Mr. Speaker, a home invasion is a truly terrifying thing. Someone has broken into the place where a family is supposed to be safe. A parent may have seconds to decide what to do. They grab whatever blunt object is handy and protect their family as best they can. Afterwards, because of the way our criminal law works, that parent may spend months or years, and thousands of dollars, answering for that decision in court.
Bill C-270 is about presumptions. Under the current law, the court looks at whether someone reasonably believed force was being used or threatened, whether they acted to protect themself or someone else, and whether their response was reasonable in the circumstances. Once there is evidence to support self-defence, the Crown has to disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt, but that does not prevent an investigation, a charge or a costly legal fight.
This bill would change that. It would change subsection 34(2) of the Criminal Code to create two presumptions for unlawful entry into a home. If someone knowingly and unlawfully enters, the law would presume they intended to use force unless there is evidence to the contrary. That is kind of a match for hearing breaking glass in the middle of the night in one's home and hearing someone moving around.
If a resident uses force against someone who has unlawfully entered, the conditions for self-defence would be presumed to be met. That changes the starting point for a court reviewing a frightening, split-second event, and it changes what officers are able to do when they arrive on the scene. It changes the way the whole situation is approached.
The reason that is important is that the legal cost of defending oneself in a self-defence situation can be substantial. One man reported that it cost about $60,000 in legal costs over a two-and-a-half-year fight after men had firebombed his Ontario home and he fired warning shots. He was eventually acquitted of firearms-related charges, and much of his legal bill was covered by supporters. That is one case that shows how costly a legal fight arising from a home attack can become.
I lived through this myself with a friend when I was practising law. It is a terrible experience. In that case, it was someone in my local community. It was 18 months before he even got his cellphone back because the RCMP were investigating whether or not charges would be laid against him.
A person who has just lived through a crime should not have to face years of uncertainty over whether a court will consider that their split-second response was reasonable. What Bill C-270 would do is give clearer recognition in the law and set the presumption where we naturally think it should be. When someone breaks into our home, when someone invades our space, when we are scared, it is natural to do whatever it takes to defend ourselves. It is natural to reach for whatever is at hand. It is natural to act in any way that is open to us, especially if it is a place where we have family who are sleeping.
What this bill would do, and Canadians are behind this, is help bring the law toward the place where a reasonable person would believe it should be. It would make life more secure for people who face uncertainty. It would make it easier for police and our society to act.
I see that I am reaching the end of my time, so I will leave it there. I am thankful for the opportunity to speak to this bill today.
