solved by relying solely on these partnerships. Support must extend beyond government sources. It is time for the private sector to step up as well.

Inuit women are the primary agents of change in Canada's north. Pauktuutit is engaged in a wide range of vital activities and projects that focus on community well-being. Pauktuutit plays an important role in knowledge translation, transforming technical, clinical, and scientific knowledge into information that can be acted upon at the community level.

Pauktuutit, however, is a small organization with limited capacity. Amazing achievements have been accomplished on remarkably small budgets, yet all too often we must turn down opportunities because we lack core capacity to support the initiative.

Given the many challenges that need to be overcome, it is vital that Canada's national government and private industry become much more involved in the health and well-being of Inuit communities.

As I close, I would like to offer Pauktuutit as a partner for government and business and remind us all that private sector interests are best served by ensuring social and economic stability in local communities.

Pauktuutit has 23 years in direct, democratic community representation and courageous engagement in sensitive issues. Pauktuutit has well-established relationships with key representatives of governments, agencies, academics, community leaders, and the private sector.

I could just go on and on talking about Pauktuutit, so I will just say qujannamiik.

Thank you.

3:50 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Yasmin Ratansi

Thank you very much.

We will go to our first round of questions, the Q and A, which is seven minutes.

We'll start off with Mr. Pearson.

April 26th, 2007 / 3:50 p.m.

Liberal

Glen Pearson Liberal London North Centre, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I would like to thank the three of you for coming. Your voices are authentic, and it means a lot to us that you've come in here and spoken to us on these issues.

The question I have is primarily for Ms. Dickson.

I direct a food bank in London, Ontario, but I'm also on the board of the Canadian Association of Food Banks. What we've been trying to do is get Canadian businesses and others in the food industry to look to transporting more food to regions such as those you're talking about.

I've done some exploring on those issues, and one of the things that I've found--and it would help me to just clarify--is there seems to be a real problem for senior women within your communities. I'm just trying to seek clarification. It seems to me that what we've found is that they have become the main caregivers.

3:50 p.m.

Executive Director, Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada

3:50 p.m.

Liberal

Glen Pearson Liberal London North Centre, ON

Senior women--widows and others who are on pension.

They're the grandmothers, and they end up absorbing an inordinate amount of the care and responsibility, as opposed to what often happens in other parts of Canada.

I've done a bit of travelling to Africa, and we've seen the same kind of phenomenon, where the grandmothers end up with this. The problem is the grandmother is on a limited pension. I think in your communities it's the same. I also think members of the family tend to take advantage of that, because there's a steady supply of income that's coming in there, however big or small.

Before we go any further, I would like to find out if that is valid, if that is happening within your communities, and how serious you see it being. If it is serious, then I would like to ask some more questions.

3:50 p.m.

Executive Director, Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada

Jennifer Dickson

It's a very valid observation. Yes, elders, Inuit women, are highly respected by their families and their communities, and yes, I think we'd all agree that there is a certain amount of taking advantage happening there.

However, they also carry a lot of the ancient traditional wisdom and are what we call the keepers of the light. They keep the carved stove, the qulliq, lit. Without them, it wouldn't be lit.

So it's a high-wire act. It's a balance, for sure. But yes, it is a problem.

3:55 p.m.

Liberal

Glen Pearson Liberal London North Centre, ON

Thank you.

In Sudan, for instance, it has actually become a form of abuse from family members. In many cases the women in Sudan, for instance, or probably even within your own communities, seek to do things like arts and crafts to try to start their own businesses. So we try, whenever we can, to help them start these micro-enterprises. But no sooner do they start becoming successful than families start becoming more dependent on that income.

Regarding your view about more private interest coming into these regions, if that does happen, how do you see that impacting people like senior Inuit women, especially the ones who are widows and are having to absorb so much of the care of their family? I'm interested in how you'd see it. As you say, just having government support isn't necessary. I think we would all agree with that. There needs to be more. We try to do the same in Africa all the time, but the particular cultural things we face make it very difficult.

Can I ask how you see the private sector actually weighing in on these particular issues, especially around women?

3:55 p.m.

Executive Director, Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada

Jennifer Dickson

That's a huge question. I don't have any personal experience of their weighing in on it at all, on a direct level, but there are some private sector enterprises that do care about the community in which they are working and that do want stability in the communities.

One of the problems in the north, as everybody knows, is that most of the communities are fly-in only, and they're very remote and very isolated, so if there is a problem with one or two of the seniors.... First of all, the average age of the Inuit is 20, so you can imagine a community of 300 people of whom 150 are under 20. It's a very unusual dynamic to see. So having an outside company come in and say it is going to get involved with watching or monitoring or ensuring that anything happens...it is a very difficult, disruptive way of doing it. I don't mean disruptive necessarily in a negative connotation; it's just that it changes everything in that community.

I hear what you're saying, though. You don't want to put resources in the hands of somebody who then becomes a target for it.

3:55 p.m.

Liberal

Glen Pearson Liberal London North Centre, ON

Yes. That's a real issue.

3:55 p.m.

Executive Director, Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada

Jennifer Dickson

It is a real issue. It's an issue in downtown Toronto too.

3:55 p.m.

Liberal

Glen Pearson Liberal London North Centre, ON

Yes, that's true.

3:55 p.m.

Executive Director, Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada

Jennifer Dickson

It's an issue, and we all have to be aware of it and watch it and make sure that we protect people whose lives we are changing.

3:55 p.m.

Liberal

Glen Pearson Liberal London North Centre, ON

Do you two have anything to add to that from your own community?

3:55 p.m.

National Board Member, Women of the Métis Nation, Métis National Council

Melanie Omeniho

Traditionally in our community, as Métis, the elderly people stayed home and took care of the children while the working-aged people went to work. As social dynamics have changed, more and more responsibility is put on our elders. I would tell you that, in some instances, it is elder abuse. Many of these grandmothers and grandfathers have fixed incomes, and they're trying to provide and care for their grandchildren and, in some instances, great grandchildren. It is really quite challenging.

I also want to tell you that they won't let you change it. They want to take care of their own children, and they will fight to take care of their own children, so in many ways we've tried to do some work at a regional level to help change policies and things so that when the family structure breaks down at that level, there are resources that come to those grandparents to help feed and take care of those grandchildren. We've lobbied really hard in some areas and have worked with the Métis children and family services organizations in our province to help change that so that there are supports coming to some of those families.

It's not all the way across the board, but we are working to do things to help provide those kinds of supports to our elderly people.

3:55 p.m.

Liberal

Glen Pearson Liberal London North Centre, ON

Thank you.

3:55 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Yasmin Ratansi

Mr. Pearson, your time is up. I know you were on a roll.

We'll now go to Madam Demers.

4 p.m.

Bloc

Nicole Demers Bloc Laval, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Ladies, thank you very much for joining us this afternoon.

Ms. Omeniho, you stated that you were lacking data on Métis women, and that you were trying to address the problem. That said, have you requested help from Status of Women Canada through its Women's Program?

4 p.m.

National Board Member, Women of the Métis Nation, Métis National Council

Melanie Omeniho

Status of Women has not been all that receptive or open to Métis women, only because there has been a program through the Department of Canadian Heritage that just this coming year is going over to the Department of Indian Affairs and Northern Development--the aboriginal women's program. Status of Women, with their limited budget, would sometimes help us on a project-by-project basis, maybe at a regional level on one particular thing or another, but they have not been receptive or open to assisting us with things like data gathering or data collection up until this point.