House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Madam Speaker, I have one quick question for the parliamentary secretary. Obviously, because he is in the inner group I am sure he has much better information than we do. I wish he would enlighten not only me but other members of my party, other members of the House and perhaps the Canadian public.

When the finance department of the Government of Canada does its projections, surely it is aware of these different aberrations that occur every year. He mentioned a list of things, income tax refunds, the reduction in the EI premiums and so on. He did not say anything about the increase in the CPP premiums. He forgot that one but I will just add that on his behalf.

When the finance department with all the brilliant minds in the world and all the Y2K ready computers does its fiscal projections, surely it must take all that into account. Can he enlighten us on that, please?

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Madam Speaker, it is a pleasure to share the floor with my hon. colleague from St. Albert.

He has done a great job in highlighting government waste. Instead of asking him a question I will simply congratulate him for his very hard work and dedicated efforts toward the task. I am sure there are over 1 million people watching this on CPAC. We really appreciate CPAC and the work it does in helping communicate important things from the House of Commons to the people of the country. I would encourage everyone to go to the website of the hon. member for St. Albert. They can enter www.reform.ca and then click on “Go to Members”, find that member and go to the home page. The member has an excellent home page on his website highlighting all the different ways in which we as elected officials have the responsibility to keep accountability on behalf the taxpayers.

I often think of this when I have to spend money in my office budget as a member of parliament. I never want to lose sight of this thought in my head when I am authorizing an expenditure. That is, this represents a taxpayer's hard work and the taxes they have to pay for say, a whole week or whatever it is, however much money I am spending.

I wish we could develop that kind of thinking in all the people who work on behalf of the taxpayers, not only elected officials but all the civil servants.

Certainly our friend, our colleague from St. Albert, is making such a tremendous contribution in this regard. I simply want to commend him. I probably embarrassed him by saying this.

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Madam Speaker, since the Liberal members are not getting into the debate I find it is my prerogative to ask questions on their behalf.

This is a question I think one of the government members would probably ask the member. If he is so eager to increase the basic exemption for members of the armed forces, because presumably their salaries are so low that they cannot make ends meet, why not extend it to everybody as the Reform Party is proposing?

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Madam Speaker, I really appreciate this speech and the approach that this particular party is taking, the party to which the member belongs. It is very refreshing to have a party that says let us do something that is financially sustainable and that is financially advantageous to those families who choose to care for their own children. That is just delightful. I have talked to a number of people who feel that this is the direction in which we should travel.

I would like the member to respond to one of the criticisms which we sometimes get on this, which is that we are trying to use a tax measure in order to direct and social engineer things the way we want them instead of letting the Liberal government social engineer the way it wants. I would like him to respond to that. I do not think it is an easy question but it is one which we often hear.

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Madam Speaker, I will be very explicit. I come from a province which has never received a penny in equalization payments. We have always paid in at the same rate as the Quebec people and maybe even a little higher. Yet they are great recipients of equalization payments. They are net gainers of anything between $8 billion and $10 billion a year.

I just wondered if the member would respond to that. Is he willing to say goodbye to that?

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Madam Speaker, I listened with some interest to the member for Sherbrooke. We know that he is more recently elected than some of us, so he is moving into the scene of looking at what the Liberals are doing with the finances.

I have a question that is really quite different. He made mention of the transfer payments and claims there were transfer payments to which they were entitled that they did not get.

Does the member have any comprehension of how large those transfer payments were and what would happen if they got their way and left the country? I am sure he has heard this question many times, but I think it is one of the larger reasons why they should consider abandoning their plan of taking a big chain saw and floating themselves out into the Atlantic Ocean.

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, it is interesting that it is the Reformers who are debating with each other but I certainly like to talk about these things.

What a delight it is to see a party that actually has a plan. In a previous intervention we talked a bit about the necessity of having a plan. The federal Liberal government since 1993 has really not had a plan at all. It had rolling targets which basically said they would hit whatever they shot at. Point the gun anywhere and whatever we hit was what we were shooting at. This is no way to run a country.

One of the witnesses to our finance committee hearings made that as a very special point. It was mentioned to us that it would engender a great deal of economic optimism in our country if the federal government would set some realistic goals, state them and achieve them. That is much more encouraging to the economy than saying we will do the best we can and meanwhile build up a slush fund for an impossible election coming up.

I would like to have the member comment on one of the things he mentioned regarding accountability and spending money properly. One of the problems we have had is that the auditor general has not been willing to sign off on the books of the federal government because of some accounting practices that are not in keeping with those of the Chartered Accountants Institute of Canada and other authoritative accounting methods.

I would like to have the member's comments not only on what things are happening there but why that is wrong and why it is discouraging to Canadian people.

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I subscribe primarily to this philosophical premise, and I admit it is a premise that is debated by economists who are much wiser than I am. We ship trainloads of money to Ottawa so that the politicians and the bureaucrats can turn around and distribute it. The premise I believe in because it makes sense to me is that instead of funnelling almost 50% of our gross domestic product, in other words the collective earnings of all of us, into government we would be better off leaving it in the hands of the people, of the families, of the businesses.

That would have a much greater impact on our economy. That money spread throughout the economy would produce jobs, demand for goods and services, and give all individuals more money than they have now.

I remember many years ago looking at my tax bill. At that time my tax bill was only about $600 or $700 a month. I was thinking of what I could do with $700 a month. In the Reform plan we want to arrange government priorities and reduce wasteful spending so we can give that tax cut to businesses and individuals, so we can leave that money out there. That is the root of prosperity.

We will have greater prosperity if we stop robbing the people of the money they have earned. Let them spend it, let them build industries and businesses, let them hire people. This is even for people who are not in business, for ordinary families. If I offered a mom or a dad $300 a month in reduced taxes, that is like earning $600. Now you would have to earn an additional $600 to have $300 in your pocket. They say no when I ask them if they would decline that offer and they ask if I am paying off the debt. They are concerned about the debt and the interest payments we are making.

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I was going to ask another question but I guess the time has elapsed so I will move right into the most important speech I have ever given. I had better not say that because maybe it would reduce the value of previous speeches.

I have many things to talk about. I travelled with the committee. We heard different witnesses. I took the occasion when we were in different towns to walk up and down the streets and talk to people instead of shopping.

I remember I talked to one man on the street in Saskatoon about what he thought was important in the budget. He happened to be a retired person. He said the thing that was killing him was taxes. He had put money away in RRSPs and was basically living in poverty because when he took some money from his RRSPs his expenses were very low and he had no deductions. He ended up having to pay $2,000 a year in taxes and was hardly able to pay his bills. For him tax reduction was very important.

I heard mechanics who said their priority was to stop forcing them to use after tax dollars to buy their mechanic's tools. That seemed very reasonable to me. Every lawyer and every doctor in the country who sets up office, shop, lab or whatever uses the tools of their trade as an expense in setting up business. Yet the poor mechanic has to pay for his tools and equipment with after tax dollars. That was a priority.

I could go on and on, but I have chosen today to speak about debt. I talked a bit about it with the NDP member from British Columbia a little earlier. I heard two distinct messages in the committee from different people which underlined to me that we adopt the thinking of the people to whom we speak.

We heard from certain people, mostly labour groups and so on, who suggested that we should not be paying off the debt. I find this very curious. It is as a result of what I will very carefully call fuzzy thinking. I think it is the fuzzy thinking of the NDP that somehow if the debt is paid off all we are doing is giving money to rich people because they are the ones who own the debt. That is how some of those people think. I strongly disagree with that.

I am surprised the NDP would not be pushing for debt reduction to the maximum as has happened with some fiscally responsible governments like the one in Saskatchewan. Although I hate to endorse the NDP in Saskatchewan, it has certainly been more fiscally responsible than some of the previous governments in that province. Let us take the label away and look at what happens to debt management and with the money.

I am in such a good mood today that I find it difficult to contain myself. I just gave a reluctant compliment to the NDP and now I will give a reluctant compliment to the Liberal government. Because the government could have increased the debt much more than it did, I will compliment it on reducing its spending by $2 billion, increasing tax revenue by $40 billion and resisting the temptation to spend the difference.

I congratulate the government because I know the Liberal way is to think of how to spend. When the next election rolls around I am sure we will see that particular characteristic of the Liberal creature come to the fore again. It is always nice at election time to roll out the goodies and buy the votes with taxpayers dollars.

This afternoon I hauled out a file on my computer. In 1996 I looked at the deficit, the amount by which we were overspending and adding to the debt. When I first came here the debt was $420 billion. We had that infamous first year where the deficit was $45 billion. After the Liberals took office they found that the bookkeeping of the previous Conservative government had given them the world record in having the largest deficit ever of $45 billion. In one year the debt shot up to $465 billion, the last legacy of what we had from the Conservative government.

Then under the federal government the Liberals reduced the amount of the deficit and bragged a lot about it. It simply meant that they were borrowing at a lower rate, that they were not borrowing quite as much. In 1996 I projected what would happen if the Liberals kept adding 3% to the debt every year. If they would have followed that pattern, according to my numbers the debt would now be about $641 billion. We know that it is around $580 billion. The fact that the Liberals resisted spending all this additional revenue deserves a compliment.

I give them that commendation, but that is the very last one. They did that mostly on the backs of the provinces and on the backs of the taxpayers. As I have already indicated, tax revenue has gone up fantastically. They are looking at a projected increase in tax revenue of around $40 billion a year over what it was in 1993 when they first took office. There is a tremendous sucking sound when $40 billion is taken out of the Canadian economy.

The federal government has reduced its own departmental spending by very little. It has done this on the backs of the taxpayers by taking increased tax revenue and on the backs of transfers to provinces. We all know that has been a huge item of debate and is really called downloading. It really has not done a very good job.

What is the impact of debt? Had we not stopped the 3% increase in debt per year, by the year 2010, which is no longer very far into the future, the debt would have grown to over a trillion dollars. That is something we cannot sustain if we want to provide services for our people, the whole purpose of government. People pay taxes in order to get services from government.

We are presently spending a tremendous amount on interest. It is our largest single expenditure item. Interest is due only to debt. There are two things that affect interest payments. One is the principal amount of the debt. The other is the interest rate.

The Liberals won the lottery. They happened to be in power during the years when world-wide interest rates were relatively low. I sometimes smile and snicker to myself when the Prime Minister particularly and the finance minister like to brag about low interest rates. Very frankly it has very little to do with them. They just happened to be at the right place at the right time.

If the interest rates increase, the interest payments on our debt increase dramatically. The fact that we now have a $580 billion debt is something that I do not believe we should take lightly. We should look at paying it off.

We speak of a surplus. It is projected to be $11 billion. Lately they have been cranking it down to get it to around $7 billion. If we wanted to pay off that debt like a mortgage, in 30 years, the year I will turn 90, we would be out of debt if the following happened, if we posted a surplus of $50 billion per year for 30 years against the debt retirement fund. That happens to be around $3,500 per taxpayer per year.

When I ask taxpayers if they are content with the federal government borrowing so much money on their behalf that each month they have to pay $300 in interest, they are not very happy. Yet that is the fact. I would love for the government to reduce its indebtedness in order to reduce tax payments.

The Reform has a very distinct plan on how to achieve this. We propose that the surpluses be applied toward the debt. As that happens, we can pay the debt at an increasing rate because as we reduce the principal the interest payments go down. It also insulates us against the danger of escalating interest rates.

I am very sorry that my time has elapsed. It is hard to believe. I barely got my introduction finished. Hopefully there will be some discussion.

Finance February 2nd, 1999

Mr. Speaker, it was a delight to serve with this member on the finance committee. Dare I say it, we spent some numbers of hours together listening to witnesses, albeit on opposite sides of the table.

I was very interested in the member's comments. We heard the same things from the witnesses, that health care is indeed a very big concern among those people at least who came to our committee. Of course we are also hearing it in our ridings. I often get testimonials from people whose loved ones had to go to the hospital. They say “Hey, we do not know what the hullabaloo is all about because we had really good care”. It is good to hear those stories on the other side.

I have a very fundamental philosophical question that I would like to ask the member who just spoke since she is a medical doctor and very interested in health care. She mentioned a deterioration of health care into a two tier system. I wonder how she would answer this question.

There are right now a fair number of Canadians who, because of their accumulation of wealth, are able to go to that part of the world where the best health care is available. I had a person in my riding not very long ago who fiddled around with Canada's health care system and finally went to the Mayo Clinic where he received a proper diagnosis of what his problems were. He had to pay for it of course, and fortunately he had the financial wherewithal to do it.

What should we really be doing so that we prevent this move to a two tier system? Should we legislate at the border? A person may not cross if their purpose of going into the U.S. is to look for health care in order to equalize it for everyone here? I think she would reject that. I certainly would.

I think if a person has the money and chooses so to spend it, that should be their choice, provided of course that they have earned the money by legal means. But we need to do something in this country so that people would not even want to go elsewhere. Under the present system that does not seem to be happening. It is getting worse and worse.

The federal government used to fund 50% of health care and used to have a really good insertion of funds for medical research, which is very good for medical services. That has deteriorated.

One of the things we heard over and over was about the exodus of our brightest people into the United States because of the research facilities that are available.

I would like a comment on the two tier system because I am very interested in it.