Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the residents of King—Vaughan, especially on a topic as important as this one.
The Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying heard considerable concerns about safeguards and oversights in the MAID process. There are serious moral and legal considerations when we discuss MAID for Canadians whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness. We are asking whether it is possible to know with enough certainty to make an irreversible decision that a person's condition would never improve.
After hearing from experts and the people directly affected, it recommended keeping the exclusion in place indefinitely. I support that recommendation. The most important thing we need to keep front and centre in this debate is that MAID must never become a cheaper or easier alternative to providing real and effective support to Canadians who are suffering. We cannot tell Canadians in a vulnerable state that the help they need is many months or even years away and then turn around and tell them that MAID is the option.
When someone finally works up the courage to ask for help and is told they will have to wait six months, what are they supposed to do tonight? What are they supposed to do tomorrow? We have a responsibility to make sure that Canadians have access to those supports when they need them most.
Bill C-41 would keep the exclusion in place for Canadians whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness. The government should instead bring forward a separate bill to maintain this exclusion, so that the House can debate and vote on that question on its own. The committee has given Parliament a clear recommendation, and the House should act on it, but questions that were raised when the government first introduced MAID are still being raised today: How do we make sure that consent is freely given when someone feels they have run out of options? What guidance do doctors have when they are uncertain about eligibility? How do we know whether a person has had a genuine opportunity to access the care that might have helped them? Being told that a treatment exists is one thing. Being able to find a doctor who provides it, affording it, getting it and receiving that treatment when one needs it is another.
Canadian seniors are concerned about safeguards. They want to know that when they go to the hospital for treatment, they will get the care they came for. A senior recently told me that a family member brought her to the hospital because she had a bad flu. They told me that during that visit, they were offered MAID without asking about it. They are now afraid to go back to the hospital. The next time this senior falls ill and their family tells them they need to go to the hospital, they may hesitate. They may stay home longer than they should. Many seniors in this country are already in a vulnerable situation. They should be able to go to the hospital, tell the doctor exactly what they are going through and feel confident that they will get the care they need.
There is one thing I am crystal clear on. Canadians who are suffering from mental illness and who can get better must have the opportunity to get better. They should never feel pushed toward an irreversible decision because they could not get the help they needed. Someone may have already tried several treatments. They may have been referred to a specialist and spent months waiting to be seen. They may be relying on a family member who is doing everything they can to help and has run out of places to call. Those Canadians are asking for something very practical. They need an appointment they can get to, treatment they can afford and someone they can call when things get worse.
We are in no position to make MAID available to people whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness. It would also be profoundly unfair to this country's medical professionals to put them in such a difficult moral and legal position. A doctor may know that another treatment is worth trying and also know that their patient cannot afford it or cannot get an appointment. We need to take seriously what that means for the patients and the doctors as well.
We cannot tell veterans who have fought and suffered for this country that the care they need, the treatment they need and the medication they need are months away and then turn around and raise MAID in the meantime. It is an insult to their service, their courage and their love of this great country. A veteran who calls for help should be able to say how difficult things have become and know that the person on the other end of that call will help them get care. They should be able to ask when they will see a specialist, what help is available while they wait, and who they can call if things get worse. After all we have asked of them, they should never have to wonder whether asking for that help was a mistake.
We need to see how the existing safeguards work in practice, especially in the most difficult cases. If a patient or a family member raises a concern, who hears it? Who reviews what happens? How does Parliament find out whether the safeguards we put in place are being followed? These questions matter to the Canadians who depend on us right now.
The special joint committee has heard serious concerns about the safeguards and oversights. It is up to us as parliamentarians to take those concerns seriously. We need to listen to doctors, nurses and legal experts. We need to hear from veterans and veterans groups, Canadians living with mental illness, Canadians with disabilities, and seniors and their families, who are often the first to see when someone is struggling. They can tell us whether the system worked for them and where they were left trying to find out on their own.
When we ask a committee to listen to those Canadians and bring forward recommendations, we have a responsibility to act on what we heard. Conservatives will continue to work in the House to make sure those voices are heard. We will fight to keep the exclusion in place for Canadians whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness. We will keep pressing for safeguards that work in practice and for Canadians who reach for mental health support to get the help they ask for.
When a senior goes to the hospital, when a veteran calls for treatment or when a Canadian who has been struggling for months finally asks for help, they should be able to count on us to make that help available. No Canadian should ever feel that MAID is their only option because the help they asked for never came.
