House of Commons Hansard #168 of the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was debt.

Topics

line drawing of robot

This summary is computer-generated. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.

Non-regression of Environmental Protection Laws Act First reading of Bill C-296. The bill establishes a process to assess and document the climate, biodiversity, economic and human impacts of proposed changes that weaken environmental protections. 200 words.

National Framework on Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder Act First reading of Bill S-234. The bill establishes a national framework for fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, aiming to strengthen prevention, awareness, research, diagnosis, coordination and support for people affected. 200 words.

Financial Statement of Minister of Finance Members debate Budget 2026, including Liberal arguments for affordability supports, housing, infrastructure, business investment and economic resilience, and opposition concerns about deficits, debt servicing, accounting practices and value for money. Speakers also discuss health transfers, immigration levels, energy and forestry policy, rural services, cadet programs and major projects such as Alto, while differing over whether the budget’s investments justify its borrowing. 42100 words, 5 hours in 2 segments: 1 2.

Statements by Members

Question Period

The Conservatives attack Liberal spending and deficits, warning of rising debt and inflation, and criticize the government’s housing record and immigration policies. They raise concerns about crime and public safety, agricultural research cuts, and Chinese influence in telecommunications and defence. They also demand accountability over the Stellantis plant sale and foreign spending on Brazil’s rainforest.
The Liberals promote the budget’s investments in housing and affordability, fiscal strength, productivity and support for workers and businesses. They highlight major infrastructure and electrification projects, defend immigration and efforts to combat crime, and point to farm and food-security investments, climate action, and support for Canadian industries facing tariffs.
The Bloc urges safeguards against climate-policy backtracking, calling for transparency and parliamentary scrutiny of decisions affecting the environment. It also condemns Bill C-39 as granting permanent powers that could bypass environmental laws, weaken workers’ rights, and sideline Indigenous peoples.
The NDP criticize weakened climate safeguards and corporate favoritism through telecom and airport privatization and secret Stellantis deals.

Financial Statement of the Minister of Finance Members debate Budget 2026, including its deficits, debt and fiscal transparency, and the government’s investments in business productivity, innovation, housing, homelessness, affordability and culture. Conservatives criticize borrowing, debt-service costs, food insecurity and foreign spending, while Liberals defend the budget’s growth and social measures. Members also raise Quebec’s health transfers and asylum-seeker costs, wildfire management, youth climate programs and ferry funding. 5300 words, 40 minutes.

Stand on Guard Act Second reading of Bill C-270. The bill amends the Criminal Code to presume that someone who knowingly and unlawfully enters an occupied home intends to use force, and that force used by a resident in response is reasonable, subject to contrary evidence. Conservatives say it would clarify protections and reduce legal burdens for people defending their families; Liberals and the Bloc argue existing self-defence law is adequate and warn the presumption could justify disproportionate violence. 7600 words, 1 hour.

Adjournment Debates

Access to health care Helena Konanz says Canadians face family-doctor shortages, long specialist waits and unreliable rural emergency services, citing closures and lost neurologists in her riding. Maggie Chi points to federal investments in health infrastructure, mental health and home care, workforce planning and health-data connectivity, while stressing coordination with provinces and territories.
Grocery affordability and debt Pat Kelly says rising grocery prices, including turkey, reflect the government’s economic mismanagement and argues Budget 2026 adds excessive debt without easing household pressures. Parliamentary Secretary Tom Osborne cites affordability benefits and investments, and says Canada has the G7’s strongest fiscal position. Kelly rejects the government’s assurances; Osborne challenges Conservatives’ support for affordability programs.
Was this summary helpful and accurate?

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:35 p.m.

Conservative

Greg McLean Conservative Calgary Centre, AB

Mr. Speaker, I listened to my new colleague's speech and would like to welcome him to the House of Commons.

That said, I heard something in his remarks suggesting that he supports the expansion of Canada's debt. We are not just talking about debt. We are talking about borrowing $765 billion from foreign banks over the next four and a half years, yet he seems to support that because his riding will get skating rink.

Did I hear that right?

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:35 p.m.

Liberal

Daniel Gobeil Liberal Chicoutimi—Le Fjord, QC

Mr. Speaker, the budget is a package of tax measures, investment measures and support measures. It does indeed contain measures that will allow us to continue investing in people, communities and organizations while improving affordability. It is a combination of decisions designed to ensure the sound management of the country's finances.

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:35 p.m.

Liberal

Louis Villeneuve Liberal Brome—Missisquoi, QC

Mr. Speaker, my colleague has a lot of experience in agriculture, so I would like to ask him about taxation. Agriculture is a major industry in Brome—Missisquoi, and many farmers are beginning to think about retirement. The taxation of farms is always an issue when it comes to transferring farms.

Can my colleague tell me how the changes announced in budget 2026 will help our farmers in this regard?

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:35 p.m.

Liberal

Daniel Gobeil Liberal Chicoutimi—Le Fjord, QC

Mr. Speaker, indeed, my colleague from Brome—Missisquoi has a keen eye. We also recognize the importance of the capital gains exemption in intergenerational transfers for the people of Chicoutimi—Le Fjord. The agricultural sector has long been calling for these measures. As we know, this exemption was previously available to the children of the farm operator and his or her spouse, as well as to grandchildren. In the new budget, we are now extending this same exemption to nephews, nieces, grandnephews and grandnieces.

Clearly, farms are becoming increasingly important. More and more families are making their living on our farms in rural areas. It is important to recognize this, to be flexible, and to adopt tax measures that will truly meet the needs of the agricultural sector.

Given the current rise in economic indicators, these decisions are important.

Message from the SenateGovernment Orders

3:35 p.m.

The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec

It is my duty to inform the House that a message has been received from the Senate informing this House that the Senate has passed the following bill: Bill C‑10, An Act respecting the Commissioner for Modern Treaty Implementation.

The House resumed consideration of the motion that this House approve in general the budgetary policy of the government.

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:35 p.m.

Liberal

Jessica Fancy-Landry Liberal South Shore—St. Margarets, NS

Mr. Speaker, I will start my speech on the budget today by mentioning that the last Monday of this month is what is called dumping day back home in South Shore—St. Margarets, weather permitting. I am going to talk today about why days like this are so important to our budget.

For anyone who has not had the pleasure—

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:35 p.m.

The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec

I have to interrupt the member.

The member for Mirabel has a point of order.

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:35 p.m.

Bloc

Jean-Denis Garon Bloc Mirabel, QC

Mr. Speaker, with all due respect for our colleague, I must report that there is a problem with the interpretation.

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

November 19th, 2026 / 3:35 p.m.

The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec

Apparently the interpretation is not working at all. I will keep talking until it is back up and running.

Oh, I'm sorry. It is the English version. Sometimes it is difficult to know which of the interpretations is not working, because I do not have the hearing piece.

It seems to be working perfectly now.

I invite the member for South Shore—St. Margarets to start from the beginning, so we can catch all of her comments.

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:35 p.m.

Liberal

Jessica Fancy-Landry Liberal South Shore—St. Margarets, NS

Mr. Speaker, the last Monday of this month is what we call dumping day back in South Shore—St. Margarets, weather permitting. I want to talk today on how that correlates with the budget.

For anyone who has not had the pleasure of experiencing the first day of lobster season along Nova Scotia’s south shore and along our southwest coast, it is the biggest lobster season in Canada. Before the sun is up, hundreds of boats will leave the wharves from St. Margarets to Cape Sable Island, stacked high with traps. Search and rescue will be standing by on the water and in the air. For a lot of families, that is the day the year's paycheque starts.

When I read the budget, I ask what they would ask: What does it do to the kitchen table? What does it do for the wharf, the woodlot or the farm in my riding? Let us start at the kitchen table. The budget puts more than $22 billion over five years into making everyday life more affordable. Let me take members to three kitchen tables back home.

First, let us talk about groceries, as every family back home knows what has happened to the grocery bill. We do not need a study to know that. We just need a grocery receipt. Early next year, the Canada groceries and essentials benefit gets a one-time 50% boost. For a family of four, that can bring upwards of $700, and that is a couple of big grocery runs. To their credit, members opposite helped pass the first version of this benefit. I really hope they remember that when they vote on our budget today.

Secondly, I would like to talk about caregivers. In 2021, Statistics Canada’s census found that three in 10 people in my riding of South Shore—St. Margarets are seniors. This puts us among the oldest ridings in the country. A lot of my neighbours are looking after a mom, a dad, a spouse or a grown child with a disability. Here is the problem: Until now, the caregiver credit helped someone only if they earned enough to actually owe tax, so the people giving up the most got the least. This budget makes the Canada caregiver credit refundable. It is worth up to $1,260 a year. One hundred and eighty thousand caregivers who get nothing from it today will now finally get something. If people are caring for someone else, they are working, and it is about time the tax system noticed.

Thirdly, on our kitchen table, we have the people who make our main streets worth the drive. If we walk down a main street in Mahone Bay, Lunenburg or Shelburne county, we will see a potter, a painter or a woodworker, and that is all before lunch. A lot of them are small businesses of one. There is a new Canada creative credit. Artists will not pay federal income tax up to the $45,000 mark of what they earn from their creative work. This means that when a visitor buys a painting in Chester, that money will stay in Chester.

Let us move on to the wharf, the woodlot and the farm. Many members in the House know I chair the Liberal rural caucus, so I spend a lot of time in this place making one argument: Rural is not the backdrop; rural is the backbone. This budget puts money behind that. Here are three examples. My grandfather grew up growing Christmas trees in Lunenburg county, which is the balsam fir capital of the world, by the way. It takes about 10 years to grow a Christmas tree. On a farm like that, we do not plan year to year. We plan for the next generation.

The same goes for the boat and the licence. Today, a farmer or a fisher can pass the operation to a son, a daughter or a grandchild, without a tax bill, the day it changes hands.

However, not every captain has a son or daughter who wants the boat. Sometimes it is a niece. Sometimes it is the nephew, who has been on deck since he was 14. For transfers starting January 1, the budget opens that door to nieces and nephews, grandnieces and grandnephews. Out here, where I am from, the family does not stop at one's own kids. Now, the tax code will not either.

Second, with regard to the tools needed to do the work, the new productivity mega deduction lets a business write off the full cost of new equipment right away. The budget’s own list of what qualifies includes things like fishing vessels, so the fisher replacing a boat, the plant adding a processing line or the boat yard in Lunenburg buying new equipment can write those off in year one. That is a tax break that can be seen on the wharf. It is tangible. That is what the budget is about.

Let us talk about the woods. There is $6.5 billion over six years, six by six, to modernize our mills, strengthen the wood supply and make new products from Canadian wood. I grew up in Queens County, and I know first-hand, we know, what happens when the mill closes. Nova Scotia has more than 30,000 private woodlot owners. For a small province, we have some of the highest numbers of woodlot owners in the country. When a mill closes, they lose a market too. The budget is about building the next one.

Third, let us talk about the hands that do the work, hiring local first, always. The budget puts up to $10,000 toward an apprentice’s first-year wages, so that the next welder in Liverpool, in my riding, can learn the trade at home and stay at home.

Ask any plant manager back home what it means when the boats come in and the lines are short-handed. The lobster does not wait. The budget sets aside money to reform a regional temporary foreign worker program around what each region actually needs, tailored to that region. We heard from tremendous numbers of local stakeholders, and they talked about labour. We are trying to answer that consultation. It is not a one-size-fits-all approach. No size fits nobody.

Let us now talk about volunteers. They have some of the most important hands out there. When that pager goes off, they leave their supper. They sometimes leave their sleep. This budget keeps their tax credit doubled and makes one simple credit for volunteer firefighters and search and rescue workers alike.

As a former principal, I will say this plainly. A first nations kid should know from year to year who their teaching assistant is going to be. I talk about this because the budget also gives some money to Jordan's principle: $6 billion over six years as part of more than $50 billion over 10 years for a reconciliation plan. That is not a one-year promise. It is a generational plan.

One more thing that rural Canada cannot afford to lose is local news. Since 2008, more than 600 local news outlets have closed in Canada. When the local paper closes, the fourth estate is absent from any council meeting. The budget makes permanent the program that puts independent reporters in small towns, with over $134 million over four years. It puts $501 million over five years into the Canadian journalism labour tax credit, which is now open to private radio and private television. I am proud that our rural caucus worked so hard on both of those measures. I would like to give a shout-out to the Minister of Canadian Identity and Culture for his advocacy.

Members opposite have moved to reject the budget. They have even suggested a new title for it. As a former teacher, I will give them some marks for creativity, but let us go with the facts. The government’s day-to-day spending is on track to balance next year, a year ahead of schedule, and Canada still has the lowest debt in the G7 for the size of its economy. Their amendment says fishing, farming and forestry were left out of a tax break for start-ups, but fishers and farmers already have their own tax—

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:45 p.m.

The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec

The member's time has elapsed. I did give the member extra time because of the problems with interpretation.

Before we go to questions and comments, I just want to remind members of something.

I will say this in French. A member crossed the line of sight between the member who was speaking and the Chair. I want to remind members that they cannot walk in front of a member who is speaking, giving a speech or asking a question during House proceedings. That is in Standing Order 16(2). It is very clear that members must not do that.

I said that in French because I believe the member in question was a francophone. I wanted to make sure he heard me.

The hon. member for Yellowhead.

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:50 p.m.

Conservative

William Stevenson Conservative Yellowhead, AB

Mr. Speaker, there was a lot, as I have gone through the budget, that I would say the member opposite gave an accurate description of, except for one thing. I am wondering if the member knows anything about AMT, alternative minimum tax. Every one of the fishermen and farmers that you are saying will not be subject to a capital gains tax is going to be subject to it.

Is the member aware of that?

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:50 p.m.

The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec

Before I let the member give her response, I did not say anything. Again, this is a reminder to members to speak through the Chair, not directly to other members.

The hon. member for South Shore—St. Margarets.

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:50 p.m.

Liberal

Jessica Fancy-Landry Liberal South Shore—St. Margarets, NS

Mr. Speaker, I am aware of the AMT and what it means for different local fishers and farmers. This is a budget for Main Street and not Bay Street. There are a lot of really good grassroots programs that are going to have effects around the kitchen table. With a budget of this size, sometimes we do not get it all for everybody, but I really am excited to vote for this budget because of all these grassroots, innovative measures that are going to have direct effects.

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:50 p.m.

Bloc

Jean-Denis Garon Bloc Mirabel, QC

Mr. Speaker, my colleague's speech certainly makes me want to eat lobster from the Magdalen Islands, no doubt about it.

The Liberals say this is a budget for Main Street, not Bay Street. They gave it the title “Masters of our destiny”. In this budget, they say they are going to privatize operations at our airports, including Aéroports de Montréal, as well as the Mirabel component, which came about as the result of a criminal expropriation. It is one of the biggest crimes in Canadian history, for which they still have not apologized. Now they are calling it “Masters of our destiny”.

Quebec was not consulted. The Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec was not consulted. We have no idea whether it would be interested.

We found out that the Liberals are in the process of selling our strategic infrastructure to an Australian pension fund that has already acquired airports in Europe, where it significantly increased the cost of air travel for passengers.

Is that what Main Street would want? Is that what being “masters of our destiny” means? Does it mean selling off an airport that is a public infrastructure asset, specifically the Mirabel airport, to an Australian pension fund without any consultation or transparency? Is that what they think being masters of our destiny means?

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:50 p.m.

Liberal

Jessica Fancy-Landry Liberal South Shore—St. Margarets, NS

Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my hon. colleague from Mirabel for that. I would love to have some Mirabel lobster as well, but I will duly note that some of the best-quality lobster comes from South Shore—St. Margarets.

Sometimes it is really easy to sit on the sidelines and throw stones, but at some point, we really have to invest in Canada's future, and that is what this budget would do. I want to share a quote from John Ruffolo, who is the co-founder of the Council of Canadian Innovators. He said, “This is the clearest signal in years that Ottawa wants Canadian companies to scale here, not sell early or leave.” He said that we are investing in some of our own.

I would also like to talk about Josh Earls, president of the Norman Wells and District Chamber of Commerce. He said, “It's unbelievable. Literally, my phone has not stopped blowing up for the past hour since they announced it”. He also said, “It's a little bit surprising because we weren't sure if it was ever going to happen”, and, “People are pretty excited” about the budget.

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:50 p.m.

Liberal

Braedon Clark Liberal Sackville—Bedford—Preston, NS

Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my friend and colleague from South Shore—St. Margarets. It is certainly one of the most beautiful ridings in the country.

She mentioned in her comments some of the grassroots initiatives that are in this budget. I think of the caregiver's benefit. I think of support for artists. Arts and culture are certainly a major industry along the south shore of Nova Scotia and across the country.

Can my colleague share her thoughts on some of those initiatives and the impact they will have in her riding, my riding and across the country?

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:55 p.m.

Liberal

Jessica Fancy-Landry Liberal South Shore—St. Margarets, NS

Mr. Speaker, the hon. member for Sackville—Bedford—Preston has been a huge advocate for a lot of the items in this budget when we talk about these grassroots programs.

I want to loop back, first, to local media programming in grassroots media. It is $134 million and $501 million for some of these local taxations and for helping us try to bolster. We talk about misinformation and disinformation. As a former teacher who used to teach citizenship and what misinformation and disinformation is, I think it is very important that we are helping our local media, so they can be a direct source for the information we are trying to put out to our communities.

Business of SupplyGovernment Orders

3:55 p.m.

Brampton North—Caledon Ontario

Liberal

Ruby Sahota LiberalSecretary of State (Combatting Crime)

Mr. Speaker, I would like to designate Tuesday, November 24, as an opposition day.

Business of SupplyGovernment Orders

3:55 p.m.

The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec

It is so noted.

The House resumed consideration of the motion that this House approve in general the budgetary policy of the government.

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

3:55 p.m.

Conservative

Shelby Kramp-Neuman Conservative Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga, ON

Mr. Speaker, Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga is home to some of Ontario’s most productive farmland, much of it worked by families for generations. It is home to small businesses that support our local economies and sustain our towns and villages. It is home to the Mohawks of the Bay of Quinte, whose history and perspectives I continue to learn from.

The people I represent understand the importance of hard work and of responsible decisions. They expect the same from their government. They expect respect for their hard-earned tax dollars, a willingness to listen and accountability for the decisions that affect their lives. These are not unreasonable expectations, yet across my riding, families are struggling to make ends meet. Seniors on fixed incomes are watching their purchasing power shrink. Food banks are seeing working Canadians who never imagined they would need assistance.

In rural Canada, affordability comes with challenges that, too often, Ottawa overlooks. For my constituents, driving is not a luxury. It is a necessity. It is how people get to work, attend doctor's appointments and buy groceries. It is how farmers operate equipment and get their products to market. When fuel costs rise, those costs ripple through our economy, affecting transportation, agriculture, small businesses and ultimately the price Canadians pay for everyday necessities.

When Canadians are already stretching every dollar, every additional cost matters. Those dollars matter just as much when the government decides how to spend them. Among the many concerns surrounding the government's priorities is the Alto high-speed rail project. Residents fear losing land held by their families for generations, farmers worry about divided farmland and rural communities face disrupted access routes and lasting impacts. These are people’s homes, livelihoods and legacies.

Who is listening to the people expected to make the greatest sacrifices? For the communities I represent, the Alto initiative will take rather than give. Major infrastructure projects may often offer economic opportunities but those opportunities do not excuse a government from thorough consultation, fiscal accountability or respecting the communities directly affected. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has estimated Alto’s construction costs at between $75 billion and $113 billion-plus. That is an extraordinary financial commitment, deserving extraordinary scrutiny.

This brings us to the federal budget. Budget 2026 projects a $62.3-billion deficit, with federal debt approaching $1.37 trillion and $60.2 billion in annual debt-servicing costs. That is more than $60 billion going toward interest on the debt rather than directly delivering new services to Canadians. Those annual debt charges are projected to climb to $85.5 billion by 2030–31. The families, farmers and small businesses I know and represent understand that borrowing sometimes has its place, but they also understand that every borrowed dollar must be justified.

As we examine budget 2026, I believe the House must answer one crucial question. Are we making decisions that strengthen the lives of Canadians or are we asking them to carry an ever-growing financial burden without demonstrating the value they receive in return? That is the standard the people of Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga and all Canadians deserve.

Next, I would like to turn to what I consider, beyond the extraordinary spending increases, the most historically significant issue in the budget, which is transparency.

The manner in which the government is doing things leaves much to be desired. Only after sustained criticism did questions surrounding the Prime Minister’s relationship with Telesat receive greater scrutiny. Only after months of demands did the government disclose the companies lending employees to its Major Projects Office. Transparency should be standard operating procedure, not a crisis management strategy. Canadians are all too familiar with the government’s history on transparency, such as with WE Charity, ArriveCAN and SNC-Lavalin, names familiar to anyone who has followed politics. SNC-Lavalin was extremely troubling. The former prime minister and senior officials were found to have improperly pressured the attorney general over a prosecutorial decision, raising fundamental questions about the independence of that office and the Shawcross principle.

This was hardly the first time a Liberal government faced questions about the administration of justice. In 1965, Justice Minister Guy Favreau left that portfolio following the Rivard affair after an inquiry criticized his handling of allegations involving attempted bribery and political interference. Favreau’s departure was followed by Lester B. Pearson’s recruitment of three prominent Quebec candidates, the “three wise men”: Gérard Pelletier, Jean Marchand and Pierre Elliott Trudeau. Interestingly, Favreau represented Montreal's Papineau, a riding later represented by Pierre Trudeau’s son, Justin Trudeau, some 41 years later.

Other names in Liberal Party history must not be forgotten. Groupaction Marketing, Coffin Communications, Lafleur Communication Marketing, Groupe Everest and Cockfield, Brown are names unfamiliar to newer members, perhaps, but not to those who remember the sponsorship scandal and the Gomery commission. I am sure my colleague from Bécancour—Nicolet—Saurel—Alnôbak remembers extremely well, and the member for Vancouver Centre probably wishes that she could forget.

The sponsorship scandal remains one of the most consequential failures of public accountability in modern Canadian political history. In a remarkable coincidence, the Gomery hearings were held in Montreal’s Complexe Guy-Favreau. The Gomery commission’s report contained salient points that remain relevant today, which is why I am going to read a small portion of it to the House.

It reads:

One message has been continually emphasized in the consultations conducted by the Commission: there is a need to rebalance the relationship between Parliament and the Government. The capacity of Parliament to hold the Government to account needs to be restored and strengthened.... If the present Report succeeds in launching a public debate that leads to a rebalancing between Parliament and Government, the Commission, for that reason alone, may be considered a success.

A reinforcement of the traditional role of parliamentarians would tend to restore public trust and the confidence that Canadians should have in their political and administrative institutions. That confidence is currently at a low ebb. It would contribute to a renewal of the self-esteem and sense of worth that should be felt by Members of Parliament. It would also restore the public’s respect for them.

The commission’s recommendations helped shape the Federal Accountability Act introduced by the nascent Conservative government as its first piece of legislation. This legislation was not perfect, nor was the government that introduced it. As that government approached the end of its mandate, it too faced criticism over accountability and failures of communication.

The institutional rot, intentional or not, is colour-blind. That is a lesson every member of the House should remember. Anyone who has walked through these halls over the past 25 years should understand the dangers that fester behind closed doors. As legislators, if we are not comfortable explaining our decisions to the Canadians we serve, we should question whether those decisions ought to be made at all.

When legitimate criticism is dismissed, when accountability is avoided and when governments stop listening, the result is predictable: a culture of complacency, indifference and arrogance every single time. Ultimately, the people who pay the price are not the politicians, political staff or public servants involved. It is the taxpayer. We must never forget that everything we do in the House, every decision we make, every budget we pass and every dollar that we ultimately spend must be for them, the taxpayer, not for ourselves

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

4:05 p.m.

Winnipeg North Manitoba

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Mr. Speaker, I have not had the time to go through all the history of former Conservative prime ministers, but I do happen to have one of the booklets, which is “Harper, Serial Abuser of Power: The Evidence Compiled.” There are a lot of pages to it. The one I thought was the biggest, of course, was the contempt of Parliament.

However, that is not the reason I stood up to ask a question. The member made reference to seniors and the issue of affordability. I just want to remind the member opposite about one question I brought up in the past, and that is about the dental program, which is there to support seniors on fixed incomes who need to get dental work done. Unfortunately, her colleagues in her party are in opposition to that program.

I am wondering if, for the sake of the seniors on fixed incomes who have used the program in her constituency, she would say she supports it?

Financial Statement of Minister of FinanceThe BudgetGovernment Orders

4:05 p.m.

Conservative

Shelby Kramp-Neuman Conservative Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga, ON

Mr. Speaker, in response to the hon. member's question, I am going to acknowledge a few things. The debt in our country is currently $1.37 trillion. More than $165 million is spent every single day to service the federal debt. To answer the member's question specifically, I would have to go back, but I think it is two in 10 Canadians who are able to access the federal dental plan, so I know that our local constituency offices have a number of concerns, questions and inquiries every single week about this. Realistically, Canada needs to be financially fit, and right now we are not.