House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Canada Small Business Financing Act November 23rd, 1998

Madam Speaker, again it is a pleasure to speak on the very important topic of the well-being of small business in Canada.

I would like to say something very obliquely about the whole issue of closure. The government uses that technique in order to stop the debate. It wants to have the bill finished, in this case today, and it is at a loss to try to persuade us to pass the bill really fast. We want to discuss it and see whether we can persuade the government to make some amendments. This is very important to us. I believe that we represent the well-being of the taxpayers much more than does the government side. It is important for that point of view to be stressed.

We are talking about the government's inability or lack of desire to seriously consider our amendments. If the government would say that the amendment makes a lot of sense and that it would go along with it, that would be the end of the story. We would not have a long debate. It would not take a whole week of debate to come to a conclusion.

However, the government says “It is our way or the highway. We are the only ones who know perfectly how this should be done”. That is not an accurate assessment of the government's abilities. Undoubtedly the government has very capable members of parliament but their ability to represent their constituencies is severely hampered by the fact that they do not have the freedom to vote according to the wishes of their constituents, even on amendments to a bill. I cannot understand that. I want that to be changed.

This group of amendments has two very important components. One is Motion No. 6 put forward by one of my colleagues. This is an amendment which protects the people who earn the money, the taxpayers.

It has already been alluded to that some people and some small businesses are concerned because as taxpayers they have to pay their taxes both as individuals and as businesses. That money is taken by the government whether they want to give it or not. It is not a voluntary fund. It is not a charity.

It is not a case of somebody from the government or elsewhere coming to the people in the little towns which I represent and saying “There is a person in your town who wants to start a business and we would like to give them a little bit of help. They are just not quite solid enough to qualify for a loan from the bank, so we would like to give them your money. How much money would you like to give them?”

In the event that the person has a solid business plan, a good reputation in the community and is not seeking to undermine by direct competition a business which is already in that town, then perhaps the individual business person would say “Yes, having this business in my town is going to be helpful. I trust this person. I will give you a cheque for $500 to help”. That would be a voluntary way of collecting this money, but that is not how it works.

When the tax man comes, it is not a voluntary donation that we make. The tax man reaches into our pockets and takes our earnings, against our will in some cases. Certainly it is true in my part of the world that most Canadians whom I speak to are quite happy to pay a reasonable level of taxation. However, in this case, that money to be taken is to be given to another business person. We are taking money away from those who are successfully earning it and giving it to others in the hopes that they will also earn it, which is not entirely a bad premise.

However, statistics show that many of these small business people who get started have a much higher than average rate of default. I guess that is to be expected because not everyone's good dream will come to fruition. Some people unfortunately will not be able to put their dreams into action and things will not quite work out the way they wanted them to. That is why ordinary banks and lending institutions will not advance the money to them. Hence they come to the government, to the taxpayer.

The amendments we are proposing are reasonable. They are probably going to be rejected by the government. Instead of listening to reasoned debate, the government would rather call all its members on command to stand up and vote for time allocation so we cannot talk about it.

We will vote on these amendments and the government will say to vote against the amendments. All the individualized robots will stand up when their strings are pulled and say that they are against the amendments, without having heard the arguments, without having heard the reasoning. Meanwhile, it all comes to an end and the taxpayer gets to pick up the bill.

I am talking about these two amendments, the first of which says that the liability that the taxpayers should pick up should be restricted to 50% of the loan. This has two effects.

The first one is very important. When a loan is granted under this program, the bank or financial institution administering it on behalf of the government will be a little more careful. It is too easy right now to say “We will decline you. Go to the Small Business Loans Act people and they will give you the money”. The banks and other institutions basically cut their potential losses but they cut them at the expense of somebody else.

I have discovered over the years that people generally are much more careful with their own money than they are when they spend someone else's. This is the premise here. The administrators of the loan system are spending someone else's money. They say “Sure, we will pick up 85% of the responsibility if this person wants to start a business. We do not think it will work but it is tough to say no to someone. Let's just say yes. If they do not make it, we will pull it out of the taxpayers' pockets. We will pull it out of the pockets of those who are competing against this person. We will end up being covered. Spread out over all the taxpayers, it does not make that much difference”.

I appeal to the Liberal members, all the green Liberals over there. I am not permitted to point out to people that empty chairs in this House are green so I will not say that. I am making an appeal to the Liberal members to vote in favour of the amendment in order to protect the taxpayer. The taxpayer is footing the bill.

It is an added incentive on the part of the person granting the loan to say “We carry a full 50% of the responsibility and therefore we must be careful”. The second reason this is a good amendment is that it saves the taxpayers money. It saves the money of the person who has put a successful business together, is earning money and is paying taxes.

Hopefully by putting in measures like this one, we can look forward to that great and glorious day when we will actually have some tax cuts, some real tax cuts and not some phony declared cuts from the other side.

Madam Speaker, I would like to have another 10 minutes to speak on Motion No. 11. If you would seek unanimous consent, I would be quite willing to do that.

Division No. 265 November 23rd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to speak to this group of amendments today. I find it rather interesting that with over 150 Liberal members in this present government, none of them feel compelled to get up and defend why these amendments should not pass.

I believe that part of a debate is to put both sides of an issue on the table and to argue back and forth the merits of the case. What we have here today is a government which is totally abdicating its democratic responsibility. The Liberals not only do not want to debate this matter themselves, they just want to ram it through, but they have also said we cannot debate it. Both of these are rather insulting.

It is insulting that the government would use its majority to force through a closure motion, or time allocation as it is technically called, in order to restrict the length of time of the debate. It is also very insulting that the Liberals will not engage me in debate. I am really nonplussed by it. The silence on the other side probably says that they will support this motion.

When I am debating with someone, for example if I have a difference of opinion with one of my children, we debate things back and forth. I will say something and my son will say something else. We will go back and forth giving opposing points of view. Eventually we have to come to an agreement. I hope it does not characterize me as a soft father when I say that sometimes things go my way and sometimes my son is able to convince me of his point of view and things will go his way. That is what the process of debate is about. We do not have that here which is most regrettable.

Just as the government has used its majority to ram through the time allocation motion, it is also going to use its majority to pull the strings of the members opposite who will then dutifully vote against these amendments. These are good amendments. These are amendments which protect the taxpayer. These amendments protect businesses across the country. These amendments really are worthwhile. The government will not tell us its reasons for opposing them.

I do not know if this is parliamentary but I will be corrected if it is not. Is it because the government members are cowards? That is asked as a question so I hope the Speaker does not stop me. It is just a question. Why are the government members afraid to defend their position on this debate?

The government will go ahead and use this process and ram through whatever it thinks is right. We see this over and over in this government. We saw it big time when we were discussing the wheat board issue. This government was totally out of touch with the aspirations of farmers in western Canada. The government used time allocation, used closure debate and control of its members, even from the west, in order to do something which is diametrically opposed to what Canadian farmers need.

I know I am straying a bit from the specific amendments that we are talking about but I am using it to illustrate a very important point. The point is that democracy only works when we have true representation from the members who were sent here and elected by the people in their respective ridings. I wish that would actually occur. Instead we have another dog and pony show where the master in the centre of the ring snaps the whip and everybody else jumps through the hoops on cue. It is very depressing.

It is time for me to say a few things about the actual amendments. We should recognize a couple of things.

It is absolutely true that small business is one of the most important factors in a vibrant economy, and in Canada there is no doubt that is the case. We are told over and over again that the highest proportion of jobs are created by small business. The role of the government should definitely be to provide an environment in which small business can thrive.

I believe quite strongly in the principle of free enterprise. I believe very much in the forces of the free marketplace in determining who is successful and who is not. I have observed over and over in my short life that individuals who have been risk takers and hard workers very often have good luck. There seems to be a correlation there. Those who are timid and pull back say “I want everybody else to look after me”. In Canada we often think there is an inalienable right that “I do not have to work. I do not have to take any risks. Somebody else has an obligation to look after me and my family”. This has become a way of thinking.

I have genuine concern for the many who have absolute needs such as those who are disabled and cannot work. We will make sure they do not suffer. However there are many people who are able bodied. We now have a string of governments that has arranged the affairs of the country in such a way that the motivation for people to take risks, to do things that are unusual, to work hard, to get up early and to go to sleep late because they are working hard all day, has been somewhat taken away. A principle has been adopted that somehow it is an appropriate role of government to take away from the person who has earned it and to use it to subsidize the person who has not earned it.

Small business is important but we need to be careful the public policy we develop is such that small business can survive and thrive because it is successful, not because of having made the correct political donations to the correct party and thereby being eligible for subsidies from the government, which is a legalized form of taking away from the person who earned it and giving it to the person who did not earn it.

Am I opposed to small business loans? Absolutely not. I have had experience with loans. I was fortunate in the sense that my partner and I had a good business plan and good backing. We went to an ordinary bank, got a loan, got our business started and away it went. I wish I could say that it was very successful, but unfortunately it was in the farming industry and in the end it did not work out that well, again partially because of government policies.

I emphasize that some people have very good ideas but do not have the capital or have not accumulated capital in their lifetime to be able to access loans. In this amendment we are saying that perhaps there is a role to play. I know that my colleagues and I have had representations from some individuals who say the Small Business Loans Act and the small business financing act have some merit and have helped people to get on their feet who otherwise would never have been able to do so.

Let us make sure that we do not put the taxpayers at a huge risk that ordinary financial institutions are not willing to take. If the bank down the street is not willing to give an individual with a business plan a loan, maybe it is because the business plan is not workable. Maybe it is because there are too many flaws. Maybe it is because the individual has not demonstrated a record of financial accountability. For us to say that we should limit the value of the loan is a valid comment.

Solicitor General November 20th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, in response to a question asked earlier by one of my colleagues, the parliamentary secretary declared that the cries for the solicitor general's resignation are based on innuendo and hearsay.

My question is simple. Is the parliamentary secretary saying that sworn affidavits by Fred Toole, by the member for Palliser and from the solicitor general are innuendo?

Supply November 19th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I agree with about 98% of what the member said. The 2% I do not agree with was the cheap shot about Reform.

What will surprise her is that I was attracted to the Reform Party because of its commitment to the health care system. I invite all members in the House to pay attention. We are spending, thanks to the governments of the last 30 years, about $40 billion a year on interest because they could not manage the fiscal affairs in such a way as to keep us out of debt.

Just imagine what $40 billion a year would do in terms of providing educational opportunities and health care. What attracted me to Reform is that it listened to the people who said health care was the highest priority to them. Therefore it is to us, but we also are committed to running our financial affairs so that we can deliver on that.

My aunt is in hospital. She fell out of bed—

Taxation November 16th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, the finance minister wants Canadians to believe that he has brought tax cuts. Maybe he is thinking about tax cuts in the countries of Liberia, Barbados and Bermuda where certain steamship lines are registered. However a local restaurant cannot avoid the finance minister's taxes by flying a Liberian flag and a corner barbershop cannot hide assets by registering in Barbados.

When will the finance minister treat ordinary taxpayers to the same low taxes that companies like CSL enjoy offshore?

First Nations Land Management Act November 6th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, what we are doing here is reversing the roles. The member had 20 minutes to make a speech and he used just a little over two. Really what he was doing was questioning our position on this. I appreciate that he recognizes those of us on this side, and I will be gracious and include everyone in the House, have an obligation to look at this legislation.

One of the things that happens to be in place right now is our motion to suspend the bill for six months. The reason for this is to provide the opportunity to get it right. I have often said to my children and to my students over the years that it is much better to get it right than to get it fast. Perhaps that is why I am so slow all the time. It is very, very important to get it right.

In this instance, this legislation has a lot of flaws. A lot of things in it just are not right. They fundamentally are not right. They are not right philosophically. They are not right socially. They tie us together as humans living on the same continent within the same boundaries with a political organization that will not work well in the long run.

All we have to do is read a little history and look at the history of different countries, countries where there is a clear delineation of the powers, responsibilities and privileges of the different levels of government. We are getting a hodgepodge. We are getting a total mess where based on race, based on factors such as personal characteristics, one set of laws applies and another set applies to different people.

There are different laws for pensions for MPs and senators as opposed to what other people have. There are different laws with respect to just about everything that can be named. We split up people and start pitting them against each other.

I would appeal to the government, to those eager backbenchers over there to finally say to the government and better yet, to stand up when the vote is taken and say “We support this six month hoist. We support that we need to work on this more. We support that we have to get it right. Let us make those fundamental changes”. I would urge the member who has just given this extremely short but I would say concentrated and valuable speech to get his colleagues together and say “Here are some things in this legislation that are fundamentally not right. Let us delay it so that we can get it right”.

Mr. Speaker, if you just tuck your head down and dive off the diving board without first checking to make sure there is water in the pool, would be an act of sheer stupidity. It is absolute folly for the government to ram this legislation through without giving it very serious thought.

The implications of what we are doing here are immense for the future of our country, our children and our grandchildren. I would like the member to elaborate a little more on what he said in his speech and to respond to what I have said.

First Nations Land Management Act November 6th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I appreciate my colleague's intervention on this subject. I am curious to know whether he has actually talked with grassroots natives in his area on this issue and whether they are in favour of what is happening in the federal government or whether they are opposed to it.

I am speaking specifically of the grassroots people as opposed to the people who are presumably in charge in the different reserves.

Points Of Order November 5th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I would certainly like to concur with what the member just said in the sense that what we are talking about here is some pretty basic democracy.

This is a decision that has been made by this House. It is definitely in the interest of private members and private members who are largely marginalized in this House by the rules. Those rules were suggested to be changed by the committee.

I take great umbrage at the House leader making the implication that somehow what we are doing is wrong. What the government is doing is wrong. When a motion has been presented in the House, when concurrence has been moved, and then the government does not act at all on it is what is in violation of democracy.

I concur very, very heartily with what my NDP colleague has said and I certainly concur with the point of order.

Juliana Thiessen November 5th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to welcome a very special visitor to Ottawa and to our gallery. Juliana Thiessen was born in Regina, Saskatchewan. To be born in the Queen City was an appropriate start for her. This April Juliana was crowned Miss Canadian Universe and went on to represent our country at the Miss Universe pageant in Hawaii.

Juliana's beauty is much deeper than her appearance. She is using her newfound publicity to promote worthy charitable causes. Here is just one. Juliana is travelling to storm ravaged Nicaragua next month as part of a charitable relief mission with Samaritan's Purse, an organization our own son Brent worked with for several years. Along with many other Canadian volunteers, Juliana will distribute Christmas gift boxes to children who need all the help and hope they can get. It is no wonder Juliana was named as one of Calgary's young women of distinction.

I invite all MPs to join me in welcoming and thanking this remarkable young woman.

Criminal Code November 5th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, that is my point exactly. We are holding out a hope to many people who are desperate because of high taxation and the real difficulty of getting jobs. Statistics show that a large proportion of people who engage in gambling activities—not the ones on cruise ships who are clearly in a different financial class—are the average people across the country who buy lottery tickets and play video lottery terminals. We are telling those people that if they put in some money they will get more back. That is the expectation and and it is false. It is an outright lie.

We should be telling those people that there is an extremely high probability of losing every quarter they put into the machine and a very low probability of getting even their investment back. It is just not there. Yes, it is false advertising.