House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was province.

Last in Parliament May 2004, as Progressive Conservative MP for St. John's East (Newfoundland & Labrador)

Won his last election, in 2000, with 53% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Poverty March 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, it gives me no pleasure to note that over 5 million of our fellow Canadians, 1.5 million of them children, are living in poverty.

That means one in six people in the nation is faced daily with circumstances that generally include insufficient nourishment, substandard or non-existent housing and an increased vulnerability to illness.

The PC party of Canada has set up a task force on poverty co-chaired by my colleague from Shefford. Our first set of public hearings will be held in Saint John, New Brunswick on Friday coming. We will be in St. John's, Newfoundland on April 19 as part of a cross-country tour.

There are no easy solutions to this difficult problem. However, it is necessary to tackle the issue and so I encourage individuals and groups to attend our meetings. Together we can make recommendations to government in the hope that policies will be implemented to close the growing gap between the rich and poor.

Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements Act March 10th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I am very pleased today to say a few words on a very important bill not only for the province of Newfoundland and Labrador but for all provinces that receive equalization payments. I believe there are seven provinces in Canada that receive them.

The provinces are very highly dependent on equalization to better their economic situation within the country. It is very important to have the bill fully debated today by all members, if for no other reason than to make the federal government fully aware of the impact of equalization payments on the seven provinces of Canada that are recipients of the equalization formula.

I was told that before the bill came before the House of Commons the province of Newfoundland requested some significant changes to the way the formula treats offshore resources, especially offshore oil and gas. The government, I am told, rejected that request by Premier Tobin and the Government of Newfoundland and Labrador. There really will not be any substantive changes made in the bill, probably a few minor housekeeping changes.

Once again the poorest province in Canada, the province of Newfoundland, will be penalized by the current equalization formula before it is given the chance to actually catch up to the rest of the country and to become equal to other Canadians.

This is what we are talking about today. We are talking about the opportunity that should be given to the have not provinces to catch up to other Canadian provinces that consider themselves to be have provinces. There cannot be any chance of a catch-up for Atlantic Canadians or for that matter western Canadians in provinces like Manitoba and Saskatchewan that also receive equalization payments as. There cannot be any opportunity given to these provinces to catch up.

There cannot be a chance for equality in the provinces unless there is some recognition given to the fact that the pool of money that will keep a province from starving is the same pool of money that will keep it permanently poor. Newfoundland has been in Confederation for approximately 50 years. In a couple of weeks Newfoundland will have been in this great country for 50 years and there is still no recognition of the one basic fact that the pool of money that will keep a province from starving is the same pool of money that will keep it permanently poor. That is the unfairness and the injustice associated with the way the equalization formula is written.

There will never be an opportunity for the provinces that receive equalization payments to be brought up to the same quality of life and the same standard of living that other Canadians enjoy. They will never have the opportunity under the current formula to reduce the horrendous unemployment problem in Newfoundland, which has an official unemployment rate of about 19.7%. That is a very serious situation indeed.

I am not saying that we should change the formula forever and a day. I am saying there should be some kind of arrangement worked out with the have not provinces which will see resource revenues clawed back on a more gradual basis. It is not to have the federal government take up all of the problems but to have these resource revenues clawed back on a more gradual basis.

Right now there is a 100% clawback on resource revenues produced by any given province. That is the basic unfairness for the poorer provinces. If the federal government wanted, it could change that to make it a bit easier for those provinces, especially in the Atlantic area, to become equal to the rest of Canada.

For instance, a Voisey's Bay development in Newfoundland could have its resource revenues clawed back on a 50% basis. The Sable Island gas field in Nova Scotia could be clawed back on a 50% basis to give Nova Scotia the opportunity to become a little affluent and raise its standard and quality of life. The federal government has within its power the ability to do that, but I do not believe that is going to be done.

In that way there would be an opportunity to bring some fairness to the current equalization formula and to bring the unemployment rate and quality of life to the receiving provinces up to acceptable standards.

A few months ago my private member's bill on Newfoundland's unemployment problem was selected and debated here in the House of Commons. The point was made by someone speaking in that debate that if we had a fairer equalization formula applied to Newfoundland as it relates to our offshore revenues, not only would the province of Newfoundland be better off but Canada as a country would be better off as well.

We have to consider the fact that we are members of this nation. Any province that becomes better off is a net contributor to our country. It makes it a bit easier to live within this country and makes it easier on the taxpayers within this country who would not have to continually be injecting funds into the have not provinces.

In the long run there is every reason for the federal government to want the provinces that receive equalization payments to be brought up to an acceptable standard. The federal government could rest a bit easier and would not have that kind of burden placed upon it.

We are all very much aware that the Canadian equalization program redistributes the wealth of this nation. Last year the province of Newfoundland received $975 million in equalization payments. This year she is going to receive approximately $925 million in equalization payments. It will be a reduction.

One of the reasons we are going to take a reduction in equalization payments this year is the population factor, the fact that so many people are leaving our province on an annual basis. It is of great concern to the province of Newfoundland that we have a tremendous out-migration every year.

One thing that determines the rate of equalization payments to a province is the population factor. The population of Newfoundland has gone down significantly over the last number of years. Over the past six or seven years we have been losing people at the rate of between 7,000 and 10,000 per year. That is quite a decrease in population for a small province like Newfoundland and Labrador.

If that kind of population decrease occurred in Ontario or B.C., it would not be a great big deal but it is devastating for a province like Newfoundland with a population of half a million to lose anywhere between 7,000 and 10,000 people a year. It is devastating not only in terms of losing some very good young educated people but because of that out-migration the province is losing equalization payments as well. That is a very big and important factor for the province of Newfoundland.

The one overriding concern is that the federal government will deduct dollar for dollar the resource revenues that a province receives. This will have the devastating effect of keeping that province permanently poor.

Canadian Broadcasting Corporation March 9th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, last week I spoke in the House against the current government practice of paying certain federal public service workers different rates of pay for doing the same work in different regions of our country.

I am now raising the matter again in the context of the ongoing CBC strike. CBC management is proposing to change a national pay system to a two tier system, with workers in Toronto and Vancouver receiving higher rates of pay than CBC workers elsewhere in Canada.

CBC is a national body. Its pay system should not treat workers in Newfoundland as second class.

I call upon the minister responsible to put an end to that practice and help bring about a resolution of the strike at the earliest opportunity.

Pay Equity March 3rd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, one of the demands of striking federal public servants in my riding is that they should be paid the same in all regions of the country. However, at this very moment a federal electrician in Newfoundland, doing exactly the same job as his counterpart in British Columbia, gets $4 an hour less.

This is the policy of the same government that recently changed our health transfers to a per capita basis, saying it wanted to make all Canadians equal no matter where they lived. If the cost is the same per capita in all regions of the country to build and equip hospitals, to hire nurses and doctors, why does it not cost the same all over the country to hire an electrician?

I support pay equity. Glaring pay inequities, be they gender based or geography based, are a disgrace and should be eradicated from the public service of Canada.

Citizenship Of Canada Act February 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. member for his question.

I am not aware of any particular instance where that clause has been abused. One of the responsibilities we have as members is to look for possible loopholes in the act. In going over the act I find that to be a loophole that ignored the problem of someone entering Canada, making a refugee claim, having the child and then the refugee claim being refused. What happens in that instance? What do we do with the child if the parent has to be deported? That is a reasonable concern. Can we force the parent to leave knowing that the infant Canadian citizen is here and could be abandoned? Or do we simply force the parent to take the child back to wherever the refugee came from, knowing it might be an undesirable part of the world?

It is a concern. It should be raised in the House of Commons. The minister should address the concern and bring an answer back to the House.

Citizenship Of Canada Act February 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to make a few comments on this bill today. Immigration is a very important area of concern. It is an area in which all of us as Canadians have a stake. Hopefully we can look at the policies of the immigration department and conclude that they have over the years served our country well. I think by and large the policies have served us well for a number of years. Now it is time to update the act so that these policies can move us into the new millennium reflecting the concerns of prospective immigrants and Canadians generally.

One point I would like to make deals with confirming that all children born in Canada, except the children of foreign diplomats, will automatically become Canadian citizens.

I want to point out to the minister of immigration that perhaps this ignores the problem of someone entering Canada, making a refugee claim, having a child while in Canada and then having the refugee claim refused. What do we do with the child if the parent has to be deported? Can we force the parent to leave knowing that the infant Canadian citizen will either be abandoned here or should such an infant accompany the parent even if the parent is returning to an undesirable part of the world?

These are difficult questions. No doubt the courts or our United Nations obligations will tell us the answers in due course.

The new act treats children adopted abroad much the same as children born here. I understand the minister's desire not to put an undue stigma on adopted children, but Canadians should understand as well that the change removes the requirement that children adopted abroad have the normal medical and other checks required of an immigrant.

My question here to the minister of immigration is are Canadians generally aware of that change and would they support it if they were fully aware of it.

The new citizenship act requires that to be eligible to become a citizen on has to reside physically here for three years. Now it allows one five years to accumulate these three years of actual residence. That is something that we can all support, given the highly mobile workforce we are into today in this global economy.

I think we can all accept that. However, I sincerely hope there are bureaucratic mechanisms to check on the facts of residency. Simply having a mailing address here in Canada is not enough and that has been the case in some instances in the past. People would apply for citizenship in Canada and simply have a mailing address here.

I have no problem with requiring that a citizenship applicant as opposed to a new refugee for example be required to speak English or French, or have some working knowledge of English or French, and some knowledge of Canada generally.

We need standardized testing or other mechanisms to ensure that such knowledge and language skills are indeed real and not simply something that will be seen on an application form.

I am pleased that so-called citizenship judges are being removed from the decision making loop. Decisions on citizenship should be made by professional civil servants who have training and who have experience in the field.

I am sure all of us as MPs deal with immigration cases almost on a daily basis. My experience as an MP dealing with actual cases that come across my desk is that there are often inconsistencies in treatment from one officer to another. Firm guidelines for decision making are required so that there is a high likelihood that a decision made on an individual in the Vancouver office is consistent with the decision made on an individual in the Toronto office. I am sure that in committee we have heard complaints associated with that concern in the past.

As for the replacement of judges with commissioners, I am wondering, and I think a lot of people would wonder, if these people are really needed. Is it just another avenue for government to make patronage appointments? If there is a public role to be performed in promoting the value of Canadian citizenship I suggest that the minister co-ordinate these efforts with the heritage minister as was pointed out by a member of the official opposition a couple of weeks ago.

Section 43 of the act makes provision for making regulations on a host of issues. I have concerns about the widespread use of regulations. Since regulations are made internally they can be changed internally and not necessarily debated here in the House of Commons or not necessarily be made available to the media for full and open scrutiny.

Regarding the oath of citizenship, I have no problems with swearing allegiance to the Queen since Canada is still a parliamentary democracy under a constitutional monarchy. We all have to swear an oath to take our place here in the House of Commons. As for the other parts of the oath there should be more public consultation as to the wording of it. There is no problem with the public being involved as long as the constitutional bases are covered and indeed it would be beneficial to have some kind of public consultation or debate on the value of Canadian citizenship generally. It would be beneficial for all of us here in the House of Commons and also for all Canadians to hear from time to time the value of being a Canadian.

All the new laws in the world will not improve the citizenship application and approval process if the proper systems are not put in place. Many of the problems with the current system come from the many inconsistencies in policy application and the lack of financial resources to do the proper jobs. The laws are no good if they are unworkable or if they are totally unenforceable. What is needed first and foremost is the political will to do a good job and the personnel and funds to carry it out.

Highways February 15th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, the existence of the toll highway in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia is an affront to all Canadians. To note that it is also part of the so-called Trans-Canada Highway only doubles the insult.

Back in the days when it was the government's duty to provide basic services, the construction of the Trans-Canada system was seen as a federal government priority. These days we have the federal government subsidizing the construction of a privately owned toll road that receives all westbound traffic from Newfoundland and the maritimes.

We are not in the United States. Up here it is the crown's job to build and maintain roads. As long as we pay our taxes we should be allowed to walk or ride on them free. This is a tax on transportation for all Atlantic Canadians.

I call on the federal government to intervene in this matter and have these tolls removed immediately so that the free flow of traffic from east to west can continue unimpeded.

Division No. 316 February 15th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I am not talking about Newfoundland alone here. I am not talking about a separate side agreement for Newfoundland. I am talking about a separate agreement that would apply to seven provinces, not including Alberta, Ontario and B.C. Alberta, Ontario and B.C., by virtue of their geographic locations, in some respects have been able to move ahead because of their prosperous economies. We thank these provinces for being able to share their wealth with the rest of Canada.

What we simply want to do is make our contribution to the rest of Canada as well. I believe in order to do that we need the federal government to look closely at this bill, to think about the have not provinces and to come up with some kind of formula that will enable less clawback on their resources until they reach a point comparable to Ontario, Alberta and British Columbia.

Division No. 316 February 15th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, we are well aware of the fact that we are poised to take a more substantive role in the economy of our country. Again I have to remind the hon. member that what we are talking about here is a province moving ahead and a province being given the opportunity to become equal to other provinces in Canada. Simply put, what we need is economic development and jobs. We need to maximize the impact of our resources and resource development. We cannot do that with the current equalization formula the federal government has in place.

We have lost so much wealth in our economy due to federal government cuts in programs and the fact that the federal government has cut our health care system to such a great extent over the last five year period, a 35% cut in transfers to the provinces. We have use our equalization payments to make up for the cuts the federal government has inflicted on us in the past.

What I have been talking about here is an opportunity for not only Newfoundlanders but for Atlantic Canadians generally and provinces that receive equalization payments to have some sort of renegotiation of that formula to reflect the fact that they are have not provinces and that they should be given the opportunity to become equal, to catch up and to raise the standard of living in their province and increase the employment rate as well.

Division No. 316 February 15th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. member for his rhetoric. That is all it was, rhetoric. As I suspected, he was not listening to a thing I had to say on this very important bill. He was talking to his colleague all the while I was speaking and he never gave me a moment of thought nor listened to a word I said.

I am not saying we should put in place a new equalization formula for ever and a day. What I am saying is that we need to work out some kind of an arrangement for have-not provinces that will see the resource revenues they generate clawed back on a more gradual basis than dollar for dollar.

As I said a moment ago, Newfoundland receives about $1 billion in equalization payments. If the Hibernia development for instance were to bring in $900 million in the run of a year, we would be only $100 million better off. Is this not what we need, an opportunity to catch up to the other provinces in Canada? Put in place a formula that will see a more gradual claw back, a 15% claw back for Voisey's Bay, a 50% claw back for Sable Island gas development that will see the province given an opportunity to become equal with the other provinces. It will see that province given an opportunity to improve its quality of life and to raise its employment opportunities and then let that province make the contribution that it should be making to the country. That is all we ask, a new arrangement that would see claw backs made on a more gradual basis.