Great. I am glad I let you know that I was recording.
At CIEL, we have spoken with over 100,000 children and youth since 2020. So today, I am trying to report their opinions and experiences with artificial intelligence.
I was with you eight months ago to talk about anti-feminism. I read your report. Congratulations. Thank you for listening to us. I also read the government's response, which said how it is already responding to the recommendations. I have a more specific message: hear, hear, that is good, but it is not enough. Let us see how we can improve the response.
First, I am going to talk to you about the perception of young people, including girls and 2SLGBTQIA+ youth. During focus groups, when we ask them what they think about artificial intelligence and how they want us to educate them, there is a consensus: They say they are tired of hearing about artificial intelligence. How did we get there? That somewhat illustrates the dichotomy between pro-artificial intelligence narratives and anti-artificial intelligence narratives.
I am quoting a teenager. He told me that he has a teacher who prohibits him from writing with artificial intelligence. Another teacher suggests AI should be used in a healthy way. One teacher corrects his work with artificial intelligence, but another teacher tells him that he is using up too much water when he uses artificial intelligence and that he must limit its use. His mother connected his account to her ChatGPT account, but when he does a search on Snapchat or Google, he uses artificial intelligence. What is he supposed to do exactly?
Between narratives about the development of AI, that it is for everyone and for the future, and fear narratives that AI is going to lead to the extinction of humanity, young people do not know where to go and they lose faith in what we are telling them.
So, our first recommendation is to adopt a balanced approach that addresses both the positives and the negatives when talking to young people, including girls and 2SLGBTQIA+ youth.
First, Canada's national artificial intelligence strategy: AI for all states that, when funding initiatives on artificial intelligence literacy, we must act as a watchdog by ensuring that a balanced approach is always used, that no campaign focuses only on online threats, and that there is a balanced view of both sides.
Then, on top of that, there is the stigma surrounding digital device use. Young people will say that they do not want to seek help, because it is yet another screen problem. They are told that they spend too much time using their phones, even though we adults are the ones who buy them phones. In Quebec, more than 80% of 12-year-olds have a smart phone.
However, when young people fear being judged, they are reluctant to talk to an adult. Who can they turn to? Why would they not turn to AI? According to a U.S. study by Common Sense Media on 1,060 teenagers, over 72% of them have already used an AI companion. About one in three teens even said they prefer to talk to AI rather than to a person face to face. We wonder why.
I will quote another teenager who opened up to us. According to him, artificial intelligence does not judge him. The risk of being judged is something that girls and teenagers from 2ELGBTQIA+ communities are all too familiar with. Tools such as Character.AI and Replika, or simply generative artificial intelligence, do more than just answer questions. They can simulate emotions in relationships and become the people to whom young people turn to discuss their most private concerns. When the questions become increasingly personal—for example, when discussing one's gender or sexual orientation—experts say this is when young people are most at risk.
Here is my second recommendation. If we want young girls and 2SLGBTQIA+ youth to turn to adults for resources, we need to secure online spaces where young people will not be felt guilty. Bill C‑34, safe social media act, sets out parameters to ensure that artificial intelligence is subject to greater restrictions in the case of AI companions and chatbots.
However, unfortunately, these platforms are not reliable. Let me give you an example: OpenAI's ChatGPT claims to have a type of user account with settings for teenagers. Researchers at Common Sense Media tested these settings. The teenager was allowed to discuss suicide, self-harm and eating disorders; no notification was sent to parents. Therefore, Bill C‑34 must also provide for audits to verify the measures that platforms claim to have put in place to comply with our laws.
Lastly, artificial intelligence is much more than generative AI; it's everything that governs what girls and young people in 2SLGBTQIA+ communities are exposed to on social media because of recommendation algorithms and content moderation. Young people—
