Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was terms.

Last in Parliament May 2004, as NDP MP for Regina—Qu'Appelle (Saskatchewan)

Lost his last election, in 2006, with 32% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Supply October 28th, 1999

If I have not been listening, I will be very interested in watching the member stand in his place here later on today and vote in favour of the motion put before the House. We will then see who is going to be listening, myself or the hon. member from P.E.I.

When Air Canada was privatized, parliament in its wisdom, and I think it made the wrong decision to privatize in the first place, decided that no entity could own more than 10% of Air Canada and that a maximum of 25% of it could be owned by foreigners. We were paralleling the Bank Act in many ways where nobody could own more than 10% of a bank and no more than 25% of a bank could be owned by non-Canadian entities, institutions, pension funds, et cetera. That is what happened.

Now the Liberal Party is considering increasing the 10% rule. I wonder why. It think it is doing that because the Minister of Transport is favouring the proposition put forward by Mr. Gerald Schwartz who is the president of Onex.

It is interesting to talk about Mr. Schwartz. Mr. Schwartz is one of the most effective fundraisers in the Liberal Party anywhere in the country, contributing and raising hundreds of thousands of dollars for the Liberal Party and for candidates in that party, in particular in the province of Ontario. I think this is part of what the debate is about. If it was not about that why would the government want to change the 10% rule? Why does the government not say to Mr. Schwartz or anyone else, “If you want to make a proposal, do it in the context of existing law”.

As my friend in the Reform Party says, it is like changing the rules in the middle of a game. That is what the Liberal Party wants to do. I am surprised at the hole that the Minister of Transport and the Prime Minister have on the backbenches. Some of these people will not rise in their place and say, “All this motion is doing is supporting the existing law in the country”. Why will they not get up and do that? It is because there is another agenda.

The minister from Toronto is favouring his buddy, Gerald Schwartz from Toronto, who is a big fundraiser for the Liberal Party of Canada. That is the kind of politics that we have here today. It says an awful lot about the need for more free votes in the House of Commons where a member can get up and voice his or her concern without fear of losing a job as a parliamentary secretary or chairmanship of a committee.

I have spoken to many members of the Liberal Party in the House who are dead set against what Gerald Schwartz is trying to do, who are not at all happy with the minister from Toronto and who are unhappy that the minister is talking about changing the rules to favour one airline over the other. Where are those people today? They are not going to get up and speak in support of the motion that is before the House.

This is a very important issue. I come from Saskatchewan. I come from a smaller market where we do not have many flights. We have very few flights by Canadian Airlines. We have a few more by Air Canada. We have very few flights in all. It is a captive market. The prices are very expensive in a small market like Regina or Saskatoon, Saskatchewan. People are very concerned about the future of the airline industry.

If the 10% rule goes through, how high does it have to go before in effect we lose control of an airline industry in the country to big financial institutions or big American airlines in the United States? I want members to think about that.

Even the Conservative Party of Brian Mulroney, when it privatized Air Canada, brought in the 10% rule for a purpose. It was to make sure the airline remained in Canadian hands. That was the Conservative Party.

Here we have a Liberal Party that is now more conservative than the Conservatives and more conservative than Brian Mulroney. It is a shame.

I can see members across the way nodding their heads in agreement that it is a real shame. If this rule goes through, we are going to lose the airline industry and people know that. It is only a matter of time before the big airlines buy out the Canadian airline industry, buy out Air Canada and Canadian Airlines. Big institutions in the United States will invest money and buy out these Canadian airlines.

That is the issue today. If we had a true parliamentary democracy in the country, the vote this afternoon on this motion would, I think, be overwhelming in terms of support for the motion put forward by the Bloc Quebecois. That is why we need change in terms of how the House governs itself.

Before my time expires, I have a couple of other things to say. One thing the government should consider is the federal government itself taking an equity position in a new national airline. I would suggest about 15%. I think 15% would give the people of the country, through the federal government, enough control to make sure that the industry stays in Canadian hands, that we have jobs here for Canadians, that rural communities and smaller communities will to be served, that the price which passengers pay when they fly on an airline will be reasonable regardless of the size of the Canadian market. I think that is one thing that can be done.

I believe that sooner or later, probably sooner than later, we are going to end up with one national airline. We do not have the market to support two big national airlines. I do not think any other country in the world, except the United States and perhaps Australia, has more than one national airline. Of course Australians have to fly almost always when they leave their country. I do not think we have the market to have two big national, successful, economic airlines in this country.

If we are going to have one airline, the government should seriously look at the possibility of an equity stake in that airline. The public should have some input and some clout. The public should have a couple of people on the board of directors of the airline and have some say over the direction in which that airline will go.

Those are some of the important issues we have to be debating today. I end by saying once again that we support the motion put forward by the Bloc. I think that the 10% rule will have to stay. If it goes, we are in danger of losing not only Air Canada, but Canadian as well within a few short years into the hands of investors from the United States.

Supply October 28th, 1999

Madam Speaker, the surprises never cease. I also want to say a few words in the debate.

I support the motion proposed by the Bloc Quebecois this afternoon on the future of Air Canada and Canadian Airlines in our country, Canada.

As I said, I really am in support of the motion put forward by the Bloc Quebecois today. I am surprised that some of my Liberal friends are not supporting it as well.

I remember, for example, my hon. friend from Prince Edward Island, when he used to be a progressive left-wing Liberal, would get up and make all kinds of speeches about Canadian nationalism and how we had to look after our own country and stand up for Canada. I remember that before he became power hungry and ran as a Liberal in Prince Edward Island. I wonder where those speeches are now.

All the Bloc Quebecois is doing today is moving a motion that respects existing Canadian law. I am sure you are surprised by this, Madam Speaker, but the Liberal Party is going to vote against it. What the Bloc is saying today is that we should respect the current law that says that no single entity, including someone as wealthy as the member from Prince Edward Island, can buy more than 10% of Air Canada. That is the law and that is what the Bloc is saying today.

What does the Liberal Party say? It says “No, we are not going to support that”.

Petitions October 27th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I am sure I will surprise you. I have a petition to abolish the Senate, signed by a number of residents of the city of Saskatoon.

The petitioners are saying that the Senate is unelected, undemocratic and unaccountable, that it costs the country about $50 million per year and that it undermines the elected role of members of parliament of the House of Commons. Therefore they call upon parliament to undertake measures aimed at the abolition of the Senate.

Banking October 27th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Minister of Finance.

The Bank of Montreal is about to close 100 branches throwing about 1,400 people out of work. This follows a year when the five men, who are the CEOs of the big banks, together made over $100 million last year, equivalent to the salary of about 4,000 mainly women bank tellers.

In light of this, can the minister tell us what he is going to do to stop these bank closures in communities that really matter? Or, is he just going to sit back and close his eyes and let the banks call all the shots?

The Late Hon. Alan Macnaughton October 21st, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I rise on behalf of our party to pay tribute to Alan Macnaughton who was the Speaker of the House from 1963 to 1965. He was first elected in 1949. He stayed in the House for seven terms until 1965.

Even though I did not know him personally when I came here in 1968—of course the member for Windsor West was here at that time—I heard about Mr. Macnaughton's reputation, which was a very positive one. He had a great influence on members on both sides of the House of Commons.

The reason he stepped aside in 1965 was to make way for a gentleman who some people may have heard of from the riding of Mount Royal, a fellow named Pierre Elliott Trudeau who became the member of parliament for that riding at that particular time.

When Mr. Macnaughton was the Speaker of the House, we should remind ourselves that it was only for two years but it was during a very difficult time in terms of being in your chair, Mr. Speaker. That was the other time in history when we had five political parties in the House of Commons like what you have today, Mr. Speaker. This makes refereeing this place a bit more difficult.

It was also during the days of the famous Diefenbaker-Pearson debates which became rather acrimonious at times and, as I understand, very heated. Mr. Pearson had just won the election from Mr. Diefenbaker in 1963. Mr. Macnaughton, who was respected by both sides of the House, was made the Speaker of the House of Commons by the prime minister of the day, Lester Pearson.

It was also a time when the House had a very divisive debate on the flag. I understand the debate went on for weeks and weeks before the days of time allocation or closure. Mr. Macnaughton made a very controversial but wise ruling at that time to split the resolution in two. He made his mark as a Speaker after only two years in the Speaker's chair.

He was a lawyer and a very successful business person. He was a very learned person, a very good academic and a very fine gentleman.

On behalf of our party I express our condolences to his family and to his many friends. He was a great Montrealer, a great Canadian, a great Quebecer and a great member of the House of Commons for 16 years.

Interest Rates October 21st, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question is for the acting Minister of Finance. Household debt now is at a record 101% of after tax income in this country. We have the highest mortgage rates now in some 42 months.

I wonder if the minister will screw up his courage and make representation to the Bank of Canada to hold the line on interest rates in this country?

Petitions October 20th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I have a petition signed by a number of people from Saskatchewan which states that the Senate of Canada is undemocratic, unelected and unaccountable, that it costs the taxpayers some $50 million per year, and that the Senate undermines the work of the elected members of parliament who sit in the House of Commons.

Therefore the petitioners are calling upon us to begin measures aimed at the abolition of the Senate. It is a good idea.

Speech From The Throne October 15th, 1999

Madam Speaker, the member talks about doing the right thing. I want to ask him about a very big crisis facing our country, namely the farming crisis on the prairies, the drop in farm income. Farm income is going down to negative levels. It is the biggest crisis since the 1930s.

We now have in Saskatchewan and Manitoba a joint alliance between all the political parties. For example, in my province of Saskatchewan all three political parties and the farm groups have gotten together and are requesting of the federal government an additional $1 billion in terms of emergency farm aid for our province. I am not talking about the AIDA program that is there now. I am talking about an additional $1 billion minimum of farm aid and farm assistance.

It is the largest farm crisis since the 1930s. People are going bankrupt. People are under stress. We have many letters here from children who have written about the stress in their families and the financial pain they are facing.

It has united all three political parties. It has united the farm groups and the chamber of commerce. It is a crisis like I have never seen because unlike the member, I was not here in the 1930s. It is a long time ago.

I want to ask the member whether he is open to helping us put pressure on the Minister of Finance and the Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food to use some of the several billions of dollars of surplus that are now accumulating to help farmers stay on the land.

I remind him that every time a farmer is better off in this country, we are all better off. When the farmer is better off, there are more jobs in the towns, cities and villages across the country. When the people have more jobs and the economy is stronger, there is more money for health care, there is more money for tax cuts and there is more money for education.

Whether the member will help us in that lobby is my question.

Agriculture October 15th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, the minister is obviously not listening. I have a letter from a 14 year old girl in Carragana, Saskatchewan. She is saying that nobody in parliament is listening to her on the farm crisis.

I wonder if the minister could answer my question directly as to whether or not there will be an extra $1 billion going to hard pressed farmers on the prairies. This is the worse farm crisis we have had since the 1930s. Could the minister answer that question directly? Would he screw up his courage and come out to the prairies to see for himself the severity of the crisis?

Agriculture October 15th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question is for the minister of agriculture. Yesterday the minister told his counterparts in Manitoba and Saskatchewan that they had to put up some money for the farm crisis themselves. That is like asking the farmers to pay for their own crisis as R.B. Bennett did in the 1930s.

The minister knows that in Saskatchewan there is a joint position of all parties in the farm groups asking for an additional $1 billion in emergency farm aid now, on top of what they already have from last year under AIDA.

Will the minister be forthcoming with that money since he took money out of the programs by eliminating the Crow a few years ago? How much money will come back to the farmers on the prairies?