House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Supply March 4th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I would like to follow up on this last exchange. There is a point I need clarification on.

It is quite clear that the secretary of state indicated that the incentive was to encourage people to enter the workforce. That of necessity says if we are going to give an incentive, we are going to put money, presumably with a tax break, a direct credit or whatever, toward helping people leave their families so they can go to work.

To me, it looks as if the government, if not forcing people to go to work because of economic constraints, is directing economic benefits to those who do in order to somehow achieve this goal. I have a problem with that. I would like her to clarify exactly what she means by this.

The Budget March 3rd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I want to ask the member whether he would answer one question. There is one minute for that. Could I do that?

The Budget March 3rd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I am intrigued with the member's speech. We share one thing. I am sure there will be some heckling immediately, but we share a genuine concern about the health care system.

I expressed that earlier in the House when I talked about my dear aunt who just died. She got very poor care and had to be moved to a private health care facility, an extended care centre run by a religious organization, so she would get decent care. He talked a little about the restoration of health care dollars.

The Liberals want us to believe that they are putting in $11.5 billion. I look at that as simply a very small amount. It is a $2 billion increase per year. The next year there will be no further increase and they are still calling that $2 billion. The next year there will be a $.5 billion increase and they are calling that $2.5 billion and so on for the next three years. They come up with this grand total of $11.5 billion when in fact it is an increase of either $2 billion or $2.5 billion per year over the next five years.

I would like the member to take this opportunity to rip into the Liberals because of this.

The Budget March 3rd, 1999

Madam Speaker, I suppose I should not be asking the member this question because I think it is unfair. I think that he, like most Liberal backbenchers, like most Canadians, does not really understand the implications of the numbers as announced.

When this budget was talked about as being a health care budget, the number which they chose to use was $11.5 billion. If we look at what the budget is, it is an annual budget. The auditor general and other accounting experts have said that annual budgets should have their annual numbers stated. In smaller print, it says $2 billion a year.

Beyond that, $2 billion this year is mentioned, $2 billion next year, $2.5 billion, $2.5 billion and $2.5 billion. They project five years in advance and use the big number of $11.5 billion after taking $20 billion out of the health care system.

It is my understanding—and I would like the member to correct me if I am wrong, if he knows, and I do not think he will know—that when they say $2 billion this year and $2 billion next, it means $4 billion more and then $6.5 billion more and so on as an accumulation. Or is it simply that next year there will be no increase at all, but rather just $2 billion more than we had in the past? Then it would be $2 billion and no increase and then another $2 billion. Which is the right answer?

The Budget March 3rd, 1999

Madam Speaker, I have enjoyed working on the finance committee with the hon. member.

I took note of one thing she said with respect to debt. I suppose nothing concerns me more than the fact that the governments of the last 30 years have driven us into debt to the point where, as she mentioned in her speech, at one stage some 31 cents of every $1 collected in income tax went toward interest. Just think of what we could do if we did not have the debt to service. The amount of money that would be available for programs would be immense.

She then talked about this $3 billion contingency fund which, if not needed, will go toward reducing the debt. She said she was sure the debt would be repaid.

I taught mathematics for a number of years and have these math and finance formulas in my head. I did a quick calculation. To get rid of the debt, $580 billion, over the next 25 years, by the time I am 85, would require the posting of a surplus every year in those 25 years of some $50 billion a year. Here we are paying a puny little $3 billion if we happen to not need it at the end of each year.

I wonder whether she would comment on a greater urgency to reducing the debt so that we could reduce the amount of interest payments and have more of the taxpayers' money available for programs or to give them a tax break.

First Nations Land Management Act March 1st, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to be able to stand to speak to this bill. It is a rare privilege, since there are not many people who will have the right to speak due to the fact that the Liberal government by the careful pulling of the strings of their voters on that side said “You have no choice but to vote in favour of time allocation and we are not going to let anybody speak on this after today”. That is shameful in my view.

I remember a number of years ago a colleague of mine at the Northern Alberta Institute of Technology where I worked had a little placard on the bulletin board in his office. It is one that is very applicable to our situation here today. It said “If you don't have time to do it right, when will you find time to do it again?” I thought that was a very good principle. We need to get things right.

I am not speaking here only of a united alternative, I am speaking generally of what our purpose in parliament is. It is to make rules and regulations which govern our country, which govern our people. We need to get it right. If we do not get it right all we have to do is look at history to see the number of countries around the world which have suffered immensely because of the fact that their government structure was not established in a correct way.

What is wrong here? First, I would like to talk about this process. Why would the government in this particular instance insist on invoking time allocation? It is a mystery to me. I think that the purpose of government, the purpose of the minister, the purpose of the Prime Minister should be to bring a solution to the long-festering problem which we have had on land claims. Let us bring a solution that works.

Overriding all of those considerations is that thing which occupies our minds so much these days, national unity. We need to be together on it. We need to make sure that members of our society, all Canadian citizens, are respectful of each other and that they respect that the limitations which apply to one apply to others.

A request has been made by the official opposition and indeed by Bloc members to make small amendments to this bill.

I worked for a while on a school board. I liked the form of democracy in the school board somewhat better than what we have here. We did not have bills at our school board, but we had motions. If the motion was not a good motion, a number of members would speak against it. When I happened to be the chairman for a while I would ask “All those in favour?” and maybe one or two hands would go up. I would say “Who is opposed?” and the other 13 hands would go up. I would simply declare the motion defeated and we would go on with our business.

What do we do here? Somehow we have this idiotic process. I am not speaking of any individual member, but we have this idiotic process. Parenthetically I have to say that it is mathematically possible and maybe even probable that occasionally a bill might be brought forward by a minister that is not perfect. That is possible. Yet we have this idiotic process which says that unless all members on the government side vote for it somehow they are being disloyal. I contend that they are being disloyal if they vote for something that is not as good as it could be. Instead, it is reversed and then we have the government forcing this vote through. Now we are not even able to speak on it.

One might ask why we do not use the time that we have to debate the issue. It is bigger than that. We are dealing with a relationship among Canadians. We are dealing with people who live next door to their neighbours.

All of us have neighbours. In my instance I have neighbours from a wide spectrum of national backgrounds. They have different language backgrounds, different ethnic backgrounds and we get along just fine.

What happens if we have rules brought in by a distant, disjointed, ineffective federal government that controls how we live next to our neighbours, who happen to be natives living on reserve lands or on native lands as they are called? What happens if we do not do that right? It introduces friction that could otherwise be resolved. All we are asking is that we take some very, very simple measures.

This government could have avoided the embarrassment of the vote at noon today. That was embarrassing. It is incredibly embarrassing that there is no thought for democracy in this place. “It is my way or no way. It is my way or the highway”. That cannot be.

Part of the legislative process, in my view, is that we also make sure that the people who are affected have an opportunity to communicate. They have done so to a certain degree already. Some of my colleagues have referred to a number of different letters that they have received. We are dealing not only with members of municipal councils who are concerned. We are not dealing only as the government tends to do, with those people who form the leadership of the natives. What we need to do is to make sure that the input from grassroots natives is also taken into account. We need to make sure that we hear them. They have some very genuine concerns and we need to hear them.

I cannot for the life of me understand why this government would be so reluctant to enter into a few simple amendments and say “Yes, that is a good idea. Let us adopt it. Let us correct this slightly flawed legislation to make it the best bill possible”, instead of allowing it to just be jammed through in its present mediocre form.

In conclusion, it is atrocious of the government to set up within the nation a separate set of nations without having an appropriate governance system. It is inappropriate to do that. It is awful that the government is suggesting that there can be pockets of municipal-like governments that are not subject to the same rules as other adjacent municipalities.

We are asking for a very simple amendment, that when the law is passed first nations must obey the rules and laws of the municipal acts of the provinces in which they exist. They have to enter into meaningful negotiations.

It is atrocious that people who have been leasing land in the area to be affected can essentially have their life savings and their homes wiped out. There is no protection for them. I do not believe that is right. The government should be paying attention to the very legitimate rights of landowners and investors who have put their life savings into their properties.

Prior to the bill becoming law some local band councils have been driving the value of property essentially to zero, putting lease rates so high that they cannot afford to stay there. It is unconscionable that the values are down and they cannot afford to sell. They ought not to be doing that.

I urge members to support these amendments. Let us do that instead of just ramming it through like a bull in a china shop. Let us listen to each other. Let us listen to the reasoning. If it is valid, let us make the changes that are necessary. Then we will have an opposition that will be supportive of the legislation as improved.

Cbc Funding March 1st, 1999

Madam Speaker, I was not intending to speak this morning but on listening to the debate I found it interesting and realized I have a few ideas members of the House and perhaps some of the people out there who pay the bills would be interested in hearing.

I acknowledge publicly and proudly that I have received a few letters and a few phone calls, not many, which say “please support the CBC. We like it and we do not want it to be diminished or abolished”. I put that fact on the record.

On balance I should also say that I have a greater number of communications from people in my riding who are asking me to seriously consider letting CBC stand on its own legs and stop propping it up with taxpayers dollars. We have both sides in the riding where I am from.

Who of us does not appreciate the CBC? I remember for many years listening to programs like the Royal Canadian Airfarce and enjoying the humour. I suppose those of us in the House have all been the subject of their ribbing humour. We enjoy it even when they poke fun at us because its usually very humorous.

I remember way back I used to almost religiously listen to Double Exposure on CBC Radio because again it was very funny, entertaining, and yet made a social comment. If I were asked if this defines what it means to be a Canadian, I would humbly submit that being a Canadian is much more than that.

I also think of a program like Cross Country Checkup on Sunday afternoons, with Rex Murphy; I hardly ever miss it. What a great venue it is to bring Canadians together. People can phone in from coast to coast. I do not know exactly how rigorous their screening process is, but it gives Canadians an opportunity to express their points of view and it gives all of us across the country an opportunity to hear those points of view.

Those are very good points, but the question here is with respect to funding. My constituents are telling me very strongly that we ought to be supporting those things that Canadians support. We believe the marketplace is what can do that.

I remember a number of years ago when one local magazine, whose name I do not want to give, published a very demeaning article about the daughter of the prime minister of the day. I did not read the article but I heard about it. I said I would never give that magazine a nickel because of what it did. I have the right to do that. I have kept that promise with one exception. On one occasion there was a very funny article. I do not believe in breaking copyright rules, so instead of making a photocopy of the article I in fact bought one issue of that magazine.

When the CBC or other broadcasters come up with things that we do not like, we have the right as citizens to boycott the product that is sponsoring the program or in other ways to exert pressure by saying we do not approve of what is happening.

One of the most obscene things I ever heard was on CBC Radio. It was totally demeaning to women. It was an outrage. This was before I was a member of parliament. I asked what I could do and there was nothing. They tax me. They give the money to CBC. They fund this stuff. They have the right to crank it out. There is no way that we can control it.

I agree the government ought not to be controlling broadcasting. They need to be kept at arm's length, but if they are at arm's length to whom will they be answerable and where is the final accountability.

The member proposing the motion has five minutes to speak and I would like to concede the floor at this stage. Let us carefully consider the funding of the CBC and the accountability of what is broadcast.

Petitions February 19th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I present a petition today with 25 names on it from Ardrossan and Sherwood Park in my riding and a few others.

The petitioners are concerned about the state of marriage in Canada and its definition by government. They are asking that we define in statute that a marriage can only be entered into between a single male and a single female.

The Budget February 18th, 1999

Very briefly, Madam Speaker, that is the point exactly. Originally it was set up in such a way that people paid a certain proportion of their income in taxes. But that proportion has gone up because of inflation, yet it does not reflect it accurately.

What this government is giving is mediocre. Again, it is using the figure $675 as an increase in the basic exemption, which actually is not used any more but that is what the government is calling it, when as a matter of fact $500 of that for most taxpayers was announced last year. It is $175 this year. The government makes it look good when in fact it is pretty mediocre.

The Budget February 18th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I agree that the numbers should accurately reflect the reality. This is where the rub comes in. What does the budget say? What is the number that is being communicated by the Liberals? What number are they using in terms of what they are putting into health care?

The number is $11.5 billion. We hear it all the time. That is because the little number of $2 billion which they are actually putting in, in the coming year, is so small. After cutting $20 billion out of health care, how would the Canadian people accept that they would only put $2 billion in? They got into their little corner and asked what they could do with this number. Like my leader said the other day, they just came up with a magic number to multiply it by. They multiplied the number by five for the next five years.

This is an annual budget. I do not mind them giving projections, but I think it is downright dishonest to say they are putting $11.5 billion into health care when in fact this year $3.5 billion is being put into the year before and $2 billion into the planned year. Those are the actual numbers. To say $11.5 billion in the face of that is just not accurately communicating to Canadians what the facts are.