Madam Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill C-41, the medical assistance in dying safeguards act, brought forward by the Liberals. MAID is an issue that people in my constituency of Lethbridge very much care about. I have certainly read many emails, had many conversations and engaged in many phone calls. I have heard from countless constituents who have serious concerns about what the Liberals are attempting here. This level of public concern is exactly why Parliament must carefully examine legislation of this magnitude. Unfortunately, however, earlier today the Liberals used their majority to shut down debate and move this bill forward at a quick pace.
When it comes to an issue literally of life and death, playing political games is extremely cold-hearted and altogether inappropriate. Canadians expect us to listen to experts. They expect us to examine the evidence and consider the consequences before making decisions with irreversible effects. Instead, the government is limiting debate on legislation that raises profound questions about consent, medical safeguards and the protection of vulnerable Canadians. This is not a minor legislative adjustment. It concerns human life, which is something very sacred.
Bill C-41 combines two very different issues. First, it proposes to permanently exclude individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness from accessing medical assistance in dying. This is a positive shift. Second, it would establish a framework for advance requests, allowing someone to request medical assistance in dying today, which would be carried out in the future. This is alarming because there is inadequate research to suggest this would be done effectively or that it would take into account the individual's capacity at the time of their death. These issues raise very different ethical, medical and legal questions, and they deserve independent study and debate.
The current exclusion of mental illness expires March 17, 2027, meaning Parliament must act before that deadline. However, there is no comparable deadline for the advance directives that are being included in this legislation. The government has tied the two together, one urgent and one not, in order to get this through quickly. Conservatives have been clear from the beginning that these issues should be separated. There is no reason to put them together, except, of course, for political gamesmanship. We are prepared to pass the permanent mental illness exclusion through all stages of the House today and send it to the Senate without any further delay.
Advance requests, meanwhile, deserve their own thorough parliamentary study, meaningful consultation and thorough debate. Religious organizations, including the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops, and disability advocates have raised serious concerns. Their voices should not be dismissed from the conversation. Parliament should never operate under artificial political pressure when considering legislation that could result in the loss of human life. Canadians deserve better than having debate limited on an issue this consequential.
At the heart of advance requests is a fundamental question: What are the fundamental requirements of consent? Consent is the question. Under this proposal, someone could request MAID while they have decision-making capacity, with that request carried out years later, after they have lost that capacity, but how can someone know with certainty what they will want years into the future, particularly before experiencing the circumstances they are making a decision about? Someone may believe today that they could never want to live with dementia or significant cognitive decline, but imagining that experience and living that experience are two very different things. People adapt. Their perspectives change and their priorities evolve. Someone who once feared a particular condition may still find meaning, comfort and joy in life after developing that said condition. How can we know that a decision made years earlier still reflects what that person truly wants?
There are also serious questions about interpreting behaviour when someone can no longer communicate verbally. The legislation would address words, sounds or gestures that may indicate refusal or resistance to MAID, but how does a practitioner distinguish an involuntary reflex or expression of distress from a genuine indication that someone does not wish to proceed? The consequences of getting that wrong, of course, are irreversible. The person will die.
Similarly, how can practitioners determine whether someone is experiencing enduring and intolerable suffering when that person can no longer communicate? It is based on the judgment of another. How can they distinguish irremediable suffering from fear, distress or confusion that may be treatable? These clinical judgments deserve much more examination than what this government is currently allowing for by rushing the bill through.
There is another concern, which is people feeling pressured to seek medical assistance in dying, because they fear they will become a burden to their families or to society. People with disabilities, seniors and those experiencing serious illness should never feel that their lives are worth less because they have need for assistance. They should never feel that their families or society would be better off without them.
I have heard directly from a woman in my riding who lives with a disability. She regularly reaches out to the medical system for help, yet has repeatedly found herself being offered medical assistance in dying rather than the support and services she truly requires. Let us think about that: Someone asks the health care system for help to improve their circumstances and live, and instead they are offered death. That should give the House reason to pause. People with disabilities deserve appropriate care, they deserve a treatment and they deserve support. Death should never be presented as an alternative to the services they cannot access. We must do better. We must not create a society where dependency is seen as a loss of dignity and where people feel they should end their lives before becoming dependent on others.
There are also concerns about implementation. Bill C-41 would permit advance requests only in provinces and territories that establish their own regulatory frameworks. This could result in inconsistent oversight and different levels of protection across Canada. Canadians deserve consistent safeguards regardless of where they live. This is concerning and deserves careful consideration, which is not being granted by the government as the bill before us, once again, is being rushed through the House of Commons.
Conservatives have been fighting to make the exclusion for mental illness permanent, which is the second component of the bill. We very much support that. My colleague, the member for Cloverdale—Langley City, championed this protection through her private member's bill, Bill C-218, which would have permanently excluded individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness from MAID. The Liberals voted that bill down, knowing that they were going to play a political game and couple that provision with the advance medical directive. It is absolutely shameful: playing with the lives of people and rushing a piece of legislation of this magnitude through the House of Commons. It is unspeakable.
At the end of the day, this debate comes down to a simple principle. Parliament has a responsibility to protect the most vulnerable. That is our job. That is the will of the Canadian people. That is what they have sent us here for, and that means listening to Canadians. It means examining the evidence and carefully considering the consequences of legislation that we pass in this place.
I will close by sharing an email I received today from a constituent. It reads, "I am very concerned about how MAID impacts vulnerable Canadians and how it will impact our loved ones with dementia and other capacity-limiting illnesses. Thank you for taking the time to hear my concerns on this."
As members can imagine, there was much more to that email, but the bottom line is that this is just one of dozens of emails, another several dozen phone calls and in-person meetings that I have taken with regards to this issue. It matters to Canadians.
We owe it to the Canadian public to take this seriously and give it careful consideration. We must hear from physicians, psychiatrists, legal experts, families, veterans, disability advocates, faith-based organizations and provincial governments. We must examine consent, safeguards and the realities of our health care system. Most importantly, we must ensure that vulnerable Canadians are protected.
Conservatives are prepared today to separate the bill into two parts and pass the protection for those with a mental illness while having robust discussions and debates, and hearing from witnesses, with regards to the advance directive piece.
