House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was air.

Last in Parliament May 2004, as Liberal MP for Don Valley East (Ontario)

Won his last election, in 2000, with 67% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Importation Of Plutonium September 21st, 2000

Mr. Speaker, Transport Canada approved the emergency response assistance plan submitted by AECL on Thursday, September 21 in accordance with the statutory provisions. I am quite satisfied that my officials did their work and took into account the wider public interest.

Agriculture September 21st, 2000

Mr. Speaker, I remind the hon. member that we talked about $178 million legislated by this parliament that will flow to the pockets of producers right across the board. That works out to the per capital tonnage amount that he mentioned.

Farmers will receive the benefit of this legislation. It is forward looking. It is legislation that has had, by and large, the support of all members of the House and the Senate. I do not think the hon. member should start quibbling at this stage when we have provided $178 million for western producers.

Grain Transportation September 20th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, I categorically deny and reject the assertion of the hon. member that the grain transportation system is as he describes it.

As hon. members know, Bill C-34 was passed by the House on division. There was great co-operation by members. This is good news for western farmers because $178 million has been put back into the system. It is very premature for the hon. member to start talking about problems that have not yet manifested themselves.

I just read a note that talks about grain shipments having increased so far this year. I think that good trend will continue.

Transport September 18th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, I am very grateful to the hon. member for raising this with me before question period but I have not had a chance to get to the bottom of it.

Under the terms of the divestiture fund, there is a specific list of what the money should be spent on and there is provision for an annual audit. Hopefully we will have some clarity later on in the week, and I hope to get back to him either privately or in the House.

Canada Transportation Act June 14th, 2000

moved that the bill be read the third time and passed.

Madam Speaker, it is a pleasure to speak today at third reading of Bill C-34 which amends the Canada Transportation Act to implement part of the government's May 10 announcement of its decisions on grain reform.

As the House will know, at second reading I spoke about the overall purpose of the bill and explained many of the measures found in the bill. I want to take this opportunity to acknowledge the extensive work done by the Standing Committee on Transport which took written submissions and heard testimony from about 30 different organizations in the short space of one week. I congratulate the members of the committee, in particular the hon. member for Hamilton West who was the chair, and my parliamentary secretary, the hon. member for Thunder Bay—Atikokan who did an outstanding job at the committee stage.

This committee has worked wonders in this parliament. They had the airline restructuring proposals last fall, the airline bill, this grain bill, plus three other bills. They have certainly worked extremely hard. I want all Canadians to know that members on this side of the House and on the other side of the House have worked with due diligence on behalf of Canadians.

The western grain industry is one of the largest segments of the Canadian agri-food sector. In dollar terms, it ranks close to the forestry industry, the automobile industry, the mining industry and the fishing industries. Total Canadian grain production averages 60 million tonnes a year, with about half of this amount being exported. Production which is not exported is consumed domestically by the livestock industry, flour milling and other value-added processing activities.

The efficiency of the grain handling system has been the subject of much debate over the past few years. Most contend that the current system cannot continue to operate as it is and still allow for the industry to maintain its competitiveness in an international marketplace.

The present system is managed centrally, making it difficult to hold anyone accountable when things go wrong. Freight rates do not vary to encourage more efficient use of the transportation assets over the crop year or during peak periods. The majority of wheat board business is allocated to grain companies and to railways by historic shares rather than by competition.

Three years ago, as I said earlier when I spoke on this at second reading, I went with my colleagues to Winnipeg to meet with all the stakeholders. We agreed that we would try to do something about the breakdown of the system that occurred in the winter of 1996-97. I feel particularly good about the process that has been followed. We appointed an eminent jurist, Mr. Willard Estey, a native of Saskatchewan, who gave us a very comprehensive report advocating reforms toward a more competitive system.

I then asked the former distinguished deputy minister Arthur Kroeger, a native of Alberta, to take the theory of Mr. Estey and put it into practical form, to put some bones to the framework, as it were, and both of those gentlemen worked exceptionally hard and brought forward their recommendations.

We have been criticized for not entirely following the recommendations of those two gentlemen. However, it was always assumed that those gentlemen would give us the overall conceptual framework and some ways that the framework could be implemented. However, ultimately it was government and parliament that had to make the political decisions. We have to make the political trade-offs.

I think we have done that successfully. The fact that even though members on the other side are not entirely happy with every aspect of this bill, the fact that there are really no dissenting voices on the other side, means that we have it right. I like to be accurate, but I cannot believe that there is actually one member of the Canadian Alliance in the House that would say no to a measure that will put money in the pockets of the western farmers. I am sure that I have not heard any dissent on the other side. I am not used to covering up for anyone, and certainly not for the misdemeanours of the opposition, but I take them at face value.

I know that everyone in the House agrees that we have it right, that we are putting money in the hands of the producers and that there has been significant changes made throughout the system. The bill will not be proclaimed unless the MOU is satisfactory. We are still holding consultations on the MOU. I have talked with the presidents of the railways. We have talked with the grain companies. My colleague, the minister responsible for the wheat board, who was here a few minutes ago, has worked very hard at trying to calibrate that MOU so that it deals with the concerns of the various stakeholders.

I think this shows that we are sensitive. We are trying to get this particular measure right.

There are four main measures within the bill which have a large impact on the problems that were uncovered over three years of discussion. First, there is the annual limit on railway grain revenue, what we now call the revenue cap. Second, there have been enhancements to the final offer arbitration. Third, enhancements have been made to the branch line process. Finally, we have added measures to help obtain and share information required for the monitoring of the grain system in a secure manner.

I do not want to unduly hold up the passage of this bill at third reading, but I would be remiss if I did not emphasize once again that the bill does contain a limit on rail revenues of $27 a tonne for the crop year commencing August 1, which is 18% lower than the effective revenue per tonne in 2000-01 under current law, announced recently by the Canadian Transportation Agency after its deliberations.

Railways will have the flexibility to vary individual grain rates at any time to reflect efficiency and to offer more innovative services to shippers.

The bill also designates the agency as having the responsibility to monitor compliance based on actual grain movements and distance hauled. If the agency at the end of the year determines there are any railway earnings in excess of the cap, the excess amounts will be repaid with a penalty.

The revenue cap will be adjusted annually to reflect railway inflation, starting in 2001-02. Shippers whose traffic starts from branch lines will have an assurance that the tariff rates for single car movements originating on branch lines will not be allowed under this bill to exceed main line tariff rates for similar movements by more than 3%. I think that is an effective guarantee.

Amendments to the CTA in Bill C-34 will also make significant improvements to the final offer arbitration process. It will require shippers to submit their whole proposal as part of the application, excluding dollar amounts. After 10 days the shipper and the railway will exchange their complete final offers simultaneously, including dollar amounts.

A simplified arbitration mechanism is proposed for arbitration involving freight charges that total no more than $750,000. In this faster process the time between the shipper filing the initial submission and the final decision will not exceed 30 days. At the request of the shipper or for arbitration of disputes above $750,000 a 60 day process will be followed.

The bill allows the establishment of a three person panel on agreement by both parties to hear more complex disputes. Of the three arbitrators, one would be chosen by the shipper, one by the railway and one by the two arbitrators. Failing that, the agency could select the third arbitrator.

There were many members of the House on both sides who were concerned with the provisions of the CTA in 1996 which allowed the railways a certain procedure for the abandonment of branch lines without recourse to the governor in council. I know this is going to be an ongoing discussion as we start the review of the act on July 1. I will be announcing the appointment of prominent people to conduct that review very shortly.

We have included in this bill, because of the urgency and the need for balance in the system, specific provisions that would not only allow the two railways to reduce their costs, but facilitate the transfer of branch lines for continued operation.

The main goal of these provisions was to ensure that a community could maintain the rail line, which is so often the lifeblood of the town. I am proud to say that since the act came into effect in July 1996 about 80% or 9,200 kilometres of track are operated by short line railways and only 1,800 kilometres of track have been discontinued. This process has resulted in the creation of 36 new short line operators.

Despite this success, Justice Estey identified some issues related to branch lines. Some of the problems included the ability of railways to transfer grain dependent lines in small segments, making a viable short line operation very difficult, and the fact that when a community does lose a grain dependent branch line it is not directly compensated. I believe the bill addresses these particular issues.

We are extending the notice period before a railway can take steps to discontinue a rail line from two months to twelve months. This would give more time for potential short line purchasers to come along. It would also allow a community based group which is ready to proceed with an offer to trigger an early curtailment of the twelve month notice period and extend the negotiation period from four months to six months. Also, either party may request the Canadian Transportation Agency during this stage to provide its estimate of the net salvage value of the line.

Bill C-34 requires that both parties negotiate in good faith. The Canadian Transportation Agency may order the railway to enter into a commercially fair and reasonable agreement, or it may allow a railway to end negotiations and continue to abandon the line if parties are not negotiating in good faith.

Not all grain lines will be retained or transferred. Therefore, the bill requires a railway that abandons a line to make three annual payments of up to $10,000 per mile to each of the municipal governments located along the line, related to the length of the line that falls within each municipality. This will ensure that the municipalities which are feeling the impact of the changes will see the benefits from these railway payments.

With respect to the monitoring provisions, I believe that these measures will ensure that we obtain information that is critical to a full and fair assessment of the results from the changes to the grain transportation and handling system. The bill ensures that the information can be forwarded to a third party monitor. The confidentiality of the information obtained for monitoring purposes is ensured.

The standing committee adopted an amendment that calls on the minister to table an annual report on the monitoring of the system to parliament no later than January 31, which is six months after the end of each crop year. The Minister responsible for the Canadian Wheat Board, the Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food and I support this amendment. We are very confident that there will be much progress to report.

Under the decision we announced on May 10, the issue of more open access to rail lines will be referred to the upcoming review of the Canada Transportation Act for priority consideration on effective ways to enhance competition in the railway sector, including enhanced running rights, regional railways and other access concepts. This review will be launched within the next few days and will be ready by July 1. In the mandate letter for the review I will request that an interim report be provided on the open access issue no later than six months after the start of the review.

Three of the government's measures on grain are realized through non-statutory means. First, a memorandum of understanding will be put in place to guide changes to the wheat board's transportation role. Second, a mechanism will be put in place to ensure the continuous monitoring, measurement and reporting of the changes by a professional private sector third party. Third, the Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food will provide for a five year, $175 million grain roads program at the rate of $35 million per year from 2001 to 2005-06. This grain road program is to be modelled on the Canada agri-infrastructure program, as implemented in Saskatchewan.

On the whole, the statutory and non-statutory measures are designed to turn a new page in Canada's grain transportation and handling system. I think they create a significant opportunity for the parties to commence a different set of relationships and to work together to build a more commercial, more accountable and more effective system.

Before I sit down I would like to thank all members on both sides of the House who have worked really hard on this measure. I know that it came late, but as I said at second reading, this was a very tough measure to adjudicate and to do things properly. The fact that there is no significant technical opposition to the bill underscores the fact that we have gotten it right, that the producers will benefit and that productivity gains will be shared.

I realize that while producers may be happy, the railways and the grain companies may not be as happy. We are trying to work out modalities in the MOU with the wheat board to address some of their concerns.

I think we have done justice to the railways by moving the open access provisions and the regional railway provisions to the CTA review to allow for a broader debate which will allow all shippers, not just shippers of grain, to have an influence on the decisions and an impact on policy changes which are coming forward.

I think the coming year will be an interesting one because the review will deal with some of the unfinished business. I am firm in my view that we have started on the road to true commercialization and reform of the system. I applaud members of both sides of the House who have agreed that this objective will be met.

Canada Transportation Act June 14th, 2000

moved that the bill be concurred in.

Transportation In Montreal June 14th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, I have discussed this matter with my Quebec counterpart and I agree with the priorities of the Province of Quebec as far as transportation in the Montreal region is concerned.

I believe that the infrastructure program provides sufficient funds for this project to be begun.

Port Of Montreal June 13th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, the decision on the future of the Port of Montreal is in the hands of the authorities directing affairs at the Port of Montreal. There will be a meeting this evening and we await their decision.

Human Rights June 5th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister outlined the government's approach to this matter, and contrary to the assertion of my friend opposite, the economic agenda did not dominate, as the Deputy Prime Minister said last week. Human rights and democracy were foremost on the minds of all there and were mentioned by the Prime Minister. The Prime Minister talked about the inclusiveness of societies in the OAS empowering citizens to deal with civil society. He talked about people not being left behind by the technological revolution. He wanted all people to share in the benefits of society.

I think it was a very successful conference, and Canada led—

Canada Transportation Act June 1st, 2000

Mr. Speaker, my colleagues from western Canada were so exhausted by the advice they gave me that I told them not to worry, that I would carry the debate this morning and that they could come back this afternoon and have a repartee with the opposition. They have been remarkable. They have been up nights. The agricultural committee of the Liberal caucus and the northern and western caucus have been marvellous to work with. It has been one of the greatest experiences of my parliamentary life to have that give and take, that thrust and parry and to come forward with a consensus.

My colleagues are looking for changes in railway track access rules as a means to increase rail competition. As I say, it is a tough issue, especially in the rail sector where there are only two companies and obviously they dominate.

Justice Estey recommended enhancing running rights to allow any person to apply for the right to run on another railway's line. This change would effectively open up running rights to provincial short lines.

Mr. Kroeger suggested that further study was needed on all methods to increase competition, especially running rights. Other open access proposals came along late in the review process, including the idea of promoting a regional railway. We have listened to all these views, as we have listened to everything else, and have decided to refer this particular complex part of the equation of open access, including enhanced running rights and the regional railway concept, to the upcoming statutory review of the act which must begin no later than July 1.

We are now busy working on the terms of reference for this review. The terms of reference will state unequivocally that the issue of open access, joint running rights and regional railway concepts are to be examined on a priority basis with an interim report no later than six months after it starts.

I know that some people have said that we should deal with this right now. Let us not plunge into a system-wide experiment that may affect the reliability of our entire system just for the sake of saying that our industry is competitive. If we want to do what is right for our national transportation system and for the grain farmers, we need to examine this particular component closely in a forum that allows all stakeholders to express their views. Some stakeholders have already indicated they are looking forward to providing representation on ways to enhance competition in the railway sector.

While it is extremely important for farmers to have a logistic system that moves their grain quickly and inexpensively, it is also important that railways are able to make appropriate choices to cut costs and increase investment and productivity. Equally important is the ability of smaller operations to increase their chances at continuing business and to provide competition in the rail sector.

One of our objectives when we introduced the Canada Transportation Act in 1996 was to establish a regime that would see short line railways come forward. This has been really quite successful.

Eighty per cent of all the lines filed for abandonment under the 1996 CTA have been short line, including in western Canada. That of course is not satisfactory for those communities on those railways that have been abandoned and not taken up by short lines. However, I do not think anyone can dispute that there was a degree of overbuilding by the railways, especially in some parts of western Canada. There could be no economic justification, in our changing times, with access to motor vehicle transport and better roads, for some abandonments to take place. However, 80% of those that filed for abandonment by CN and CP going to short line rail is a pretty good accomplishment.

This bill addresses a number of problems that were identified during the grain consultation process. The amendments to the act will help to further encourage the establishment of short line railways in all parts of Canada. It will also help out communities that lose a grain dependent line by having the railways provide transitional compensation.

As an aside, I must say that I am very sympathetic to the members from western Canada who have drawn attention to this aspect of the 1996 act. This will be a focus in the first six months of the review because there are ramifications in other parts of the country, especially in large urban areas like greater Toronto, greater Vancouver and big cities like Montreal where the railways, by virtue of changing patterns and better highway system, are moving out of the core. They wish to abandon lines in the centre of these cities.

In my view, it is folly to rip up track if there is a potential use whether by a short line or a freight operator, as we have seen under the act, in parts of western Canada, Ontario, Quebec and elsewhere; or if those rights of way can be used for commuter and urban transit. A municipality in Halifax right now is considering the purchase of a line that CN wants to abandon. This would alleviate congestion in Halifax. The same thing is happening Toronto. It is the same in Vancouver with the Arbutus line which is a potential corridor from Vancouver airport to the downtown core.

This is something we have to be very sensitive to. I am certainly very cognizant of getting a better handle on the abandonment process.

The government does recognize that when we do abandon, especially trackage in western Canada, it puts increased pressure on rural roads. As a result, the Government of Canada will be prepared to make a contribution of $175 million over five years to help address this problem.

Not only do these provisions help us move toward a worldclass system but they will provide a better protection for communities. Too many communities in western Canada have suffered because their rail lines have gone. The way of life represented by these towns is an important part of the fabric of this country and must be preserved.

That is why we are giving communities a new chance to take a direct involvement in the operation of their local branch lines. That is why we want to improve grain roads to assist these communities and to keep them thriving.

It is no good if this country ends up having all its population living in Halifax, Montreal, Ottawa, Toronto, Winnipeg, Calgary, Vancouver and other large cities. Rural Canada is an indelible part of who we are as a people and it must be preserved. The Liberal Party will preserve it and this bill does preserve it.

In this type of environment, it is important that the benefits of reforms are seen by all system participants. That is why we are introducing a monitoring mechanism. Continuous monitoring will be designed and implemented by an independent, private sector third party that will measure and assess the impact of reforms on farmers, on the wheat board, on the efficiency of the system, including the ports, and on the overall performance of the grain handling and transportation system.

This mechanism of monitoring will help the government determine if changes are making the appropriate impact. As I have said, the grain industry is too important to Canada's economy and to our way of life for us not to monitor these changes closely. The fact that it is being done at arm's length will put paid to any notion that somehow this is an inside evaluation done by the government for its own nefarious reasons. We would never do that. The fact that this will be independent, arm's length monitoring underscores our sincerity. I know the hon. members on the other side understand that the government is sincere about continuous monitoring.

Clearly, the wheat board, the grain companies and the railways will have to work together to develop new industry procedures that reflect the changes. If they choose to compete and if they choose to manage the system effectively, then the system will reach its full potential and farmers will benefit.

The government has introduced this bill which is the main part of a reform package that will modernize the grain handling and transportation system. If we want a worldclass grain logistics system, then we need to move forward. We need to make the system more accountable, more efficient and more cost-effective. The package within this bill is part of a move to bring us closer to that goal of efficiency and competitiveness. Canadian farmers deserve this type of system. They need it to maximize their advantages in the global marketplace.

I am aware that we have a narrow window of opportunity in terms of the parliamentary time to get this package in place. Again, I want to thank the members on the other side for their support and co-operation in getting this bill through. I truly believe that by embarking on this step we will see competition improve in the years to come.

As a member from outside of western Canada, if I can make the observation, I think there is an element of fear based on history and past practices of stakeholders that inhibits the embracing of total reform. That is understandable. When people have been at the mercy of the elements and at the mercy of big institutions, like the railway companies and the grain companies, they know that the farming they are engaged in is always fraught with difficulty.

I think it was U.S. President Roosevelt, going back to 1932-33, who said that the greatest fear is fear itself on the part of the people. I understand that fear. I understand those people who say that the wheat board is their only guarantor of fairness and equity. It is the only one that will be there to regulate the system.

The wheat board has an important role and will continue to have an important role in the marketing of grain, but what is at issue in this debate is its role in transportation, logistics and to what degree it should remove itself in the name of greater competitiveness. It is not inconceivable that once we start along this path those people who had fear in the past will see that their fears are now assuaged in a way that will permit them to introduce even greater flexibility and competitiveness down the road. I really believe that.

I think there is a dynamism in western Canada and in the farming community that is really quite admirable, especially among younger farmers going into other crops, into lentils, peas, barley, soya and all these various non-grain crops. There is now more food processing being done in western Canada.

Back in the old days, when I was first a member, it was always the point that we had to change the Crow and make changes to the transportation regulatory system so that competitive forces could be unleashed and secondary manufacturing processing could be done in western Canada. That is now happening. Diversification of the farming community and greater processing is being done, and we welcome that. Meat processing is not done in the stockyards in Toronto on St. Clair Avenue anymore. It is done in places like Calgary and other cities in western Canada.

Not only is that right from the point of view of economics, but it is right from the point of view of social equity as a nation. For too long too much of the production was done in the large centres in the east. Now we are seeing a greater diversification and a greater equality in the economic activity across the country.

In that vein, this act, if passed, and I hope it will be passed expeditiously, will be another landmark reform that enables producers, other interested parties and stakeholders in western Canada to gain better economic solidarity, better prospects, become more prosperous and ensure Canada's reputation as one of the greatest farming nations in the world and certainly one of the greatest grain producing farmers in the world.