Mr. Speaker, while I am pleased to rise today to speak to Bill C-41, an act to amend the Criminal Code with respect to medical assistance in dying and to make related amendments to other acts, I do so out of deep concern.
As many Canadians are aware, Bill C-41 was introduced just one day before the House was scheduled to vote on the member for Cloverdale—Langley City's private member's bill, Bill C-218, which was introduced to ensure that the temporary pause in providing MAID for persons whose sole condition is mental illness would be made permanent. The Liberals could have voted for it and dealt with this issue once and for all.
Whether it was the minister's intent to upstage my colleague and perhaps take the credit for finally responding to the concerns of Canadians, including many experts who raised the alarm, or whether he was responding to the recommendation by the AMAD committee to permanently exclude from MAID eligibility persons whose sole medical condition is a mental illness, no one could have imagined the absolute skepticism portrayed by the government with the introduction of Bill C-41.
Under the current Criminal Code framework as amended by Bill C-14, Bill C-7, Bill C-39 and Bill C-62, MAID is legal for persons with a grievous and irremediable medical condition, and their natural death need not be reasonably foreseeable. While Bill C-41 would amend the Criminal Code to prevent the scheduled expansion of MAID to individuals whose sole condition is mental illness, it includes a new provision that would allow individuals with an incurable condition that will affect their decision-making capacity to make an advance request for MAID. The country has seen a major expansion of MAID since 2016. In 2024, 16,499 people died as a result of MAID, making up 5.1% of all deaths at that time. The bill before us today seeks to expand the provision of MAID again by virtue of enabling advance directives.
The core issue with the advance request provision is that the individual may sign off on their death today, with the potential of being unable to communicate withdrawal of their request later. Changing one's mind about receiving MAID is not uncommon. According to Health Canada's sixth report on MAID, 692 individuals withdrew their MAID request, but under the proposed framework in Bill C-41, the practitioner would have to assess their consent retroactively.
Additionally, the bill would place extraordinary weight on practitioners to interpret a patient's prior wishes and decide whether those circumstances envisioned have been met, even though the patient can no longer speak for themselves. Consider a person diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease, for example. In later stages of the disease, they may lose the ability to communicate and may experience cognitive and/or physical decline. However, the person does not exhibit signs of distress such as extreme anger, anxiety or agitation. In this circumstance, how would the practitioner determine whether the individual is in an advanced state of irreversible decline in capability? Would they be deemed to be experiencing enduring and intolerable physical or psychological suffering?
Canadians are being asked to get MAID instead of being treated. Although statutory safeguards are present in existing legislation and are proposed in the bill, these safeguards have not prevented ineligible people from receiving or being offered MAID. The leader of the official opposition recently and quite correctly pointed to the case of Kiano Vafaeian, who was diagnosed with diabetes, depression and vision loss. Mr. Vafaeian was eligible for MAID in British Columbia, despite being previously rendered ineligible in Ontario. Mr. Vafaeian's conditions were treatable, yet he was able to end his life at only 26 years old. The case of Vafaeian speaks to the fragmentation issue within the MAID regime between provinces, and the loose interpretation of eligibility by medical practitioners.
The inappropriate recommendation of MAID is a common issue in our health care system, especially toward disabled persons and elderly persons. Recently, the National Post reported on a B.C. physician who offered MAID to an elderly patient whose only symptom was back pain. Veterans Affairs Canada has also launched its own investigations into cases where veterans seeking disability and mental health supports were inappropriately offered MAID by VAC caseworkers.
That said, I would like to acknowledge my colleague the member for Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan's private member's bill, Bill C-260, the proposed preventing coercion of persons not seeking medical assistance in dying act. It would create a summary offence under the Criminal Code for a Government of Canada employee other than a medical practitioner or nurse to initiate a discussion with a person about the availability of MAID, especially if that employee is in a position of trust or authority.
What is most discouraging about the discussion we are having today is that we do not need to be debating this legislation. We could be debating the government's most recent budget bill, which was tabled earlier this month. As I noted earlier, the government could have saved the justice department a bunch of time and energy by simply supporting my colleague the member for Cloverdale—Langley City's private member's bill, Bill C-218. It was a simple and uncontroversial bill that deserved to be supported. As was mentioned in an earlier speech, the government could have supported Bill C-314 in the previous Parliament.
However, rather than voting for a Conservative MP's bill, the government deceived Canadians by telling them that the Liberals would vote against Bill C-218 because they were going to propose their own legislation to do the same thing. What they did not tell Canadians is that their bill would include more than just the issue of MAID expansion to those whose sole underlying condition is mental illness.
In closing, I would like to remind every member of the House and Canadians who might be listening that the legalization of MAID and the subsequent changes to the MAID regime in Canada have all necessitated amendments to the Criminal Code of Canada. We are not debating amendments to the Canada Health Act or some bill dealing with health care provisions. We are changing the Criminal Code to allow medical professionals to end someone's life. This is a matter of life or death.
It is my belief that vulnerable Canadians from every part of the country should be provided with hope and help, not simply a pathway to state-facilitated death. Medical assistance in dying is one of the most serious and deeply personal issues that we as parliamentarians can address. The priority must be protecting vulnerable Canadians, respecting individual dignity and ensuring that any changes to the law include strong safeguards and accountability. We must guard against any circumstance in which people feel that MAID is their only realistic option because adequate supports are unavailable. While I welcome the exclusion of mental illness as the sole underlying condition and am willing to support that part of Bill C-41, advance requests raise profound questions about consent, capacity and safeguards. It is my belief that vulnerable Canadians from every part of the country should be provided with hope and help.
Parliament must get the answers right before changing the law. To do that, parliamentarians need to have the opportunity to debate this new provision instead of having this piece of legislation rush through Parliament to meet some self-imposed deadline that could have been dealt with long before we got to this place.
