I am now ready to rule on the question of privilege raised on October 6, 2026, by the House leader of the official opposition concerning the alleged premature disclosure of Bill C-40, an act respecting production, procurement and investment in relation to national defence and national security.
During his intervention, the House leader of the official opposition argued that specific details of Bill C-40 had been shared with journalists before the bill was introduced in the House. He based his assertion on two news articles published before the bill was introduced in the House, which, in his opinion, provided substantive information that could not have been gleaned from the title of the bill, nor deduced from previous government consultations and announcements. The member noted that these articles cited anonymous sources who were not authorized to discuss this information publicly. He posited that such a disclosure constituted a contempt of the House.
For his part, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House asserted that there is no prima facie question of privilege. He assured the House that, following its own investigation, the government found no evidence that anyone leaked the contents of the bill while it was on notice. The parliamentary secretary also argued that the legislative details discussed in the news articles in question have been in the public domain as matters of government policy for some time, speaking specifically to deliberations and consultations undertaken by the government on defence procurement and other topics related to the bill. He assured the House that these conversations did not occur at a time even close to the notice of the bill. Finally, he suggested that the information cited in the news articles was at times speculative and uncertain, casting further doubt on the possibility that specific provisions of the bill were divulged.
During a second intervention, the House leader of the official opposition sought to rebut some of the parliamentary secretary's arguments. He questioned the scope and thoroughness of the government's investigation before it concluded that no internal leak had occurred. He also argued that the policy information the government claimed was already in the public domain could not account for everything revealed in the news articles.
Members are right to affirm that it is a long-standing expectation that the House must be the first to be informed of the details of specific legislative measures that will come before it. As explained by Speaker Milliken in his ruling of March 19, 2001, on page 1840 of the Debates:
The convention of the confidentiality of bills on notice is necessary, not only so that members themselves may be well informed, but also because of the pre-eminent [role] which the House plays and must play in the legislative affairs of the nation.
The Chair has on many occasions been asked to rule on matters regarding the right of the House to have first access to legislative measures, including recently in the current session. One factor to consider is whether the allegation has been met with any admission or denial of responsibility, or alternative explanations. In the case before us, the Chair is faced with two different assertions, one claiming that the rights of the House were violated, and another, from the government, denying that details of one of its bills were prematurely divulged. In other words, the facts are disputed. This is reminiscent of other situations where, taking members at their word, the Chair was reluctant to intervene.
However, it is important to note that the government's responsibility is not the only element that must be considered by the Chair. Speaker Rota stated on March 9, 2021, at page 4762 of the Debates:
While there is indeed a well-established practice that a member must be taken at their word, the fact remains that the government's stating that it is not responsible for the premature disclosure of a bill is not in itself sufficient to convince the Chair. I would add that the source of information is one factor among others and that it is important first and foremost to determine whether precise details were provided before the House was made aware of them. The Chair must thus take into consideration all the information before it and reach a conclusion based on the facts presented by the members.
With this in mind, I felt it appropriate to review the news articles in question and the text of Bill C-40 now before the House. Having done so, I find that the similarities between the text of the bill and the details in the news articles remain at a high level and do not provide sufficient grounds to conclude that a leak of the bill itself has occurred. Further to this point, while members may be correct in stating that the details published in the news articles go beyond what is revealed in the bill's long title, this cannot stand as a reliable test for judging whether the precise contents of a bill have been divulged.
The Chair also notes that the news articles do not directly address the question of whether the sources cited had access to a copy of the bill itself, or to its specific provisions, and were therefore even in a position to share it, nor has any convincing evidence been brought to the Chair's attention that would demonstrate that the sharing of information between the sources and journalists, or between the government and the sources, took place in the window between when the bill was placed on notice and when the bill was introduced.
During his intervention, the parliamentary secretary stated that related public consultations were taking place well before Bill C-40 was placed on notice. As Speaker Regan affirmed in his ruling of June 8, 2017, at page 12320 of the Debates:
The right of the House to first access to legislation is one of our oldest conventions. It does and must, however, coexist with the need of governments to consult widely, with the public and stakeholders alike, on issues and policies in the preparation of legislation.
After reviewing all the evidence provided, the Chair cannot determine with any degree of certainty that the entirety of the bill, or specific sections thereof, were divulged prior to its introduction in the House. The government's assurance that it has no knowledge of a leak, the substance of the details published in the news articles and the lack of clarity around the nature and timing of the anonymous sources' information all contribute to this conclusion. Accordingly, the Chair does not find that this case constitutes a prima facie question of privilege.
