Madam Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for his excellent speech. One of the reasons we need further study and debate on advance requests is that there are many practical issues the government is not prepared to address or respond to, concrete questions about how things would work.
For instance, I asked this of the justice minister twice this morning, and he would not answer: Should a person be told before their life is ended? Regardless of what they have written in the past, should they be informed on the day when it is happening? The minister could not give a response to that.
Another very practical question is this: What happens if you have disagreement among medical staff about how to interpret an advance request? If someone has made an advance request that states that if certain conditions are met they would want to end their life, there might be some doctors who would say that they think the conditions are met and other doctors who would not think the conditions are met. One family member might bring the case to some doctors, and other family members might bring it to other doctors. How do we resolve a situation in which there is legitimate ambiguity or disagreement about whether the conditions of an advance request are met?
These are some of the practical challenges. I do not know if the member has thoughts on how we would answer those, but the main point is that these are real problems and the reason this issue needs to be understood in detail. There needs to be more clarity in the legislation at the very least.
