House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Division No. 298 December 3rd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. There have been discussions with all the parties and I think you will find unanimous consent that the amendments which have been given in the name of the member for Calgary Southeast will be deemed to have been moved and seconded.

Petitions December 3rd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, the third petition is signed by some 25 people, mostly in my riding. There are one or two stragglers from Edmonton on this one.

It concerns the family. The role of parents is being diminished and the petitioners ask respectfully that parliament retain section 43 of the Criminal Code which permits parents to use reasonable force in training their children.

Petitions December 3rd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, the second petition is similar in principle. It has to do with marriage.

The petitioners pray that parliament enact legislation such as Bill C-225 so as to define in statute that a marriage can only be entered into between a single male and a single female.

Petitions December 3rd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to present on behalf of my constituents three petitions this morning.

The first has to do with the CRTC. Some 100 petitioners ask that parliament review the mandate of the CRTC which would not only permit but encourage the licensing of religious broadcasters.

Royal Canadian Mint Act November 30th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I have one more little comment that has to do with the actual competition.

What would happen if the mint were to produce all its own coinage out of the Winnipeg plant? We hear that it took only 20% of its supply from Westaim and 85% from elsewhere. That is because of the bidding process, NAFTA and other suppliers. There have been a few occasions where I understand the timeline given was insufficient for Westaim to deliver on a timeline that was not usual. It had a real fast order and Westaim said it needed a little longer to fulfil it so it went elsewhere. That is fair but that has happened very seldom.

The problem is that by building this plant in Winnipeg, Westaim thinks it can supply all its needs with this plant that has only one-third the capacity of the present Westaim plant in Fort Saskatchewan. The arithmetic just does not add up. The fact is it is competing.

The other thing that really bothers me is that the minister said we would not be competing. The documents from the mint itself said it expects to make $3 million in revenue not from Canadian sales but from sales to foreign countries buying these blanks.

The concept of not competing is very inconsistently communicated. I think it is going to happen and it is wrong.

The other thing we need to recognize is that many foreign countries actually like to deal with governments and it gives them a tremendously unfair advantage.

Royal Canadian Mint Act November 30th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, this is a real challenge because it is a balancing decision.

A couple of general principles could be applied. One I would use is that if there has been or is already a private firm or competition among private businesses, the government should stay out of it. If it is already being done and done well, the government should simply stay out of it as a matter of principle. That is a principle of government. It is in place but the Liberal government is ignoring it.

It is supposed to be a principle of governing that it does not compete with private enterprise. On the other hand we have those situations where the government can do best. I think of an example which relates back to my youth a long time ago. I remember when I grew up in Saskatchewan that my dad was the chairman of the Bode telephone company.

Members have probably heard of Alberta Government Telephones and B.C. Government Telephones. Now they are evolving into the different names and we have Telus. Before Saskatchewan Government Telephones ever came along there were literally thousands of individual telephone companies spread around all the provinces. My dad was the chairman of the local one and there were five subscribers. It was a big company. We had five people on the line and two longs and a short was us.

My grandfather was with a different company, the Peel telephone company. If we wanted to phone my grandfather we had to dial one long, which was the operator. She would hear this as sat in her little office in Swift Current. Everyone has seen Lily Tomlin do this. Well there she was in Swift Current pulling the cord out and connecting our line to Peel. Then she would dial grandpa's number. He would answer, or grandmother would answer, and we would be able to talk to them.

That was very inefficient and going nowhere. What happened in each province at least out west is that all these little individual companies got together and formed an organization that would allow the whole province to do it together. It was done under the auspices of the government. It was a fine co-operative effort on behalf of the people. At that stage it was a totally legitimate way of doing things.

That is probably no longer the case. With communications being what they are, it is probably better to let free enterprise and competition rule.

Royal Canadian Mint Act November 30th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, there is a balance to be reached here. I am not one to say the government should not do anything. I spoke against it building this coin plating plant because there is a very fine plant in business. It has a very long history of producing excellent coin blanks not only for Canadian use but across the country. I do not see any need for the government to get into that business.

There are things that government should be doing. As a people there are things we can do collectively through our government more efficiently than having everything privatized. For example, the post office as a crown corporation is an entity that can do a good job for the Canadian people. In some instances the individual outlets of the post office have been privatized. They are put out to tender.

I have heard both sides of the story. Some people say that it is great they can go to Shoppers Drug Mart at 10 p.m. and can get postal services, something they could never get before. Yet there are other people who say they cannot get the service they used to have because the people sometimes are not trained, their regular post office people have gone away and somebody else from cosmetics is filling in and they do not know the answers. There are some problems.

As parliamentarians and as a government we have an obligation to account to the people of Canada how we are administering their tax dollars and how the corporations that are run on their behalf are operated. It is not totally one side or the other.

I would not want to see everything in the country privatized, but I certainly have objection to the government using income from taxpayers and from corporations to run in direct competition with the people who have paid the taxes in the first place.

I remember many years ago there was a move in Saskatchewan where I grew up. There was a guy who had a good business—he supported his family with it—running a bus from Battleford up to Meadow Lake. He made a run a day and he always had enough passengers and freight that he could fill up his bus. He made the run and everybody was happy. He made a living on it.

Lo and behold the Government of Saskatchewan, the NDP government that likes to run everything on behalf of the people, bought the business. It gave fine service as far as I know. The service was not diminished but it lost money ever after that. Every year it posted a loss on that run and put this guy out of his job. That was a wrong decision.

Royal Canadian Mint Act November 30th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I am again honoured to stand in my place here in the House of Commons to represent my understanding of what is good for Canadians and to represent also the needs and aspirations of a number of people in my riding. That certainly does apply in the case of Bill C-41.

I cannot help but begin my speech by saying that the member from the NDP who spoke sure did drift a long way from the intent of what the bill is about. I was very disappointed that he allowed himself to be reduced to getting into a whole bunch of innuendoes that does not fit this place. It is disrespectful of what the House of Commons represents as well as what we as individual members are to do here.

I want to talk about the various implications of the bill. I am sure most members are well aware that as with almost any bill there are some good parts and some bad parts. I would like to use the first few minutes of my time to talk a bit about the process in terms of how bills are brought in and how these decisions are made.

It is very important for the government, whichever party it is that is governing at the time, to listen very carefully to people who have problems with a bill or motion. Usually it is government bills. The government should pay close attention when we have some legitimate concerns.

I would like to congratulate the hon. member for Tobique—Mactaquac. He is indeed an honourable member of the committee. It has been good to work with him, although I will admit that I was there as a substitute and I am not a regular member of that committee. The member, by compromising, did win one point.

I want to throw out the question: Is that really what we ought to be doing? Should we really be selling out on five items in order to gain one? That is what we are reduced to. It does not matter whether the members are on the opposition side or whether they are backbenchers on the Liberal side. The instructions that come to the committee are from the minister, the deputy minister or whoever it is in the department. We detected that in this bill as we have seen it so often before.

Yes, this amendment was put forward and yes the hon. member talked to other members about it and he was able to persuade them. But the member himself said that he would like to thank the minister for being open to his amendment. One person. I know, we balance this. The minister is ultimately responsible for the operation of the department. That is true. There is a lot of obligation on his part. But in this particular instance we also need to recognize that there are some concerns beyond just this one that got horse traded into existence. I wish there would have been a greater openness.

I hesitate to do this so soon before the joyous season of Christmas, but I have to admit that I sometimes despair of the process used in this place. I really wish we had a much more open and more democratic way of doing these things.

Speaking about this bill, the first issue I am going to talk about is the one that causes me a great amount of concern. The mint is a crown corporation, but this bill gives to the mint new rights and powers which exceed what it had in the previous act. It might be illustrative to read the amendment which we know is going to be passed. Once the government decides that it is going to do something, that an amendment is no good and another one is okay, we know the Liberals will pass it based on previous experience and knowing how they operate.

The bill says that in carrying out its objects “the mint has the rights, powers and privileges and the capacity of a natural person and may in particular” and then there are several things listed. One of the things the mint may do in particular is it may procure the incorporation, dissolution or amalgamation of subsidiaries and acquire or dispose of any shares in them.

The mint as a mother corporation may have a whole bunch of subsidiary corporations. To me, that is fraught with danger. When there are subsidiaries and subsidiaries and so on, it removes accountability further from the minister and hence from this place and hence from the people.

The bill will permit the mint to acquire and dispose of any interest in any entity by any means. When somebody says “I am going to give you the right to do anything that you want by any means you choose” I have a bit of a problem with that.

Of course, the preamble says it must use this power in order to promote the well-being of the mint in order to carry out the objects of its incorporation. The mint may buy a corporation or it may set one up by any means it wants. Perhaps it would pay $29 a share for a little subsidiary corporation that it wants to own. Then it can dispose of it by any means that it wishes. All one has to do is use one's imagination on how this could happen.

The very subtle thing here is it would permit the mint, using the backing of the government as its financial base, to procure anyone who dares to compete with it and then to dispose of them by basically shutting down the business. That is scary. We need to be careful about that.

The next thing listed that the mint might do also has all of these all-inclusive terms. The mint can generally do all things that are incidental or conducive to the exercise of its powers and the bill talks about the coins of the currency of Canada, the coins of the currency of countries other than Canada, gold, silver and other metals, and also metal plaques, tokens and other objects made or partially made of metal. Generally the mint can do all things that are incidental.

If I were to allow my imagination to run freely, and I do not do this often, I usually have a disciplined mind, but if I were to just let it run a little freely, one of the things the mint has to do is to move its product from place to place. I can see that it might want to have a subsidiary trucking company or perhaps it might want to buy a railroad or two. I am exaggerating of course, but this bill would allow the mint to do that if it so chose. It is something we really need to guard against in giving a crown corporation this kind of power. There has to be a continued line of accountability and approval related directly to what is good for the people.

There is a section that has to do with non-circulation coins. We know there are a number of coins produced every year, coins for medals and coins for commemoration. I imagine we will be inundated with coins at the millennium. I have read a few articles on that topic. In 1867 the country was born and in 1967 we had coin for each province to commemorate. It was a series of quarters. I imagine this can happen again.

Medals and non-circulation coins and collectors coins may be determined both in characteristics and denomination by governor in council, which means the minister can authorize it. It can be announced and that will be the end of it.

When it comes to circulation coins, happily the amendment from my colleague from the Conservative Party did gain approval and certainly with our support as well. There is a danger when circulation coins are brought in or removed that the people could be ignored in the decision. One thing does concern us, the amount of public debate and accountability when characteristics of coins are changed. As the coin business goes this also is very important to Canadians. There are literally thousands of people use coin operated equipment. When a coin is changed in design or structure, that has implications to machines that accept coins as payment.

There is a cost saving measure now to steel plate coins with nickel on top of them so they would be nickel plated steel. When that happens the density of the coin changes. Any mechanism in the machines to detect whether this is a genuine quarter or just a slug will be affected. I have talked to the administrative people in the mint. They are fine people. They are friendly. I found them very easy to talk to and I am sure they would make sure that when they changed the composition of coins or the shape of coins they would pay attention to this. But there is nothing here that requires them to so. It just says they can do whatever they want to in order to pursue their own objectives, presumably to make money for the mint.

Our penny has changed in the last couple of years. It went from a 12 sided coin to a fully round coin. Of course we do not use pennies except in Swift Current, Saskatchewan. I do not know if they still do.

In places around here you can pay one dollar for 10 minutes in parking meters. Swift Current had 12 minutes of parking for a penny. I could not resist the temptation, though I was just going into the post office and back out, I plugged in five pennies because it felt so good to get an hour of parking for five pennies. That was several years to.

Municipalities that have parking meters need those meters adjusted if the coin composition changes, if the shape changes or if the weight changes in order that the parking meter will accept the appropriate coin.

I think it is a ripoff at Ottawa's airport right now where it wants us to put our credit card in and then dings us for a dollar every 10 minutes. To me that is a huge ripoff because we only go there to pick someone up. To rip people off that high is not acceptable.

That is a diversion almost as far away as my NDP member so I had better get back on to the list of things I am concerned about.

Included in this act are a definition and a few little changes on what constitutes legal tender. Everyone once in a while we hear someone who is fed up with a big bill they got so they pack up five big pails of pennies and pay the bill with pennies. The person to whom they are paying it really does not have to receive it because legal tender is limited, as it always has been. Usually they accept it and the guy gets his day in the sun and his picture in the paper.

However, the limits are also given. For example, Mr. Speaker, if you owed me $40 you could pay that with $2 coins but you could not pay it with $1 coins. Those limitations are given here. Using $2 coins is limited to $40 and using $1 coins it is limited to $25. Using 10 cent pieces, quarters and 50 cent pieces is limited to $10. Using nickels is limited to $5 and using pennies is limited to 25 cents. The person can actually demand currency other than pennies for any debt owed which is greater than 25 cents. I expect that sometime soon we will have a move to remove the penny since I think its usefulness in this inflated era is reduced in value and I am not sure we should maintain it. Perhaps it should become a giant collector's item. I would certainly favour that.

I want to say something now about the mint and its production of its own blanks. This does impinge on the Westaim Corporation which operates in my riding. I have spoken on this topic before and it is a continued distress for me. I have talked to both sides. I have talked to people from Westaim and I think they are very fine people just like the people in the mint.

There are certainly two sides to this debate but there is one side I think really needs to be emphasized. Even though one can argue it is not borrowing from the consolidated fund nor is it taking money directly from the taxpayer, it is a government guaranteed loan. This legislation states that it may borrow now instead of a maximum of $50 million up to $75 million and may get it from either the consolidated revenue fund or from any other source.

Of course for the building of the plant in Winnipeg it did use other sources. It borrowed $31 million through the sale of regular financial instruments and received a very good rate. Why not? If I as an investor wanted to put some money somewhere I know the mint is a really safe place to put it. I am willing to accept a lower rate of interest. The mint gains by that and by being backed up by the government and the investor is a beneficiary because that investor knows the mint is not going to go broke unless the whole country goes broke. I suppose that is always a possibility but it is much more remote than for other corporations.

The coin plating plant is competing with private enterprise, competing with the job that 100 people in my riding have been doing successfully for 30 years, with the backing of the Canadian dollar, including the taxpayer dollars that have been collected from Westaim and its employees.

They are forced as taxpayers to back up their very competition that is driving business elsewhere. I find this very distressing. It is a faulty principle. The government is getting out of business. It has privatized with NavCan. It has privatized a whole bunch airports. We even have portions of the military forces being run by private groups on contracts. In this instance it is going in the opposite direction. It is wrong headed. It is wrong for the government to be in competition.

Royal Canadian Mint Act November 30th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I really do not have a question but I do have a comment.

This is the House of Commons. It is a place with elected officials. One of the things that really bothers me about this presentation is the implication and innuendo that the member used. It reduces the respect that this place can generate.

For example, I had a number of people from the NDP support me in both the elections in which I ran, including the candidate for the NDP. I do not think he would want me to say that because of the presence of an NDP member on my executive I should automatically be considered a really bad guy. That is my comment. I think the hon. member is out to lunch.

Income Tax Conventions Implementation Act, 1998 November 27th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, it is a great opportunity for me to continue my debate. I will not say I was rudely interrupted by question period because I think question period is a very important part of the role of parliament. For us to stop and hold the government accountable for the things it is doing incorrectly or failing to do is a very important. I wish when such a great speech like mine is interrupted by question period that we would also have an answer period as well. But that is for another time.

I was talking about the fact that we have double taxation in Canada. We have this wonderful bill, Bill S-16, before us. It is a great bill. It is long overdue. It is time we start recognizing there is a global economy. We need to not only trade with other countries but compete with them. For us to have an agreement on taxation will help the businesses from Canada that are dealing with these foreign countries and the foreign countries will benefit.

Undoubtedly there is an advantage to when Canadians take their expertise and investments to other countries. But there is also an advantage to us in the sense that we can help, on the international scheme of things, to make these different countries financially strong. This does a couple of things. It helps the people in that country. It gives them goods, services and expertise that they would otherwise not have. It helps Canadian people and Canadian businesses. It gives them an outlet for their creativity and for their investment dollars. It is a good return but we must make sure the tax regime is good.

As I said earlier, I believe in the principle of fair international taxation. Why can we not have that same principle enacted in Canada? We have the statistics. Over the last five years since this Liberal government has been in power the real take home value of the average Canadian family has gone down by $3,000 a year. Meanwhile taxes have gone up.

The Minister of Finance will say we have decreased taxes. He can point to one or two little examples where they have reduced the rates marginally. I commend him for it. Why should I withhold a compliment for the Minister of Finance? He is worthy of so few that when I do find an opportunity I should give it to him. So yes, it has been great that he has taken a few little taxes down a bit. But the big picture shows the opposite. Collectively we are paying more taxes than ever.

I am thinking of thousands of families I am speaking for right now, not only farm families in Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Alberta, but families in farms, working families, union people, all kinds of people right across the country who every month have difficulty paying their bills.

Yet we extract taxes from them at every turn.

We take the GST, the HST. We take the excise tax and the income tax. We take the UIC tax. It is a tax because by very definition money that is extracted from one citizen which goes to someone else is a tax. It is a function that governments in Canada have assumed. Governments believe it is a proper role for them to take money from the person who earned it and give it to someone who did not earn it.

Do not get me wrong, there are many instances where that is good. It is perfectly fine for us as a society to reach out in compassion and care for those who cannot look after themselves. That is why I became a Reformer. I am interested in making sure Canada's finances are run in such a way that we can do the things we truly value.

Let us make sure we look after those who are ill and cannot work. Let us make sure we look after those who are in dire straits. Let us make sure we have health care for people who need it.

The principle is sound and it is supported by the majority of Canadians. No Canadian should be denied needed health care because of lack of financial resources. I am deeply committed to that, notwithstanding the misrepresentations of that belief given often by people on the other side. I am deeply committed to that.

But what do we have in this country? We have three levels of government, in some instances four, and they tax and they tax and they tax on tax. I gave two illustrations before I was interrupted. One was the illustration of the tax on the tax on the tax on gasoline. The second was property tax.

This has nothing to do with the federal government but I sometimes think it would be a good thing for municipalities to say that when they have taken taxes from a property that over the years accumulate and reach the original value of the property, then we have taxed 100% and surely that is good enough. I have sometimes thought that might be a limitation.

I would like to see municipalities, provinces and certainly the federal government have some sort of curbs on their relentless grabbing of our dollars because Canadians have to work for those dollars.

Many of us get up early. I worked at NATE, the Northern Alberta Institute of Technology. In order to do my work and stay ahead of my students and the rapidly changing technical field, I often got up at 4 o'clock in the morning so I could get to work. I would work on the equipment before the students arrived so I really knew what I was doing so I could act authoritatively.

I got up at 4 o'clock in the morning and sometimes, in order to supplement our income, I would teach night classes. I used to say I work on Tuesday nights for me and on Thursdays for Mr. Trudeau because our marginal tax rates are about 50%. We are taxed to death.

I taught those evening classes because I enjoyed teaching adult students who came for night courses. I had some wonderful experiences and great relationships with some of those people. But we also needed the money in our family because it was more and more difficult to make ends meet.

It is worse now than it has ever been. We have families whose disposable income is down by $3,000 a year since 1993. The government keeps taking it.

The example I was using was property tax. I remember several years back when I did a calculation. I earned $4,000. Right off the top the Government of Canada and the Government of Alberta extracted from my earnings let us say 40% as a nominal number. The marginal rate is 50% but of course there are some basic deductions.

Of my original $4,000, 40% of that is $1,600. I am now left with $2,400 which I deposit in the bank. Then I take out my cheque book, go to the county office and pay my property tax. In that year my property tax was $2,400. So I wrote a cheque for $2,400. Now the municipality can say it only taxed $2,400. But the fact is that I had earned $4,000 to pay the $2,400 bills because we have taxes on taxes. Bill S-16 is right in principle because it says an investor should not have to pay income tax in Vietnam, or in Croatia or in Chile and then when he brings that money on his investment home pay income tax here again. There is an agreement here that we should avoid double taxation. The same thing is true for pension funds and other earnings. This is a very good agreement.

However, I wish we could apply that principle of avoiding double taxation. Though I have not discussed this with anyone else in the party I have talked to other people about it. They think perhaps we should have some deductions for Canadian families that are struggling. Perhaps we could have a deduction for interest on their mortgages as in the United States. Perhaps they could have a deduction for their property taxes so that they do not have to pay their taxes with after tax dollars and avoid that double taxation. This is an urgent need.

We have before us a bill which goes in the right direction on an international agreement. It is correct in principle and I support the bill. I presume most of my colleagues will vote in favour of it when vote time comes. Meanwhile the principle we are dealing with here is very important. We need to start applying it to Canadians who earn money in Canada. Let us stop taxing them to death.

I sometimes think Canadian taxpayers, and I am one of them, feel like 500 pound governments are using us as a trampoline. Of course I would be rather bouncy and it would work not too bad but there are a lot of other people who would not be able to take the crush. We have right now thousands of families really struggling to pay their bills yet the taxman is relentless in his demands.

This is a little off topic, but I am being given parliamentary immunity from relevance right now since everyone is very tolerant. I appreciate that. I need to say something about government policy in the long run.

Here we have a government making a policy. But it just happens to be true that the area in which I live and which I represent is suffering immensely these days from long term, wrong headed policies of the federal government. I am speaking about the government's policies on agriculture. With its monopoly in the wheat board we have guaranteed to farmers almost consistently the lowest price is the law instead of the highest price. International buyers wait until the Canadian Wheat Board announces its floor price and then that is the price they offer and it becomes the price. It is absolutely crazy the way it does this.

Instead of holding out for a good price the Canadian Wheat Board claims its only obligation is to sell the farmers' wheat. It is not accepting its responsibility to sell the wheat at a reasonable price and perhaps to withhold it when it is being sold at a loss.

Instead the farmers are forced by legislation to give their wheat to the wheat board whether they want to or not. They cannot find another market for it. It is against the law, unless they happen to live in Ontario or Quebec. Then they do not have to. They are free of the wheat board. But in western Canada where farmers are suffering so much that is one of the factors.

The other factor of course is taxation. I spoke to a number of farmers in the last couple of weeks over this issue. They are saying taxes on taxes on taxes. I had one farmer this week say to me “When I make a deposit into my NISA account in order to spread off my income in years of loss, why does the government take taxes off that? Why is that deduction not tax deductible?” It should be.

I hope the finance minister and the agriculture minister start waking up on policy needed in Canada right now. If we would provide these farmers with a tax regime and a system of selling their grain at a reasonable market price, at least something above cost, whether it is grain, animals or whatever, then we could survive internationally. We could compete with the best of them.

The government has to start applying the principles domestically that it is using in Bill S-16 and recognize that it is 20 years of bone headed Conservative and Liberal policies with respect to agriculture that have brought us to the place where now we are on our knees begging and pleading for disaster relief.

This is a manmade disaster. It could have been avoided. The crops in western Canada were generally not that bad this year. There were areas where they were not good. It is despicable in a year when a farmer has a good crop that he still cannot make it. He might as well get out of the business and that is what is happening.

When I was in farming a number of years ago we took some animals to the market one day and came back with more than we went with. The animals did not sell at the auction. When we went to take the truck back home, somebody had thrown a few calves into our truck.

We went there with six calves to sell and came back with eight because the farmer could not afford to keep them. He figured I would take them. Of course I could not bring myself to kill these young calves. We kept and fed them. I used my mate's income to subsidize the farm.

That was 15 years ago but those policies are still in place. While the Liberal government comes out with good things in Bill S-16 now and then, every time it has a good principle it applies it in only a narrow fashion. I ask the Liberals simply to consider applying those same principles to Canadian businesses, to Canadian families, to Canadian farmers. Let us get the country up and strong like it should be.

There is not a country in the world that has the wealth we have. If everything is added together such as our natural resources, our agricultural capabilities, our manufacturing capabilities, our mines, minerals and resources, what a wonderful country to travel to.

Canada is a safe country. People here are not generally worried about crime because Canadians care for each other. We do not go around beating each other on the head.

We have an excellent industry of tourism. We have a vigorous population. No one can live at this longitude and not be vigorous. Winter comes every year. We are good, hardworking and dedicated.

I am typical of Canadians who get up at 4 a.m. and do a job. When I grew up on the farm, my dad used to say the Lord put the sun in the sky as a light for us to work and it is wrong for us to waste it.

In summer when the sun came up in Saskatchewan at 5 a.m., we were out in the fields. That is what the light was there for. We worked hard. It is a shame that government policies over the years have basically stolen from us what we have worked so hard to earn.

I think of the family farm where I grew up. What a shame government policies put the continued ownership of that family farm at risk because the government cannot get it right. The government had better start getting it right. We will have a good debate Monday on this.

When people get on a roll they see things clearly. I commend the government for what it is doing in Bill S-16. I hope it spends this weekend studying. I used to say to my students on Fridays “There are no classes tomorrow. Sunday is the day of rest. You can go home and study”. I hope the Liberals study this bill on the weekend.

The bill will probably come to conclusion and pass today. It has some good principles on taxation. I hope the members go home and study it tomorrow. I would like not just every Liberal in the House but every Liberal in the country to go home and contemplate.

Tomorrow morning when they wake up contemplate how they are killing the country with excessive taxation and with bone headed government policies. Let them fix it. Let them serve Canadians like they say they are serving them. Let us see them do something tangible for farmers as they are doing for investors with this bill.

I drifted far from Bill S-16 on occasion but have always kept it as my goal in the distance. I have always come back to it.