House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Aboriginal Affairs April 2nd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I taught math for 31 years and I want to talk math with the Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development.

A total of $5.5 billion is targeted for about 400,000 on reserve natives. If we divide that we get almost $14,000 per person or about $55,000 per year per average family.

How can a family with a take-home income of $55,000 live in abject poverty? It is easy. They do not get the money. Government officials, native officials, band councils, chiefs, lawyers and endless advisers get the money. There is nothing left for ordinary band members.

What happens when one of them points this out? They get hassled and threatened. What happens if they write a letter to the minister? Their letter is sent to their hasslers. What happens if someone asks for a impartial independent inquiry? They are ignored and called names.

I urge the minister to do her math, recognize that there is a big problem and get to the root of the matter with an independent inquiry.

Income Tax Act March 31st, 1998

Mr. Speaker, it is a delight to stand in the House of Commons to speak on behalf of families across Canada and to add my words of encouragement to the government to show a little compassion for families, especially young families starting up and buying their first homes.

It is a pleasure to speak in favour of a tax break, something the Liberals just cannot get into their heads. If there is a little surplus, would the Liberals turn it back in terms of a tax break? No. Most of them think they better put it away for an election fund. They think they better keep that money ready in case there is an election. Then they can haul out the millennium fund. They would have all this money to reduce the debt and to reduce taxes and everything will be tickety-boo, great.

The Liberals will win the election because they will have all this money. It is unconscionable. It is terrible that they hang on to their money to use for political purposes. Meanwhile, they are shutting their eyes to the needs of Canadian families, young people and their children.

The bill before us is a private member's bill. I wish we could strengthen Private Members' Business. In my observations in the few years I have been here it seems the ideas which best represent the needs and the wishes of Canadians are presented in Private Members' Business. Those are the times when we get motions and bills like the one before us today which say to the House of Commons, to the government, that there is a need out there which has been identified by an elected representative. The individual MP has raised a matter that has been chosen and we can vote if it is a votable motion as this one is.

Most of the motions go by after debate for an hour and are set aside and nothing is ever done. What a total waste of the time of representatives elected by the people to run the country.

My colleague from Portage—Lisgar has brought forward a very important motion that would provide for a tax break on the money used to pay interest on a mortgage. I think that is absolutely necessary.

When I was a young man, and of course that takes us back decades, it was considered a big expenditure to buy a home. At that time when my wife and I bought our first home. The capital expenditure was $20,000; that was the price of our first home. I remember saying to my wife that a mortgage for 25 years was a long time. The amount of money we had borrowed was $14,000 and I calculated that we would pay over 25 years about $14,000 of interest and $14,000 against the principal.

I am speaking in round numbers, in case anyone is out there checking my mathematical credentials. I have rounded off liberally. If anyone wants the exact numbers, I will provide them. However this is a fact. To purchase a home at 6.5 % over 25 years one pays about 50:50 interest and principal.

Where does that interest go? It goes into the profits of people who have invested money through their banks and other financial institutions. The financial institutions turn around and give people like my wife and me a loan in the form of a mortgage.

It is absolutely incredible because as a home owner borrowing money I have to earn the money, pay taxes on the money and then with the money left after all the taxes pay interest. What happens to the people who receive the interest? They end up paying taxes on it.

As a matter of fact any business can deduct an interest cost as part of their business. Why can a family not deduct their interest cost as part of operating and providing for their family? My colleague is setting forth an eminently sensible proposal. I am amazed because I have read into what other members have been saying in their speeches that they will probably vote against it. It just blows me away. Why would they do that? Why would they continue to make it difficult for young families to get ahead, to buy homes and to start building some capital savings for their future?

Instead the government is most interested in tax, tax, tax and preferably tax the taxes, which it does too. That is another speech that I will give at some other time.

I urge all members to vote in favour of the bill. It is a very good bill. It is long overdue. It would put us, at least in this area, on an equal level with our American neighbours. Goodness knows what kind of a brain drain we have because our brightest young people are going to the States with its favourable tax situation and favourable job situation with a much lower rate of unemployment.

This is a very important measure. I urge all members to use their heads, to think independently and to carefully analyse, as we have done, the implications of the bill. Let us not hide behind technical excuses, that we cannot do this because of that. On and on they will go. Let us not do that this time. Let us rather make a bold decision to do what is right and to vote in favour of the bill.

Hepatitis C March 27th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are spending money on hiring public relations consultants and they are ignoring the victims. They have spent more time drafting damage control plans like the one that was leaked last night than they have consoling the dying.

Why will the government not compensate these victims instead of fighting them in court and turning off their microphones at press conferences?

Hepatitis C March 27th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, to this government the lives of some hepatitis C victims are worth less than those of others. If people were affected in one year they are eligible; it if was one year before they are not.

My uncle died just two months ago. He is one of the faceless names being callously dismissed. Why will the government not show some caring and compensate these victims fairly, instead of punishing them for dying at the wrong time?

Taxation March 24th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I am delighted to speak on this motion. It is put forward by an NDP member, although I do not like to say that because this is private members' business and when we deal with private members' business we should take the political designations out of it.

I have had occasion to get to know the member. I am impressed with his sincerity and his genuine desire to help families and to help people who are facing tremendous financial stresses and pressures in our country nowadays. I dislike having to say that I like this member, I like his ideas, I like his general principles and then immediately say that I am going to speak against his motion. I must do that for a very simple reason.

The member has proposed a motion that would selectively give assistance to families that are raising children. The motion states that the House “should consider implementing a tax credit or tax rebate that would compensate parents for the substantial costs of enrolling their children in youth activities”.

There is such a wide range of activities that our children engage in. Are we talking about summer camps? Are we talking about sports and music lessons, which have already been mentioned?

Another example of where the costs are tremendous is in providing an education for our children and teenagers. Are we going to extend a tax credit to people who choose to enroll their children in private schools, as my wife and I did? We had specific reasons for that and it took a considerable sacrifice on our part to do it. However, I do not regret it for a moment. It was money that was very well invested.

The truth is that we paid for those tuition fees with after tax dollars because the income tax system does not permit a deduction of those fees. If I were to speak in favour of this motion, then I would say that should also be included. For example, to pay an annual tuition of $4,000 a year for my young boys to attend the school of their choice and our choice, that $4,000 tuition required that I earn about $8,000.

My colleague from Calgary mentioned that the marginal tax rate is over 50% in Canada. This means I would have to earn over $8,000 in order to write a $4,000 cheque to the school. This would be a tremendously high proportion of a family's income. That extends to every area.

I then think of my children as young people on their way to university and college. It cost quite a bit of money to provide them with either transportation and room and board at home or with housing and tuition, the cost of books and cost of clothing, all of those costs, while they were students. According to our Income Tax Act, those costs were not deductible even though for us to help our guys, because they could not get a job or got a poorly paying job with few hours, we had to subsidize their education. It was fairly costly.

I would also like to commend my children for working very hard and very long hours in order to earn as much as they could. Here again, should that be with after tax dollars when we start paying $8,000 a year to educate a young person in college or university?

I would think that if we are going to provide deductions for hockey lessons and trombone lessons so that one day when they are prime minister they can provide some music, it should surely be acceptable to provide deductions to the parents or other relatives who are actually paying the fees to further the education of these young people.

I would like to propose something which is actually much better. Instead of introducing into the Income Tax Act new provisions, new categories where the items can be either deducted from income or entered as a tax credit eligibility, it would be much superior for us to simply try to get rid of our debt so that we can stop charging 30 cents on every $1 for interest. We thereby would provide tax relief to all Canadians at all levels with more disposable income. We could all use it.

It would help our economy. It would help our students and young people. It would help all of the families if we had a reduced tax load. More of them would be able to have jobs. More of them would then add to the economy. They would have a higher disposable income and more money in their pockets in order to provide for the needs of their families, whatever those needs are, the actual explicit expenditures they encounter or indirect ones.

Many families nowadays are really struggling. We have heard many times in this House that in order to have a balanced budget in the home both parents must work. As a result we have the social needs of the children, their parenting needs and also the tax needs to provide for the ability to look for day care or whatever is needed for the children, many of these things. The government should be out of the tax picture.

I would love it if in this country parents could have a free choice as to where they use their money for educating, training, or providing recreation for their children. Certainly they should have the choice of whether or not they want to actually parent their children themselves or hire others to do it. There are too many people who because of our excessively high rate of taxation simply do not have that choice. We are slaves to our tax system.

The member for Winnipeg—Transcona mentioned in his speech, and I have had the same experience, that charitable organizations have to charge the GST on the different functions they do to try to raise money to behave in a charitable way in their community. I do not know how this government can do that and still have any collective conscience.

I do not know how the Minister of Finance, the Prime Minister and all those individual Liberal members over there can sleep at night knowing that what they are doing is wrenching every dollar they can from Canadians in order to provide for the things that they value. It gives them such a sense of power to be able to tax Canadians and then decide where they will give it back.

We have noticed lately that if these people are good Liberal members with a paid up membership they are more likely to be eligible to receive a government appointment and things like that. It is unconscionable.

Whenever I think of voting for a bill that spends money or of approving an expenditure of a committee, I like to think in my mind of any family back in my riding whose whole annual tax bill in some cases will go to provide for that expenditure. We need to become much more conscious here of the burden we are putting on people.

Budget Implementation Act, 1998 March 24th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I am going to stand here and do exactly what the hon. member asked us to do, which is to congratulate him. I am going to congratulate him and the Minister of Finance. Why am I doing that? Because they finally opened their ears and heard the Canadian people.

I do not think that if he were truly honest he would exclude the Reform Party's influence in this. We are the ones who came here and for the first time in over 30 years it became respectable to talk about governments becoming smaller, spending less and getting the fiscal house in order.

The thing I take exception to is that the Liberals try to pass it off as if we are already out of the woods. The fact of the matter is, now that we are in tax time, for every $1,000 taxpayers send to Ottawa, $300 is for interest. There is a lot of urgency to reducing and paying off the debt so that we can start cutting those interest payments, so that we can reduce taxes and have money to spend on the programs we value.

The finance minister keeps setting these loosey goosey targets. The present target is to pay off the debt in 200 years. That is $600 billion at the present target of $3 billion a year and 200 years is not good enough.

Royal Canadian Mint March 24th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, the Royal Canadian Mint has decided to get into a new business, competing directly with a world recognized plant in my riding.

The minister has chosen to ignore some important facts. Westaim can and is ready to assure the supply.

The government's unfair competition with the private sector is putting the jobs of 100 people in my riding at risk. The new Winnipeg plant the government wants to build will cost $48 million in construction costs and lost savings. All of this is for a plant with unproven production and technology.

Will the minister assure us today that he will stop this project or at least put—

Budget Implementation Act, 1998 March 24th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. Since there was some expression of interest in interrogating and cross-examining the member for Medicine Hat, I would ask that you seek unanimous consent to extend his time by 10 minutes so that debate can take place.

Business Of The House March 19th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, it is my honour and my delight and my privilege to ask the famous Thursday question and to inquire about the legislative agenda that is planned by the government for the coming days.

Hobby Farmers March 18th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, it is a real honour to stand in favour of my colleague's motion. There is no doubt that the challenge to farmers these days is higher in all likelihood than it has ever been, although I remember as a youngster growing up on a farm in Saskatchewan that things were not very easy then either.

In the year I was born the farm had produced nothing for two years in a row. When I said in another speech in the House that I grew up very poor, it was because of that fact. When I came on the scene in 1939 two things happened: the drought came to an end and the war started. I do not know how we would correlate that.

Let me turn to the motion and the definition of farmers and the need for government help when they meet disaster. The speech of the parliamentary secretary gave one of our grievances out west. There seems to be an immediate program for disaster in some parts of the country. In no way are we insensitive and unsympathetic to that. However, we observe that when we have similar disasters in our part of the country the federal government seems to be much less sensitive to them. It seems to be very difficult for us to obtain help for those who need it.

There are many areas in which there seems to be a discriminatory attitude. I had an interesting case reported to me in my riding. A young farm couple was having a great deal of financial trouble making ends meet. It was tough. Income was slow and there were many pressures in terms of higher costs and the need to work long hours for a very low rate of return.

This couple found that there was federal legislation stacked against them. She had to take a part time job to pay the bills and keep the farm running. Lo and behold, she got in what we call euphemistically the family way. She is now eligible for UI, as most people are, having taken a job in one of neighbouring towns. It is one of the benefits under that program.

Because she also had an interest in a farm, the government applied some very stringent and unreasonable rules in computing their average, forcing them to take 15% of their gross income and apply it as income to the family. She only wished they could make 15% of their gross income; it was much less than that. As a result, she is ineligible for the UI benefits that everyone else receives. They were and are a family that is struggling financially.

In the north end of the wonderful constituency of Elk Island there are farmers who for two years in a row have not had a crop, either because of too much rain at the time of seeding or too much rain at the time of harvesting. They have not been able to get their income. As a result they are facing tremendous financial pressures.

Is there help for them? No. It does not seem to come from anywhere. Their financial distress is as severe as those who suffer from more immediate and sudden weather disasters, which we have heard a lot about in the last couple of years.

I emphasize again that I am neither unsympathetic to them nor saying in any way that they should be cut off. What I am saying is that there ought to be a system of equity applied so that different members of society and the farming community are treated equitably. Those with financial difficulties because of circumstances totally beyond their control as in the case of aberrant weather should have assistance from a government program as do others in different parts of the country.

A lot of people are part time farmers and part time everything else. Some farmers in my riding and elsewhere who among other things went into trucking because there was not enough income from the farm to keep the farm going. Consequently they get involved in trucking or some other part time business. They take employment in the oilfields or in my riding in some of the chemical plants. Some farmers in Saskatchewan had to take jobs in the potash mines just to supplement the farm income and keep on farming.

As a result they are ineligible in their farming operation for some other benefits. Even with the passing of the Crow rate there was some tremendous inequities because of the application of certain rules that apply on the federal scene.

I urge members of the House to support strongly my colleague's motion. Action should be taken. The motion was not drawn for being a votable motion so it appears, having had the pleasure of getting this off our hearts, nothing will be done about it. That is wrong. Action should be taken.

The motion is one of great importance and urgency. If we cannot vote on it in the House and bring in an act that will result in some changes, at least my colleague has brought the matter to our attention, to the attention of the government and to the attention of ministers who are in a position to do something about it.

If the government were to bring forward a bill to address the issue in the way my colleague is suggesting, it would receive the attention the House would be willing to give it. Certainly our party would support it, provided that it met the criteria my colleague is suggesting. We should do that.

I challenge the government and the minister to look at it, to treat it as a matter of urgency and to do something about it. It is not sufficient and it is not satisfying to me as a member of Parliament for farm families in my riding, in Athabasca, in some cases who have been in the farming business for years and for generations, to face the loss of their property at this stage. I urge the government to do something about it and to bring in a government bill that will bring this matter to a resolution.

I sincerely hope this will not have been just an hour of debate but that something will result from it.