Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise on behalf of the people of Windsor West.
I want to speak about this bill from the perspective of someone who has spent 30 years in policing. During those years, I attended calls that one does not simply forget when one goes home at the end of one's shift. I have responded to calls involving people threatening to take their own lives. I have walked into homes where a husband or a wife was desperate for help because someone they loved had reached a breaking point.
We see the fear in their faces when we hear someone's spouse ask us to do something because they do not know what else to do. Then we have to find a way to connect with the person in crisis. Sometimes they are angry. Sometimes they do not want to talk. Sometimes they tell us that they do not want to live anymore. As a police officer, we do not walk away and accept that as the end of the story. We try to calm things down. We listen. We get them help. We protect their life, because we know that the way someone feels in the middle of a crisis is not necessarily how they would feel tomorrow.
I have also attended family disputes where children are caught in the middle. Let us think about a little boy or girl sitting in their bedroom, hearing their parents screaming at each other, watching police officers come through the door and possibly seeing an ambulance pull up outside. That child does not understand the legal issues or the problems between their parents. They just know they are frightened. They do not know whether their family is going to be okay. They are very afraid. Those experiences also stay with us as a police officer. They stay with the families. They remind us just how vulnerable people can be when their lives are falling apart.
I am not suggesting that every MAID situation is the same as a suicide call or a family crisis. They are not. However, my years in policing taught me that we should never assume that what a person is experiencing today is all they will ever experience for the rest of their lives.
That brings me to the advance request provisions in this bill. I understand why someone might take an advance request. They may have watched their parents suffer through dementia. They may be frightened about losing their independence or their ability to recognize their family. Those fears are real, but what happens years later?
Let us imagine a woman who made an advance request when she was healthy and fully capable. She was terrified of developing dementia. Now she has dementia. She can no longer express herself or talk clearly, but her husband takes care of her every day. Sometimes she recognizes him. Sometimes she smiles when he walks in the room. She enjoys a visit from her grandchildren. Her family knows she is not the same person she once was. They also see that she still has moments of happiness. Now let us imagine the family having to deal with the decision to carry out the request she made years ago. One child says that it is what she wanted and they have to respect it. Another asks if they are sure because she still has good moments where she enjoys being with them. Sadly, the person whose life is at stake may no longer be able to answer that question. That is the difficulty. We are relying on a decision made years earlier, even while the person's circumstances, experiences and perhaps even their wishes may have changed.
The bill includes safeguards. I recognize that. However, I want Canadians to think about how difficult it can be to determine what someone is communicating when they can no longer speak for themselves. If we misunderstand them, there is no second chance.
There is another issue we cannot ignore, which is the pressure people can feel when they become dependent on others. I have seen families struggling to care for loved ones, a husband trying to manage his wife's illness, children trying to look after an aging parent while raising their own children and working full time. These families are often exhausted. They need help. Too often that help is very difficult to find, if not impossible. Now let us think about the person receiving that care. They see their spouse losing sleep. They see their children missing work. They worry about the cost. They start thinking that, because they are putting everyone through this, maybe they would be better off without them. Nobody has to say those words to them. They may come to that conclusion on their own.
That is why access to proper care matters. Home care, respite for caregivers, palliative care, mental health services and disability supports are not extras. They are part of giving people a genuine choice. A person should never feel that death is the only option because the support they need to live is not available. That is an inhumane part of our current medical system, the lack of adequate care.
I support permanently excluding mental illness as the sole underlying medical condition for MAID, but I also believe that the advance request provisions need further scrutiny. We have to ask the basic questions. How do we know that the request made years earlier is still what the person wants today? How do we distinguish between the physical response and an expression of refusal from a person who cannot talk anymore? How do we make sure that family pressures, financial worries or the lack of ability to care are not the influencing factors? Who carries the consequences if we get this wrong?
In my 30 years as a police officer, we learned to protect people. That is fundamental to what we do, and that should be fundamental to what we do here as parliamentarians. Our obligation to our fellow citizens is to protect their lives, not to squander them and not to waste these moments when we have the ability to do things right and to do right by the people we are here to serve.
