Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was terms.

Last in Parliament May 2004, as NDP MP for Regina—Qu'Appelle (Saskatchewan)

Lost his last election, in 2006, with 32% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Infrastructure March 10th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Prime Minister. There is a special road leading to a special chalet in Grand'Mère built at public expense on land leased from the town at the price of $1 a year. I have no doubt that the RCMP built this road for proper security reasons. There is something odd about this lease. It runs for 10 years and can be renewed for another 15 years.

Does the Prime Minister expect to be in office until the year 2023, at which time the Minister of Finance will be 85 years old? Does the Prime Minister—

Points Of Order March 5th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I would also ask for unanimous consent to table a memo entitled “Talking points on the spending estimates for the Senate”. This is a memo sent to all Liberal MPs.

The Senate March 5th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, the minister has not answered the question. I will ask him once again. I have a lot of respect for many government backbenchers in the House. I hope the minister has the same respect for his backbenchers as I have.

Will the vote on the estimates coming from the Senate where it wants an extra 6% this year on top of 10% last year be considered an issue of confidence in the Government of Canada? Answer that question directly. Will it be a confidence vote or not? We have to know that. Are members free to vote their own minds?

The Senate March 5th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question is to the government House leader. I want to ask him what the government considers to be a motion of confidence. It pertains of course to the request of the Senate for a 6% increase in its budget this year after a 10% increase last year.

According to parliamentary procedure a vote against the Senate estimates is not a vote of non-confidence unless the government deems it to be so.

I have a copy of a memo that went out to all Liberal MPs yesterday that appears to be deeming this vote a motion of non-confidence. My question is very simple to the minister.

Will the government be considering the vote on the estimates coming from the Senate for its increase of 6% a matter of confidence in the government?

The Senate March 4th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question for the Prime Minister was about the abolition of the Senate. No wonder we have cynicism when questions are not answered.

Fourteen years ago the Prime Minister, speaking in the House, said “I am appalled by the attitude of the prime minister”, meaning Brian Mulroney. “He is the prime minister and he wants to abolish the Senate. He has enough members to do it. He does not have to play games with anyone in this House and cop out like that”.

In light of those statements by this Prime Minister in those days, why does he not now consult with the premiers in the provinces and put a motion before the House to start the process of the abolition of the Senate?

The Senate March 4th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Prime Minister. It is a follow up to my question about the Senate a couple of days ago.

Some of the senators, who of course are unelected, are now threatening to delay or even to block some of the work of parliament because of a dispute over the request for an extra 6% in their budget on top of 10% last year. Such an action would thwart the will of the elected member of parliament.

Will the Prime Minister now consult with the premiers in the provinces and, after that consultation, come before the House and put the appropriate resolution before the Parliament of Canada to abolish the Senate?

Petitions March 3rd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I too have a petition surprisingly signed by 104 people, I guess representing 104 senators. I notice they are from Hamilton, London, and Grimsby, Ontario; and Saskatoon, Regina, and Pilot Butte, Saskatchewan; and so on. These people are saying the Senate is undemocratic, unelected, unaccountable and costs the Canadian people some $50 million a year. They are saying it undermines the role of MPs in the House of Commons. They want to modernize parliamentary institutions. Because of that, these 104 people are calling upon the House of Commons to begin the process of abolition of the Senate.

The Senate March 2nd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, the hon. member is not applying and never would.

When the Prime Minister was the member from Shawinigan back on March 5, 1985, he asked the following question to the then prime minister. He said “Mr. Speaker, I am a bit appalled by the attitude of the Prime Minister. He is the Prime Minister and if he wants to abolish the Senate he has enough members to do it. He does not want to have to play games with us or anybody in this House and he should not cop out like that”.

In light of that, will the Prime Minister accept his own advice, show some leadership, and appoint someone from his own party to consult with the opposition to try to find a consensus as to what to do with the other place?

The Senate March 2nd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I have a question for the Prime Minister about his constitutional responsibility to appoint senators. There are now three vacancies in the Senate and depending upon court proceedings there may be a couple of others. The legitimacy of the Senate is now in tatters.

Would the Prime Minister consider a pause or a freeze on the appointment of senators for a few weeks or months and instead appoint someone from his own party to consult with members of the opposition parties to see if we could find a consensus on what to do with the Senate in this parliament?

The Budget February 18th, 1999

I really hesitate to ask a question, Madam Speaker. I do not want the member to get too worked up in the House.

It is the member's party that had the biggest cutback in the history of this country in terms of health care in February 1995. Even with the additions in this budget, it will be 2004 before the same expenditure is made that was made in 1995 in terms of transfers to the provinces for health care. Nine years later we get back to 1995.

Is the member not ashamed and embarrassed to sit in a government that was so conservative that it had the biggest cutback in terms of social transfers in the history of this country? Is he not ashamed of that?

I know the member from Scarborough who sits behind him, the fellow with the beard, hangs his head in shame when I talk about that issue. Does the hon. member share the same opinion as the member from Scarborough?