Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was terms.

Last in Parliament May 2004, as NDP MP for Regina—Qu'Appelle (Saskatchewan)

Lost his last election, in 2006, with 32% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Taxation November 1st, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Minister of Finance.

Canadians want tax cuts, but not just any kind of tax cuts. A recent poll by his friends at Earnscliffe confirms what the NDP has been saying all along, namely that 55% of the people back a rollback on the GST as a first step toward cutting taxes.

When will the Minister of Finance finally catch up with the Canadian people and roll back the GST, which is the most regressive and difficult tax in the history of this country?

Committees Of The House October 29th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I think the member for Elk Island has summed it up. There is nothing more he can say and it is such a shameful thing for the Reform Party to try to warp basic democracy and the grassroots especially. I agree there is nothing more he should say. No wonder he hangs his head in shame in this House of Commons.

I remember when the Leader of the Opposition went around here saying that we should consult people more often, that we should listen to the people more often and have more input from the so-called grassroots.

People should be aware that the motion before the House is to allow the finance committee to go around the country to hear from Canadians. The Reform Party is saying no. It is saying no to people in my riding who are suffering from the worst farm crisis since 1933 and 1935. It is saying no to those people having a say to the finance committee which is made up of all five parties in this House of Commons. People should note that.

It is one thing to pick a fight with the Government of Canada, but it is another thing to hold other people hostage because of an ideological point of view. That is what is happening here in the House of Commons today.

I want to know whether or not the member for Kamloops agrees with those statements.

Committees Of The House October 29th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I do not know if the Reform Party member was in the House when I started to speak. I am not saying that at all. I started by saying that there should be a full debate and that the committee should travel and should hear from people. That is exactly what I am saying.

I am also saying that I do not want the Reform Party to hold the people of Saskatchewan hostage and deny the finance committee the right to travel to Saskatchewan, or anywhere else in the country, to hear about the important issues that are facing farmers, fishermen or people concerned about the health care system and so on.

Reformers are a bit mistaken. We are not saying that there should not be a full and fair debate. We are not saying that they should not have an opportunity to express themselves. There have been many times when opposition parties have had a great deal of impact on government policy and have forced governments to back down. They have the opportunity in terms of the Nisga'a debate to express themselves, to mobilize public opinion and to make their point of view known. We have not said that there should not be a committee travelling on the issue.

This debate is about whether or not the finance committee should travel across the country to hear from the ordinary citizens of Canada. We believe it should. We believe the Reform Party is wrong in trying to stop the finance committee from hearing from the good people of Saskatchewan and the people from other parts of the country on issues that concern them. We do not want the Reform Party to hold the people of the country hostage because of its concern over one issue.

Committees Of The House October 29th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I want to split a few minutes with my colleague from Kamloops to say a few words in support of the motion before the House today which states:

That the question be now put.

I do not think we need a lengthy debate on whether or not we put a question allowing for a vote on whether the finance committee should travel to hear from the Canadian people. I think we should do that as soon as possible.

I said before that I sympathize with some things the Reform Party is saying in terms of proper hearings on the Nisga'a agreement and treaties across the country; perhaps not just B.C. but other places as well.

I sympathize, having been here many years and as I have said many times myself, that time allocation is now used too often. Actually if we want to get historical about it, the current government House leader used to get up in row three over here and complain about the Mulroney government using time allocation time and time again. He did it with great eloquence.

Even the member from Pembroke is hanging his head in shame. Look at him back there. The cameras could not record that he was standing on chair. I hope his feet were clean when he did that.

The government House leader often used to say that when they were in government some day they would not do the same thing and would allow free and full debates, with all eloquence and so on. However the Liberals do not necessarily do the same thing in government as they do in opposition.

I also appeal to the Reform Party that despite the fact there should be a full debate on any issue in the House or in the committees, I do not think it should hold people involved in issues in other parts of the country hostage for its particular issue. This is really what is happening by denying the finance committee the right to travel.

I will use the example of Saskatchewan. We all know about the farm crisis and the two premiers who came here. Farm incomes are now at the lowest level since the 1930s. The wheat board just announced yesterday that the price would drop another 4% or 5% in terms of the forecast for this crop year. That is a serious issue. I think we all agree with that.

If we do not pass the motion before the House the finance committee will not go to Regina. It will not allow Mr. Larson, president of the Saskatchewan Wheat Pool, different farm organizations, different individuals, the chambers of commerce, the cities of Regina and Saskatoon or other prairie people, a chance to address the finance committee.

It is like a fight in a schoolyard. The Reform Party is saying that it is not getting its way, so it will punch other people back and not let them get their way as well. At least Reform Party members are being honest that they are using one of the few tools they have, but they are denying the rights and privileges of other Canadians because they feel their rights and privileges on a certain issue are not being met.

I do not think that is the way to achieve justice: “If I do not get my way then by damn you are not getting your way either”. I do not think that is the way we should operate. There are ways of making a point; there are ways of advocating a position.

I have seen opposition parties over the years stop a majority government dead in its tracks. I remember in 1985 the Mulroney government tried to partially deindex old age pensions. Within a week or two, despite the fact that it had the biggest majority in the history of the country at that time, riding at over 50% in the polls, between the pensioners and the opposition parties the government was forced to withdraw the proposal to partially deindex old age pensions. There are ways of doing it, but it is not done by denying the rights of other people, and this is what will happen today.

As an aside, is the Reform Party saying that the democratically elected members that form the House of Commons Standing Committee on Finance cannot travel to hear the opinions of people? What does it want to do? Does it want to send the Senate banking committee around the country to hear people's opinions, that undemocratic, unaccountable, unelected chamber? Is that what it wants to do?

We should stop playing games. We should vote on the motion as soon as possible to make sure that the finance committee can travel around the country to hear the views of the people on the fishery, the farm crisis, health care problems, or the problems of the homeless. There are many problems. The Reform cannot hold us hostage because it is unhappy with one particular issue. If we all start doing that this place will collapse in shear chaos.

I appeal to the Reform Party to come to its senses. The Reform Party used to talk about the grassroots. It wanted to hear from the grassroots. It wanted to hear from ordinary people.

Where are these members now? Where is the member from Nanaimo. I am sure he is embarrassed by his party's position that would deny ordinary people to speak about the farm crisis. That is exactly what he is doing by not allowing the finance committee to travel around the country.

Committees Of The House October 29th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I apologize to the member from the Reform Party for raising a point of order at this time, but I want to raise a question of order.

Members of parliament are watching television in the lobby. They are watching the Minister of Human Resources Development make an announcement on employment equity worth about $3 billion to $3.5 billion.

My point of order is that historically major announcements have been made in the House of Commons where the opposition parties can respond. It has been an almost iron-clad practice for many, many years.

Madam Speaker, I hate to put you on the spot, but perhaps you could consult with the table to see whether or not an announcement of this magnitude should have been made here in the House where the people's representatives can respond.

Committees Of The House October 29th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I have a short preamble to the question I have for the minister. I agree in some ways with Reform that closure and time allocation are used too often. I think we all agree with that. I also do not think it is necessary to have the finance minister go to London to make a financial statement. However, my understanding is that his motion before the House is not just about London, it is about allowing the finance committee to do what it traditionally does, which is to go around the country to consult the people. Unless I am mistaken, I think I have heard the leader of the Reform Party talk about grassroots and consultation with the ordinary folks of this country. I know in my case that people in Saskatchewan are quite anxious for the committee to visit Regina. It will be going to Regina to talk about the farm crisis. I spoke with the president of the Saskatchewan wheat pool yesterday.

I want to ask the minister across the way whether he can confirm that his motion indeed does say that it is not just London, but that this committee will go around the country to sell people in five or six different—

Agriculture October 29th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I want a commitment from the government that when those numbers are complete it will table them in the House.

I would also like to know why, at the same time the Prime Minister says the numbers are improving, the situation is getting better. The Canadian Wheat Board revised its predictions for prices this year and dropped those predictions by 4% or 5%, which means the situation is getting worse, not better?

How could the government be so out of touch when the Prime Minister is saying that things are getting better on one hand and the wheat board on the other hand says things are getting worse?

Agriculture October 29th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, yesterday the Prime Minister of Canada ambushed the premiers of Saskatchewan and Manitoba, saying he had new numbers that showed the farm crisis was not as bad as thought on the prairies. Yet he would not reveal those numbers publicly to the premiers or anybody else in the country.

I want the Prime Minister to make a commitment to table those numbers in the House or, better yet, to come out to Saskatchewan and Manitoba and give the numbers to the people. If he does not do that, is he saying that these are phantom numbers which do not exist?

Supply October 28th, 1999

Madam Speaker, this is not a very difficult question and the answer is that Onex president is Gerry Schwartz, and that he gives a lot of money to the Liberal Party.

This is why the member from Prince Edward Island does not dare stand up in this House and vote in favour of the Bloc Quebecois' motion. Mr. Schwartz contributed to the election funds of several Liberal candidates in the Toronto area during the last election campaign. This is one of the reasons why the Liberal Party will not support the motion.

Supply October 28th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I learned a long time ago that there is a difference when a Liberal talks about principles and when a Liberal puts something into action and into effect. Sometimes there is a long distance between the two.

I remember my grandfather telling me many years ago about the Liberal Party promising medicare in the campaign of 1919. I did not see medicare in this country until about 1965 after it was brought in by a CCF government in the province of Saskatchewan. There is a long distance between the principles of the Liberal Party and the action of the Liberal Party.

I remember very well the Liberal Party campaigning in this House against the GST. Does anyone else remember that? I was here. I saw the Liberals filibuster on the GST in the House of Commons. They spoke in committee hour after hour, “If we are elected to government in this country, we will abolish the GST. We will get rid of the GST”. About the only one who stood by her word was the Minister of Canadian Heritage who resigned her seat and ran in a byelection because of her commitment on the GST. I remember those debates.

I remember my friend from Prince Edward Island when he was the national president of the farmers union based in Saskatoon. I remember going out to his retirement and cheering him on as a good progressive left-wing thinker. Part of the reason was that he campaigned against the free trade deal. He was campaigning against NAFTA.

His Liberal Party was campaigning against NAFTA and the free trade deal. The Liberals were sitting in these benches calling Brian Mulroney a sell-out. They were elected and what happened? We are still part of the FTA. We are still part of NAFTA. There have been no changes, no amendments, nothing. We are now talking about selling our water. We are now part of the WTO. That former Canadian nationalist, Sergio Marchi,—I can use his name now as he is at the WTO—was campaigning against those deals. What is he doing now? He wants to expand them more and more.

That is the Liberal Party. Madam Speaker, I am sure if you were not in the chair you would get up and agree with me, because that is the history of the Liberal Party. Liberals say one thing and they do something else.

When members of the Liberal Party campaign in the opposition, they campaign for the left and they sound like New Democrats. When they are in government they sound like Conservatives, except for the last few years when they have sounded like Reformers. The Reform Party has set the agenda for them.