The House is on summer break, scheduled to return Sept. 15

House of Commons Hansard #19 of the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was citizens.

Topics

line drawing of robot

This summary is computer-generated. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.

Promotion of Safety in the Digital Age Act First reading of Bill C-216. The bill proposes a duty of care for online operators regarding child safety, strengthens reporting of child sexual abuse material, criminalizes deepnudes and online harassment, and protects civil liberties. 100 words.

Post-Secondary Education Financial Assistance for Persons with Disabilities Act First reading of Bill C-217. The bill proposes tuition-free post-secondary education for Canadians with disabilities to remove barriers, unlock potential, and promote inclusion in colleges, universities, and trade schools. 100 words.

Alleged Misleading Minister Testimony in Committee of the Whole—Speaker's Ruling The Speaker rules on questions of privilege from the Members for Mirabel and Lakeland, alleging ministers made misleading statements in Committee of the Whole regarding carbon rebate funding and Bill C-5 project selection. The Speaker explains procedural requirements for such questions and the high bar for finding deliberate intent to mislead. Finding procedural rules not met and no evidence of intent, the Speaker rules no prima facie case of privilege exists. 1500 words.

Citizenship Act Second reading of Bill C-3. The bill amends the Citizenship Act to address "lost Canadians" and allows citizenship by descent beyond the first generation. It requires a Canadian parent to demonstrate a substantial connection (1095 cumulative days in Canada) for future generations. Government members state it corrects past injustices and responds to a court ruling. Opposition members support fixing "lost Canadians" but criticize the bill for potentially diluting citizenship, lacking security checks, and not providing estimates of impact or cost. The Bloc supports the bill's principle but highlights immigration system dysfunction. 57300 words, 7 hours in 2 segments: 1 2.

Statements by Members

Question Period

The Conservatives criticize the government's broken promises on tax cuts, highlighting high grocery prices and increased spending on consultants. They raise concerns about the Prime Minister's conflicts of interest and condemn Liberal soft-on-crime policies, citing rising violent crime and repeat offenders released on bail. The party also addresses the housing crisis and "anti-energy laws" preventing pipeline construction.
The Liberals highlight an income tax cut for 22 million Canadians, aiming to put up to $840 in pockets. They focus on building one Canadian economy via major projects like steel and aluminum, aiming for the strongest in the G7. They also discuss being tough on crime, planning to stiffen bail rules and impose stricter sentences, alongside defence investment, housing, and Indigenous relations.
The Bloc questions the government's handling of the tariff crisis, calling the Prime Minister's strategy a failure. They raise concerns about potential conflicts of interest related to Bill C-5, accusing the Prime Minister of benefitting Brookfield.
The NDP criticize Bill C-5 for violating Indigenous and constitutional rights and bypassing environmental reviews, calling for its withdrawal.

Adjournment Debates

Housing affordability for Canadians Jacob Mantle questions the Liberal's housing strategy, citing rising home prices in his riding and a lack of choice for buyers. Caroline Desrochers defends the government's plan, highlighting tax cuts, the 'build Canada homes' initiative and modular construction. Mantle asks about meeting the goal of 500,000 new homes annually.
Canadian energy production Cathay Wagantall accuses the government of sabotaging energy resources and calls for the repeal of anti-development laws. Corey Hogan cites growth in Canadian oil and gas production and argues that social and environmental protections are pro-development. Wagantall asks why the government doesn't repeal laws it admits don't work.
Housing crisis and affordability Eric Melillo raises concerns about the Liberal's unfulfilled promise to build 4,000 housing units using surplus properties, citing the Auditor General's report. Caroline Desrochers defends the government's comprehensive housing plan, highlighting investments and initiatives to increase housing supply and affordability, and accusing Melillo of focusing on only part of the Auditor General's report.
Was this summary helpful and accurate?

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:35 p.m.

Winnipeg North Manitoba

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Mr. Speaker, I am sure the member realizes that the legislation is before us, in good part, because of a decision that was made in an Ontario superior court. In that decision, there is reference to a double standard. The administration of Stephen Harper made changes, in essence establishing two tiers of Canadians: those born here in Canada and those who are naturalized here in Canada, becoming permanent residents and eventually citizens.

Does the member, and the Conservative Party, believe today that it is okay to have a double standard for Canadian citizens?

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:40 p.m.

Conservative

Vincent Ho Conservative Richmond Hill South, ON

Mr. Speaker, rights come with responsibilities. Citizenship is more than a legal status; it is a bond to this country.

If someone has never lived here, never contributed and never shown any connection to Canada beyond a parent's passport, how can we say they are truly Canadian? We are not talking about military families or aid workers here. We are talking about a wide open policy with no limits and no accountability. That is not compassion. That is recklessness.

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:40 p.m.

Conservative

Connie Cody Conservative Cambridge, ON

Mr. Speaker, right now the Liberals are criticizing Harper's first-generation limit and claiming they need to fix the system. I decided to go look at Hansard, and the Liberals passed a unanimous consent motion to pass Bill C-37 at all stages on February 15, 2008.

Why is it that Liberals continue to mislead the House? Would the member agree that the Liberals today are a far cry from the Liberals from a generation ago, who believed in all-party consensus on immigration policies?

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:40 p.m.

Conservative

Vincent Ho Conservative Richmond Hill South, ON

Mr. Speaker, let us be clear here. This is not about punishing Canadians born abroad. It is about respecting the meaning of Canadian citizenship.

My constituents in Richmond Hill South did not get citizenship handed to them by bloodline. They earned it. They waited. They worked. They sacrificed. All we are saying is, if someone wants citizenship, they should show the same commitment.

The bill erases that standard and replaces it with a bloodline test. That is not fairness. It is privilege. Conservatives believe in equal opportunity, not automatic entitlements.

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:40 p.m.

Conservative

Frank Caputo Conservative Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola, BC

Mr. Speaker, while we were prorogued, we had a special constituent born: Remi Robson Murray, the grandchild of my former teacher Cam Murray and the child of Aidan and Jessie. I welcome Remi to our great Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.

I also want to give a special shout-out to my goddaughter, who is celebrating her graduation this weekend, Emery Britton. It has been a pleasure and an a honour watching her grow into the young woman she is. I am so proud of her.

To my hon. colleague, we have heard a lot of talk from the Liberals. Would he agree that over the last 10 years, their talk and their rhetoric have not matched their actions?

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:40 p.m.

Conservative

Vincent Ho Conservative Richmond Hill South, ON

Mr. Speaker, the Liberals have spent the last 10 years erasing our heritage and breaking our immigration system.

Instead of trying to fix that immigration system, fixing that backlog and capping the levels of immigration, they have decided to exploit this opportunity, a bill that was tabled by our side of the aisle under the Senate, and turn it into some vanity ideological project. It is simply insulting, and it is simply a mockery of everyday Canadians, especially immigrants who have worked hard their entire lives, and who have paid their dues, paid their taxes and contributed to Canada.

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:40 p.m.

Liberal

Bardish Chagger Liberal Waterloo, ON

Mr. Speaker, could the member perhaps just bring it back to the legislation? The fact is that with Canadian citizenship, rights and privileges do come with responsibilities, which I agree with.

Does the member agree that the right way to provide suggestions and amendments to the legislation would be at committee?

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:40 p.m.

Conservative

Vincent Ho Conservative Richmond Hill South, ON

Mr. Speaker, if the Liberals truly cared about fairness and cared about fixing their legislation, they would clear the backlog that real immigrants are facing right now, instead of turning the bill and this opportunity into a vanity ideological project.

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:40 p.m.

Trois-Rivières Québec

Liberal

Caroline Desrochers LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Housing and Infrastructure

Mr. Speaker, I want to start by saying that I will be sharing my time with the member for Spadina—Harbourfront.

I acknowledge that we are gathered on the traditional unceded territory of the Anishinabe Algonquin people.

I am pleased to rise today to speak to Bill C‑3 and the transformative power of Canadian citizenship. Fundamentally, this bill is about people, real families, as well as their history, their sacrifices and their deep and lasting ties with Canada, regardless of where their careers or lives take them.

I am an example of this myself. My two children were born in New York when I was completing my master's degree. Although they have lived in Canada for most of their lives and my ancestors settled in Batiscan, near Trois‑Rivières, in the 17th century, the law enacted by Stephen Harper's Conservative government could prevent my grandchildren from holding Canadian citizenship or require them to undergo security screening to ensure that they are entitled to citizenship should they decide to study or work in another country at some point in their lives. What the Conservative government did affects the choices of people who wish to study or work abroad because, if they do that, their children might not get Canadian citizenship.

Citizenship is a legal status, but more than that, it is about belonging to a diverse, welcoming community bound by shared democratic values. In today's world, where migration and mobility are facts of life, Canada has a chance to lead by example. While some countries restrict access to citizenship, Canada is taking a more principled approach with this bill, an approach that encompasses diversity, cross-border families and the lasting ties that Canadians have with other countries.

Many Canadians live and work abroad. There are Canadian expat communities in big cities all over the world. These expats work in a variety of fields, including international development, the arts, science, education, global trade and humanitarian work. These citizens have deep ties to Canada. They often move back here to raise children, take care of loved ones and build new communities. Taking action to make sure that their children can share this identity, even if they were born or adopted abroad, is not simply a matter of fairness. It also makes our country more cohesive and influential on the world stage.

Today, I want to share what new Canadians told us about why Canadian citizenship is important to them, how becoming a citizen affected them, and what we should do to continue to protect the rights, responsibilities and shared values of citizenship.

The act of becoming a Canadian citizen is often described as a very proud moment. As my Conservative colleague mentioned, people are proud to make Canada their home and proud of the journey they took to get here. Becoming a Canadian citizen is the culmination of years of sacrifice, hard work and perseverance, not just for the person themselves, but often for their whole family. It is a moment that connects them to their community. It is also an opportunity to take part in something greater than themselves.

Many MPs have had the honour of witnessing the emotional impact of that moment. Newcomers, often accompanied by their children, clutch their certificates tightly, knowing that their family's future is safer in our wonderful country. That feeling of pride goes beyond borders. People around the world hope to get the opportunity to make Canada their home. To those fleeing conflict, persecution and hardship, Canadian citizenship represents a fresh start, a second chance at life. It is a privilege that most do not take lightly.

The gratitude expressed by new citizens is profound. People often talk about the opportunities that Canada offers, especially when it comes to education, health care and peace. These pillars of Canadian life are the cornerstones of a better future, not only for new citizens themselves, but also for their children and future generations. Whether through volunteering, participating in local cultural events or simply getting to know their neighbours, new Canadians are actively involved in strengthening the fabric of our society. They embody Canada's spirit of generosity and contribute in many ways to the success of their communities.

As a government, we must remain vigilant in ensuring that Canadian citizenship remains a beacon of and a commitment to inclusivity, fairness and security. That is why we have introduced Bill C-3: to ensure that access to citizenship remains fair and transparent.

At a time when disinformation and division, including division here in the House, can threaten confidence in public institutions, Canada must show that its commitment to fairness extends across borders.

Providing thoughtful, inclusive pathways to citizenship beyond the first generation affirms that Canadian identity is shaped not only by place of birth, but also by connection, contribution and values.

This bill aims to automatically remedy the status of individuals who would have been Canadians were it not for the first-generation limit. It also creates a forward-looking new framework for citizenship by descent. In the future, children born abroad beyond the first generation will be eligible for citizenship if their Canadian parents can demonstrate a substantial connection to Canada. This is important. In the future, as long as the Canadian parent who was born abroad spends a cumulative total of three years in Canada before the birth of their child, their child will also be born a citizen. There is no need to be conducting security screening on babies.

The objective and structure of the Citizenship Act have been that children adopted abroad by Canadians and children born abroad to Canadians are treated as similarly as possible, and this will continue to be the case after Bill C‑3 comes into force.

The great privilege of Canadian citizenship comes with great responsibility. It is a responsibility to engage, to contribute and to build on the values that make our country what it is. Citizenship is not just a destination. It is a journey and a commitment to community, justice and mutual respect. This is why, once Bill C‑3 is passed, Canadians born outside Canada who adopt children abroad will have to meet the same substantial connection requirement to have access to the direct grant of citizenship for adoptees as they would have to meet to pass on their citizenship if they had a child born abroad. These children, whether adopted abroad or born abroad, will also have to meet the substantial connection requirement to pass on their citizenship if they have or adopt children abroad in the future.

In conclusion, obtaining Canadian citizenship is an important and emotional step. It is a privilege that entails opportunity and gratitude, as well as a responsibility to stay true to the values that unite us. Citizenship is not simply a legal matter. It is a reflection of who we are and who we include. By passing Bill C‑3, we will be choosing connection over exclusion, equity over limitation. We will be telling Canadians around the world and their children that their connection to our country is important and that their stories, contributions and sense of belonging are part of what makes Canada strong.

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:50 p.m.

Conservative

Brad Redekopp Conservative Saskatoon West, SK

Mr. Speaker, I listened to the speech intently. One thing we need to know as we study this bill in the House and maybe further in committee is the impact of it on Canada. In other words, how many people would this bill impact? How many new Canadians would it create?

I ask that because it is important. It would affect the administrative requirements of Canada with people applying for citizenship, applying for old age security and applying for passports. Also, there would be financial implications. If people are going to gain old age security, that is going to be a cost.

I wonder if the member has an idea of how many people this bill would impact and what the cost would be.

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:50 p.m.

Liberal

Caroline Desrochers Liberal Trois-Rivières, QC

Mr. Speaker, those are excellent questions that should be addressed at committee, which is the next step for this bill.

I see no reason to continue down the path of division. I think that enough Canadians have come forward. We have seen people here.

As a newly elected member, I was not here during the last Parliament, but I know that this bill has been under discussion for a very long time and that information has been shared and examined in committee. Now, I think that Canadians expect us to move our study of this bill forward.

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:55 p.m.

Winnipeg North Manitoba

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Mr. Speaker, I agree with the member that there has been a great deal of discussion over the years in regard to this particular issue. One could argue that we could date it all the way back to 2008-09. Whether it is debates inside the chamber or debates in committee rooms, there has been a great deal of discussion.

I hear there are concerns from the Conservative members, and I believe it would be beneficial for the Conservatives to have amendments. We are heading into the summer, and I am not convinced the bill is going to pass before the break, but it would be wonderful to have more dialogue and discussions about potential amendments.

Could I get the member's thoughts on that? The minister made it very clear in her opening remarks that as a minister, she is very open to ways the bill could be improved. Could she provide her thoughts on the willingness of the Minister of Immigration to hear amendments?

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:55 p.m.

The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec

Before I recognize the hon. parliamentary secretary, I would like to have members' attention.

As colleagues are entering the chamber before question period, there is a lot of noise. If we could, let us continue with debate.

The hon. parliamentary secretary.

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:55 p.m.

Liberal

Caroline Desrochers Liberal Trois-Rivières, QC

Mr. Speaker, yes, I believe the Conservatives are continuing a tradition of relying on divisive slogans and rhetoric.

As my colleagues and the minister herself pointed out this morning, we are open to amendments, as long as they are constructive and in the spirit of what we are trying to do, which is to fix the legislation that was passed in 2009.

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:55 p.m.

Liberal

Julie Dzerowicz Liberal Davenport, ON

Mr. Speaker, I have a very quick question for my hon. colleague, who gave an excellent speech. What is the importance of introducing this legislation right now?

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:55 p.m.

Liberal

Caroline Desrochers Liberal Trois-Rivières, QC

Mr. Speaker, we have been trying for a long time to get this through so we can right the wrongs of the past and fix what was put in place. I think it is important that we do this as quickly as possible.

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:55 p.m.

Bloc

Maxime Blanchette-Joncas Bloc Rimouski—La Matapédia, QC

Mr. Speaker, my colleague said that it is very important to pass this bill. Her government could have already done that, since it had a majority from 2015 to 2019. It knew both the problem and the solutions. This goes back to 2009.

Today, the government is telling us that we need to restore public confidence in our immigration system. We are not going to get there by recycling bills that have been dragging on for many years.

I would like an honest answer from my colleague. Does she really think that the bill will address the root of the problem within the Department of Citizenship and Immigration, which is the most dysfunctional department in the federal government?

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:55 p.m.

Liberal

Caroline Desrochers Liberal Trois-Rivières, QC

Mr. Speaker, I am a little confused, because I heard my colleague speaking earlier and it sounded like he agrees with the bill that was introduced.

I would say that we are continuing our efforts in that direction. As a newly elected member, I am looking ahead to the future with our new government.

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:55 p.m.

Taiaiako'n—Parkdale—High Park Ontario

Liberal

Karim Bardeesy LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Industry

Mr. Speaker, the member shared her family's story in the context of this bill.

Does she have any other stories she could share, perhaps in a different context, but still related to this bill?

Bill C-3 Citizenship ActGovernment Orders

1:55 p.m.

Liberal

Caroline Desrochers Liberal Trois-Rivières, QC

Mr. Speaker, earlier I shared the story of one of my constituents whose child was born prematurely while he was travelling. Now the child is three months old and needs medical care. Unfortunately, he cannot get his Canadian citizenship because his parents were born abroad. This means he cannot receive medical care because the Régie de l'assurance maladie du Québec, or RAMQ, refuses to issue him a health insurance card because he is not a Canadian citizen.

This issue is causing real problems for some children.

IranStatements by Members

2 p.m.

Liberal

Ali Ehsassi Liberal Willowdale, ON

Mr. Speaker, I rise today to address the escalating war between Iran and Israel.

For almost five decades, the Iranian regime has repressed its own citizens and exported violence beyond its borders, yet this odious Iranian regime certainly belongs to the dustbin of history. This military confrontation, however, should be constrained by the principles of international law and not be permitted to devolve into wanton destruction.

The citizens of Iran are in a particularly precarious spot. They have endured decade upon decade of brutal repression, and the overwhelming majority detest the theocratic regime in Tehran, yet they are caught in the crossfire of a war they are not responsible for and that is not of their making, nor is the Iranian regime making any provisions for their safety.

That is why Canada should call on all parties to this dispute to exercise maximum restraint and also fully embrace the recently announced diplomatic initiative—

IranStatements by Members

2 p.m.

The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia

The hon. member for Calgary Heritage has the floor.

Sati Rani KaurStatements by Members

June 19th, 2025 / 2 p.m.

Conservative

Shuv Majumdar Conservative Calgary Heritage, AB

Mr. Speaker, this is nearly a century in a minute. I rise today with a heavy yet grateful heart to honour my didu, Mrs. Sati Rani Kaur, who passed away peacefully at 94 on January 11 in Kolkata. Predeceased by my dadu, Mr. S. C. Kaur, she leaves behind three daughters; three sons-in-law; three grandchildren, including me; and three great-grandchildren. She was my last surviving grandparent, now with my father's parents, Hirenda Lal Majumdar and Sobhya Majumdar.

Didu's life was a tapestry woven through 94 years across British India and through decades of partition, liberation and decolonization. Raised in Bangladesh, she carried the resilience of a land shaped by struggle and independence. A Sanskrit scholar and educator, she taught students, including my father, in Rangoon before the turbulence of Burma's military junta, in Delhi amid India's fight for freedom and later in Kolkata, a city pulsing with a cultural rebirth.

Her strong will and Hindu heart defined her. She lived life on her own terms.

Om Shanti.

Oakville Family RibfestStatements by Members

2 p.m.

Liberal

Sima Acan Liberal Oakville West, ON

Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize one of Oakville's most anticipated community events, the Oakville Family Ribfest, starting today.

This annual celebration is made possible thanks to the tireless efforts of Oakville Lions Club and the Rotary Club of Oakville Trafalgar. Through the dedication of exceptional volunteers, Ribfest not only brings the community together but also raises critical funds to support our local charities. I also want to take a moment to recognize the incredible people of Oakville. Their generosity and community spirit are what make events like Ribfest so successful year after year.

Additionally, tomorrow I will be proud to welcome 70 bright students from Eastview Public School in my riding of Oakville West. These young leaders are the future of our country, and I look forward to sharing with them the important work we do here on behalf of all Canadians.

I would like to wish everyone a happy Canada Day.

National Indigenous Peoples DayStatements by Members

2 p.m.

Conservative

Billy Morin Conservative Edmonton Northwest, AB

[Member spoke in Cree and provided the following text:]

Neegan Ninaskomon Nohtwiynan kise manitou Kiya neegan kanigan nistamun oma waskigan Tansi Kitamskahtinawaw Kakiyaw Niwahkamahkanak Nahtohkitopi ekwa Wapikihew Nitsikason Maskekosihk ekwa Amiskwaciy waskihigan Ochi anoch Kinoteh kaskomtikohk Opaskahhopism nistano peyaksap kahkimeh Nehiway kisikaw

[Member provided the following translation:]

First I acknowledge our father, our kind creator. Mr. Speaker, the leader of this House, hello greetings, all my relatives. My name is Sacred Rider White Eagle. I am from the Enoch Cree Nation and Edmonton. I acknowledge June 21 as National Indigenous Peoples Day.

[English]

National Indigenous Peoples Day is a day of celebration for many things, including leaders who have built bridges between Canadians and first peoples.

I acknowledge two teachers of mine: Okimaw Notha Willie Littlechild from Maskwacis, a former Conservative member of Parliament, our international chief, and truth and reconciliation commissioner; and Victor Houle from Onihcikiskwapowin, a public servant with decades of experience with Indigenous Services Canada. It is often those humble, hard-working public servants who make the difference in the mission toward honouring treaty, Victor being one of them.

From this side of the House, we wish all those trailblazers and all peoples a good Saturday this Saturday, National Indigenous Peoples Day.