Thank you for inviting me to participate in this study.
My name is Anne Marie Pinard. I am an anesthesiologist specializing in chronic pain at the CHU de Québec–Université Laval. For the past 14 years, I have devoted all of my clinical time to caring for people living with chronic pain. I am also a full professor at Laval University.
I have been actively involved at the provincial and national levels in several initiatives related to chronic pain, some of which involve veterans. Every year, I see 10 to 12 veterans at my clinic who are struggling with chronic pain. Over the years, I have come to understand and respect military culture. Veterans of the Canadian Armed Forces have often faced difficult situations, and not just while deployed. They are overrepresented among the population living with chronic pain. Roughly 20% of the general population suffers from chronic pain, but among veterans, the proportion exceeds 40%, and is likely 50% among female veterans. Mental health issues are also very common. Among veterans living with chronic pain, an estimated 60% also have mental health issues, whereas in the general population, that figure is around 30%.
In my work, I am extremely fortunate to collaborate with an interdisciplinary team. In the most complex cases, we develop an individualized treatment plan that is realistic, progressive, and, above all, developed in collaboration with the patient and their loved ones.
Chronic pain is not simply persistent pain; it is a complex phenomenon involving a hyper-reactive nervous system, cumulative fatigue, difficulty tolerating physical exertion, sleep disorders and past traumas that have left their mark. In this context, best practices rely on fine-tuning, gradual progression, respect for limits and the genuine integration of mental health considerations.
My experience with programs offered by private clinics is quite extensive. About a dozen years ago, programs with a rather rigid structure were very common. Patients with complex cases or mental health issues were often left feeling battered by this type of program. Such programs gradually disappeared because their effectiveness was fairly limited in complex cases. The mental health aspect was rarely taken into account. Often, there were no psychologists, occupational therapists, or social workers on these teams. What I have observed in recent years—I say this cautiously, but also with genuine concern—is a tendency to replicate this rigid, standardized approach in the care pathways of certain veterans.
Over the past few years, likely since the creation of Partners in Canadian Veterans Rehabilitation Services, I have observed a significant decline in the ability to collaborate—or indeed, an inability to do so at all. I am seeing long delays before assessment and access to initial services. Based on my experience with this program, I can say that the assessment is rarely conducted by a team that includes, among others, a physician with a good understanding of both military culture and chronic pain. Above all, once the program has started, it is very difficult to influence the content, intensity, or frequency of treatment, even when the clinical situation deteriorates. This one-size-fits-all approach is precisely what was abandoned, for example, by the Commission des normes, de l’équité, de la santé et de la sécurité du travail a few years ago.
We must return to what is effective in cases of chronic pain: collaboration and adaptation.
We must then seriously consider what secondary and tertiary care clinics may be doing concurrently. If a plan already exists, it must be integrated, not bypassed.
We must also integrate mental health in a structured way. Success often depends on linking mental health and physical interventions.
Finally, professionals working within these programs need solid training in both chronic pain management and military culture.
I also believe we need to improve transparency. Opaque decisions, a lack of feedback, and a flood of paperwork undermine trust and the quality of care.
I hope you will also have the opportunity to hear the views of those who work with veterans, particularly in clinics for operational stress trauma, as well as case managers, because they are the ones experiencing the concrete consequences of the system as I see it today.
I will conclude with a simple image. We wouldn't dream of offering the same size of clothing to all veterans, saying it is standard issue and they must adapt. Yet, my clinical experience sometimes leaves me with the impression that this is what we are doing when we impose a single, fixed and rigid model on people whose clinical realities are profoundly different.
