Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to rise on behalf of the residents of Simcoe North to speak to a very important issue.
I recognize that many arguments have been made. Some have talked about process with respect to MAID. Some have talked about how the government has implemented time allocation to cut off debate on a vast expansion of medical assistance in dying.
The Liberals are not being totally genuine in their approach, because they suggest that this bill has to be fast-tracked because of a court decision that a bill has to be passed by the spring. That is only half true. It relates to only one section of the bill, which is whether MAID should be expanded to include individuals whose sole condition is that they are suffering from a mental illness.
This is the first time the House has considered language to expand MAID for advance directives. It is the first time this chamber has been given that language. That was just a couple of weeks ago, and here we are, fast-tracking this bill to go to committee. Yes, there has been a MAID joint committee with the Senate, but members of this chamber have just received the text mere weeks ago, and we are being asked to fast-track it through Parliament.
I do not expect that I will persuade colleagues on an emotional argument, but I think, from a process perspective, that these are highly regrettable actions by the government.
If I may, I will turn to an angle or aspect that I think deserves further consideration. When we, not just parliamentarians but many Canadians, think about MAID, we often think about the textbook examples. By that I mean the examples that clearly fall within any of the legal guidelines. We do not consider the edge cases, the cases that are in the grey zone, or the cases that are debatable or where there may be differing opinions.
I will use an example to illustrate my point. Did members know that a significant majority of Canadians would like to see capital punishment reinstated in Canada for murder? In fact, it is over 60%. I think that is because, when people consider whether capital punishment should be reinstated, they think about the textbook case, the heinous crime and the offender who is 100% guilty, beyond a reasonable doubt, of some of the most grotesque crimes and murders of innocent people. People think of that as the use case for capital punishment.
I would submit that we should not be talking about the textbook cases. We should be talking about the edge cases, the cases that do not fall squarely within the bounds of the law, where someone might have made a mistake in a criminal case, so then an innocent person might be wrongly put to death. That is the reason many Canadians do not support reinstating capital punishment: An innocent person could be killed because of a mistake, or what I will call an edge case.
That same position or way of thinking has come up or is evidenced by some of the discussion here. I have incredible sympathy for any member of the House who feels differently from how I do about expanding MAID for advance directives. I think we should all be given the opportunity to have our own personal view, and I am glad that we will be having a free vote on this side of the House.
However, I am not thinking about the textbook compassionate case. I am thinking about the case where we are not sure, where someone might change their mind but we do not know, or worse, where someone might feel pressured or coerced into making a decision that they cannot reverse at a later date. We are also being asked to expand the application of MAID to a group of individuals. This would largely be the single biggest expansion of a subset of individuals that would become eligible for MAID, without the system's assurances or evidence that the system can even implement the safeguards today.
Let me repeat that. The system with today's safeguards is riddled with examples of people who may have accessed MAID but should not have accessed MAID, because the safeguards did not work for them. The chamber is being asked to expand the eligibility criteria for MAID to a system that has shown itself incapable of administering the safeguards appropriately today.
Let me give a couple of examples. There is the case of a 26-year-old Ontario man who requested MAID multiple times in Ontario and was denied because he did not meet the criteria, according to physicians in Ontario. He found his way to British Columbia in order to receive MAID.
There is the 61-year-old in British Columbia whose only listed criterion for MAID was hearing loss, who received MAID after only one month. That case is not even supposed to fit within the current legal framework, yet it happened.
There is the case of a London, Ontario doctor who assessed a patient with inflammatory bowel disease and a history of mental health issues outside a Tim Hortons and later personally drove that individual to receive MAID.
These are not fictional cases. These are cases today, where the current safeguards have not been implemented appropriately. What is worse is that Parliament is being asked to expand MAID without the ability to even question the regulatory bodies that are responsible for implementing the safeguards on MAID today. They have refused to show up to the committee. The physicians and surgeons in Ontario have not appeared before committee. They have been asked. The College of Physicians and Surgeons of British Columbia have been requested to appear before committee. They have refused. How is it possible or appropriate for members of Parliament not to be able to test the very bodies that are supposed to implement the safeguards to expand MAID when they will not even answer questions about how they are doing today?
The coroner in Ontario looked at over 4,000 deaths and identified that 88% of them fell within the legal framework but almost 13% needed further investigation. What happened with those 13% of cases? We do not know the full story, because we cannot ask and get the questions answered, and there has been no provincial legislature that has tried to get those answers either.
I find it highly regrettable that we are going to make this decision without all of the available facts, and I hold no ill will against any other members who feel differently for reasons of emotion or compassion. I think those are valid views about these compassionate textbook cases, but I think about some of the cases that are not textbook, and I think the current system shows us that a number of those cases exist. They are not few and far between, and I would submit that if even one individual has their life ended who might otherwise not have wanted it, it would be a travesty and something we should seriously consider.
