Madam Speaker, I will be rising in opposition to Bill C-41 and the use of time allocation for a bill that every Canadian has a legitimate opinion on.
There are two provisions in this bill, which are advance requests and excluding mental illness as the sole underlying condition for MAID eligibility. I will ask members to excuse my political cynicism, but the Liberals have voted down two Conservative bills in the last two years, Bill C-314 in the last Parliament and Bill C-218 in this Parliament, which would have permanently excluded mental illness as a condition for MAID eligibility, as is in the legislation today. Now they have used time allocation to force through a bill that deserves serious consideration. They are proposing the same permanent exclusion for mental illness, while tying it to the separate and deeply consequential second issue before the House of advance requests. My remarks will mostly focus on that.
For my constituents, in 2016, Parliament passed Bill C-14, which legalized medical assistance in dying. Bill C-14 required that, to qualify for MAID, a person must have a grievous and irremediable medical condition, be experiencing intolerable suffering and have a natural death that was reasonably foreseeable.
In 2019, the Quebec Superior Court ruled that the reasonably foreseeable requirement was unconstitutional. This led to the introduction of Bill C-7 by Mr. Lametti, which separated MAID applicants into track 1, those whose natural death is reasonably foreseeable, and track 2, those whose natural death is not reasonably foreseeable. Bill C-7 also introduced the waiver of final consent, wherein a person who had already been assessed and approved for MAID could sign an agreement allowing MAID to proceed if they were to lose capacity before the scheduled procedure.
Today, through Bill C-41, the government is seeking to expand that concept into advance requests. An advance request is a written directive made by a person, while they still have decision-making capacity, asking to receive MAID in the future if specified circumstances occur and they are no longer capable of consenting at that time. For example, a 70-year-old diagnosed with Alzheimer's could say, “If I no longer recognize my spouse or children, cannot communicate meaningful choices and require complete assistance with all daily activities, I want MAID to be provided.” Since the individual will be unable to provide consent in the future, it will be left at the discretion of their medical provider to determine when the criteria are met.
Importantly, Bill C-41 does not restrict advance requests to people whose natural death is reasonably foreseeable. Therefore, it would extend to track 2 cases. This means that someone who is not approaching the end of their life could receive MAID just because they have lost certain physical or cognitive abilities, or maybe their life circumstances have changed. That is a key point right there. The Council of Canadian Academies warned the government in 2018 that no combination of safeguards can eliminate every risk of someone receiving an assisted death against their wishes. This is a key point. Can we respect individual autonomy under advance requests?
Even Liberal MPs and cabinet ministers have previously acknowledged these key concerns. In 2024, the former minister of health, Mark Holland, said in a discussion about advance requests, it only stands to reason that we should take a few more months to make sure that the system is ready, to hold a conversation and to allow everyone in every family across Canada to participate. The actions of the government today show no such restraint. The Liberals are tying two separate issues together.
Also in 2024, the member for Thunder Bay—Rainy River, who served on the MAID committee and who is a physician, raised concerns about the willingness of some MAID practitioners to approve requests. He said, “there are a lot of MAID practitioners who are very zealous about its being all about one's personal autonomy and saying it is not for them to question someone's suffering, and who are quick to approve people.” This is too serious of an issue to face time allocation today. Parliament must take the time to unpack and examine the safeguards surrounding another expansion of MAID in Canada.
Let us look at some of the dangers of advance requests. Number one is the loss of contemporaneous consent. An advance request cannot fully anticipate a person's future quality of life. Dementia Justice Canada has raised concerns about the proposed safeguards in Bill C-41 and stated that, “if the practitioner...is uncertain whether the person's words, sounds, or gestures amount to a refusal, Bill C-41 does not set a limit on the number of times the practitioner can try again.... The practitioner must only wait 30 days each time. Repeated attempts could continue until the person gives up or loses the ability to resist.”
Inclusion Canada CEO, Krista Carr, has also warned, “Consent at the time is the most basic protection a person has. Parliament should not take it away.”
My second concern is that advance requests could turn failures in health care and social support into reasons for death. People may consider MAID because the support they need is inadequate, inaccessible or delayed. A deteriorating health care system can undermine the meaningfulness of individual choice. For example, a paraplegic who has lost social support could request MAID even if their death was not reasonably foreseeable.
Consider the circumstances facing many Canadians with disabilities, such as long waits for medical treatment and specialist care, limited access to mental health services, inaccessible or unaffordable housing, social isolation, or insufficient community support. Failures of our health care and social support systems should not become reasons for someone to pursue medical assistance in dying, but they already are.
A running issue in my community is whether we even have health care services. This spring, Mission Memorial Hospital's ER experienced 51 consecutive days of overnight closure. These are hard questions, and Parliament is not given adequate time to discuss them.
My third point is that disabilities may be treated as a source of suffering. The disability advocacy group Living with Dignity has raised concerns about the potential normalization of MAID for people experiencing significant impairments. The organization stated, “What they need is help to live, not medical aid in dying under a veneer of compassion.”
My fourth point is with regard to socio-economic status and MAID requests. We must also examine the relationship between poverty, social isolation and requests for MAID. A study examining requests for medically assisted death at London Health Sciences Centre between 2016 and 2019 found that a disproportionate number of requests came from patients of lower socio-economic status. The Ontario chief coroner's 2024 report identified similar characteristics among track 2 MAID recipients whose natural death were not reasonably foreseeable.
A higher portion of these individuals were elderly, lived alone and were more likely to list an extended family member, caseworker, lawyer or health care provider as their next of kin. The report also documented a case involving a woman who “experienced social isolation, which greatly contributed to her suffering and request for MAiD.”
Health Canada's sixth annual report on medical assistance in dying revealed that 61.5% of track 2 respondents self-identified as having a disability. The United Nations Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities has also challenged Canada's approach, with committee vice-chair Rosemary Kayess questioning whether the situation amounts to “State-sanctioned euthanasia”, and this is before advance requests would even expand MAID even further.
The committee warned that the concept of choice creates a false dichotomy, setting up the premise that, if persons with disabilities are suffering, it is valid for the state party to enable their death without providing safeguards that guaranteed the provision of support. The committee recommended that, rather than expanding MAID access to include advance requests, the Government of Canada ensure that Canadians can afford to live and have access to health care, housing and mental health supports. These are matters of life and death.
My final point is with regard to financial bias. Advance requests call into question financial bias. Think of a scenario where an elderly person qualifies for MAID under track 2 and is sitting on a piece of land or a sizable amount of money. They may be pressured by a family member to put in place an advance request so that their family members can receive their inheritance earlier. It is hard to say that, but those are the questions we need to have answered in the House.
In conclusion, the government's own members have previously acknowledged that advance requests present significant ethical, medical and practical challenges. The health minister said it would be irresponsible to proceed without robust public debate. We have not done that. In my own community, people point to the abuse of MAID at Fraser Health. We have not addressed that, and we are not addressing that. Parliament is not taking the time to get this right. Time allocation, especially, is not the answer.
Canadians deserve careful study and legislation that puts the protection of vulnerable people first. I will be voting against the bill on the procedural tactics of the government alone.
