Good morning.
I am appearing today on behalf of the Open Digital Literacy and Access Network, or ODLAN, in my role as director of education and strategy. Our non-profit's vision is to help Canadian 2SLGBTQIA+ communities grow and thrive in the digital age through safe, accessible and inclusive digital spaces. ODLAN creates resources, hosts training sessions and conducts research to work towards a more equitable online experience for 2SLGBTQIA+ people. We collaborate with dozens of grassroots organizations that serve community groups from large-scale systems like Fierté Canada Pride to kitchen table-size organizations that provide space in rural and remote communities. Essentially, we help queer and trans folks stay safe on the Internet.
Professionally, I am positioned to speak to the impact of artificial intelligence on underserved communities because I've been building curricula on generative artificial intelligence, large-scale data infrastructure, data privacy and sovereignty, and open source intelligence systems for over 10 years, with over a dozen published courses for post-secondary education institutions. My doctoral research on digital citizenship education policy has allowed me to publish on the relationship between policy and the practical implementation of technical literacy in the classroom.
I also teach an original curriculum on digital citizenship education at York. This was designed to reflect digital literacy standards in alignment with the Council of Europe and was published through their databases as an example of Canadian parallels to their digital citizenship education standards. This background has given me the opportunity to see the impact of AI at both the macro international scale and the micro classroom scale.
With my academic and educational hat on, I can confidently tell you that the majority of first-year university students are using AI multiple times a day, every day. They've been doing it since the pandemic. LLMs like ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude have been adopted by youth with the same velocity that we adopted the Internet in the 1990s—with great enthusiasm and minimal instruction, to the detriment of their mental health and critical thinking skills, atrophying their neurological pathways. This has been the equivalent of giving a toddler the keys to a Ferrari and letting them figure out how to drive it on their own. Most students know how to use AI, but very few have any technical knowledge of how it works, how the output is built on datasets heavily biased towards straight white men and how their personal data is being bought and sold on a secondary market for profit.
In my work with ODLAN, I see the implementation of AI at an organizational level. There is the same lack of foundational knowledge among its users of how data is collected, analyzed and regurgitated by these AI systems they have to adopt. Many organizations serving communities like these have no choice but to work with Google G Suite or Microsoft Office 365 licences, both of which come with mandatory artificial intelligence embedded. There's no opt-out feature, yet these two American tech giants provide the only free licence options—a necessity for a non-profit's tight budget. Queer and trans folks organizations are very concerned about their data privacy and data retention. There is no affordable, Canadian-owned and -operated alternative to cloud-based systems such as G Suite and Microsoft 365.
Google and Microsoft require consent to collect and track all user data associated with your email, cloud drives, desktop hard drives and bio data surrounding those datasets. They then sell this data on the resellers market to third party companies, beyond the user's control and knowledge, as much as they want to and for as long as they want to. These two companies also require consent to have access to all organizational data uploaded to their clouds, including the ability to review and delete anything they want, whenever they want, without prior notice to the organization. An example of this happened in October to JusticeTrans, which had their entire archival database erased by Microsoft without warning. Microsoft deleted over a decade of carefully collected primary health research.
Google and Microsoft have been quietly surveilling and erasing queer and trans datasets from non-profits globally over the past few years, without options for recovery or recourse. Why are companies like Google, Microsoft and Meta able to have absolute control over Canadian, government-funded, non-profit research and 2SLGBTQIA+ community work? We know their artificial intelligence systems screen for risky or inappropriate content and consider queer and trans people and their identities as inherently sexualized. This means that trans-inclusive mental health groups that are regularly censored or filtered as inappropriate for the general public are quietly being deleted from Facebook and Instagram.
What's the solution? How can we move towards rebalancing women and gender equity with artificial intelligence and other digital infrastructure systems? The answer lies in consent-first, self-sovereign data systems that are hosted locally in Canada. People need to be able to retain ownership of their personal identities and should have to give explicit consent for what and with whom they are sharing their personal information.
This concept already exists in our federal and provincial systems of data collection for medical health data. We could extend it to include our personal data. Canada could also implement policies similar to the European GDPR, which has the right to be forgotten. This would allow Canadians to revoke their consent of data sharing with these tech giants at any time. This premise also needs to be applied to the generative AI companies.
