House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Information Commissioner May 8th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, an access to information commissioner is supposed to be an advocate of openness, someone who will fight against Liberals who want to shred documents and hide facts. The last thing we need is a political Liberal patronage appointment. That is like putting Mr. Fox in charge of chicken coop security.

There should be an open competition for this job. Why is the Prime Minister ignoring Canadians who want facts and instead looking for the Liberal with the largest paper shredder?

Royal Canadian Mint May 8th, 1998

It is no wonder, Mr. Speaker, that the Minister of Public Works and Government Services does not want the issue of the coin plant in Winnipeg to come before the committee.

In yesterday's question period the minister gave a spectacular show of contradictions. First he said the issue was before the courts so he could not comment. Then, when asked why they are going ahead with it if it is before the courts, he said that the court case has nothing to do with it. He says they are not competing with a private company and yet he claims that competing worldwide will give the new venture its viability.

Why did the minister give instructions to the committee to refuse our requests to examine this issue? It is clearly because he is afraid of all the contradictory answers. This is costing $38 million to build, plus $18 million in lost savings. That is a total of $56 million and not an ounce of justification for it.

Motions For Papers May 6th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I am sure you will correct me if I am wrong, but is it enough for the parliamentary secretary to only suggest it? Does he not actually have to do it?

Motions For Papers May 6th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I request that we call Motion No. P-16.

That an Order of the House do issue for copies of all documents relating to the Royal Canadian Mint building a coin plating plant in Manitoba.

Supply May 5th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I listened with close attention to the hon. member's speech. There is one thing though that I would like to ask him about.

There is in fact, as far as I can tell, no evidence of how many real victims there are in this hepatitis C case. We have numbers all the way from 6,000 to 60,000. The government will choose to use the higher number to try to build an argument against it because of high cost.

The numbers may in fact be a lot lower. I was wondering whether the hon. member would care to comment on this point. Perhaps, instead of talking about absolute numbers in terms of how much budgetary money should be available, we should simply set a principle that all should be treated equally and then find out how many there actually are.

Supply May 5th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I appreciate your warning and your advice. I will follow that advice, but I want the record to show that I find it very offensive for this member to put out the words that he is putting out which are so far from the truth they cannot be accepted.

Dna Identification Act May 4th, 1998

Madam Speaker, I am intrigued with the subject of identification of people. Fortunately I do not have an identical twin; the world could not take two of us. There is little doubt that I am a unique individual. The DNA that would identify me is like an individual serial number that is cranked out at the time of manufacture. This identifies me as a unique person.

When my wife and I were first married we moved to a little town in Alberta. Some of my acquaintances, having come from a large city, said “How can you stand living in that town? Everyone knows what you are doing”. I said “But I am not ashamed of anything I am doing so let them know who I am”. The reason I say that is that I think it underlies the principle we are debating in this DNA bill.

Those people who have not done anything wrong want the identification process to work correctly so they are not incorrectly accused of and convicted of a crime. On the other hand, those who have done something wrong are the ones who in our little town would hide behind the shades at night and leave town so no one would know what they were doing because they were not doing things they were proud of or they could defend in the community.

Consequently when we come to identification there really is a dual question. It is that ancient question of a justice system. There are two objectives in the justice system with respect to identification of criminals. As my colleague has just stated, the overriding principle of our system ought to be the protection of law abiding citizens. Consequently what we want to do is to correctly identify those in society who are not playing by the rules. They are the ones engaging in criminal activity which endangers the life, property and safety of ourselves and our families.

What we want to do in this dual objective of identification is to correctly identify the person who has actually done the crime. The second part of that which is really the mirror image of it, is to make sure that we do not falsely identify a person. In other words, we want to identify the person who is guilty and name the person as guilty rather than innocent. On the other hand, we want to be able to demonstrate that the person who is innocent is falsely accused.

I taught mathematics and statistics for a number of years and we had in sampling for example the type A and type B errors. One error was where if one had a sample in a manufacturing process and wanted to know whether or not a batch should be approved, one error was that you let the thing slide through when in fact it should be rejected. The other error was that you rejected it when in fact it was a sample that was within the specifications.

DNA is new technology which enables us to do this. It enables us to identify individuals in a unique way. With respect to criminal activity, it is unique because individuals who commit certain crimes leave behind telltale traces of identification. It is as if I had my social insurance number on little pieces of paper and whenever I walked, every three feet one of those little pieces of paper would drop and they could be traced to see exactly where I went. Criminals leave particles of skin, hair and other parts of their bodies in various ways. Sometimes they are injured and they leave some blood. There are many different ways in which to get a unique sample that carries the serial number of the individual.

What we are talking about here is using that technology in the most efficient way so that our law enforcement people can identify correctly the people who are actually guilty and exonerate those who are not guilty.

With respect to the motions that are before us today, I would like to speak just in generalities. We need to make sure that the police have the mechanisms to ensure that the DNA samples which are collected and kept are done so in such a way that the identification process can be implemented in the most efficient way.

Consequently there is a great need to make sure that the police are able to collect samples and maintain them in a secure fashion. Certainly we also have to guard against the incorrect use of DNA as an identifier because obviously those who become aware that this is the identification that is used will soon invent ways of transplanting DNA evidence in order to implicate people who are innocent. All of those processes have to be very carefully safeguarded.

It seems that what we are talking about here is protecting the innocent and making sure that the guilty ones are the ones who are hauled on the carpet.

As I was saying in my analogy with respect to being ashamed of what one is doing, I really think that we err when we make rules favouring even the accused. I have often said that if I am accused of a crime I want the truth out if I am innocent, I really do. If there is a databank somewhere which contains the DNA identification codes of a whole bunch of different individuals and I am innocent of that for which I have been accused, I would appreciate there being a databank available so that the true culprit could be found, arrested and found to be guilty.

Frankly, I think that only those who are afraid of being caught would like to see the samples destroyed in a timely fashion. They would want to make sure that the track of identification is wiped out as quickly as possible in order to reduce the probability that they would be identified, accused and convicted of the crime.

When it comes right down to it, on behalf of law-abiding citizens of the country we want to strengthen this bill. We want to make it so strong that it actually works and works efficiently and favourably to its purpose. Those who say that we cannot do this and that they do not want to do it, to a degree I do not really care what they say. They may have their objections but what takes precedence here?

We talk so much about the rights of privacy, the rights of this and the rights of that. I sincerely ask at what stage do we say that the rights of law-abiding citizens and the rights and the protection of those citizens takes precedence over somebody having a DNA sample that maybe they should not have? That becomes secondary.

Of course I would be very concerned if somebody had my fingerprint, my DNA signature and was able to use it incorrectly against me. I want safeguards on that, there is no doubt about it. At the same time, let us not hamper our police forces and our law enforcement agencies in their ability to do their work.

Coinage May 4th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, it seems to me that good decisions come from correct information. That is why we tried to get the issue of the Mint's new coin plating plant to the parliamentary committee.

The various players in this issue have contradictory views and interpretations on costs, savings, security of supply, jobs, international demand and various other subjects. Why not let the committee sort this out?

No, the government does not want the facts to come out. Is this because it is afraid of being embarrassed? Is it afraid of being shown that it is wrong? It seems to me that if the government is so sure of itself it would be eager to appear before the committee and lay its cards on the table. Then it would be vindicated and could get on with its project.

The government's refusal to allow the committee to study this issue is suspect indeed.

Criminal Code May 1st, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I certainly want to add my congratulations and thanks to the hon. member for Mississauga East for her tenacity and courage in continuing this fight and bringing this important debate to the House.

I am also very pleased to see that after the third time this private member's bill has come this far and is going to be votable. We will find out when the vote is held who actually speaks for Canadians and who speaks for victims.

I am actually really restraining myself in my reaction to the speech we just heard. I cannot use the words because they are unparliamentary. It is really deplorable that the frontbench of this government has so little regard for victims in this country.

While I was sitting here listening I thought of the word empathy which means feeling with someone who is hurting. It is different from sympathy. Empathy is feeling with.

Recently I went to Saskatchewan to visit my parents. We drove down a road that we drive every time we come from our home in Alberta down into Swift Current, Saskatchewan where my parents live. When we make a certain corner I always think of a person who died at that corner. That person was Eugene Martens.

He was a rancher who gave part of his farmland in order to put up a camp for children and young people. I attended that camp as a youth and later on as a counsellor. It was one of those situations where a man had a significant influence in my life because of his generosity. He was killed on the corner of highway 4 north of Swift Current because, I believe, of icy roads. It was not because of drunken driving. It was an accident.

Even though this man was not a member of my family, every time I go by that place I think of that person and I say a little prayer of gratitude for his life and for what he did. That helps me to empathize with a person whose family member, a loved one, has had their life taken from them by someone else's negligence or by someone else's misguided and wilful act.

When I think of their pain and how they must hurt it absolutely drives me to distraction to think that there is a government in Ottawa that cannot empathize with those victims. I cannot understand how that can be. All one has to do is try to put oneself into the same situation.

We are dealing with the question of changing the rules for sentencing. How should a criminal who was charged and convicted of committing a serious crime be sentenced?

The present system is that individuals who are charged with more than one crime at a time often get concurrent sentences. That is incredible. One can take a life, or two, three, four or more and at a certain time their sentence starts and they are able to serve all sentences at the same time whether they have killed one person, two, three or eleven, a significant number in this country. It is unconscionable that we allow that to happen.

Our media paid quite a bit of attention to the application of Clifford Olson for eligibility for early parole last summer. I was interviewed by a local person and I said really he should have had 275 years. When we think of each of those victims, if life sentence means 25 years in prison, ll times 25 is 275. Then I said if he behaves, we will let him off after 250. That is not to make light of it in any way. Here are families of victims with an inescapable sense that some of the lives taken do not matter. There is no penalty for them at all.

I am indeed one of those who believe that a life sentence should mean life. It should at least mean 25 years.

The Senate May 1st, 1998

Mr. Speaker, Alberta Premier Ralph Klein is bravely proceeding with Senate elections. He knows it is time to give senators the respect of explicit approval of the voters.

We get only doublespeak from Liberals on this subject. In 1993 the Prime Minister promised “We will have an elected Senate. As Prime Minister I can make this happen.” Now in power, he does just the opposite. The justice minister says that the constitution requires the Prime Minister to make the appointments but she fails to mention there is nothing preventing him from appointing a person who has been chosen by the people.

What about Liberal Senator Nick Taylor? He was a key opposition player in carving out the Alberta Senatorial Selection Act 10 years ago, but now he says that mental patients on leave from psychiatric wards will be seeking the position. What an insult to candidates. What an insult to Albertans. What an insult to people with mental disabilities. He should be ashamed of himself. He should run for election and test whether this kind of outrageous statement has the support of Albertans.