Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was terms.

Last in Parliament May 2004, as NDP MP for Regina—Qu'Appelle (Saskatchewan)

Lost his last election, in 2006, with 32% of the vote.

Statements in the House

National Housing Act April 29th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I want to say a few words in this debate on the housing bill.

I ask publicly of the senior minister in the House today, the Minister of National Revenue, why has the Liberal Party strayed so far from its progressive roots of Lester Pearson and Paul Martin, Sr. when it comes to social policy and social housing?

I remember years ago when the ministry of urban affairs was created. I was a member of the House when the first policy steps were taken in the Trudeau years toward more social housing in Canada. In the last few years it seems to me that the Liberals have forgotten where they stood in those days when they were more progressive.

It seems to me that the Reform Party has had a tremendous impact in setting the agenda, in being the rudder in terms of the new Liberal policies. The Minister of National Revenue is shaking his head, I can hear it from here. I think he would probably agree with what I am saying if we had the kind of parliamentary system that would allow a bit more freedom and independence for expressing ourselves in the House.

The Liberal Party at one time was socially progressive, starting with the great thinkers conference in Kingston many years ago with Tom Kent. Lester Pearson was leader of the opposition. I remember people like Eric Kierans in the party and the three wise men coming out of Quebec, Trudeau, Pelletier and Jean Marchand. They talked about a new and just society, about participatory democracy. They swept a young man, the member for Vancouver South—Burnaby, the Minister of National Revenue, off his feet and into what he found was a great social democratic revolution. All of a sudden it went poof and the whole thing disappeared.

This is an open debate. We have 10 minutes on each of these amendments. I would like the Minister of National Revenue to explain why the party has lost its way. This minister is very ambitious. He wants to take on the Minister of Finance as a leadership candidate. He wants to challenge Brian Tobin and the Minister of Health as the left-wing progressive Liberal in terms of challenging the Minister of Finance for the leadership of the Liberal Party of Canada.

I think we ought to hear from the Minister of National Revenue and have him explain what his vision is for social housing and what his vision is on what we do about homeless Canadians. I am sure the Reform Party is sitting here with great anticipation to hear where this Liberal stands.

Just last night I was coming back from a function at the Cuban Embassy, and I did not see the minister there by the way. I saw homeless people sleeping under a bridge not too far from Parliament Hill. They were not Cubans, they were Canadians. These were homeless people. A number of years ago there were not many homeless people around the streets of Ottawa, Toronto, Montreal, Regina or Vancouver. Now there is homelessness.

The government has established a ministry responsible for homelessness and the minister is from New Brunswick. I want to know what the vision of that ministry would be. Will there be funding for that ministry? A New Brunswick member is here in the House. Perhaps he knows whether or not there will be funding for that ministry of homelessness. What is the vision? How do we find homes for people?

We have a government bill before the House today that is going to be regressive in terms of the amendments. It seems to be tilted toward the marketplace and commercialization of CMHC in terms of its lending policies, and the influence of the Minister of Finance and his conservative bent.

I would like the Minister of National Revenue to tell us what the vision should be in terms of social housing, homelessness and what we should do about the number of Canadians who are suffering from falling incomes. The gap between the rich and the poor has widened radically in the last five to ten or twelve years. Yet the government across the way is the government that has made the most drastic cutbacks in the history of our country in terms of social programs, particularly health care.

Of course the taxes go up. They go up very unfairly and indiscriminately. It is an unfair tax system in Canada. Most taxes are placed on the backs of the people who are least able to pay them, low income and middle income people.

In any event, we have a lot of time this afternoon. I would like to sit down now and give the Minister of National Revenue an opportunity to tell us what his vision is of social housing, what his vision is in terms of homelessness, what his vision is in terms of where we should go to narrow the gap between the rich and the poor. After all, as we all know, he wants to be a leadership candidate on the left of the Liberal Party. He wants to challenge the Minister of Finance to the mantle of the leadership of the Liberal Party of Canada. I want to know where he stands.

Tobacco April 29th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Minister of Finance.

As the minister knows, billions of dollars in the new CPP investment fund is now being invested to reflect the TSE 300 index and that includes investment in Imperial Tobacco through its parent company Imasco. As members know, Imperial Tobacco is targeting young people, trying to addict them to cigarettes.

Does the minister agree that it is morally and ethically wrong to link, at least in part, the quality of seniors' pension plans in the future to addicting young people to cigarettes today?

Association's Act April 28th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, we of course agree that there is unanimous consent for this. It is a bill that is routine in terms of being accepted by all parties of the House.

However, I did want to register, on behalf of my party, an objection to the fact that this originated in the Senate. This appears to happen more and more often with this government. It is not elected, it is not accountable and it is not democratic. The bill should originate in the elected House of Commons representing the people of Canada. I am sure the member for Sarnia—Lambton would agree with that.

Hepatitis C April 28th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Minister of Health.

Last summer Joey Haché travelled across the country collecting over 35,000 signatures asking for fairness in compensation for victims of hepatitis C. Joey Haché was with us today in Oral Question Period and a lot of people who have hepatitis C are watching what is happening here.

I want to give the Minister of Health an opportunity to speak directly to Joey Haché and others who suffer from hepatitis C and to tell them why they have not been fairly compensated with a just compensation and why it has not been done over the last several months.

Canada Pension Plan April 27th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question concerns the Canada pension plan.

The government is aware that there are about 100 firefighters in the hallways this week lobbying. I think the government understands as well that this is the most dangerous occupation in the country.

The firefighters are requesting that they be able to qualify for reduced CPP benefits at age 55, with full benefits at age 60, rather than the current ages of 60 and 65.

Would the Minister of Human Resources Development agree to propose an amendment to the Canada pension plan so that firefighters can receive those benefits at an earlier age because of their dangerous occupation and do so without financial loss?

Supply April 27th, 1999

Madam Speaker, now there is a very important UN initiative. The secretary general is in Europe. This is a very important initiative. We support it.

Also in the future there is going to be a ceasefire, there is going to be a settlement, and hostilities will stop in that part of the world. I believe there is going to be a need for an international force to keep the peace. We believe in our party that the force should come under the auspices of the United Nations.

Supply April 27th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I certainly agree and I think that is what I said at the beginning of my remarks.

I am pleased there are some initiatives on the diplomatic front. I am pleased our Minister of Foreign Affairs will be involved in these diplomatic initiatives. I am pleased the Secretary General of the United Nations is now trying to involve himself and the United Nations in seeking a diplomatic solution to what is happening in Yugoslavia and Kosovo.

I fully agree with what the member has said. I am sorry I was not here for question period yesterday. I have no idea what the Minister of National Defence said either inside or outside the House.

Supply April 27th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I wish to say a few words in the debate this morning, basically to underline the importance of a serious diplomatic thrust to try to bring an end to this very unfortunate conflict. Hopefully the initiatives being taken now by the foreign affairs minister, by the Russians and by others will bear fruit. We should put a real emphasis on trying to accelerate the diplomatic efforts of finding peaceful solutions to what is happening in Yugoslavia, what is happening in Kosovo.

It need only be said in passing that we oppose what Milosevic is doing. It is abhorrent. It is barbaric. Something has to be done to stop what he is doing to the people in Kosovo. I also believe that we should try to escalate the presence of the United Nations in terms of it taking an initiative to do what it can to bring about a very peaceful solution. Right now people are suffering in that part of the world. People are being bombed. People are being killed. People are being exterminated. That has to end and end as soon as possible.

I want to try to bring a bit of human face to this situation if I possibly can. In 1968 I had the opportunity to go into the middle of a very vicious civil war in Nigeria, into the breakaway province of Biafra. This morning I dug up a comment in a speech I made in the House on November 26, 1968, a little over 30 years ago. I was only 12 years old; I was elected at the age of 11 or thereabouts to the House.

I spent two weeks over there. I spent one week on the Nigerian side and I spent one week in the war zone on the Biafran side. I had an experience which changed my life forever in terms of what humanity is all about. I literally saw people dying after being bombed. I saw people dying of starvation in huge sick bays in refugee camps.

At that particular time I travelled there with a Liberal member of parliament by the name of Ralph Stewart. Before us a couple of other MPs had gone, a Conservative named David MacDonald and a New Democratic named Andrew Brewin. We went there to try to bring attention to the suffering and the need for some humanitarian help.

I can remember flying into what was then known as Biafra. At that time the Nigerian armies had encircled the province of Biafra. There was a form of genocide going on where hundreds of thousands of people were dying. We flew in under the cover of darkness on a church plane bringing drugs and landed on a small jungle air strip. I spent seven horrifying days actually seeing what happens when there is war.

I remember being caught in a bombing raid and having bombs drop literally a few metres away. We thought we were going to die because these bombs were coming out of the darkness of a jungle night. People were screaming. Some people were saying the rosary. Other people were crying and running and being scattered.

The terror is hard to put into words. I reread the speech I made in the House back on November 26, 1968 describing the trip. The then minister of external affairs was Mitchell Sharp, and he spoke right after me.

One of the things we saw was a Catholic hospital that had just been bombed. Another was a Red Cross hospital that had just been bombed, both of them by mistake, I am sure, according to the military authorities at the time.

We also went to many refugee camps and what they called feeding centres and sick bays. They would feed people at five o'clock in the morning just before dawn, before sunrise, because if the bombers came over and saw a huge crowd of people in a jungle opening there was a chance that there could be an attack.

One of things I referred to in my speech, and I remember it to this day, was going to a feeding bay where they had 3,500 pregnant and nursing women coming for their daily iron pills and a bit of fish stock that was provided because of the protein in fish.

To go through this experience, to get caught in a bombing raid, to hear the airplanes doing the strafing, to go up to a war front and see wounded soldiers, and to be close enough to hear the rat-a-tat-tat of machines guns in the darkness of a jungle night, it certainly had an impression on me. I did not think I would come back many times during that one week. It had an impression on me of how uncivilized human beings are at times to one another. Everything has to be done to bring an end to that kind of torture and torment. I just wanted to relate some of those comments to try to make this situation a little more real.

The brunt of the situation now is being borne by the Kosovars who are in huge refugee camps. Some are in Macedonia and some in Albania. Many of the Kosovars are still trapped behind the lines in their native province, the part of Serbia they come from and have lived for many years. Many of these people are dying of starvation. Many of these people are being shot. They are being executed.

I remember when I was in Biafra, for example, at a hospital or a church when a worker came out of the jungle with a child in his arms who might have been four or five years old. The child was basically just the skeleton of someone who was barely clinging to life. In my life I have never seen a person as emaciated or skinny as that little child was.

That kind of thing is happening now. It is happening in Yugoslavia and it is happening because of a madman named Milosevic. It is also happening because there are NATO bombs being dropped in Yugoslavia.

When I was in these little jungle villages and lying there with bombs dropping, I realized one thing. A bomb does not discriminate between a very poor black African peasant and a white politician from the western world. It does not discriminate at all. If one did not believe that going into that situation, it becomes a reality extremely quickly when a bomb is dropping out of the sky. We all have the same kinds of fears.

Those people are going through hell on earth and there is no better way of putting it than that. It is an absolute hell on earth. We should do what is being initiated today. We should do whatever we can to escalate the diplomatic offensive by bringing in Russia, the United Nations and other countries like Canada that are highly respected in the international forum and building up the diplomatic offensive to try to bring an end to the killing, the torture, the bloodshed and the hell on earth that is occurring in that part of the world. That is what we have to do.

At the same time we should signal as a country that we do not want to escalate the conflict by being part of a naval blockade. I do not think we should be doing that. It just leads into the possibility of making the situation more of a tinderbox. It brings in the possibility of a conflict with Russia.

The oil that goes into Yugoslavia comes primarily from Libya and from Russia. As the President of France, Jacques Chirac, said a few days ago, if one stops a ship bringing oil to that part of the world it is basically an act of war. We know the situation now in Russia where there is basically no government. It is a situation that is almost analogous to anarchy. There are ultranationalists, communists, unrest and economic chaos. It would not take much to push that country into a situation where this conflict could escalate beyond control of the world.

We should do everything we can, absolutely everything we can, to bring a diplomatic end to this kind of a crisis. Those people are suffering. Those people are dying.

As we talk today there is a child dying. There is somebody being shot, someone being mutilated. Thousands of people are hungry. People have lost their families. People are crying. People do not know where their homes are. Their homes have been destroyed. This is real and genuine human suffering.

We stand here in a parliament well dressed, well fed, well nourished and with shelters over our heads. It is difficult to imagine the suffering these human beings are going through. They are like us. They are human beings. They are being deprived of their loved ones. They are human beings that suffer pain and death and see their families being killed.

This kind of thing is very dangerous and could escalate. We have a fine reputation around the world, going back to the days of Lester Pearson and before, where we are the peacemakers. We are respected. We have diplomatic clout and diplomatic power. We should do all we can to escalate that and emphasize that in the hours and days that remain in the next week or so.

Petitions March 24th, 1999

The other petition is one that will probably surprise you, Mr. Speaker.

I have a petition signed by 104 Canadians calling for the abolition of the Senate. They say the Senate costs $50 million a year, that it is undemocratic, unelected and unaccountable. I can even see the Liberal whip shaking his head in acknowledgement of that. The petitioners say it should be abolished. With great pride I table this petition. Mr. Speaker, I hope you will consider it very sincerely because you have tremendous influence on policy in this country.

Petitions March 24th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I have the honour to table two petitions in the House today.

One is signed by what appears to be hundreds of people who ask the House of Commons to pass a private member's motion on the Tobin tax. Of course, we did that yesterday in the House of Commons.

The petition deals with the notion that we have a financial transaction tax in concert with the world community because of the tremendous flow of capital around the world, over $1 billion a day. I want to table this petition. Of course, the motion passed yesterday by a vote of 164 to 83, with some members of all parties supporting it.