House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements Act March 9th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I would like to thank my hon. colleague for his speech regarding this bill.

I know the member has a large interest in the funding of health care which has had quite a history in Canada. When our forefathers put our Constitution together, they gave explicit responsibility to the provinces to run the health care system in each province. Over time, particularly in the last 30 years or so, there has been quite a shift in this. The federal government originally intervened by paying voluntarily apparently with no strings attached 50% of the costs. It used its spending power to intrude into a provincial jurisdiction. Over the last several years that has eroded. The number which I last heard is 13% of actual costs are covered by the federal government although it continues to tax us the same.

I presume the member has given some thought to how the federal government should be participating in the health care funding. I would appreciate it if he would give us his insight into this and perhaps tie it into the whole idea of equalization. I would like to know from him whether he would like to see the CHST separated from equalization or merged with it, perhaps like the giant HST where the sales tax was merged. Perhaps we could merge the outgoing money, instead of the incoming money and equalize it per capita for each province and territory so that they could provide close to equal services to their people.

I do not know how much thought the member has given to it, but I would be very interested in his response to that question.

Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements Act March 9th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I value the intervention of my colleague. He gave some very good insights into the whole process of equalization renewal.

It is very curious that the legislation requires the program be renewed every five years but departmental officials work on the process for approximately two and a half years. We get that from the auditor general's report. The officials work in the back rooms. There are consultations with the provinces, also in the back rooms. However the final say is given by parliament because it is the expenditure of federal money. It is money for which we as members of parliament are responsible.

It is very curious and totally inadequate, even according to the auditor general, that parliament be given so little time. As I mentioned earlier in an intervention, we were given but three working days to study the legislation when it was introduced at first reading. We had no time to look at it in advance. We had no time to study it and look at the different convolutions.

I would like to put on the record of the House of Commons in this short question and comment period something the auditor general has said because I think it is very important:

We believe that the process needs to be opened up to facilitate wider participation in the consideration of changes to such a fundamental program.

Many interest parties, including some leading academics, have given considerable thought to this program and we believe their views could be useful. The government tried this approach once, in 1981, when it established the Parliamentary Task Force on Federal-Provincial Arrangements (Breau Committee), which focused on all fiscal transfers, including equalization. Its report, Fiscal Federalism in Canada , stands today as one of the best public assessments of Canada's fiscal situation.

Then he went on to say that he did not know whether this should be the approach but that it was an effective way of involving parliamentarians. He made the following recommendation:

The Department of Finance should ensure that parliament is consulted in a meaningful way on the periodic renewal of equalization.

My intervention is probably more a comment than a question, but certainly I would invite the member from Calgary to concur with what I just said.

Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements Act March 9th, 1999

Madam Speaker, my hon. colleague from Saskatchewan happens to be, by the way, the MP for my parents and from the area where I grew up. We actually have no differences. Because of the limitation of time I only had 20 minutes and I could not really get into the details of that. I was saying that. The one quote I read actually specified that provincial governments could even use it to reduce their provincial tax levels if they wanted to, total unfettered use by the provinces. Yes, I am totally in agreement with that.

It is interesting also that a number of witnesses appeared before the committee on Bill C-65. One of them was Dr. Boothe from the department of economics at the University of Alberta who held that view very strongly.

I do not know whether I am permitted to do any free advertising here, but there is a book available. I know I cannot display it because that would be considered a prop, even worse than the flag, possibly. There is a book written by one Dr. Dan Usher. He is a member of the economics department at Queen's University.

He gave us a very good presentation in our committee. Dr. Usher's book is entitled The Uneasy Case For Equalization Payments . He addresses both the question of the principle of equalization and the question of the formula. Many speakers said that we should base it on per capita income, average per capita income across the country, and that for those provinces which are sufficiently low on a per capita income provide some sort of rebate to the provinces to equalize it. In other words, it would top them up a bit so that they are not substantially disadvantaged because they live in a very poor province.

Those issues require a long term debate. That is why I would like to see the government do something. In the report I mentioned, the government said that we should discuss it, have a longer term, come up with a white paper and have some technical input. We just barely got started in committee and it was done because it was rammed through so fast.

I could see after we started that the debate should probably last a couple of years. We could hear from different academics, those people who think about these things, and think the thing through. Let us analyse it. Let us look at the different options. Let us choose the best one.

I anticipate that the next round of negotiations will come about in another five years. It has to be done every five years. Perhaps by then we would be ready to bring in a new equalization formula which is open, which is transparent and which provides for accountability.

At the beginning of my speech I said the taxpayers in my province, because they are not eligible for equalization grants, have a very large interest in making sure that their money is properly spent and well accounted for. It cannot be done with this legislation because the formula is convoluted.

In the finance committee I asked a witness how many people in Canada knew how the formula worked. He looked to his left and his right, because he had two or three officials with him, and said “We are all at the table here but I am not sure they all know exactly how it works”.

That is not right. We cannot have accountability to taxpayers when we have that kind of formula. They try to figure out, for example, with the new legislation what is the fiscal capacity of a province on lottery revenues and on gambling revenues. It has many variables. It has to do with how much money is available. It has to do with the psychology of the fact that very often people who have less money available are more likely to spend money on lottery tickets for that little glimmer of hope. It has to do with some people who have a deep philosophical conviction with respect to gambling and will not participate in it, so we get into the psychology of it.

Does this group that determines the equalization payment really think it can get into the heads of the people in Manitoba and determine why it is they are not buying enough lottery tickets? If they did they would have this much income and therefore would be cut out.

Does my hon. colleague know that the province of Manitoba will lose in equalization entitlements under the act about $50 million? There are other areas where equalization entitlements go up a bit, so the grand difference to Manitoba would be about $37 million. However it will lose $50 million. It would be getting $87 million if it were not for the fact that it is penalized because the people of Manitoba are generally too smart to buy lottery tickets. That is unconscionable.

That is the type of thing we have to get our heads around and solve in the great problem of equalization. I recommend this book by Dr. Usher to every member of the House and certainly to every Canadian who is interested in this subject.

Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements Act March 9th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to stand in the House to represent the people of the Elk Island constituency which I would venture to say is the best constituency in the whole country. I also say I have the best woman in the world as a wife. I hope that everybody else would say “no, it's my wife”. I really love my constituency and the people in it. They are very good.

I also represent the province of Alberta which has been a net payer into the system except for one occasion approximately 30 years ago when it received a very small equalization payment in one year. In the broader sense I represent the people of Elk Island but also the people of Alberta who have a very great interest in how their money is spent. This money is taken from them through the coercion of taxation and they have every reason in the world to demand accountability on how that money is spent. I am here to represent not only my riding but the province of Alberta.

I really am sorry that the member from the Progressive Conservative Party who answered my question totally misread it. I asked what I thought was a decent question that could have addressed the question of the mathematics and the formula used and whether equality is really equality. The member debased himself into an answer with political rhetoric. The NDP member joined in on it. Somehow they think by oft repeating this message Canadian people will believe it. That is just not true.

People in my riding want to keep this country together. I suppose one of the reasons the support for me and our party out west is so strong is that we are the only party that has ever come up with a decent plan for keeping this country together, reaching out to Quebec in a tangible way, trying to meet its needs and aspirations which this Liberal government and the Conservatives before it rode over roughshod. We are reaching out to it.

These people criticize us because we occasionally have dialogue with members from the Bloc. I think it is about time we dialogued with all people of Quebec. A fairly good number, 50%, have been sending separatists to the House of Commons and to the provincial legislature in Quebec.

That sends a very strong message. There is trouble in Ottawa. It is time to address it honestly and try to find a solution to it. Instead, what we get is this attempt by the Liberals, and now the Conservatives who have joined in, to crawl over each other and put each other down. They do not want us to work together. They want power.

I do not know whether this is going to be misunderstood, but I do not want power at all. I have no need for it. My ego does not require this kind of a cheap ego trip. I want to serve the people of Elk Island, the people of Alberta and the people of Canada. Unless we are going to write off Quebec like these other parties are doing, that includes an honest and open dialogue with the people of Quebec.

My question to the member was very clear and explicit. Does he have a hope that Quebec, with its vigorous population, its strengthened natural resources and all of its other amenities and strengths, will ever become independent in the sense that it will be able to row its own canoe and be financially independent? I would hope so. That would be my desire for every province in this country, and it is certainly true for the province of Quebec as well.

I reach out to them because I believe that we need to do what we are proposing in the new Canada act. We need to make sure that we listen to and obey the Constitution of the country which puts a lot more responsibility with the provinces and gives them the freedom to run their programs. That is what the original Constitution envisioned.

Successive Progressive Conservative and Liberal governments have chewed away at that, primarily by the use of spending power. They tax all Canadian citizens individually. They tax individual businesses. They do not tax the provinces. They tax the taxpayers. They then turn around and with all of this money that they have in their pockets jingling away, they take it and put it into wherever they think it should go.

We have no objection to the principle of equalization. In fact if I were to get this debate right on stream, I think it is appropriate for us to once again read the principle of equalization that was adopted in the Constitution Act, 1982. This is something I believe we could support wholeheartedly, provided it is done properly. Section 36(2) of the Constitution Act reads:

Parliament and the Government of Canada are committed to the principle of making equalization payments to ensure that provincial governments have sufficient revenues to provide reasonably comparable levels of public services at reasonably comparable levels of taxation.

I doubt if there are very many Canadians across the country who would disagree with that as a principle. There may be some, but I am not one of them. I am one who believes in lending a hand of help to people who are truly in need. Later on I will address how we actually determine this equitability or equality.

The principle of every citizen in this country having access to education and to be not denied the right to extend their education beyond high school because of financial restrictions is a principle that I would endorse most wholeheartedly along with 99.99% of Canadians.

It is unconscionable that we have in this country a two tier education system, thanks to Progressive Conservative and Liberal governments, where the people who come from rich families can march right out of high school into post-secondary institutions. Because they are rich they have the money to pay the big tuition fees, the big cost for books and all of the other expenses that are involved. For many Canadians it involves living away from home while they are going to school. If they are rich they can afford it. But what happens if they are poor?

Over the years governments have deteriorated the transfer of funds to the provinces, which they should not have been into in the first place, but they got into it by use of the spending power. When they did that originally it was for a good cause and it was done well. The principle was that no one in the country should be denied the right to post-secondary education because they could not afford it.

The federal government taxed the money from all of the people and from all of the businesses. Then it paid the money back to the provinces so they could provide educational facilities at reasonable cost.

In the mid-fifties and early sixties I was a university student, a recipient of that largesse. I am grateful to this day. It was a wonderful privilege. I was the first member of my family—and I have mentioned before that I am a first generation Canadian—to go on to university. What a privilege it was to be educated and then later on get into the business of education so that I could pass on the knowledge which I had gathered. I believe in that principle.

What do we have now with this Liberal government? The government has a fancy scheme of putting students into interminable debt. When these students graduate from school they will have a debt as big as half a mortgage on a house.

Shortly after I graduated my wife and I got married and started a household. In today's world, if a young couple were to do that, together their debt load for their education on average is equal to the debt of buying a house. How are they going to also finance a house? How are they going to finance the starting of their business, be it a law practice, a dentistry practice or whatever it is? They cannot because they have so much debt. They are in debt federally because their share of the federal debt is $20,000. They are in debt provincially because all of the provinces have been going into debt. They are in debt personally because they have encountered all of these wonderful student loans.

I really believe that we ought to look at that again. I do not believe that we are investing properly in our young people. I believe that if equalization payments are to be made from the federal government to the provinces it should be done in such a way that it helps those who are in need.

I think about health care. Every once in a while we hear of people, in fact too frequently, who because they are rich can afford to go to the United States to get superb health care.

I know of a family who lives in my community. It is actually a very sad story. This young married man, who has a couple of children, was feeling tired. His mother was also not feeling well. But they could not get any proper diagnosis in our health care system. First, they wait six months to get in line. When they do get into the health care system there is inadequate equipment. Many of the really skilful medical practitioners have gone off to the United States where there is more money available for their research and for them to be able to practise their profession.

These people, because they had the means, went to the Mayo Clinic. Unfortunately my friend was diagnosed with MS, which is a very serious disease. They could not even figure out what it was here in Canada. Fortunately he had enough money to go there. He also took his mother along. Unfortunately they diagnosed a terminal disease and she has now since passed away.

We often hear the hue and cry “We don't want a two tier health care system”. The fact of the matter is, we have it.

This government started out with a good principle. The principle was to make equalization payments so that people in the different provinces could have an equal level of services without undue taxation.

When the federal government originally brought this in it funded 50% of health care costs. It did that quite consistently for a few years. Then payments started to decrease. I do not know if my number is accurate, but a number which I heard recently put it as low as 13%.

In other words, we are still being taxed. Nobody in the country feels that their tax rates have gone down, notwithstanding what the Minister of Finance says. If we look at our bottom line at the end of the year we realize that the average family has, as the statistics from Statistics Canada show, a take home income of $3,000 a year less.

We are still being taxed to the hilt, but health care is no longer being funded adequately. What the government has done in the present budget is woefully inadequate in terms of restoring what it should be doing relative to the original purpose of equalization.

There are two issues. One is to provide comparable levels of services at reasonably comparable levels of taxation.

What does the equalization plan do?

I do not know whether people who are watching on CPAC or even members of the House are aware of this, but one of the strange things is that both the provincial and federal governments tax individuals and businesses and then the federal government pays some of the money back to the provincial governments directly.

Originally that was to be done without strings attached, recognizing the legislative and the constitutional right of the provinces to manage these affairs.

I found a really interesting quotation in the report of the auditor general. One of the recommendations in that report came from the Rowell-Sirois commission which was formed in 1937. That is interesting because it happens to be two years before I was born. It was a dominion provincial relations commission. One of its recommendations was that the dominion government should make annual national adjustment grants to the needy provinces. The report went on to describe that.

Then the commission wrote that the grants would be unconditional and the provinces would be free to decide how to spend them or whether to use them to reduce provincial tax rates. In other words, the principle of equalization was embodied in the report of 1937.

Have we lived up to that? No. Now we have a top-down, heavy-handed federal government saying to the provinces “We will give you the money”. But are there strings attached? Big time.

My province of Alberta, which as I said in my introduction I am here to represent as well as all of Canada, has been dinged several times. Even though this was its own jurisdiction according to our Constitution, the federal government, utilizing its arbitrary and heavy-handed ability to spend the money it taxes, simply withheld funding from the Alberta government's portion of health care. That is unfair. It is wrong. It is illegal, but no one stands up to the government.

Then we have the separatists. Liberal members cannot figure out why they are here. They shake their heads. Instead of trying to ask the question “Why are they here?” they continually accuse them. I will not do that. I will not accuse the separatist members for being here. Their people back home sent them here. As far as we know the elections were fair and square and the ballots were properly counted. There are enough people out there who say “We are so fed up with Ottawa that we want out of this thing”. That is terrible.

I know of several families whose children have left on very, very bad terms. It is painful. Those parents hurt when that happens. We as Canadians all hurt when somebody leaves or threatens to leave.

We do not end up criticizing them, bawling them out and yelling at them. We sit down with them. We want to talk to them. We want to find out what are their true legitimate grievances and to solve them.

What has happened with the Liberals? Over and over all they have done is added more grievances to their list. That has to come to an end. It has to be communicated to the people of Quebec so that they will send people here who want to work with the federal government.

Notwithstanding some of the political rhetoric we get around here, and I say this as humbly as I possibly can, I believe that the Reform Party and the principles we espouse contain the seed of the grand reconciliation we need so desperately in the country. Then we can say to the people of Quebec and to all other provinces that we will respect the Constitution and make sure they have the right to manage their affairs properly.

When I speak to the equalization bill I believe we need to get back to the principle which says that we tried to reach an agreement with the provinces so that their people could have the same level of services in education and particularly in health. When we think of welfare, public services like national highways and roads and so on, there are huge costs of running provincial governments. There is absolutely no problem on the part of the Reform to say that those who are truly in need should be able to have those needs met.

In the last minute I would like to say something about the formula. Given that we are admitting we will do that, how do we determine what is equitable? That is the problem. The legislation requires that the act be renewed every five years. We have known since 1994 that this would expire in 1999. What did the government do? Two or three working days before it was introduced in the House we were given notice of it. Then the government almost immediately invoked closure. It had to push it through because it had to be done by the end of the month. I agree with that.

I disagree with the amendment we are speaking to which says we will basically hoist it. I do not think we want to put the provincial governments into such a disaster as the Progressive Conservatives would propose with their amendment that would not give them these payments. We need to have a longer process.

I propose that we ought to do that. The next process should start as soon as this one is renewed. Let us hear from some academics. We heard some very excellent witnesses in committee. Let us have some academics to answer these—

Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements Act March 9th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I would like to ask the member a question with respect to the province of Quebec.

We know Quebec has been a part of Confederation since the very beginning. It is one of the oldest provinces. It contains one-fourth of the country's population. It has a hardworking population. It has a fair number of natural facilities. It has a lot of natural resources. It has a strong agricultural community. It has a vigorous people and yet year after year somehow it needs money from Ontario, British Columbia and Alberta in order to finance the basic programs for its people.

Does the member have any hopes, any dreams for the country, that the province of Quebec, one of the strongest provinces in the country, will eventually become self-sufficient and be able to provide for its own citizens from its own revenues? Is that an anticipation or are we really looking at perpetually having the other provinces support this very vigorous province?

The reason I ask has to do with the whole basis of equalization. It seems the formula used is such that it demeans the people of Quebec by making them dependent on the rest of the country and does not provide for them an opportunity to be self-sufficient. I would like to see that happen. I wonder what the member has to say about that. I would appreciate his comments.

Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements Act March 9th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I heard part of the member's speech while I was in my office. I missed some while en route and heard the end of it while I was here. There may be some gaps and perhaps he has addressed this point.

I have a very simple question. The Conservatives were in power for nine years. During that time there were, as with this government, no substantial changes made to the equalization program. There was no concerted effort to fix up the problems in it and to try to make it a true equalization payment system instead of what it has become. I wonder whether this represents a new thrust on the part of the PC Party or whether it just wants to gloss over the errors of the past. I am asking a sort of rhetorical question.

I am really intrigued with the idea that the Tories now want to basically scuttle the bill in order to send it back to committee, which would mean it probably would not meet the deadline for continuing the payments to the provinces. Is he actually interested in scuttling it or in revamping it? What exactly is his purpose?

Foreign Publishers Advertising Services Act March 8th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. Is it parliamentary and do the rules permit a vote to be taken on a motion that has not been debated in the House?

Foreign Publishers Advertising Services Act March 8th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I feel constrained to try to stop this Liberal filibuster. The Liberals invoked closure on this bill. We are ready to go on to the next group and see if we can get some debate going on the next group of amendments.

The Liberals are filibustering us, which is appropriate from a government that does not like to debate the issues but rather likes to just ram things through with its pulling of the strings of its backbenchers who vote the way they are told. There is no democracy. There is no debate. There is no consultation with Canadians across the country to see whether they support this.

One of the very interesting movies I saw not many years ago is called The Mouse That Roared . It is an old movie. I have discovered that if one sees any movies that are newer than about the last 20 years they will probably tend to corrupt one's morals.

It was about a small country that had interminable financial difficulties. In order to solve this problem, the prime minister or the president of this small country decided to declare war on the United States on the thinking that after it had lost the war, which undoubtedly it would, then the United States would, in its true fashion, pour millions and millions of dollars into the country to rebuild it which would restore its economy.

I was just wondering if that is what Canada is now trying to do. Is it declaring war on the United States fully expecting to lose so that our economy will be restored? I really do not think so.

This whole bill is based on a couple of totally wrong premises. One premise is that Canadian magazines cannot survive unless they are protected. I reject that. We have the same thinking from the heritage department when it comes to Canadian artists. It thinks that poor Canadian artists are so mediocre that they cannot make it unless the government prevents radio stations from playing other artists. They must play Canadian artists. I reject that.

If we look at some of the award shows these days we will see a fair representation from Canadian artists. They seem to be making it fine. There is no law in the United States which says they must play a certain amount by Canadian artists. However, those Canadian artists on their own and because of their merits are able to do this.

I contend it is the same for magazines. Canadian magazines appeal to Canadian readers in their particular niche of interests and they can make it very well, thank you, without government interference.

There is another premise which I roundly reject in this bill, that culture will somehow be either destroyed or made less vibrant if the government does not protect it. That is fuzzy thinking, Liberal thinking, thinking that says unless the government regulates, promotes, taxes and sends a whole bunch of investigators and supervisors into it, it will not happen. This is a totally wrong premise.

I grew up in a culture which is not one of the ones on the protected list, which is another problem. If we turn over the promotion of culture to government then we get a list of culture, A culture, B culture. We get all these different lists and anybody who is not on the list unfortunately has to make it on their own, which they will. Meanwhile their tax dollars are siphoned off in order to support other people's cultures.

I am quite convinced, from my own experience, that culture is something which we need to let the people control. It should not be handed over to a government bureaucracy. All this crying from the Liberal side about needing to do this in order to preserve our culture is just a bunch of hogwash. It just does not fly. It is a false premise, fuzzy thinking and wrong thinking.

I am quite convinced this bill is very ill advised. We are not fearmongering but strictly being realistic when we say that it puts at risk a lot of Canadian trade with the Americans because they have already given notice that they will do this.

I know members over there are saying let us not just fold every time somebody makes a threat. Of course not. We have our own sovereignty but let us choose the issues we will fight for. Let us make sure they are worth fighting for. Let us not pick a fight on something that is unnecessary, ineffective and that will only take us into a huge amount of trade disputes with the Americans.

I am ready to dispute with them anytime but does this government do this? Does it do it when it comes to our farmers and trade? No. The government puts up its own barriers. It says it will not let Canadian farmers send their wheat to the United States. It puts up its own barriers and prevents farmers from doing that.

Here it is saying it will put up a barrier to protect Canadian industry. That is just garbage because at every other turn it does just the opposite.

My contention and my statement in my short intervention unplanned as it is, is simply to appeal to the government backbenchers to think, just good old plain put the brain in gear. They should think for themselves. I know I cannot address them directly.

They should not simply vote for this because the Minister of Canadian Heritage has her political life on the line and there is a big move to try to save her face. I have no interest in having her lose face, but she could gain face by backing off on this legislation. I would like to see her come into the House today and say “I am withdrawing this bill until we do more study on it and find out whether or not it is really needed, and whether or not it is effective, and whether or not it is based on right premises and right thinking”.

It is unconscionable that the Liberals are ramming this bill through. They have put in closure and are filibustering on the amendments in Group No. l so we cannot discuss the amendment in Group No. 2 which is the minister's motion. I cannot understand this. It is absolutely frustrating.

This is one of the things that brings this parliament into disrepute across the country. The people of Canada are not being heard. They are not being consulted. They are not being informed correctly. They always receive all sorts of different messages which are meant to give them the message the government wants them to believe.

This example is way off topic but it shows what I am talking about. When it comes to health care funding the government wants us to have $2 billion, $2 billion, $2.5 billion. When it is all added up it is $11.5 billion. The fact is that the health care funding is going up this year by $2 billion and next year it will be zero because it is $2 billion more than it was last year, next year as well. Yet the Liberals want Canadians to think it is going up another $2 billion. It is not. That is the type of message the Liberals give. It is not a fair way of communicating with Canadian voters, Canadian taxpayers.

That is exactly what is happening with this bill. The government is giving out its message. I am going to say it, Mr. Speaker, and you can call me on it if you want to, but it is totally false information. The government is deceiving the people of Canada with this misinformation. It is time that the Liberals withdrew the bill and said to Canadians that they are going to look at it again because they want to do it correctly.

Employment Insurance Act March 5th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I will be brief. The member from the PC Party chided me for not knowing the difference between debt and deficit. It is my contention that he is the one who does not understand. He and members on the Liberal side frequently talk about paying off the deficit.

By definition it cannot be done. The deficit is an amount that one borrows. The best one can do is to reduce the amount of borrowing or to stop borrowing. One cannot pay off a deficit since it is intangible. It is simply the amount borrowed.

I objected to the use of the terminology because many people do not understand it. It confuses them into thinking that we are paying off or have paid off the debt which still stands at close to $600 billion. I just wanted to correct that point.

Supply March 4th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. Would you clarify for the House whether this member is hopefully sharing his time?