Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you to the members of the committee for the opportunity to speak today.
My name is Pnina Alon-Shenker, and I'm an associate professor at Toronto Metropolitan University. I have studied age discrimination in the workplace for more than a decade. My most recent work, co-authored with Professor Asher Alkoby, addresses the gaps in legal protections for menopausal workers. This study was shared with the committee prior to this meeting.
Although available data suggest that menopause affects a large segment of Canadian workers, employment and labour laws remain largely silent on menopause. In the absence of explicit legal protections, employer-initiated menopause policies are rare, and menopausal workers encounter barriers to meaningful participation in the labour market. Indeed, women's labour force participation declines significantly as they age. This decline may be caused by a variety of factors, but there is some evidence to suggest that these include menopause-related challenges.
We found that there are very few litigated cases in Canada on menopause at work. The cases we discussed confirm previous findings that workers often lack the knowledge of what they experience and what they need, and when they do, the absence of inclusive workplace policies, together with persistent stigma, prevent them from seeking or receiving appropriate accommodation.
Menopause is often perceived as a personal problem rather than a human rights issue. Further, discrimination claims are reactive in nature, and they often mark a breakdown of the employment relationship in ways that are difficult to restore. Raising awareness through education of workers, employers, health professionals and adjudicators is critical not only for ensuring that such claims are brought forward and that they succeed, but also for preventing discriminatory practices in the first place.
The dearth of case law in this area is unsurprising. Menopause and its effects on women's health are still understudied. There is a substantial knowledge gap, lack of awareness and stigma surrounding menopause. Survey data show that unmanaged symptoms and the challenges experienced by menopausal workers contribute to reduced working hours, job loss and premature exit from the workplace. The impact on employers and the economy is also significant, including lost productivity and difficulty retaining top talent.
Other countries, such as the U.K. and Australia, have recognized the economic and social significance of these challenges and have conducted comprehensive parliamentary studies informed by extensive consultation with stakeholders. We are pleased to see that the Standing Committee on the Status of Women has now embarked upon a similar initiative. The U.K. and the Australian experiences make clear that there is no one solution that fits all workers and sectors, and that the way forward requires the introduction of integrated and coordinated measures to support menopausal workers.
Our study underscores the importance of exploring a multifaceted regulatory approach that would increase awareness, support employers' interest in retaining and attracting talent, effectively address stigma and silence and protect workers' choice and autonomy at work.
Indeed, Canada would benefit from a comprehensive national strategy that would promote the introduction of proactive regulatory measures and be accompanied by awareness-raising and education campaigns to break the silence surrounding menopause at work. Proactive regulatory measures that we recommend in particular include the introduction of workplace policies, menopause training, paid leave of absence and a stronger right to request flexible work arrangements.
Further, we argue that there is an important expressive value in explicitly recognizing menopause under human rights legislation at the intersection of age, sex and disability. This could help raise awareness, facilitate the development of menopause-related workplace policies, promote proactive duty to remove barriers, and create a clearer pathway to accommodation requests and more inclusive workplaces.
Finally, our review of other jurisdictions observed a normative shift towards a universal right to workplace accommodation. Focusing on the actual need for accommodation regardless of the individual's physical or mental condition would ensure the effective removal of social and environmental barriers that restrict meaningful participation in society of all Canadians.
Indeed, research shows that women wish to remain active in the labour market and are often able to do so with simple and inexpensive support and adjustments.
This approach would also help address concern—
