House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, one of the nice things about this place of debate is that semi-occasionally we settle down and start talking about things in a rational way and putting forward our views.

I want to say publicly—and I know it is a little risky for me to do this—that I have a lot of respect for the member who has just spoken. He does a fine job in articulating his views. I do not necessarily agree with those views, but he has a fine way of explaining them and communicating them. I would like to commend the member on that.

I have a question for him with respect to the grand scheme of things. I grew up in Saskatchewan. That is the home of what is now the NDP. I remember it when I was a youngster as the CCF, the Canadian Commonwealth Federation. I remember well listening to Tommy Douglas on the radio when I was a kid, as my dad did. Dad has never told me this, but I would not be a bit surprised if from time to time he voted NDP. I know there are a lot of people in my riding who used to vote NDP and finally saw the light and voted Reform.

This member seems to have a good perspective because of his years as a legislator, as an MP and as a good thinking person. Exactly what does he think about the nature of our debt?

If we look back 25 years we had no debt. Now one-third of our government expenditures goes toward paying interest on the debt. The member said that we should not be too radical in cutting the debt. Yet the fact of the matter is that we could increase our spending on programs and on things we value by 50% if we did not have the interest payments.

Would the member expand a bit on the whole concept of debt and interest payments and what that does to the country?

Taxation February 1st, 1999

Mr. Speaker, it was terrifying. The bandit forced me to go from room to room in my house and watch while he and his accomplices loaded half of everything I owned into his truck to haul away. I was powerless to stop him. When he was done and left I phoned the police. But they would not help.

Why did the police not come to help? The answer is simple. The bandit was the tax collector.

If an ordinary criminal were to come into my house and take half of everything I own, we would not let him get away with it. But when it is the tax collector, he is authorized to take half of my earnings every year and the only person who can get into trouble is me if I do not help him load.

It is high time that we gave Canadians some tax relief. It just is not right to take half of their earnings year after year after year.

Nunavut Waters And Nunavut Surface Rights Tribunal Act December 4th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I have to admit it may be a breakdown in our party but I am not aware of this and I would have to decline that unanimous consent until we know something. It can be done again later if it is on the fair and square.

Taxation December 4th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, this is supposed to be the highest court in the land. In any other court if the minister answered a question like that he would be in contempt of court. I want an answer to this question, not flippant responses. I want to know when the government will start reducing the total payroll tax load on employers and employees so we can get people working again.

Taxation December 4th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, for this government to say it has increased employment is like me saying I lost 25 pounds at Christmas and not telling anybody that I gained 30. This is ridiculous.

The fact is that after January 1 every employer and every employee will be sending more money to Ottawa. Money sent to Ottawa means money not at home to create jobs.

Why will the government not admit this and start dealing honestly with people?

Salaries For Stay At Home Mothers And Fathers December 3rd, 1998

Madam Speaker, I am delighted to be able to speak to this important motion. The parliamentary secretary has assured us not to worry, that the Liberals are in charge and everything will be fine. I guess we should relax easy knowing that the family is protected. Yet I find it rather ironic that while it is undoubtedly true that the Liberals are committed in principle to supporting families and to not undoing the facts of biology, they do indeed tax families much more heavily if those families make the determination that one of the parents is to stay home and look after the children.

I have some firsthand experience with this since my wife has worked as a nanny. The best and most important principle is that parents should be given a free choice as to who looks after their preschool children and their school age children before and after school. Different parents for different reasons make different choices. My wife has done such a great job raising our own three children so I can go on public television and tell all the members in the House that the family that had my wife as nanny probably could not have chosen better, except if their mother could have stayed at home, but she was working and that is her choice.

When our children were young my wife said she would be a full time mom and stay with the children. All our lives we lived on one income. We chose to live on only my income because we thought it was very important for the children to at least have mom home. It would have been wonderful if we both could have stayed. We would have been even more skinny than we are now. That would have been most unfortunate. All those years we paid a penalty for that choice. Had we made the same amount of income between us, with my wife earning some and me earning some, our tax bill would have been considerably less.

I remember teaching night classes. I taught at a technical institute. One of the pleasures of that job was to teach night courses. We had wonderful young people during the day and in the evening the institute filled up with working people who went there in order to upgrade their skills. I taught mathematics and computing. I had a lot of people who wanted to learn how computers worked. You can tell by my age that I was invented about the same time as computers were. They were new when I was a young man giving instruction at the technical institute. I worked Tuesdays and Thursdays. I remember saying back then that I work on Tuesdays for Trudeau and on Thursdays I get to work for my family. That was because even then the marginal tax rate was around 50%. If my wife had been able to earn that money she would have had a lower taxation rate because that is the way the tax structure was.

I always felt that the real solution, not the solution this member is proposing of paying a salary with taxpayer dollars, is simply to arrange our tax system in such a way that families that make that choice are not discriminated against by the tax system. That is something I strongly believe in. It is something I hope this government will very quickly implement. I do not expect it but I would like to see it in the next budget. We are probably only about two and a half months away from the next budget and I would like to see that happen in the next budget.

I wish the Minister of Finance would say, as the parliamentary secretary just said, we value families. I hope he follows that by saying beginning today we will no longer have discriminatory tax practices against those families that choose to have one parent at home. I would be so appreciative. If that happened it would be very persuasive because it is such an important thing, although maybe not enough to make me vote Liberal.

Of course I will not vote Liberal because the Reformers are the ones who thought of this and that is one of the reasons I joined the Reform Party. We are promoting the idea. That is one idea I really wish they would steal. I think it is so critically important.

I remember over the years sometimes it was tough, especially with my working overtime and being involved in a lot of voluntary organization for which I got no extra money. Sometimes I did not get to see my family as much as I wanted. I really wished that there would have been a less discriminatory tax practice even against the parent who was out trying to earn a living so that I would not have had to work as many hours in order to provide for my family.

I strongly urge the government to consider that. Certainly the member who has brought forward this private member's business today has the right principle, to free up parents to make those choices. We just disagree in the detail of how it should be done.

Canada Customs And Revenue Agency Act December 3rd, 1998

Madam Speaker, I just want to float something here. We have some 200-plus motions to do this way. There have been no discussions, but I wonder whether hon. members in order to expedite the matter would consider giving unanimous consent to deem all motions moved, seconded, recorded divisions requested and deferred.

Canada Customs And Revenue Agency Act December 3rd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I am glad we finally got to Group No. 2. I also regret that we have time allocation on this so that we cannot express our genuine concerns about these things.

While we have been sitting here I wrote my newspaper column. One of the things I put in my column is that there are two ways of getting legislation through the House. One is to engage in a fair and an even handed debate, negotiation, give and take, and to come up with a set of rules that is good for people.

I hope that when Canadians trust us to form the government I will not have changed my mind on this. I believe it is a legitimate role for the government to listen to what members in opposition are saying. I noticed one of the members over there gave a hearty laugh. I guess he is eagerly looking forward to being on this side of the House again.

When that happens I think it will be important for us, when we are on the government side, to recognize that everything may not be perfect every time. If I have any role to play in it, I will listen very carefully to what the Liberals on this side of the House have to say on our legislation. I hope we will have the humility to receive fairly legislation the Liberals bring to our attention that they feel is not as good as it could be.

I have not spoken on this group at all and so I would like to address myself primarily to the motions put forward by the Reform Party, although the others also have merit. I am not going to spend as much time on those.

I am going on the assumption that this independent agency will happen. We have seen this over and over. The government will arrange for this vote to pass. This government has already, with its majority, voted for closure. I think this is the tenth time in the last few months.

I will not mention names since I am not allowed and I will not mention ridings since I do not want to embarrass anyone here, but some in the Liberal Party when they were in opposition raised a hue and cry when time allocation was used by the Conservatives of the day. The Liberals said this is wrong, it is a defeat of democracy. The Liberals had all sorts of bad things to say about the use of closure. Now they are on the other side and on command they vote in favour of it.

I suppose I am setting myself up for another quotation maybe four or five years down the road, whenever the next election is, when we form the government.

I think it is important to listen to these debates and to when an amendment is put forward to improve it. That is what I am trying to do now. I know members will not have been given the freedom by their party to vote in favour of these very reasonable and rational taxpayer protecting amendments.

I wonder if we would find among them some statesmen, if we would find among them some politicians who will rise up and represent the people who sent them here, the electors, and they will vote in favour of those people instead of simply following the party line. The purpose of my speech is to persuade Liberal members to do that and to give them solid reasons for so doing.

One of the problems with this agency is the question of accountability. Right now we have some degree of prime ministerial accountability. We have some ministerial accountability. Last night on TV I saw a clip of the Prime Minister when he was leader of opposition. He wagged his finger and said “when we form government you can count on it that ministers will accept responsibility”. We have seen a number of instances in the last little more than five years where that has really not quite been the case. Of course, the Prime Minister continues to say they have no scandals, because what he does is pinch his eyes shut and pretend they are not there and then he can proclaim that there were no scandals. There have been a couple. The Prime Minister said he believes in ministerial responsibility.

What I want to do right now is simply challenge the Liberal members when the vote is held on these amendments to vote in favour of Motion No. 3. Motion No. 3 increases the responsibility and the accountability of this new agency to parliament instead of making it into a faceless irresponsible bureaucracy whose function is to separate the taxpayers from their money and which will not have political of any other kind of accountability to parliament.

We insist that should be done. We want to ensure that the employees, the directors and the commissioner of the new agency are held accountable not to the minister in the backrooms but to parliament directly. I do not think anyone on the Liberal side, if they were on this side and the Reformers were speaking on the other side, would be against this motion. They would vote in favour of it.

Let us not allow walking across two sword lengths of aisle change important principles we believe in. I would simply urge them to do the right thing for taxpayers. I suppose basically everyone n the country is affected by this legislation. That is another reason why it is so odious for the government to have invoked closure on this.

It is absolutely necessary that the government so arrange its affairs that people believe in our government and believe in our tax system. Our tax system is predicated on voluntary compliance. If that is missing, the system falls apart.

We have seen it in the last number of years where with the very undemocratic imposition of the GST many people have gone into the underground economy. They do not agree with it. They said it was not done correctly. They did not have representatives representing them in parliament.

If we just jam this legislation through, two days of debate and it is finished. It is a fait accompli. It is mandatory for us. We have no option but to make sure people support this legislation.

We should take the full length of debate on it so that we as members of parliament can hear what our constituents are saying and we can respond to them and make sure the taxation system is fair, which I believe most people believe in. I have yet to hear anyone in my riding say to me they do not want to pay any taxes at all. But I have heard many times that they want fair taxation and a fair taxation system.

If we vote in favour of Motion No. 3, put forward by my Reform colleague, it would help to provide accountability of this new agency to parliament. It would help people to have faith in and to really have a good feeling about paying their taxes, something they have never had before in their lives. I am sure the Liberals would want the taxpayers to feel good when they send their money to Ottawa.

Division No. 298 December 3rd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I think the hon. member requires a lesson in parliamentary procedure. He is not to challenge the Chair, a lesson I have learned well, and I think he should pay attention to that rule. It is very important that he do that.

Division No. 298 December 3rd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, we have some amendments that were put forward by the member for Calgary Southeast. It was my understanding that we were to deal with those one at a time as we go to the next group. I am just asking for unanimous consent that they be deemed to have been moved and seconded when we get to them.