House of Commons Hansard #158 of the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was online.

Topics

line drawing of robot

This summary is computer-generated. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.

Alleged Premature Disclosure of Bill C-40—Speaker's Ruling Members consider the opposition’s allegation that Bill C-40 was disclosed to journalists before introduction; the Speaker finds insufficient evidence of a leak and rules there is no prima facie question of privilege. 1100 words.

Safe Social Media Act Second reading of Bill C-34. The bill would require social media platforms and AI chatbot services to reduce online harms, protect children through safer design and age-related safeguards, remove certain harmful content quickly, and disclose safety plans. It would establish a commission to oversee compliance and impose penalties. Members broadly support improving online safety but raise questions about privacy, free expression, enforcement, regulatory powers and consultation with provinces and Quebec. The House refers the bill to committee for study. 45600 words, 6 hours in 2 segments: 1 2.

Bill C-41—Proposal to Apply Standing Order 69.1 Kevin Lamoureux argues that Bill C-41 concerns only medical assistance in dying, not unrelated topics, and therefore is not an omnibus bill subject to separate votes under Standing Order 69.1. 400 words.

Statements by Members

Question Period

The Conservatives accuse the government of staging a futile EU summit, while demanding action on trade barriers and a threatened carbon tariff. They blame deficit spending for inflation and rising costs, criticize failures in anti-money-laundering oversight and bail policy, and raise concerns about immigration security screening, support for Canadian industry, and transparency around the Prime Minister’s wife’s appointment.
The Liberals emphasize diversifying trade through stronger European ties, energy cooperation, and expanding non-U.S. exports. They defend affordability supports and social programs, promote crime prevention and Indigenous policing, and highlight investment in industry, infrastructure, and ocean conservation. They also point to housing construction, high-speed rail, and efforts to cut red tape.
The Bloc warn that ending federal carbon pricing risks European tariffs on Quebec metals, while weakened pesticide rules could threaten agri-food exports. They also defend Quebec’s authority over its international relations and criticize Ottawa for disregarding Quebec’s prerogatives.
The NDP condemn Bill C-39’s environmental and Indigenous impacts amid wildfire-smoke deaths, and criticize the government for rising living costs and interest-rate hikes.

National Strategy for Soil Health Act Second reading of Bill S-230. The bill would require a national strategy to protect, conserve and improve soil health, including measures for research, information-sharing, consultation and parliamentary reporting. Supporters say it can coordinate expertise and strengthen food security and farm resilience; critics raise concerns about federal jurisdiction and argue that cuts to agricultural research undermine the bill’s goals. 8700 words, 1 hour.

Adjournment Debates

Firearms confiscation compensation Alex Ruff cites shipping problems in the firearms compensation program and asks whether owners will still be paid if administrative failures cause them to miss the deadline. Jacques Ramsay says affected owners will be accommodated and receive fair compensation. Ruff disputes the government’s description of banned firearms and asks Ramsay to define “military-style assault rifle”; Ramsay says experts identify them and points to broader gun-control measures.
Rural health care access Helena Konanz says resignations by Penticton’s neurologists and recurring emergency-room closures leave seniors in her rural riding without local care. She urges the federal government to adopt a “blue seal” program to fast-track unaccredited doctors. Kevin Lamoureux says credential recognition and residency placements are provincial responsibilities, while citing federal health funding and seniors’ dental coverage.
Spaceport contract oversight Greg McLean accuses the government of wasting defence funds on a $200-million contract with Maritime Launch Services, alleging excessive lease payments, inadequate oversight and benefits to company insiders. Mike Kelloway defends the agreement as a way to build sovereign launch capacity, citing Canadian spending requirements, project milestones and support from local and provincial partners.
Was this summary helpful and accurate?

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

5:05 p.m.

Bloc

Luc Thériault Bloc Montcalm, QC

Madam Speaker, if I were a bit of a joker, I would ask my colleague to repeat what he heard.

In any case, in a documentary from the early 1980s, if I remember correctly, entitled Comme en Californie, a computer whiz tells the interviewer that, one day, human beings would enjoy relationships more in front of a screen than in real life. Now that may be happening.

During a study on AI and the harms of artificial superintelligence at the Standing Committee on Access to Information, Privacy and Ethics, psychologists told us that, right now, chatbots can induce psychosis in people, even adults, who had no such symptoms before being in contact with a chatbot. That could take just 72 hours.

Would my colleague agree that the companies that manufacture this type of technology should be liable for the harmful effects and that compensation should be provided when such effects occur?

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

5:05 p.m.

Conservative

Luc Berthold Conservative Mégantic—L’Érable—Lotbinière, QC

Madam Speaker, I will not repeat what I hear on TV because it would be a little disrespectful, but it was not very pretty. It was a really horrible sound, enough to make me go back to the living room to see what was happening on television. That is all I will say.

Concerning my colleague's question, I think that is a different matter. Where mental health is concerned, I believe that everyone, even the web giants, has a role to play. We cannot allow anyone to manipulate the mental health of another person in any way. We cannot let people who have been manipulated in some way go untreated or without services. This is an important issue made all the worse when young people are involved, because they are even more easily manipulated, and their mental health is more easily affected.

I will say yes to anything that will spare young people problems like this. No matter what is involved, I am ready to give it my careful attention.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

5:10 p.m.

Conservative

Steven Bonk Conservative Souris—Moose Mountain, SK

Madam Speaker, I assume the Liberals are aiming to have some definite outcomes from this bill, but we are lacking definitions. For example, one of the main items they are discussing is online bullying, yet we still do not have an official definition of bullying. We do not even have a definition of the social media they are targeting.

Could my hon. colleague mention how on earth we can measure something when we do not even know the proper definitions to measure it by?

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

5:10 p.m.

Conservative

Luc Berthold Conservative Mégantic—L’Érable—Lotbinière, QC

Madam Speaker, I am going to pick up on the expression I used earlier. Is making the sound of an animal in heat bullying? It may not necessarily be so. It can give someone a fright. My Bloc Québécois colleague seemed a bit intimidated. This is indeed a very problematic situation. We need to define what constitutes bullying before determining the penalties for bullying.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

5:10 p.m.

The Assistant Deputy Speaker (Alexandra Mendès) Alexandra Mendes

Is the House ready for the question?

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

5:10 p.m.

Some hon. members

Question.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

5:10 p.m.

The Assistant Deputy Speaker (Alexandra Mendès) Alexandra Mendes

The question is on the motion.

If a member participating in person wishes that the motion be carried or carried on division, or if a member of a recognized party participating in person wishes to request a recorded division, I would invite them to rise and indicate it to the Chair.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

5:10 p.m.

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux Liberal Winnipeg North, MB

Madam Speaker, I request that it be passed on division, please.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

5:10 p.m.

The Assistant Deputy Speaker (Alexandra Mendès) Alexandra Mendes

I declare the motion carried on division. Accordingly, the bill stands referred to the Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage.

(Motion agreed to, bill read the second time and referred to a committee)

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

5:10 p.m.

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux Liberal Winnipeg North, MB

Madam Speaker, on a point of order, I suspect that if you were canvass the House, you would find unanimous consent to call it 5:30 p.m. so we can begin private members' hour.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

5:10 p.m.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

5:10 p.m.

Some hon. members

Agreed.

Bill S-230 National Strategy for Soil Health ActPrivate Members' Business

5:10 p.m.

Liberal

Dominique O'Rourke Liberal Guelph, ON

moved that Bill S-230, An Act respecting the development of a national strategy for soil health protection, conservation and enhancement, be read the second time and referred to a committee.

Madam Speaker, 8.2 billion people around the world have something in common. We all rely on the soil, the critical ground beneath our feet, to sustain us.

Globally, scientists estimate that the average soil depth on land is in the order of about only one metre. Of course, it can vary dramatically. Prime agricultural land in Ontario can often have only half a metre to one and a half metres of soil before reaching glacial deposits or bedrock, while some prairie soils can be two to three metres in depth. The life-supporting layer of life on Earth is remarkably shallow. It is extraordinarily valuable, and it is at risk.

The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations found that 33% of earth's soils are already degraded and over 90% could become degraded by 2050. In Ontario, 68% of Ontario's farmland is at risk of unsustainable soil loss. Like any scarce resource, we need to protect it, conserve it and enhance it, but this can only be done through a coordinated national approach to protecting Canada's soil resources.

That is why Bill S-230, an act respecting the development of a national strategy for soil health protection, conservation and enhancement, is so necessary and so timely. Introduced by Ontario senator Robert Black and passed in the Senate on March 26, Bill S-230 builds on the Senate's agriculture and forestry committee's excellent 2024 report entitled “Critical Ground: Why Soil is Essential to Canada's Economic, Environmental, Human, and Social Health”.

The title says it all. The report describes how this one metre of soil is essential for ecosystem services that enable all plant, animal and human life on earth. It is one metre for water purification and storage, climate and flood regulation, nutrient cycling, carbon sequestration, and the provision of food, fibre, fuel and habitat for organisms. I encourage everyone to look it up at SenCanada.ca.

It is a page-turner, a fascinating and thorough examination of soils across Canada, including forest soils and permafrost. It is informed by 153 witnesses, 74 briefs and fact-finding missions with farmers, producers, industry and researchers right across Canada. Someone who is not already fascinated with soil and soil health before they read this report will quickly become an advocate. Canada owes Senator Black a debt of gratitude for his lifetime of leadership in Canadian agriculture, and Parliament owes him a debt of gratitude for championing this legislation.

In the House, we often talk about Canada's food security. We talk about grocery prices, supply chains and our ability to produce and process more food here at home. They are important priorities, especially at a time when international trade uncertainty, rising production costs and extreme weather are placing pressure on Canadian farmers, families and food prices. However, there is another part of our food system that is so foundational and deserves much more attention, and that is the health of the soil that makes agricultural production possible.

Soil provides crops with essential nutrients and water, supports biodiversity, stores carbon and helps agricultural land withstand drought and heavy rainfall. When soil loses its structure, nutrients or organic matter, farmers can face lower productivity and higher costs and are more vulnerable to extreme weather. Those factors translate into higher costs at the grocery store for Canadians.

Restoring degraded soil can take years, even decades. According to the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, restoring soil health, biological activity, carbon content and water-holding capacity can take anywhere between five and 20 years under good management. Fully regenerating the soil can take centuries.

We use the word “generational” in the House quite a bit, and this is a generational issue. We use “vital” a lot in the House as well. What more appropriate word could apply to our soil health? Vitalis, meaning life, pertaining to life and necessary for life, captures the essential nature of healthy soils, which are necessary for our environmental, food security, sovereignty and economic needs.

The city of Guelph is home to more than 50 agricultural organizations, industry associations, research institutes and government agencies. That makes us one of Canada's largest agri-food innovation hubs. The Ontario Federation of Agriculture, the Ontario Soil and Crop Improvement Association, the Arrell Food Institute, Bioenterprise, and the Ontario Agri-Food Innovation Alliance all call Guelph home. The University of Guelph's Ontario Agricultural College is ranked number one in Canada and among the top 15 globally, anchoring world-leading soil and agri-food research right here in Ontario.

University initiatives such as Soils At Guelph connect researchers, farmers, industry and government to deliver real-world solutions across climate, crops, biology and water systems. State-of-the-art soil monitoring systems at the Ontario crops research centre in Elora are among the only facilities of their kind in North America, supporting Ontarian and Canadian producers with valuable agricultural data for more than 45 years.

We understand the important relationship among soil health, one health, and agricultural innovation and resilience. Every day, researchers in Guelph and right across Canada seek to make soils, plants and agriculture more resilient, more abundant and more affordable. These findings really matter to farmers, who are working every day to manage input costs, improve productivity and remain competitive, and who are extraordinary champions of soil health and protection.

It is an exciting time. Agriculture is increasingly high-tech. Farmers, producers and ranchers are using technology to protect and restore soil health by making agriculture more precise, efficient and sustainable. Using GPS-guided equipment, satellite imagery, soil sensors, AI and data analytics, farmers can apply water, fertilizer and crop protection products only where they are needed, reducing waste and minimizing impacts on soil and waterways.

New technologies also support practices such as cover cropping, reduced tillage and precision nutrient management, which help prevent erosion, build soil organic matter, improve water retention and increase resilience to drought and extreme weather. Together, all these innovations are enabling farmers to produce more food, while preserving the long-term health and productivity of the soil on which agriculture depends and on which we all depend. Understanding soil health is equally important in preparing Canadian agriculture for a changing climate.

In 2021, severe drought in the Prairies contributed to a 37% decline in Canadian wheat production. Healthy soil cannot prevent a drought, but better soil structure and higher organic matter can improve water retention and help agricultural systems become more resilient. Practical soil health solutions benefit both farmers and the environment, and demonstrate that agricultural productivity and environmental sustainability can be complementary. In fact, the long-term success of Canadian agriculture depends on it. Canadian farmers, producers and industry are leading in this respect.

Canada already has tremendous expertise. This bill calls for consolidation, enrichment and evolution of that expertise across the country to ensure that it informs and guides a coordinated, long-term national effort. Our government has already taken an important step toward achieving this goal. On March 26, the Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food announced the Government of Canada's commitment to advancing a national agricultural soil health strategy, alongside Senator Black and Alan Kruzel, farmer director at the Soil Conservation Council of Canada, with which the government will partner to develop the strategy.

This builds on the significant work already undertaken by the council, farmers and industry partners across the country who have been working on soil health strategies for years. However, without an overarching federal strategy, as proposed in this bill, we lack the ability to protect and conserve agricultural and forestry soils in this country.

This announcement marked an important step forward for Canadian agriculture: the recognition of soil as a critical national asset that supports the livelihood of Canadian farmers, our food security, agricultural productivity and environmental sustainability. This strategy will be informed through regular engagement with provinces and territories, indigenous agricultural groups, producer organizations, academia and industry, ensuring that regional realities and long-term agricultural priorities are reflected in this development.

Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada will also work with the Soil Conservation Council of Canada to establish a committee structure and advisory working groups, bringing together expertise in research, knowledge sharing, soil data and incentives to support sustainable agricultural practices. The objective is to build on existing knowledge, strengthen coordination, improve soil health information and support the long-term resilience of Canada's agricultural lands. It demonstrates that the government is already taking steps to advance a national approach to agricultural soil health, building on the momentum created by farmers, researchers, industry partners and Parliament.

The fact that work on a national strategy is already under way does not diminish the importance of this legislation. It reinforces it. The March announcement establishes a commitment to collaboration and action. Bill S-230 would complement that work by establishing a legislative framework with clear responsibilities and reporting requirements to support accountability over the longer term. Together these efforts would provide an opportunity to ensure that protecting and enhancing Canada's agricultural soils remains a national priority for generations to come.

The legislation also aligns with Canada's first national food security strategy announced by the Prime Minister in July. That strategy focuses on increasing grocery competition, expanding food processing in Canada, growing more fruits and vegetables year-round and reducing regulatory barriers. However, if we want Canadian farmers to produce more food, we must also protect the very foundation of our food system by keeping farmland and soils healthy, productive and resilient.

Time is of the essence, and the momentum is strong. That brings me to what Bill S-230 would accomplish. First, the legislation would require a national strategy that recognizes soil as a strategic national asset essential to domestic and international food security. We recognize the strategic importance of our energy resources, critical minerals and transportation infrastructure. Our agricultural soils deserve similar attention, because they sustain our ability to produce food, fibre and fuel. Importantly, the legislation would also connect soil health with agricultural production that is both sustainable and profitable.

Second, Bill S-230 would require measures to improve our understanding of the condition of Canadian soils. That includes examining degradation, compaction, nutrient availability, contamination, carbon content and water-holding capacity. Better information would help identify emerging risks, assess the effectiveness of different practices and guide future research and policy decisions.

Third, the bill would support education, research, technical assistance and knowledge sharing. This means helping farmers access practical information about effective soil management practices while recognizing the importance of indigenous knowledge and stewardship. It would also provide for consideration of a national soil information system to improve how knowledge is collected and shared, which is very important.

Fourth, the strategy would include recommendations concerning a national advocate for soil health, alongside appropriate targets, timelines and resources. This one is essential. These provisions matter, because national priorities need clear objectives and ways to measure progress. The legislation would also recognize diversity in Canada's agricultural regions. What works for a grain producer in Ontario may not be appropriate for a rancher in Alberta or a potato farmer in P.E.I. That is why meaningful consultation is essential.

Finally, Bill S-230 would establish an important accountability mechanism. The national strategy would have to be tabled in Parliament within two years of the legislation's coming into force. The minister would then be required to report on progress within three years after the strategy is tabled, and every three years thereafter. These reports would assess what has been implemented, what results have been achieved and what work remains outstanding.

We have established how urgent this is. Bill S-230 would provide an opportunity to reinforce the progress that has already been made and to support accountability for the years ahead. Our national food security strategy, our agricultural investments that support innovation and our environmental priorities all align. Soil health connects all three.

The work being done across Canada is a testament to what is possible when research, agricultural productivity and environmental stewardship come together. We have an opportunity to build on that progress, because protecting our soils today means protecting Canada's ability to feed itself tomorrow. It means carbon capture in our wetlands. It means healthy forest soils.

Soil health, our food security and sovereignty are not partisan issues. I hope all members of the House will support the bill's referral to committee.

Bill S-230 National Strategy for Soil Health ActPrivate Members' Business

October 29th, 2026 / 5:25 p.m.

Conservative

Kurt Holman Conservative London—Fanshawe, ON

Mr. Speaker, I rise today with concerns regarding this proposed act and also regarding the recent Liberal cuts to science and research for agriculture.

Yes, the member endorses the bill, but how can she endorse it with the Liberal government's making all these cuts?

Bill S-230 National Strategy for Soil Health ActPrivate Members' Business

5:25 p.m.

Liberal

Dominique O'Rourke Liberal Guelph, ON

Mr. Speaker, first I would acknowledge that the original private member's bill came from a member opposite. It is Senator Black who is carrying it forward for an important conversation.

I believe there is a lot of investment currently happening in agriculture research. I think the question is worth a conversation, and I will continue to support agricultural innovation and research in Canada.

Bill S-230 National Strategy for Soil Health ActPrivate Members' Business

5:25 p.m.

Bloc

Sébastien Lemire Bloc Abitibi—Témiscamingue, QC

Mr. Speaker, my colleague's speech was so long that we thought she was filibustering. We are accustomed to it. I serve with her on the Standing Committee on Transport, Infrastructure and Communities, and I recognize her patience. I was pleased to hear from her today.

One of the things our regions have in common is the academic work done there. The University of Guelph is renowned for its work on soil. The same is true of the Université du Québec en Abitibi-Témiscamingue and the Institut de recherche en agriculture et agroalimentaire. In that context, yes, there are collaborations.

For anyone really interested in soil health, would it not have been more appropriate for her to speak out, as my colleague suggested, against the cuts to science and research, and to propose investments in our university research chairs so that more data could be gathered, rather than encroaching on provincial jurisdictions?

Bill S-230 National Strategy for Soil Health ActPrivate Members' Business

5:30 p.m.

Liberal

Dominique O'Rourke Liberal Guelph, ON

Mr. Speaker, as we know, many of the studies carried out by the research institutes have been transferred to other research centres in Canada or to university centres. We can talk about the framework in which research can be conducted, but I can assure the House that I will be a champion for agri-food research in Canada.

Bill S-230 National Strategy for Soil Health ActPrivate Members' Business

5:30 p.m.

Liberal

Emma Harrison Liberal Peterborough, ON

Mr. Speaker, I would like to give an opportunity to my colleague from Guelph, which is the epicentre of so much research when it comes to agriculture, to say what it means for her to be the sponsor of this bill in the House.

Bill S-230 National Strategy for Soil Health ActPrivate Members' Business

5:30 p.m.

Liberal

Dominique O'Rourke Liberal Guelph, ON

Mr. Speaker, my colleague is a beef farmer, has restored the soil on her property and is an ardent champion of agriculture in Ontario. We talk a lot about the importance of agriculture. There was a lot of battling over who else would be able to speak to second reading of this private member's bill.

I think that when we are in a centre of agricultural excellence, when we are surrounded by farmland and when we understand what this would mean to our food security and our ability to feed the world, we cannot help but be extremely passionate about the topic.

Bill S-230 National Strategy for Soil Health ActPrivate Members' Business

5:30 p.m.

Conservative

Steven Bonk Conservative Souris—Moose Mountain, SK

Mr. Speaker, one thing we know is that most innovation in agriculture is driven by farmers. No one knows their land and their animals better than they do.

The member said in her speech that this can be achieved only through government action, yet we have seen that some of the most incredible innovation, of any field at all in Canada, is in agriculture. Why does she now think it has to be done by the government?

Bill S-230 National Strategy for Soil Health ActPrivate Members' Business

5:30 p.m.

Liberal

Dominique O'Rourke Liberal Guelph, ON

Mr. Speaker, it is not that at all, because we are acknowledging the work of the folks who have been doing this work for decades. We are acknowledging the work of universities and researchers. We are identifying what the gap is and a national system that could help coordinate, really supercharge, and have accountability for that.

One hundred and fifty-three witnesses spoke to the Senate's agriculture and forestry committee. This is absolutely about putting farmers, producers and ranchers in the middle of the conversation to see how we can help them and how we can reward them as well for supporting soil health.

Bill S-230 National Strategy for Soil Health ActPrivate Members' Business

5:30 p.m.

Bloc

Sébastien Lemire Bloc Abitibi—Témiscamingue, QC

Mr. Speaker, on the day that the bill was introduced, the minister announced that he was going to work with the Soil Conservation Council of Canada to create an agricultural soil health strategy. That is nice, but the council he created includes no representatives from Quebec. Not only is he introducing a bill that encroaches on Quebec's jurisdictions, but there are no Quebeckers to make their voices heard in Ottawa. Is there a problem?

Bill S-230 National Strategy for Soil Health ActPrivate Members' Business

5:30 p.m.

Liberal

Dominique O'Rourke Liberal Guelph, ON

Mr. Speaker, misleading people is really quite sad. This is a framework, and all provinces, including Quebec, will have to be consulted. Let us be clear. This is an extremely inclusive bill for producers, industry, researchers, governments and indigenous peoples.

Bill S-230 National Strategy for Soil Health ActPrivate Members' Business

5:30 p.m.

Conservative

John Barlow Conservative Foothills, AB

Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise to speak in favour of this bill, which comes from Senator Robert Black, who should be commended for the work that he and his team did on developing his soil study, which was released last year. One of the most important parts of this study is that it highlights what Canadian farmers are already doing. Over the last 10 or 11 years, the government has done all it can to mislabel farmers as a problem child, when we know that farmers are doing incredible work. I just want to highlight some of the incredible work they are doing.

The Global Institute for Food Security, out of Saskatoon, did a study a couple of years ago that highlighted the incredible work in conservation and soil health that Canadian farmers are already doing. For example, the carbon footprint of canola grown in Canada is 67% lower than the canola grown anywhere else in the world. A trainload of wheat grown in Canada can go around the world three times before it has the same carbon footprint as wheat grown in Europe. GHG emissions from agriculture in Canada are about 8% of our GHG emissions. If we compare that with the rest of the world, where the average is about 25%, it shows the incredible technology, innovation and advancements that have happened right here in Canada. Lastly, about 95% of Saskatchewan farmers are already using zero till or minimal till.

However, this is where the problem arises with the bill and what the government is claiming it wants to do. It is claiming it wants to highlight soil health and encourage Canadian farmers to do science and innovation, but the initiative I talked about, how 95% of Saskatchewan farmers are already doing minimal or zero till, was developed at the research centre in Indian Head, Saskatchewan. That technology or that type of precision agriculture would not have happened had it not been for the lengthy study and research of our top scientists at Indian Head. That research and science is no longer going to be happening, as the Liberal government has announced.

One of the first things the Liberal government announced after the election in 2025 was that it was going to shut down seven critical research farms and experimental farms right across this country. They include farms in Lacombe, Alberta; Indian Head, Saskatchewan; Swift Current, Saskatchewan; Portage la Prairie, Manitoba; Guelph, Ontario; Quebec City, Quebec; and Nappan, Nova Scotia. In fact, last Friday, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada had the dispersal sale of the beef herd in Nappan, Nova Scotia. One hundred and forty years of critical breeding and forage research has now been lost.

To the member for Guelph, who was talking about the importance of soil health in her speech, I want to highlight that every one of the research centres being shut down by the government was doing soil health research. I find it difficult that Liberal government members are saying how passionate they are about soil health and ensuring that agriculture has the tools it needs, when the first thing the minister and the government did when it came to agriculture was shut down seven critical research centres right across Canada. In fact, more than 50% of the cuts to employees at Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada came in science and innovation. More than 70% of the total budget cuts came in science and innovation.

One moment they are saying how important science, innovation and soil health are to Canadian agriculture, but on the other hand, they are dismantling the very foundation of the science, innovation and research that happen in Canada. They are dismantling that, making it extremely difficult for farmers to achieve the goals the Liberal government is setting out.

When it came to those budget cuts, it was not a budget decision; it was a principles and values decision. I want to give a couple of examples, if I may.

Closing these research centres is going to save the government about $200 million over a decade, but we are talking about $700 billion in new deficit spending over the next five years. Here are some things the government did spend money on: for Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, over the last five years, $16 million on consulting and management fees; $22 million on beans for women for empowerment in the Democratic Republic of the Congo; $20 million on building equitable climate-resilient African bean and insect sectors in Africa; $16 million on leveraging equity and gender-just poultry in Kenya; and $8 million on gender-just, low-carbon rice in Vietnam. It also put $8.5 million into a cricket factory that has now gone bankrupt.

They put $40 million into a prison farm which is millions of dollars over budget, and $8 million to transfer the barn at Rideau Hall into a storage facility. Out of more than $300 million in spending, that funding would have kept these research centres open and operating for a decade. This is not a budget decision, this is a values and priority decision by the government, and there are consequences to that.

Further to talking about how important soil health in food production is in Canada, Ontario, where my colleague who is sponsoring this bill lives, in Guelph, is losing 300 acres of farmland every single day. About nine farm families are being lost every single week. Our focus should be on protecting, or doing all we can to protect, critical and highly productive agriculture land. Yet the government is plowing ahead with a $150-billion high-speed rail, a train that no one will use, that will impact literally hundreds of thousands of acres of farmland and thousands of farmers.

I want to highlight one farmer, Wyatt McWilliams, who was at our agriculture committee a couple of weeks, ago talking about the impact that this is having on his farm, not knowing what the future of a generational farm will be in his Ontario community. What made his testimony so moving is Mr. McWilliams was one of the brothers who started the Hay West initiative in 2002 when western Canada was suffering a devastating drought. Mr. McWilliams got more than 1,000 family farms to donate 60,000 large bales of hay, which was moved across Canada to ensure that farmers in western Canada had feed for their cattle. He was given the Order of Canada for that initiative helping farmers in another part of this country.

However, his reward, for launching that initiative and stepping up when he was needed most, from the current government is it is going to expropriate his farm for the $150-billion high-speed rail that is going to go nowhere. No one is going to ride this.

When the government is again talking about the importance of food security and food sovereignty, how can it make that claim when on one side it is shutting down critical research centres and experimental farms and, on the other side, building a high-speed rail that is going to dissect thousands of farms across Ontario and Quebec? It kind of shows where the government priorities are.

We want to see how important this soil study is, but the government cannot profess to talk about how important this is when its actions are saying something completely different. That is something that we are trying to highlight. It is not that we are against this bill, we are trying to say we are against the hypocrisy of the Liberal government, when it is now saying how important farming is and how important Canadian agriculture is and we know that is simply not the case by the actions that are actually happening.

Now the government is talking about cozying up to the European Union, which could further devastate Canadian agriculture if we somehow have to abide by EU standards when it comes to maximum residue limits, pesticides, crop protection products, hormones or carcass washing. Already we cannot get our beef, pork and wheat into the European Union. Now the government wants to align itself even more with EU standards. An Irish farmer told us at committee a couple of weeks ago that trying to farm in the EU is cruel. Those were her words exactly.

As Conservatives, we certainly support the premise of this bill and again applaud Senator Black for all of his work and for being an incredible champion for Canadian agriculture. We certainly look forward to seeing where this study will go and highlight the incredible work that Canadian farmers are already doing. As Conservatives, we will continue to fight for our farmers to ensure that they have the tools they need to be competitive and economically viable and to continue to grow.

Bill S-230 National Strategy for Soil Health ActPrivate Members' Business

5:40 p.m.

Bloc

Sébastien Lemire Bloc Abitibi—Témiscamingue, QC

Mr. Speaker, it is never easy to rise after the member for Foothills. I hope I will be forgiven if my remarks are not quite as lively as his.

I am nevertheless pleased to take part in this debate because Quebec is a nation recognized internationally for its abundant natural resources. In Abitibi—Témiscamingue, for example, we are known for our water. Thanks to our eskers, we are home to one of the largest sources of pure water anywhere. It is no coincidence that our water has even won international awards. Our predominantly boreal forests form part of one of the largest forest ecosystems on the planet. They sustain our communities. They capture and store immense quantities of carbon. Beneath our feet lie gold and copper, which have made our region renowned for mining.

That said, there is one resource that receives far less attention. It is a resource we do not see because we walk on it every day. I am speaking, of course, about soil. We have plenty of it in Abitibi—Témiscamingue. We are also home to the Institut de recherche en agriculture et en agroalimentaire, or IRAA, at the Université du Québec en Abitibi‑Témiscamingue, known as UQAT. We even have a leading expert on our soils: Vincent Poirier, director of UQAT, whom I would like to acknowledge today.

During his recent appearance before the Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food, Mr. Poirier pointed out just how detrimental the cuts to Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada's research centres and experimental farms would be, because it is impossible to conduct research without being in the field. He had this to say:

Soil can't be moved. It's unthinkable to do that. It's also impossible to move climate conditions. We can try our very best, but there's so much complexity involved in the natural environment that I would say it's unrealistic to think that we can recreate everything under controlled conditions.

That is the backdrop against which this bill is being introduced. This bill calls on the government to develop a national strategy to protect, conserve and enhance the health of agricultural soil. Maintaining research funding would have been a good start. We also need to put the bill into context. Right now, we are also dealing with the Alto high-speed rail project, which is going to absolutely destroy some of the best farmland in Quebec and Ontario. No one in the Liberal Party or on either the Standing Committee on Transport, Infrastructure and Communities or the Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food wants to address the actual consequences of this project, and yet, the Senate is telling us in this bill that we need to protect farmland. Does anyone understand where the Liberals are headed now?

I am forgetting an important point. This bill is yet another federal intrusion into areas of provincial jurisdiction. Once again, the federal government is trying to dictate what the provinces should do, especially since the bill speaks of “consulting” the provinces when, in reality, their consent should be required. Without consent, the answer is no. I think that should be obvious. What is more, Quebec is already taking action and has already made progress in protecting its farmland. It already has a plan for sustainable agriculture that was tabled by the ministry of agriculture, fisheries and food, and I would like to congratulate its new minister on his appointment.

The Act respecting the preservation of agricultural land and agricultural activities and the Commission de protection du territoire agricole du Québec are also important pillars of soil protection and the preservation of Quebec's agricultural lands. Together, they form the backbone of a comprehensive framework developed and tailored to Quebec's realities.

Incidentally, Alto should also be required to comply with that Quebec legislative framework. I would very much like my Liberal colleagues to confirm that the Alto project will be subject to an assessment of its impact on Quebec's agricultural land and that it will obtain authorization from the Commission de protection du territoire agricole du Québec. In the interest of getting this right, it seems to me that this project cannot simply sidestep the most basic laws. I imagine Bill C‑39 probably already includes provisions that would allow it to do just that. I will not apologize for that aside.

My point, once again, is that Quebec has already taken action. Why, then, does Canada need to adopt this policy? Is it because some provinces are reluctant to act? If certain provinces wish to sacrifice their agricultural land, that is their choice. It is not up to Ottawa to tell them what to do.

Another thing that astonishes me is that, on the very day this bill was introduced, the Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food announced that he would be working with the Soil Conservation Council of Canada to develop a national soil strategy. What is even more astonishing, however, is the composition of that organization's board of directors: Not a single Quebecker sits on it.

I will say it again: There are no members from Quebec. In other words, the strategy is being developed by an organization that has no roots in Quebec. They are unfamiliar with Quebec's reality, so how can the minister delegate the development of a strategy that he considers important for Canada to a group that does not, in fact, represent the whole of Canada? This is the most basic of principles.

What also shocks me is that two of the seats are held by people who serve on the boards of Fertilizer Canada and CropLife Canada, two organizations that advocate for the use of pesticides and chemical inputs. That amounts to putting the fox in charge of the henhouse. Pesticides and chemical inputs have a harmful impact on the quality of our soil. Everyone knows that. This shows that, with Bills C-30 and C-31, the government has sided with the pesticide and chemical input companies, as well as giving them a seat at the table. However, it has failed to ensure Quebec is represented.

Instead of investing in and continuing research at Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada's research centres and experimental farms to discover new plant varieties and new, more regenerative practices, the government is placing even more importance on the chemical inputs and pesticides industry.

That said, when we talk about market diversification, the European Union's presence in Canada over the coming days is a reminder that Europe should be one of the markets we are targeting. However, our pesticide policies are causing Europe to close its doors to many of our agricultural products, precisely because of the use of these pesticides.

In short, this soil strategy and this bill are first and foremost about forcing Canadian provinces to protect their farmland. However, Quebec is already at the forefront in this respect. A few examples of what Quebec is doing include tools like Info-Sols, which provides an overview of Quebec's soils; OGeMOS, a simulation tool for soil management; and Terranimo, a web-based application to assess the risks to agricultural soils. That is not even mentioning the fertilization reference documents and the various pesticide regulations that Quebec has developed.

Today, we are witnessing another attempt by the government to interfere in the jurisdictions of the provinces and Quebec. If Ottawa truly wanted to protect farmland, it would start by asking its members on the Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food to study the Alto project immediately, to better understand its impact on farmland. If we truly want to recognize farmland as a strategic national asset, that begins with a government that refuses to sacrifice its best land in Quebec and Ontario essentially to save an hour of travel time.

In closing, I would like to accept the olive branch extended to me by my colleague from Guelph during questions and comments and simply say this: If she thinks what I am saying is untrue because our interpretations differ, yet she wants the support of the Bloc Québécois, she should try to convince us rather than accuse us of saying falsehoods.