Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was terms.

Last in Parliament May 2004, as NDP MP for Regina—Qu'Appelle (Saskatchewan)

Lost his last election, in 2006, with 32% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Taxation May 27th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Minister of Finance. The Toronto Dominion Bank released a study yesterday that said that personal incomes in this country are now 26% lower than in the United States. It also said that much of the damage was done due to government layoffs and cutbacks between 1993 and 1997 which cost us 180,000 jobs. Guess who was Minister of Finance during those years?

Besides cutting taxes for his wealthy friends and his buddies like Conrad Black, what is the Minister of Finance going to do to help increase the disposable income of the ordinary Canadian in this country? I know he is very close to Conrad Black but what about—

Government Grants May 25th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Prime Minister.

Will the Prime Minister explain to the House why he announced a $600,000 grant for a hotel in his constituency three weeks before that same hotel even submitted a business plan to federal officials?

Public Sector Pension Investment Board Act May 25th, 1999

Give me one quote.

Public Sector Pension Investment Board Act May 25th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I think there has been a real move toward executive government in the last 20 or 30 years.

I was first elected in 1968. Of course, I was about 12 years old then. I remember the great debate in 1969 when there was a move to take estimates off the floor of the House of Commons. The argument of the opposition in those days—the opposition leader was Mr. Stanfield, our leader was Tommy Douglas and Réal Caouette was the leader for the créditiste movement—was that the committees of the House must be strengthened to bring accountability to the committees of the House.

The House sat until the end of July. It was a debate that went on and on into the hot days and evenings of the summer of 1969. Of course that never happened. The Trudeau government rammed through the legislation in the end and we have the committees as we know them today.

I also remember 1984 when the Liberal Party came back with 40 some members after its great defeat at the hands of Brian Mulroney. In opposition those members started to talk a lot more about bringing in accountability. They wanted better parliamentary democracy, fewer confidence votes, more free votes and other things about which a lot of us are concerned. However, once they were elected again in 1993 they sort of forgot about that.

I remind members that the government across the way has had a majority for five years. It received 38% of the vote in one of the lowest turnouts in the history of the country when 67% of the people in the last election voted. When we take 38% of the 67%, it is sitting there with well under a third, probably a quarter of the Canadian people who have endorsed the government, and yet it has this awesome power of a majority and it cracks the whip all the time to make sure it happens.

I will give an example of what I mean. The other place, which we call the Senate, wants an increase of $5 million in its budget this year. It is, by definition, not elected, not accountable and not democratic.

We have checked with the procedural experts in your office, Mr. Speaker. No minister is responsible for the Senate. There is no one across the way who can answer on behalf of the Senate. If no minister is responsible for the Senate, therefore the government is not responsible for the Senate and therefore if one votes against the estimates of the Senate it is not a motion of non-confidence in the government across the way.

We will be having votes on the estimates, probably on June 9, and we will see the cracking of the whips as the Prime Minister deems the vote on the Senate estimates to be a matter of confidence.

The latest polls indicate that about 5% of Canadians support the existing Senate and 95% do not. Some Canadians want the Senate to be abolished, some want it to be reformed. That is not part of the argument. Five per cent of the people support the existing Senate, and yet the Prime Minister will crack the whips and deem that to be a confidence vote.

I think that is the best example of the need for radical parliamentary change to make this place democratic, meaningful and accountable to the Canadian people. It is actually quite embarrassing to vote for $5 million to be given to an institution which only 5% of the Canadian people want, especially when it will be deemed a confidence vote by the Prime Minister.

Public Sector Pension Investment Board Act May 25th, 1999

A Liberal member is saying that they cannot spend it. This is very revealing. Maybe he should talk to retired public servants, retired RCMP officers and retired military personnel in the country. The Liberal government is saying that they cannot spend it, that they have too much money and that they cannot have higher pensions. The government says the Canada pension is better indexed. It says retirees cannot spend the money so it is going to take the money from them and use it for other purposes.

This is a Liberal member revealing in the House today that these retired pensioners cannot spend the money. I hope our pensioners understand that the Liberals' position is that pensioners cannot spend the money so it will take it use it for other purposes. That is a very revealing statement. I am sure, Mr. Speaker, that you, as a very non-partisan officer of the House, would be scandalized to get up in your place and comment on a question like that.

I hear laughter from across the way. The Liberals are embarrassed to hear this Liberal member from Hamilton saying that they cannot spend the money. What has been said today is very revealing. It is more revealing than when the minister got up and read a prepared and scripted text written by bureaucrats.

I want to make three points. The first point is that the government has really held the pensioners in the country in contempt by not having a proper public hearing on this bill today. It is a very major step and a major initiative. There should have been very extensive public hearings so pensioners could have had a say in what was happening to their money. If we had a parliamentary democracy that was worth writing home about, the pensioners would have had a say. However, that is not the case.

I noticed an article in the paper awhile ago by a very distinguished journalist, Doug Fisher. He said that the government was really holding the pensioners and the opposition parties in contempt. He said that the government was ignoring the parliament of the country by bringing in closure to force the bill through the House of Commons. I gather the Prime Minister will designate this as a confidence vote forcing Liberal backbenchers to vote with the government to make sure this is railroaded through the House.

The time has come for serious parliamentary change so some of the Liberals across the way, who do have some independent, free thinking minds, can get up and speak their minds and their piece on this. It is about time we had that kind of parliamentary reform and change, but that has not happened.

Later today the Prime Minister will use his power and his whips to make sure that Liberal trained seals on the backbenches get up and vote yes in favour of Bill C-78. That really is a tragedy and a shame in terms of our parliamentary democracy.

I am sure many Liberals across the way, like the member from downtown Toronto, are hanging their heads in shame because they cannot get up and speak their piece. All they can do is laugh at the plight of the pensioners.

I remember back in 1985 when Prime Minister Brian Mulroney tried to partially de-index old age pensions. There was a huge demonstration on Parliament Hill and grey power across the country organized rapidly. A little woman, Madam Denis, went up to the prime minister and said to him in French “You lied to us. Vous avez menti”. The people forced the largest majority government in the history of this country, which I believe had 211 seats and was sitting at over 50% in the polls, to back down. That government is not here today and one of the reasons is because of what it tried to do to seniors.

I remind the Liberal government that if it wants to take a leaf out of Brian Mulroney's book it is well on its way to alienating a lot of Canadians, a lot of seniors in this country. That is one point I wanted to make.

The other point I want to make concerns the investment board which will be set up to invest part of the money in the fund. We have discovered that there will not be any ethical screening of those investments. For example, the Canada pension plan now has an investment board which invests about 15% of CPP funds in the stock market. That investment is made in accordance with the TSE 300 Index, which means that some of the money is going into Imasco which owns Imperial Tobacco.

Imperial Tobacco is a company which is encouraging young people to smoke and become addicted to cigarettes. I think that contravenes a stated public policy of the Government of Canada, including the Minister of Health, that we are encouraging people to stop smoking. We are aiming campaigns at children to encourage them to stop smoking. On the other hand the Canada pension plan is tying part of its future success to kids who smoke by buying shares in Imperial Tobacco. I think that is wrong.

I know that the Minister of Finance is committed to look at that in terms of the Canada pension plan. I wish the minister in charge of this bill would also take a look at whether we should bring in ethical screening in terms of the investments board's investments when it comes to the superannuation of retired public servants. I do not think it is right to invest pensioners' money in companies like Imperial Tobacco and indeed other companies which pollute our atmosphere, which use child labour in different parts of the world and which are irresponsible socially and ethically. I would urge the government to amend this bill to bring in ethical investment guidelines. I would certainly support an amendment to that effect.

I cannot support a bill that is going to take $30 billion away from the pensioners of this country, but we could certainly improve the bill. That is what parliamentary democracy is all about, suggesting ideas and policies to make legislation better. However, again the trained seals across the way are going to vote in accordance with the Prime Minister's wishes. The member from the central part of Toronto, the member from Spadina, wants to be a cabinet minister, so he is not going to alienate the Prime Minister.

If we had some serious democratic reform in the House the member from Spadina could propose an amendment to bring in ethical screening of the investments made by the investment board. That is what we should be doing in this case and in other cases as well.

I want to address the whole question which has become controversial with some Liberal backbenchers, which is that the benefits will apply to people in conjugal relationships. The issue that is raised time and again is, are the rights of gays and lesbians to be treated the same as people in common law relationships. I certainly support that thrust of the bill.

I want to make it very clear that we should be treating people equally in this country, regardless of sexual orientation or personal circumstances. Therefore, I would appeal to Liberal members who are in opposition to that part of their own bill to support the thrust of the bill in terms of equality of people whether they are living in a common law relationship or whether they are gays and lesbians living in that type of relationship as well. That is very important. There was a supreme court decision very recently and I think we are making progress in that general area.

I want to say once again that I am discouraged closure was brought in on this bill. I was very dismayed to hear a Liberal member say in the House today that seniors do not need the $30 billion, that they could not spend it anyway. The member from Hamilton said “They could not spend it anyway”. Hansard will indicate that is exactly what he said from his seat on the far left-hand side of the House.

I also believe there should have been proper parliamentary hearings and discussions. There should have been hearings with retired military personnel, retired government workers and the RCMP over the direction of this bill and what to do with the money in the fund. That has not happened.

Let us make sure that when we set up investment funds, which is something new in terms of pension legislation in the country, we bring in the principle of ethical screening to make sure that the public funds being invested on behalf of pensioners in the future and today will be done ethically in accordance with the wishes of the vast majority of the Canadian people.

Public Sector Pension Investment Board Act May 25th, 1999

I hear a Liberal member on the other side saying nonsense. I wish he would get up in the House and make a speech about this and face his constituents who are concerned about the government taking $30 billion of their money and using it for general revenue purposes.

Public Sector Pension Investment Board Act May 25th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I will be very brief because the member for Winnipeg North Centre is very anxious to give a long speech in the House today and I want to share my time with her.

We have a very important bill before the House today, Bill C-78, which deals with the pension funds and superannuation of retired public servants, including the RCMP and the armed forces. It has become a very controversial bill because the government wants to use the $30 billion surplus that has accumulated in those funds to go back into the consolidated revenue fund or to the Government of Canada so it can pay down the debt or use for its general operations.

I submit that this is really theft of a lot of money that the federal government has collected in pensions. It should go for pension purposes for retired public servants in the country.

Carriage By Air Act May 14th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I do not believe the triple E idea is ever going to happen. We would need an amendment to the Constitution and the unanimous consent of all provinces along with the federal parliament in order to do that. I do not think we are ever going to get Quebec to agree to have the same number of senators as Prince Edward Island, let alone Ontario having the same number of senators as New Brunswick. If we did get that agreement the powers would be so weak and ineffective it would not matter if we had a Senate in the first place. It comes right down to the fact that this is never going to happen.

I do not think we need a second elected body in terms of bureaucracy and the many more politicians who would be funded. The amount involved would be greater than the $50 million we see today. This would invite gridlock between the two Houses.

In answer to the member's question, we need to bring accountability into the House of Commons. We need to bring the review process into the House of Commons by reforming and democratizing this place.

The powers of the Prime Minister's Office and the Privy Council Office have to be reduced. These questions were raised in the House today by the Reform Party and I certainly agree. The appointment of justices and the appointment of senior people in the government should have a parliamentary and democratic review as is done in most countries around the world.

Our parliamentary committees should be stronger and have more independence where legislation can be initiated. We should have fewer confidence votes in the House of Commons. All kinds of bills go through this place that should not be confidence bills. Parliamentarians should be able to vote their own line and express their own point of view. That should be done.

I also believe that we should have fixed election dates, fixed dates for budgets and fixed dates for throne speeches. This would again take power away from the government and away from the Prime Minister and the executive.

Why do I say that? I say it because we need big democracy in this country. There have only been two elections since 1921 where a majority of the people voted for a majority government and those were the governments of Mackenzie King in 1945 and John Diefenbaker in 1958. Every other time a majority has been elected by a minority of the people. This Liberal government has the support of 38% of the Canadian people, yet it has had a majority for five years. I think that is wrong without accountability built into this place.

We should be looking at modernizing our electoral system by bringing in a mix of proportional representation so the vote of the people is reflected by the composition of the House. We are now one of only two or three countries in the world without a mix of PR. We are not a modern electoral democracy and the minister across the way knows this.

Even Britain, the mother of parliaments, has a mix of PR in the Scottish assembly and the Welsh assembly. In the election after the next, it will be brought into the United Kingdom parliament itself. There is an election taking place now for the European parliament where every member from Great Britain is being elected through PR, through regional constituencies.

Those are things which we should be looking at. Every other country in the world has modernized its electoral system. We can do it in Canada as well.

Carriage By Air Act May 14th, 1999

He did not scurry or crawl but he did make an exit. Maybe he will come back in again after he has a bowl of soup or something.

I want to raise this very serious question because this bill originated in the other place. In the last poll I have seen, the other place has the support of about 5% of the Canadian people. Five per cent of the Canadian people support the existing Senate, support the structure of the other place.

There is a great debate in the country as to whether or not it should be abolished or reformed. Of the remaining 95% of the Canadian people, they are roughly divided equally between reforming the other place and electing it in some way, and just abolishing it and getting rid of it. That is the debate.

It seems very strange that the government across the way would originate a bill in a place that is not elected, not accountable and has the support of 5% of the Canadian people. I do not know another democracy in the world that would legitimize the other place by originating a bill in the other place when it is not elected.

We are not talking about a board, or a commission or an agency. We are talking about a legislative body that can initiate legislation to change the laws of the country. I think that is a serious democratic issue in a modern-day parliamentary democracy.

Mr. Speaker, I see you sitting in your chair looking pretty sad yourself when you start reflecting on the state of democracy in the country. I am also pretty sad to see the government doing this time and time again.

The Canadian people do not support that institution. Ninety-five per cent of Canadians are saying that they do not support the existing institution of the Senate. Yet the government time and time again will go there to initiate legislation. That is fundamentally wrong. I would like to see government members stand up and defend why they do this.

There is one minister in the House now who is listening very carefully to this debate. We have time this afternoon for him to get up and respond as to why they insist on doing this. The time has come for us to have a serious debate about electoral and parliamentary democracy and how to make this institution more meaningful.

I knew the government House leader many years ago. I remember in 1968 when I was first elected he was working in the House. The turnout in that election campaign was about 80% of the population. In the last election campaign it went down to about 67%. More and more people are giving up on the electoral system. They are losing confidence in the electoral system. More and more people are cynical of politicians and the political process.

One reason is that we have a legislative body that initiates legislation. It is not elected, not accountable and not democratic. We cannot get back at those people. If a Reform member from British Columbia or an NDP member from Regina does something people do not like, every three, four or five years the people can say no. I experienced that in 1993 when I lost the seat of Yorkton—Melville in Saskatchewan.

What can we do about a senator? There is nothing that can be done about someone in the other place, short of their being convicted for some serious criminal activity and being forced out by their colleagues. There was one who was living in Mexico for a long period of time. He had to resign under the pressure of public opinion. Short of that, there is no way of holding those people accountable and keeping their feet to the fire.

There are members in the other place who do not live in their home provinces and hardly ever go back to them. They do not go to meet their people. Some of them have even lived outside of the country. They draw a salary and expenses roughly equivalent to those of a member of parliament. They travel the world. People think they are like American senators so the red carpet is rolled out for them. That is the kind of institution we tolerate. We spend $50 million a year of taxpayers' money funding the other place.

Think of the homeless people under a bridge a few blocks from Parliament Hill who could use a few thousand dollars for public housing. Think of the money we could put into training and skills to put people to work. Think of the farmers we talked about in question period today who are now on a suicide watch because they do not have money to pay their bills. Yet we pay those people in the other place, who have no obligations whatsoever in terms of accountability, $50 million. And the government across the way initiates legislation in the other place.

I hope the government House leader will rise to his feet and explain to us how in the name of modern democracy he can tolerate such a situation. I can say that the Canadian people do not tolerate it. Only 5% of them support the other place, yet we have a government that ignores the wishes of 95% of the Canadian people. My oh my, once in power how they change their minds and how they change their hearts.

I hope the minister across the way will answer the questions on behalf of the people of this country.

Carriage By Air Act May 14th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, at the outset I want to say that I am splitting my time with the hon. member for Churchill River.

This bill is called Bill S-23. For people watching today, bills come here called C which means Commons. Some are called S which means they originated in the Senate rather than the House of Commons.

I object to having a bill originating in what we call the other place. The other place is not elected, it is not democratic and it is not accountable to the Canadian people.

I see the minister, who is the government House leader across the way, hanging on to the curtain in the back. I would like to know from him why more and more bills are originating in the other place. I can see him shaking his head but I cannot hear what he is saying. Now he is scurrying out the back door.