House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

The Senate October 9th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, in a speech given in Alberta in October 1990 the Prime Minister said: “The Liberal government in two years will make the Senate elected. As Prime Minister I can make that happen”.

The words are very clear. In two years the Senate will be elected.

I ask the Prime Minister what is the meaning of these words spoken.

The Senate October 9th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, today I would like to add a powerful influential voice to the argument in favour of an elected Senate.

Here is a quote: “The Liberal government in two years will make the Senate elected. As Prime Minister I can make that happen. ” That was the person who is now the Prime Minister making a speech in Alberta in October 1990.

Here is another quotation from this influential voice: “To meet the hopes and dreams of those who live in the west and the Atlantic, a reformed Senate is essential. It must be a Senate that is elected, effective and equitable”. I am quoting the Prime Minister of the country who said those words right here in the House of Commons on September 24, 1991.

Why does the Prime Minister now argue against an elected Senate? If his words in the past meant anything, he should now be working hard to achieve these reforms. He is powerful and influential. Albertans are getting sick and tired of his continual excuse making. Let him get on with the job and do it.

Tobacco Act October 8th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the comments of my hon. colleague and would like to ask him a question.

In the speech I made earlier I indicated that the government was cowardly in bringing in legislation which limits the advertising of cigarettes. It is something that I agree with in principle. I do not think we should be allowing a process that encourages young people to start smoking. However, the government is cowardly in doing that without also declaring that tobacco is a dangerous substance.

By labelling it so, the government would then have the moral and legal right to actually limit that advertising. Otherwise it runs into the question of being challenged under the human rights protection act or whatever in terms of limiting freedom of speech when it says to a company that produces and markets a legitimate product that it cannot advertise its product. Presumably the product is 100% legitimate. It is even subsidized by the Government of Canada. It seems to me that there is an anomaly.

Would the member for Lethbridge comment on that? Would he also favour declaring it a dangerous substance and going all out to stop this cancer on our society, with a pun intended there?

Tobacco Act October 8th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, to my knowledge the government has had a policy for a number of years, if not decades of assisting farmers who want to make the transition out of producing tobacco into producing other food crops. If the same amount of money were made available, one could achieve the same goal and help the taxpayer at the same time by phasing out the subsidy for tobacco on a rational basis, perhaps cut it back 10% to 15% per year until it is gone.

If we had a decent competitive marketing system, these farmers should be able to thrive on the world markets with very superior Canadian products which we are producing. Of course it would include things like a wheat board which is accountable and which allows some freedom for an individual farmer to grow and to sell the crop of his or her choice.

With respect to the subsidization of farmers growing tobacco I firmly believe that should be phased out relatively rapidly.

Tobacco Act October 8th, 1998

I don't remember. All I remember is that I found a package of cigarettes that was not completely empty. Of course I never spent my hard earned money on them. For some reason I felt an obligation to try it. I did so all alone. I do not believe I finished the cigarette that I took out of the package because it caused me to cough and wheeze and choke. Being a person who all my life had been somewhat given to an intelligent process of thought and analysis, I stopped and said this to myself: Self, I think this is stupid. It does not make any sense at all to take into one's body that which the body by natural means seems to so violently reject.

I do not think I finished that cigarette, although I do not really recall. I am fairly old now and that probably happened about 50 years ago. I do not recall what exactly happened, but I do know that I made the decision that I would not smoke cigarettes. It had nothing to do with advertising. It had nothing to do with peer pressure. It had to do simply with an intelligent decision. To this day I am very grateful that I made that decision.

We should take account of the fact that tobacco companies make a large amount of money. One of the ironies that I find in government operations is that while on the one hand we are talking about the increased costs of health, on the other hand we are talking about the dangers to our young people and the need for us to protect each other and ourselves from ourselves, according to the Liberal government's philosophy.

At the same time we are subsidizing and assisting farmers who produce tobacco products. To be pushing and pulling on the same object at the same time seems rather schizophrenic, to say the least, and does not clearly show where one is headed. The subject of assistance to the farmers who produce the product is a whole subject for another day. It seems to me that we ought to rationalize this and at least be consistent in the various arms of government with respect to what we are trying to achieve.

I do not like to use the word hypocritical. I know that it is against the rules to apply that term to any individual member of parliament. I suppose that to collectively lay it on the feet of the governing party today is on the verge of being incorrect. But it is the only word that I really know. If we look at the dictionary definition of hypocrite, from the root word it means that you are wearing a mask. You are trying to pretend that you are something you really are not. That is the definition of a hypocrite. I hear the Liberal government say over and over that it is concerned about the health of Canadians and that it is concerned about the social impact of smoking, but at the same time it pours resources into the production of the product. To me that it is hypocritical. That is doing one thing with the hands while the face and the mouth are trying to give a different message.

I do not believe that we ought to approve this particular bill. We should be opposing it because of its lack of clarity. It does not show a clear direction in terms of where this government is going on this particular issue. It does not, in my opinion, have much hope of significantly changing what is happening in the world of smoking these days.

What I would like to see more and more is a really solid education component for all of our young people beginning in junior high. This should include actual visits to hospitals. I have heard of young people who had relatives who got lung cancer. They had to visit those relatives. They saw how they were breathing through a tracheal tube. They saw how they were unable to speak because of throat cancer. They saw firsthand the devastation. Although I am not proposing that we try to shock our young people into an action or a decision, I believe that should be a part of the education process. It should be a part of the experience.

Why does the government not undertake to produce some films that make some sense? Quite often we hear criticisms of the National Film Board and the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation about some of the garbage they produce using taxpayers' money. Why do they not undertake to do a good, solid, medically based analysis on film and make it available at a cost that school boards can easily afford? Make it available to the school boards. Show it to children. Maybe show it repeatedly to them. I would like to include the health benefits of not smoking. I would like to include the financial costs of taking up the habit versus entering into a savings program. If all of the Liberal members when they were youths had learned how to save money maybe we would not have a $580 billion debt today.

We have to stop thinking that way. We need to start thinking in terms of saving our money instead of spending it on a habit which is statistically a proven killer. I certainly urge the government to not promote this type of action but to promote an action that will in reality affect our habits. For goodness sake, let us stop subsidizing the production of tobacco products.

Tobacco Act October 8th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I would like to say a few things on the Tobacco Act and the resolution of the government to make some changes to the bill before us.

A number of years ago when I was an instructor at a technical institute, I remember having a number of students who took up the habit of smoking. We all know that it is a habit that is very addictive. In fact, of all the people I have spoken to over the years, and I am old enough to have spoken to a number of them who got hooked on this habit, a number of them have said to me that they wish they had never started because once you are hooked it is very difficult to stop. It is almost as bad as eating. Once you start eating it is very difficult to quit.

Over all the years I have spoken to people who smoke, I have never once encountered a single individual who suggested to me that I should start. It is such a devastating thing for health reasons and also for costs.

On several occasions as a mathematics instructor I was able to persuade some of my students to stop smoking. I did that by utilizing part of my curriculum in the math department. Whether I was teaching computing and how to set up functions on a computer or whether I was teaching exponential functions, one of the things we did in the realm of math or finance was to talk about the future value of a deposit annuity.

I specifically remember one student who admitted to me that he smoked about one and half packs of cigarettes a day and that his wife smoked well over a pack a day. Between the two of them they were putting almost three packs a day away.

It is very costly to do this. A lot of people look at the price of a package of cigarettes and think only of the present value of that. However, as anyone who has ever sold RRSPs or anything else in terms of accumulating value can attest, value is greatly enhanced exponentially as one makes deposits over a long period of time.

I do not remember the exact numbers nor do I remember at the time what the prevailing interest rates were, but I remember my students when they were learning to use their electronic calculators, learning exponential functions and learning computer programming. I had the students compute the function 365 multiplied by 5, if that was the price of cigarettes, multiplied by the nominal interest rate, say .1 because in those days it would have been around 10%, divide by, in big square brackets, 1 minus 1.1 to the power of say 45, that number of course representing the number of years a student would work from age 20 after finishing his or her degree and working until age 65.

The students as part of their exercise computed the accumulated value of their cigarette money. If instead of putting the money into cigarettes they had put it into an RRSP, it came to, as I recall, $1.3 million with the assumptions that I used. I had a number of students tell me they were going to change. They said that instead of smoking and having nothing when they retire, they were going to put their $5 a day into a little box and once a month they were going to run it down to their RRSP agent and when they retired they would have $1.3 million on which to retire. That is the financial cost of smoking. We all know of the human and health costs. There is absolutely no justification for people who get hooked on cigarettes. They cannot justify it from a health point of view, not for themselves and not for those around them in their own household or in their office. As a result we have seen in the last number of years a great increase in the number of buildings which have become non-smoking buildings because of the devastating health effects. One could probably see in the future a massive lawsuit against cigarette manufacturers. They will be held legally responsible for the devastation they have caused, the early deaths that have been caused and the problems this has caused, not only to the lives of smokers, but also to the lives of their family members.

I do not know whether it is going to come to that or not, but we have certainly had lawsuits of great magnitude in recent years on different issues. Maybe that is going to come. Maybe the cigarette companies are going to have to tally up one of these days and admit that they have caused a lot of devastation.

I say to the Liberal government that ever since we came to the House in 1993 this has been an issue. Very little has been done. As a matter of fact, shortly after we arrived the government took the unusual step of reducing the tax on cigarettes. Its claim was that this would reduce the criminal act of smuggling illegal cigarettes into the country. If the price of cigarettes sold at the counter was reduced, then the motivation for smuggling would decrease and that would reduce smuggling.

I do not think that is a good principle. If we were to take the logic of that principle and apply it to other areas I suppose we could legalize bank robberies, prostitution, theft, embezzlement and other things and, lo and behold, there would be no more crime. It would be a wonderful way of fighting crime, just by declaring that everything we do that is wrong is not a crime any more. Our jails would be empty and we could proclaim ourselves to be the most wonderful country in the world.

Over the years successive governments have tried to reduce the amount of smoking by increasing taxes and, to a degree, they were effective. I personally know people who, when the next tax increase kicked in, said “That is it for me. That pushes the straw onto the camel's back. That breaks his legs and I am not going to smoke any more”. Increased costs in fact do act as a deterrent. I believe that it was a total act of wimpishness on the part of the government. Instead of enforcing the laws, it simply reduced the price so the criminals would of their own accord lose their profit motive and quit.

I am not certain whether the whole act of smoking should be illegal. This is a question one really needs to ask. As long as cigarette smoking is legal in the country it is incredible that we should pass laws that would prevent a corporation from advertising a product which is legal.

For example, we have people advertising certain foods. Maybe looking at me sideways, Mr. Speaker, you can tell how much weight I have lost. I have tried to say no to food lately. I do not want to do any free advertising, but that slim trim diet is working.

There are many products which may be harmful, but we do not take draconian measures to say they cannot be advertised. If the government were really honest with Canadians, looking at the scientific evidence about the harmful effects of smoking on health, it would declare tobacco as a dangerous substance. Then it would have moral and legal grounds for reducing and restricting the advertising of the product. As long as it is a fully legal product, from the point of view of freedom of citizens and the freedom of companies to work in Canada, we have to ask that question.

At the same time I recognize the vulnerability, especially of young teens, to the pressures of advertising. As long as advertisers are able to make a product look exciting and youthful, as if all young people are doing it, as if all of our heroes are doing the smoking thing, it will look attractive and will draw more people in. I think that more people begin smoking because of peer pressure than because of advertising. That is just a guess that I am making.

Bill C-42 is an attempt to solve the problem or at least to reduce the amount of smoking, by young people in particular. The government is looking at a five year transition period on restrictions to advertising. It has never been proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that advertising causes people to take up the habit of smoking, but this is what the government proposes to do.

This must be true confession time on nationwide television. I have to blushingly admit to all people here and to anyone who happens to be listening out there that I did at one time smoke a cigarette.

Royal Canadian Mint October 2nd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, that is exactly what I am going to do. I am going to thank all members of the House for their kind consideration of this very important private member's bill. I appreciate the tone in which the debate was held.

I would like to respond by saying two things.

First, in a quick response to the letter that was quoted, I do not want to do what I think we are finding others guilty of, so I would like to simply ask two questions with respect to the letter. I am talking about the statement that is repeated over and over by the minister that Westaim gave an intention to go out of business.

I would like to ask whether the government, in quoting this letter, would at some time totally and accurately describe the actual circumstances under which the letter of intent was signed. Second, is the government prepared to disclose the date on which that letter of intent expired and became null and void?

The fact of the matter is that Westaim is in the business. It was in the business at the time the mint announced its intentions to build the plant. It is a strong company. It is not a question of whether it is intending to vacate that field.

I would like to emphasize that and to indicate to the government that the continued use of that statement is really quite inappropriate.

The last statement I would like to make is that I hope as a result of this discussion we can get into a wider discussion on a basic philosophical question. That is, should the government be in the business of competing with business?

One person in my riding, not specifically on the Westaim question but on another one, asked whether the government should be in the business of competing with business thereby driving out the business. It is a fundamental principle which we recognize that where the taxpayers are behind the government, it gives the government funded operation a huge and unfair advantage. There is another case which I did not mention because I ran out of time.

Who buys coinage products? Everyone probably knows there are two main buyers. There are those who buy some types of coins and medals or coins commemorating sovereigns or whatever, and the big market is governments. When any government around the world is looking for a supply of coinage products, we have little old Westaim, and I say little old strictly and only in comparison to Government of Canada.

To many foreign governments, dealing with another government is very important. They have a huge advantage without even talking about the actual price at which they bid. It could happen that Westaim in future international bidding contracts could have the lower bid and a superior or at least equal product, but would lose the bid because other countries want to deal with the government instead of a private enterprise. Government has absolutely no business being there.

I hope that this debate today will be enlarged so that we can carry on with that larger debate. I think this is so crucial to our whole situation.

In conclusion, I thank the members of the House. Let us move forward to see if we can bring the facts to the table and get a resolution to this deeply philosophical problem.

Royal Canadian Mint October 2nd, 1998

moved:

That an order of the House do issue for copies of all documents relating to the Royal Canadian Mint building a coin plating plant in Manitoba.

Mr. Speaker, I am absolutely delighted that finally we have a venue for an open and parliamentary debate on this issue.

Those who have been following this story know that it has been almost a year now since this story hit the fan, so to speak. It is a situation where approximately 100 jobs in my riding are being jeopardized by a decision of the government to build a coin plating plant in Winnipeg, the back door of the Minister of Foreign Affairs.

I might also give another quick little political plug here because I think it is very appropriate. I have a strong suspicion that if the plant I am talking about, the private enterprise plant Westaim Corporation, were in a Liberal held riding we would not be discussing this right now. I do not think the issue would have gone this far. That is just a suspicion I have, based on my observations of the way this place works and what I have seen happen around here in the last few years.

Let us get down to the actual issues. The motion is for the production of papers. The motion specifically says that we want to have the papers released that will finally show the truth of the decision making process on this issue.

I have in my speech, which will be taking place in the next few minutes, a number of questions which I would like to have answered. I am just conjecturing here but I believe there is probably already a canned speech ready for the parliamentary secretary. My hopes of getting these questions answered is somewhere between zero and nothing. I want to pose them anyway and then I am going to urge members of this House in the interests of truthfulness, disclosure, openness of government to support the motion since if there is nothing to hide then the government should be eager to have everything out in the open so that the truth can be known.

If they vote against it, we can only conclude that the motivation must be that they want to deal in innuendo and in half truths or non-truths in order to justify their actions.

That is a big challenge for these Liberal members. I think they need to very seriously consider what the implication of their vote is. If they say no, it is really equivalent to the shredding of papers in the Somalia affair. It is a possibility that we can have the non-disclosure of all this information. That is really all we are after. Let us have the facts.

The other thing which underlies this question is that government decisions, especially as pertaining to the expenditure of money and the operation of the business of government which includes crown corporations, the mint, should be made prudently and be based on true facts. The decisions should be done wisely.

With all due respect, humbly I submit that some of the facts of the case here have been quite systematically ignored. I want to see what those facts are.

Very briefly, the government proposed last year to build a coin plating plant in Winnipeg. The cost at that time was projected to be around $30 million. Since then there have been two other numbers that have been publicized, $31 million and $38 million. We do not know at this stage exactly what the final cost of the plant will be. However, we do know that it is a plant of about 56,000 square feet with a capacity for producing plated coin blanks of approximately one-third of the capacity of the Westaim plant in my riding which is at issue here.

The other issue is the question of savings. In a press release last October it was said this would also lead to savings. The first number touted was a saving of $9 million per year and the second figure given was $9.5 million per year for a total saving of between $18 million and $19 million in a two year timeframe.

This is not a saving at all since moving the job from one location in the country to another at the expense of one and giving it to another is not a real saving. Furthermore, the savings could have also been achieved simply by continuing at the original location.

I believe this decision was based on the incorrect answers to three questions. First, is there security of supply? The government said no. I and the people in my riding and the Westaim Corporation emphatically say there is security of supply.

Second, are there cost savings? As I indicated in my introduction, I will talk more about the real and perceived savings and how they can be achieved.

Third, should the government be in business competing with existing businesses and threatening them? This is a philosophical question. I am not sure we will get the answer from the papers but it is one which also demands an answer. Should government be in an industrial process business?

To the question of security of supply, Westaim Corporation has been a major supplier to the mint since 1961, albeit at that time under a different corporate name. It is the same plant, the same organization and it has evolved over time. Now it runs under the name of Westaim.

In 1961 the corporation began producing nickel strip for the 5 cent coin. We call them nickels because they are made of nickel which came from the Westaim plant in my riding. In 1968 it began supplying the blanks for the dime, the quarter and the 50 cent piece. We all know what high quality coins Canadians have, so there is no question about the security of the supply and the quality of the supply. The coin blanks are pressed into actual coins by the mint which is a proper function of that crown corporation.

Westaim Corporation has subsequently supplied all the blanks for the loonie. Everyone who has a loonie in their pocket is dragging around metal that was produced in my riding. I want everyone, especially Liberal members, every time they look at a loonie or spend one to think of the wonderful riding of Elk Island just out of Edmonton, Alberta because that is where it originated.

The nickel strip portion of the two dollar coin is made at Westaim in my riding, so we have a large contribution to the coinage of Canada. Westaim in its coin production has been a solid business for over 30 years. It is doing just fine. For anyone to imply that the security of supply is at risk is totally incorrect. This is an international company. It produces coin products for markets all around the world, including recent large contracts to China and Brazil. Besides supplying Canada's domestic market it is a large exporter, thereby helping greatly in Canada's economy. It also does high tech research and production.

What really intrigues me, since my uncle died in a fire accident, is that Westaim produces a very high tech biomedical, totally sterile dressing for burn victims. It markets this all over Canada and the United States. It is an expensive but very effective product. It is very good at it. It has a research department in advance display technologies.

Recently it announced a breakthrough. We all have these little desktop computers. It could be that very soon computer manufacturers will be buying these thin screened, multicolour displays from Westaim Corporation in Fort Saskatchewan. It has excellent surface engineered products.

It recently announced a breakthrough regarding some fine powder materials which are used in the production of these high tech rechargeable batteries that all of us have in all our electronic equipment.

Does that sound like a business that is not able to give a secure supply? I guess not, so my contention is the decision was made based on less than perfect facts.

With respect to the security of supply and an answer to some of the things the minister said, even in this House as a response to questions that I raised and also that members of the other parties raised, Westaim has offered to the mint, if it is really concerned about it, to actually sign a contract, to dedicate the production from one line to the mint.

In other words, it is ready to say if at any time the mint wants to run the same kind of production it will be able to get out of its Winnipeg plant it is available right here and right now. That is because there is a worldwide oversupply in this market.

It just boggles the mind when one wonders why the government is trying to get into a business in which there is a present oversupply and in which there is not a foreseeable future of increase since we are moving more and more to electronics, credit cards and soon we will probably have cash cards. Coins are not an ongoing growing industry. They are level at best, with peaks admittedly.

When the Europeans bring in the new Eurocoin, zippo, there is a big demand for large coins. Canadians decided to have a $2 coin. Suddenly there was a demand because from zero the whole country had to be supplied with all the coins needed in that denomination.

Now that the loonie is in production and has been for over 10 years, the $2 coin now for a few years, the amount of production required to replace the coins that are lost or hoarded is not anywhere near what it is when a new coin is introduced. It is not a matter of the government getting into a business for which there is a huge ongoing and increasing demand. It is one where really what it is doing is upsetting the market and intruding into a business that is currently totally adequately covered by Westaim Corporation in my riding.

I say parenthetically with respect to the offer of the one of the three lines in the Westaim plant, the minister made a false statement in the House on March 24 this year when he said that the president of Westaim refused this offer. That is wrong. The president of Westaim made the offer. Again, I think we need to deal with actual facts when making these decisions.

Let me get to my second question, cost savings. They claim there will be a saving of around $9 million to $9.5 million per year. The fact is that only a small portion of that saving can be attributed to the fact that they will be producing their coin blanks in-house instead of purchasing them from Westaim. The largest component of that saving is due to the fact that they are changing from a nickel base to a steel base for their coin blanks.

Just the change in material and the cost of the process would produce this change and if they were to simply enter into a long term arrangement with Westaim, that saving could be achieved, just as with their new plant in Winnipeg they are proposing. There is only one difference, that the saving could be achieved almost immediately instead of waiting for two years until this plant is in full operation. At least we hope it will be in full operation.

It will be a brand new untested plant and, as with all new plants, it will have start-up pains. Therefore instead of saving $9 million to $9.5 million per year starting in the year 2000 or later, we could save that right away. There is another $18 million.

The minister in the House said this is not going to cost the taxpayer anything. That is not true. The mint is a crown corporation. If it makes money that money accrues to Canadians. If it looses money that is money that is lost to Canadians. If it reduces its total net profit that comes essentially and eventually from the pockets of the taxpayers of this country.

I submit that if we take the price of $38 million for the plant and $9 million a year for two years in savings, we are looking at a total of $56 million that the mint is expending when if it simply stayed with the present set-up there would be $56 million less to spend which is money saved and equivalent to money in the taxpayers' pockets. When the minister says this is not going to cost the taxpayer anything, it is not so.

This comes to my next topic which I am not up to yet but these things overlap a bit. They claim to be making money but the fact is they will not be making very much money if they are not going to compete internationally. The minister said we were not going to compete internationally. If they are not going to I do not know where they will get the money to provide all the domestic needs in this country. Unless we get into the business of issuing a new coin and a new denomination every other year there will not be that big domestic demand. Either they are going to contradict what the minister said and compete internationally or they are not going to make any money.

Furthermore, if the claim they will be making money it is inevitable that they will be making it at the expense of an existing corporation, a taxpaying corporation in this country. Any business they get which will allow them to make money will be money taken directly away from Westaim Corporation in my riding. I think that is wrong.

I have already spoken about the premise of increasing demand. Frankly, the documentation available shows that not to be so. That is not correct information. There is of course a present peak in demand for coin production because of the Eurocoin but when that passes it is expected to level off and, as I said before, the excess of supply in both plated and non-plated coin products is somewhere in the neighbourhood of between 30% and 50% which is the excess of supply right now. It is absolutely foolish to be getting into this business.

Let me address my third question. Should the government be in the business of competing with business? My answer is a hearty no. It may not do this. It is an affront to our concept of justice and decency for the government to use its clout to compete directly in a business with private enterprise. Would we allow if it were to say let's start a factory to build cars and compete with the car manufacturing places? What about a used car lot? Would anyone buy a used car from our Prime Minister? I do not know.

What kind of businesses is the government going to get into? It may not compete directly. Furthermore, a recent bill in this House proposes to give the mint not only additional borrowing powers but additional borrowing powers from the consolidated fund. It is terribly unfair to have business A run by the government being able to use taxpayer money directly borrowing from the consolidated fund in order to compete with a private enterprise firm that is doing very well, thank you, as long as the government butts out and keeps out of this business. It has no business intruding there.

There is also a very great contradiction. It is the policy of this government to not compete with business. We have noticed how it has been privatizing. NavCan is an example. All the airports in the country are being privatized. Even some components of the military operations are now being put out to contract for private involvement. We also have the government printing operations.

There are many examples of it. It is getting out of the business of being in business in order to let private enterprise do its thing. We already have private enterprise being very successful. The government is incorrectly intruding in it, in violation of every decent principle that we could possible think of.

I strongly urge the government to vote in favour of this motion of the production of papers. When the facts are disclosed and truly known, and when we look at the contradictions in the debate so far, because there are some real sincere questions, hopefully we can rationalize this and even at this late date we can stop the government from this inappropriate intrusion into private business.

Canada Small Business Financing Act October 2nd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, on a point of order, I believe this member is very close to imputing improper motives to fellow members of the House. That is against the rules of this House. I would ask him to withdraw that.

Cancer October 2nd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I want to tell members today about Beverley and Susie. It is almost 18 years ago that each of these young women, then in their early teens, found out that their mothers had cancer. Beverley's mother survived; Susie's unfortunately succumbed to the disease. It was devastating to Susie, her father, her sister and her brothers.

Beverley is our daughter. Her mother who survived is my wife. We are so grateful for God's healing. Susie is our son's wife.

Pretty well everyone in Canada has been touched by this dreaded disease. During October, cancer month, let us do all we can to further the cause of research. Let us reach out in love and caring to those who are in the middle of the battle.