Evidence of meeting #45 for Veterans Affairs in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was education.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Robert Luke  Chief Executive Officer, eCampus Ontario
Booth  Chief Executive Officer, True Patriot Love Foundation
Lowther  Chief Executive Officer and Co-Founder, Veterans Emergency Transition Services
Larochelle  Advisor, Recognition of Acquired Competencies (RAC), Cégep Marie-Victorin
Blanchard  Founder and Chief Executive Officer, Veterans Entrepreneurship Hub (Vet-Hub), VeCATS Inc.
Thorne  Chief Executive Officer, Veterans Transition Network

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

I call this meeting to order.

Good morning. Welcome to meeting number 45 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Veterans Affairs.

Pursuant to Standing Order 108(2) and the motion adopted on May 25, the committee is meeting as part of its study on the civilian recognition of military skills.

Today's meeting is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. Members and witnesses may attend in person and via the Zoom application.

I would like to make a few comments for the benefit of the witnesses and members.

For those participating by video conference, click on the microphone icon to activate your mic, and please mute yourself when you are not speaking.

For those who are on Zoom, you can select the appropriate channel for interpretation: floor, English or French.

I would like to welcome our witnesses on this Thursday morning.

From eCampus Ontario, we have Dr. Robert Luke, chief executive officer. From True Patriot Love Foundation, we have Mr. Nick Booth, chief executive officer. From the Veterans Emergency Transition Services, we have Mrs. Debbie Lowther, chief executive officer and co-founder.

We will start by giving each of you five minutes to deliver your opening remarks. After that, the rest of the hour will be for a series of questions with the members of our committee.

I would like to start by giving Dr. Luke the floor for five minutes.

Dr. Robert Luke Chief Executive Officer, eCampus Ontario

Good morning, Madam Chair and members of the committee.

Thank you for the opportunity to provide the committee with information and insight on the important topic of civilian recognition of military skills.

The women and men who serve in the Canadian Armed Forces gain valuable skills that contribute to Canada's professional military capabilities. The successful transition of veterans into civilian occupations is not a “nice to have”; it is an absolute necessity for the well-being of our veterans and the productivity of our economy.

To date, there has been a lot of work done on transitioning highly skilled veterans into the civilian economy. Veterans Affairs offers career transition services and the education and training benefit, to name two. There are supports for job takers—those who are seeking employment—and job makers—entrepreneurs who are pathfinding to self-employment.

For those who might not know what eCampus Ontario is, we are a not-for-profit that is funded primarily by the Ontario government. We support Ontario's public post-secondary institutions to use digital technologies and connect education to employment. We help get people into programs and into jobs.

For the past three years we've had a productive partnership with Employment and Social Development Canada's job bank. Our flagship platform, skills for jobs Canada, is the country's national upskilling platform. It provides Canadians with over 5,000 courses, all indexed with labour market information from institutions in nine provinces, and in both official languages. Skills for jobs Canada is linked to the job bank's training finder. This means that, when Canadians go to the job bank to look for education and training, they have ready access to thousands of short, affordable and flexible upskilling and re-skilling opportunities that help them develop job-relevant skills.

Skills for jobs Canada uses large language models to ensure courses are indexed with relevant labour market information and AI tools to help people using the site. Over the past year we have been working with our partners from across Canada to orient skills for jobs Canada to the needs of veterans transitioning into civilian employment. We have built AI agents that help veterans understand how the skills they have learned in the military apply to civilian occupations. When additional education or training is needed, we help find this quickly.

We offer free courses that act as an on-ramp to advancing career-relevant learning. This includes free learning on artificial intelligence, a course designed for the layperson to gain fast insights into AI. For those wanting to learn more, there are over 280 courses on artificial intelligence in the skills for jobs Canada database. Our road map includes a digital credential wallet that enables all learners to store and showcase their skills and competencies. Together, these supports help ensure that all Canadians can participate in the economy.

We are proud of the work we have done to support people in this volatile economic time. We are proud to help the Government of Canada convene education providers from across the country to meet the education to employment needs for all Canadians. We are proud to now make these tools and resources available to veterans.

If I had just one recommendation to make, it would be this: Make it easy for veterans to access supports, with best-in-class digital and artificial intelligence tools, while linking to Canada's higher education institutions. Together, we can ensure that all Canadians, including our highly skilled veterans, can contribute to a productive economy.

I recognize that introductions are short, so I welcome your questions.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

Thank you very much.

Mr. Booth, go ahead for five minutes, please.

Nick Booth Chief Executive Officer, True Patriot Love Foundation

Madam Chair, vice-chairs and members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to be here to discuss veteran transition through skill recognition and employment, and I hope, its contribution to well-being.

During this period of remembrance, I first want to acknowledge the Canadian Armed Forces members and families impacted by the recent incidents at CFB Wainwright. True Patriot Love is proud to be partnering with Support Our Troops and the Edmonton military family resource centre in establishing a dedicated support fund to assist those affected and their families. Our thoughts are with them.

Thank you, also, to the serving members and veterans in the room and across the country. Thank you to the committee members for your cross-partisan dedication to our military community in these challenging times, both in Canada and geopolitically.

True Patriot Love is Canada's national foundation for the military community. Since 2009, we've invested over $62 million in high-impact programming, research and advocacy in close partnership with the Canadian Armed Forces and Veterans Affairs Canada. Our focus is on ensuring that those who have served have the support required to thrive at every stage of their transition to postmilitary life.

Each year, approximately 8,000 armed forces members are released from service. About half move directly into the civilian workplace, with nearly one-third still in their prime working years. They leave the armed forces with advanced technical training and skills. They have team-building and leadership experience, and they have a powerful desire to continue to serve their community.

However, significant barriers remain. Civilian employers often struggle to understand military experiences or map military qualifications into corporate roles. Veterans, in turn, may not know what roles they are best suited for, and if they do secure employment, a civilian workplace can be culturally jarring. When a veteran's operational rank and level of responsibility are not mirrored in civilian roles, it can lead to underemployment, loss of purpose and identity fracture.

To fix this, we must first change the narrative. There can be a tension, often driven by fundraising or the media, between supporting those in need and promoting the talent in our serving members. Whilst not ignoring the struggles that some veterans face, we must replace this with an understanding of capability. Veterans are skilled, resilient assets whose service-related injuries, should they be present, can be readily accommodated in modern workplaces.

To accelerate this, we can build on the strengths of programs already under way here, such as last year's True Patriot Love employer declaration, which was signed by a dozen major companies in Canada, and the ecosystem connect events we've now been running across four provinces.

As well, we can look at our closest allies, which have proven blueprints for corporate mobilization. At the CIMVHR Forum last week, a joint session was held with eight of our allied nations to look at different approaches to retention, developing a strong reserve force and postmilitary transition. In the United Kingdom, the Armed Forces Covenant has mobilized over 13,000 businesses to make public pledges to recruit and support the military community. In Australia, the national veteran employment program drives structured engagement through the veteran employment commitment, which is an evidence-based accreditation system in which more than 600 employers are benchmarked. Crucially, the Australian Defence Force itself manages formal civilian accreditation directly, offering transitioning personnel recognition of prior learning up to two years post release.

Drawing from these international lessons and previous studies, such as the foundation's 2017 veteran transition report; our current building a veteran-ready Canada initiative, on which we're partnering with Veterans Affairs; and the 2023 ACVA recommendations, we point to four practical priorities.

First, establish a national military skills transition framework. True Patriot Love has developed recommendations for a military skills translator that accounts for the role of rank and soft skills, as well as leveraging AI to support communicating military experience in a civilian context. This framework could be piloted immediately, for example, within the federal public service or national defence procurement contracts.

Second, create targeted pathways into high-need sectors. Recognizing a veteran's orientation toward having purpose, we've worked with Accenture to develop an employment pipeline into the health care sector, adapting the U.K.'s proven step into health program model. This could also be adapted to other sectors or provinces where key skills are needed.

Third, unify transition practices across government and industry. We urge industry and federal and provincial governments to standardize skill portability, encourage veteran employee resource groups, undertake military cultural competence training and protect reservist leave through alignment with National Defence's with glowing hearts program.

Finally, scale employer recognition. Successful programs in the United States, such as Hiring Our Heroes and veterans on Wall Street, demonstrate the power of corporate mobilization. Last month, True Patriot Love hosted our celebration of service on Parliament Hill—many of you were there—where military employers come together. This could be so much bigger. We should match the ambition of Australia, where the veteran employment awards are a national event, hosted annually by the prime minister.

To conclude, when we build a transition ecosystem that honours the full capability of veterans, it sends a clear message that skills forged in uniform are invaluable, and that our communities and economy are made stronger by those who served our nation.

Thank you. I look forward to your questions.

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

Thank you very much, Mr. Booth.

Mrs. Lowther, you have the floor.

Debbie Lowther Chief Executive Officer and Co-Founder, Veterans Emergency Transition Services

Good morning, Chair and honourable committee members.

Thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today as part of your study on the civilian recognition of military skills.

I must admit that I had mixed feelings about accepting this invitation. On the one hand, I always appreciate the opportunity to share our frontline experience in supporting veterans. On the other hand, I was frustrated.

In February 2023, I appeared before this committee to discuss a national strategy for veterans employment. While I appreciate the committee's continued interest in improving outcomes for veterans, I must respectfully question the need for what appears to be a largely duplicative study.

Many of these challenges have already been examined, and recommendations have already been put forward. Before we undertake another study on substantially the same issues, shouldn't we first be examining which recommendations from the previous study have been implemented and why others have not? At some point, we must ask whether the issue is a lack of understanding or a lack of action. Veterans do not need us to continually study the barriers they face; they need us to remove them.

Since 2010, VETS Canada has provided emergency assistance to Canadian Armed Forces and RCMP veterans experiencing homelessness, at risk of homelessness or otherwise in crisis. Through our frontline work, we have witnessed the challenges veterans face in transitioning to civilian life, including the failure to adequately recognize the skills, training and experience acquired during military service.

Members of the Canadian Armed Forces develop extraordinary skills in leadership, logistics, technical operations, problem-solving and crisis management, yet upon release, many discover that years—sometimes decades—of experience are not readily recognized by civilian employers, educational institutions or regulatory bodies. A veteran who has managed personnel, budgets and complex operations may be told they lack civilian management credentials. A military technician with extensive experience may be required to repeat training to obtain civilian certification. These individuals are not lacking skills. They are encountering a system that does not adequately recognize the skills they already possess.

At VETS Canada, we see how barriers to meaningful employment can contribute to financial instability, housing insecurity and, in some cases, homelessness. Stable employment provides more than financial security. It offers purpose, structure and belonging, things many veterans struggle to replace after leaving the military.

We believe several practical steps are necessary.

First, Canada needs a standardized system for translating military qualifications and experience into civilian credentials, developed collaboratively with governments, educational institutions, regulatory bodies and industry.

Second, recognition of military experience must begin before release. Transition planning should include assessment of transferable skills, identification of certification requirements and access to bridging programs that recognize prior learning.

Third, civilian employers need better education about the value of military experience. Highly qualified veterans should not be overlooked because their experience does not fit a conventional civilian résumé.

Finally, veterans facing additional challenges, including disability, mental health concerns or housing instability, must have access to coordinated, individualized support.

At VETS Canada, we understand that employment cannot be considered in isolation. A veteran worried about where they will sleep tonight or how they will feed their family is not necessarily in a position to pursue civilian credentials or a new career. Housing, employment, health care and transition services must work together, not operate in separate silos.

The men and women who served our country have already demonstrated their ability to learn, lead, adapt and overcome challenges. They should not have to start from zero simply because they have exchanged their military uniform for civilian clothing. Recognizing military skills is not about giving veterans an unfair advantage. It is about ensuring they are not placed at an unfair disadvantage because they chose to serve their country.

At VETS Canada, we believe those who protected our home should never be without one. We also believe they deserve a fair opportunity to build meaningful and successful lives after service.

In closing, I will reiterate what I said at the beginning: Veterans don't need another study confirming what we already know. They need meaningful action on what we've already learned.

Thank you for your time. I welcome your questions.

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

Thank you very much to the witnesses for being with us this morning.

We will now move on to the next stage, which is questions from members.

I'll go to Mr. Barrett for six minutes.

8:35 a.m.

Conservative

Michael Barrett Conservative Leeds—Grenville—Thousand Islands—Rideau Lakes, ON

Thanks, Madam Chair.

Thank you to the witnesses for your presence here today and for the insight that you're going to provide in your advocacy for veterans.

Ms. Lowther, I'm in violent agreement with you. I think that the frustration that you've shared, if I can characterize it as that, is something veterans continue to face systemically, and it's nothing new. This isn't something that's happened in the last 12 months, 24 months, 10 years or 20 years. This is an ongoing challenge that the men and women who serve our country continue to face.

They have demonstrated and continue to demonstrate the ability to overcome all manner of adversity. However, for challenges that seem pretty straightforward—whether it's about access or the administration of benefits—it seems as though we're looking to discover fire or reinvent the wheel on an annual or semi-annual basis. Your frustration was well expressed and done very respectfully.

Having addressed your comments, did you have a follow-up that you'd like to make in response to that before I move on with my first question?

8:35 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer and Co-Founder, Veterans Emergency Transition Services

Debbie Lowther

No. I think my statement basically said where we stand.

8:35 a.m.

Conservative

Michael Barrett Conservative Leeds—Grenville—Thousand Islands—Rideau Lakes, ON

Okay. Thank you very much.

I'm going to start with you, Mr. Booth. It's very nice to see you.

You talked about the Hiring Our Heroes program in the United States. I understand that employers who are covered by regulation—anyone who has a single federal contract or subcontract valued at $200,000 or more in the U.S.—also has to report annually to the U.S. Department of Labor a headcount snapshot of how many veterans and new hires they have in that reporting period.

Do you think that this would be helpful for us in Canada when it comes to the areas that the federal government regulates, specifically, what's within their remit for federal government contractors?

8:35 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer, True Patriot Love Foundation

Nick Booth

The short version is yes.

I'm not an expert on how the procurement assessments are done, but it does seem to be a significant opportunity as we're rightly investing more heavily in Canadian defence capability for the first time in many years, as we would all accept. There are two elements to that, which I would hope will be considered.

First is the point on employment. For me, it would be a perfectly sensible requirement to ask people who are bidding for those contracts or, indeed, already have them, what their is approach to military cultural competence, training and hiring of veterans, as well as to make that a stipulation of winning those contracts. That would be very sensible.

Second, when there's an element of channelling funding from some of those contracts into veteran care—a conversation that the honourable member and I have had previously—I do have a concern that, as Canada faces increasing global instability, we're not necessarily doing the same amount of preparation for post-conflict readiness.

People will come back from the next conflict—I fear, when it happens, it may be sooner than any of us would wish—with a significantly higher level of challenges, skills and transition needs than in previous conflicts. We must get ready for that, and thinking about the system in its entirety would be a sensible way to do that.

The other point, if I may, is on Hiring Our Heroes—in terms of Deb's comment. It had a key responsibility allocated to it, and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce ran that program. The system is quite well built. I would agree that it doesn't work perfectly, but I think it's better than it used to be. We'll come back to that perhaps.

It's not entirely clear how the joints fit together well. That's an area in which the committee could perhaps make some additional contributions in terms of how those seams between the educational section, the military section and the employer section fit together.

8:40 a.m.

Conservative

Michael Barrett Conservative Leeds—Grenville—Thousand Islands—Rideau Lakes, ON

I think it's—

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

I have a point of order, Madam Chair.

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor.

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

Madam Chair, I've been fairly patient since the meeting started, but Zoom isn't working. As a result, for anyone listening remotely, including my assistant, the interpretation isn't working. We may have to suspend the meeting while the issue is being resolved.

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

That's exactly why I spoke French. I wanted to see if things were working technically. Apparently they're not, so we apologize.

I apologize to the witnesses.

I will suspend the meeting for a few minutes while we resolve the technical issue with interpretation.

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

I call the meeting back to order.

MP Barrett, you have the floor for your questions. I'm sorry again.

8:45 a.m.

Conservative

Michael Barrett Conservative Leeds—Grenville—Thousand Islands—Rideau Lakes, ON

From the top...?

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

From almost the top...not quite. Thank you. You have a little buffer.

8:45 a.m.

Conservative

Michael Barrett Conservative Leeds—Grenville—Thousand Islands—Rideau Lakes, ON

Thanks, Madam Chair.

With my remaining time, the question is, how do we incent employers to hire veterans?

Federal procurement seems to be low-hanging fruit. They should award points heavily based on not only the number of veterans who work for these organizations—this should be publicly reported—but also the number of veterans who will be available to work on those contracts. That seems, on its face, very simple. It's not something that has been done. It's definitely not something that's being done. How do we do that? Should we do that?

I can start with you, Ms. Lowther, or you, Mr. Booth.

8:45 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer, True Patriot Love Foundation

Nick Booth

Thank you.

I think we should try to do that.

The other way I would suggest we might look at it is with sector-specific initiatives, because that will mobilize people towards their own business interests if they're bringing transitioning military members or veterans in who have targeted skills in their industry.

I will refer back to the step into health program that I made comments on in my notes. NHS England has piloted step into health for about nine years now, and over 100 NHS trusts in England now have veteran-hiring capability. In fact, centrally, NHS England has a dedicated veteran-hiring unit. It has been extremely successful in bringing transitioning members and veterans into the health system, not just with medically related trades but also with all the different skills that a big health system will require.

True Patriot Love received permission from the NHS to use the system, and we've worked pro bono with Accenture to build it into a Canadian framework. We're now ready to pilot that, so we're looking for either a health authority or a key province where we can move forward and test that in the Canadian context, particularly as we strengthen our health systems postpandemic and do all of those other things we need to do around health preparation. This would be a very good way of saying, “Here's an industry”, and if you align the relevant bits of the industry, then people can see their own advantage in following this route, not just because it's the right thing to do.

8:45 a.m.

Conservative

Michael Barrett Conservative Leeds—Grenville—Thousand Islands—Rideau Lakes, ON

Right.

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

Thank you very much.

Again, you have my apologies.

We will now go to Madame Chatel.

Mrs. Chatel, you have the floor for six minutes.

Sophie Chatel Liberal Pontiac—Kitigan Zibi, QC

Thank you very much, Madam Chair.

Thank you to the witnesses for being here today for this important study.

I really like the idea of changing the narrative. We often hear that substantial accommodations are required for jobs available to veterans because they face mental health challenges. That's true, and we need to make sure that the most vulnerable people receive adequate support during this transition.

At the same time, we don't talk enough about the extraordinary skills that members of the Canadian Armed Forces acquire while in uniform. Their skill sets are relevant to occupations other than security guard positions. Those are super-important jobs for which they are highly qualified. However, the face of the armed forces is changing with the advent of new technology and the modernization of warfare, as we can clearly see in Ukraine, where it now involves drones, robots, technology and cybersecurity. The face of the forces is changing at breakneck speed.

Mr. Luke and Mr. Booth, you talked about the rise of artificial intelligence, which may be a threat, a tool, or both. For younger veterans—those in their early forties or late thirties—transitioning to civilian employment, how can we provide them with meaningful work commensurate with their skills?

These people also want to serve their country. How do we give them the opportunity to pursue that mission with a second career?

We need people in aerospace and cybersecurity. We talk a lot about procurement, but we also need to talk about the severe labour shortage in the aerospace industry. We have the capacity to train only 25% of the people needed to fill 65,000 vacancies over the next decade. How are we going to attract these people and prepare them to serve Canada in these sectors?

8:50 a.m.

Chief Executive Officer, eCampus Ontario

Dr. Robert Luke

Thank you for the question.

I'll answer in English if that's okay.

There's a very important concept that you have put on the table. With the new defence industrial strategy, for example, we have an increased focus on support for the military, on how people are both entering and exiting, and I would like to relate this to the dual-use economy as well.

You have rightly recognized that the kinds of skills serving members need today to prosecute the kinds of wars that we are seeing around the world have changed dramatically with the rise of artificial intelligence and the concomitant needs for cybersecurity. These are all very important. When our veterans are transitioning into civilian employment, they often carry with them advanced security clearances, and they can go into those dual-use sectors quite readily.

A few of the things that I've heard some of my colleagues say are quite important here. How do we ensure that people know what skills they have when they are leaving the military? The Canadian Armed Forces does an excellent job of articulating the skills and competencies that you need to progress through various ranks and trades, but I'm not certain that we do a good job of helping these people understand how to articulate those skills.

We have another issue with respect to some of the services and supports we have. These are really good services and supports, but they're created on multiple websites. Bringing them together is one of the things that we have addressed. For example, through conversational AI agents, we circumvent the information architecture that might have made sense when we designed it but has resulted in a lot of different supports on different websites.

The AI agents go and collect that information and say, in a conversational way, these are the skills that you have. These are the occupations that they are relevant to, and here's how you can transition to them with minimal required training. There's a very important series of things that we can do. As for the point that Ms. Lowther made, we can do this today because it's something that needs to be done right away.