House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Royal Canadian Mint Act May 19th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, it is a privilege to rise again in the House to debate an issue that is of importance to Canadians.

I would like to begin my intervention by simply stating that the intent of Bill C-82 is to establish a new $2 coin for Canada. The parliamentary secretary this morning, in introducing the bill in the House, gave a fair amount of rationale for it. I will not repeat those things, which we obviously agree on. They are already on the record. However, I do want to make a number of comments about what he said and refer directly to the provisions of the bill.

One thing I think we ought to understand is that even though in his presentation this morning he made rather voluminous reference to the changing of other coins-the penny, the nickel, the dime and the quarter, which are all being changed in content and hence in weight-that has nothing to do with Bill C-82. He was merely talking about another initiative, which is done by regulation and which apparently is going to proceed whether this bill is passed or not.

The fact of the matter is that if Bill C-82 does not pass and if Parliament fails to approve the authorization of the new two-dollar coin, then if the other regulations are implemented there will be wholesale changes required in order to manage the currency of our country by many, many merchants and vendors, irrespective of what this bill does.

I am not proposing that we ought to change the rules and that everything should be done in the House, because we would undoubtedly run out of time. I believe there is a proper role for setting of regulations that will determine certain aspects.

The introduction of the coin is not terribly controversial. We have had very little feedback. That is probably due to the fact that this initiative is not yet well known. I doubt whether it will generate a great deal of public outcry. It could even be that the bill will be passed before the public becomes aware of it. I do not think it has sufficient importance that it will grab the attention of the media. It looks as if it may be pushed through faster than what we can normally communicate via usual communication methods to our constituents.

In order to keep our options open we in the Reform Party will most likely oppose the bill. When I say that immediately the cry is: "They are in opposition; they are against everything". That is not true. In this instance we are doing it with a very open mind. In the event that the unanswered questions we have at this time receive satisfactory answers, we will have no hesitation to show support for the bill.

As I understand, the primary motivation for introducing the $2 coin is as a cost saving measure for the government. Much is made of this point. I cannot help at this stage to talk about the very important issue of cost cutting. The government would like Canadians to believe that it is cutting costs at every turn. If we look at the issue we are down to a very small amount of petty change. I say that in relation to the deficit and debt. If members opposite listen carefully they will hear in the next few minutes what I mean. I am not saying things to evoke a reaction. There is empirical, numerical evidence of what I am saying now.

We have a tremendous debt and a huge deficit. We commend the Liberals for bringing it down; it is better than increasing it. It is good that the deficit has been reduced. We ought not to delude Canadians into thinking that our debt problem is solved or that our debt is decreasing because it is not.

Not only does the budget of this year call for total government expenditures of $2 billion in excess of what was spent last year, but at the end of the fiscal year we will have another $32 billion of debt that we did not have when we entered this fiscal year. That is the straight fiscal reality. I am merely echoing what was reported by the Minister of Finance when he tabled his budget.

While I say that it is wonderful to be reducing spending and thereby hopefully reducing the rate at which we are going into debt, I also need to criticize it. Perhaps I can use a sports analogy. It is wonderful for the football team to gain a yard. That is better than losing a yard. On the next play it gains another yard. However, if only two yards in two plays have been gained in Canadian football the ball has to be kicked away. The opportunity has been lost.

At this time the matter is severe. Even though the government is saying this and I will echo it, there is a savings of $254 million over the next 20 years. I am not opposed to that savings, but it is as though we are gaining another yard and meanwhile the game is slipping away from us. We need to be cognizant of that fact. We need to address it very seriously.

I hesitate to say this. If Canadians hear me say that $254 million is petty change I will get hammered for it. I do not mean it. It is a lot of money, but relative to the total picture what we are doing in this measure is barely whittling away at the edge of the problem. The problem is so large that it is as if we are trying

to take the water out of the Pacific Ocean with a teaspoon. It will never happen.

Let me bring the numbers into perspective. I have shared before in the House that mathematics is my game. I have had some 31 years of experience teaching the subject. I have loved it and have used mathematics since I was a child.

In preparing my speech I immediately got out my calculator, did some number crunching and thought about what it meant. We need to be aware that the mention of savings, which is so highly touted by the other side, is extremely mediocre. Let me tell members how little the savings really are. I am sorry that we are spending time in the House today dealing with this one while the big ones are getting away from us.

A famous politician one time said: "I do not have time to be shooting rabbits when I should be after bear". That was a quotation of Tommy Douglas. That is what we are doing.

I ask the House to listen to the numbers. The $254 million savings is over 20 years. Usually when the government wants accolades for its savings it says a quarter of a billion dollars, which is a wonderfully big number. Then its voice drops when it whispers quietly "over 20 years" so that nobody notices that it is over 20 years.

What does this mean? It means $12.7 million in savings per year. We are going to deny it but we need to get it into the perspective of what it actually means in terms of the taxpayer.

I did a couple of side calculations. Here is one of them. Because of our massive debt, our interest payments of some $40 billion per year work out to about $110 million per day. Let us remember that I just said this was a cost saving of $12.7 million per year. Therefore we will save in this measure $12.7 million over the whole year. Meanwhile we are spending $110 million per day on interest. In the perspective of how viciously we are attacking the budget, this is not the measure.

Another way of putting it is that the savings "to be realized" by the implementation of the $2 coin will pay for our annual interest. This savings will account for the interest payment for two hours and 47 minutes of the year. That is the big saving.

Let us do it but let us recognize that if we are to do it and finally bring the debt under control, we will have to take some big steps. We will have to stop stepping gingerly. We will have to start looking at the big expenditures and at the big savings. Otherwise we will lose the game while busily wondering whether we made a yard or six inches.

I would like to bring it down to the individual because it is very appropriate. Not only does it put the savings into perspective. It also puts the economics into perspective. I made some assumptions because I do not have access to instantaneous figures. We are not yet on Internet in the House. It is impossible to get that technology going so it is difficult to get up to date measures.

I made a few assumptions on data that was several years old. It was the best I could get. Assuming 29 million Canadians, the savings this will produce will amount to the sum of 44 cents per year per Canadian. Over the whole year, after we have implemented the plan, every Canadian will say: "I have an extra 44 cents in my pocket this year".

Let us stop to think about it. The change in coinage will probably result in every coin operated machine in the country, telephones, food vending machines and lottery machines which I do not approve of in any case, having to be changed.

With the measure Canadians will save 44 cents per person per year. If the merchants increase the price on vending machines by 10 cents to recoup the cost of changing the machinery, any individual who uses a machine more than four times a year will end up spending more money. That puts the economic perspective of the measure into a different light. We need to think about these matters. Whether Canadians are paying money via their taxes or whether they are paying via the goods and services they purchase, it is still money out of their pockets.

I did another calculation. There are approximately 13.5 million Canadians who while filing income tax also pay tax. There are approximately six million taxpayers who file to receive the refundable tax credits. They are really out of the tax picture; they are only doing the paperwork. Those who are actually contributing to government income via the tax system number around 13.5 million to the best of my knowledge. If we forget about the people of Canada and only talk about the 13.5 million taxpaying Canadians, the savings are quite a bit more because there are now fewer people who are sharing the savings. The $254 million that will be saved by introducing the $2 coin gives every taxpayer a break of about 94 cents per year.

As a taxpayer I am sure that I use a coin operated machine more than 10 times per year. I am presuming. Maybe they will only increase the price by 5 cents. Maybe some of them will not increase the price at all, which I doubt, because it is our information that to change the coin recognition mechanism of machines will cost $500 per machine. That is the smallest number I have read about. I believe every coin operated machine in the country will increase their prices. I can anticipate a Pepsi or a chocolate bar which now costs 90 cents undoubtedly going

up to $1, so it will require a loonie. Maybe the new machine will accept a $2 coin and give a loonie back, so people will have almost exactly the same money in their pocket in terms of weight as before.

It has been mentioned that one of the reasons for doing this is that $2 bills do not last. That is also true. I know I cannot use props; I really know the rules around here. I cannot haul out a $2 bill, but I looked at one before I came here that was worn. The $2 bills get a lot of mileage. It reminds me a bit about the way the Canadian government handles grain. The government likes to put it on trains and give it a joy ride before it arrives at its destination. We do that with our currency as well.

The $2 bill undoubtedly does a lot of travelling. Statistics tell us that on average the $2 bill we have been using extensively since the $1 bill was discontinued lasts only a year and then it must be reprinted at a cost of 6 cents. It costs 6 cents every year for every $2 bill in circulation.

The coin, because it will last for 20 years, will not have that cost. It will cost approximately 16 cents to produce, but as we all know coins last for a very long time. To show that I am a true Reformer, when I was walking down the sidewalk the other day I saw a penny and I stopped to pick it up, as Reformers would be wont to do. I was amazed to see that the penny was almost as old as I am. Somebody had just dropped it. It was not quite as old as I am. The date on it as I recall was 1945 and I am six years older than that. But I thought it was really significant that that coin could last as long as I have. I assure you that no bill in circulation would last that long.

I have stated the cost per taxpayer and the saving per Canadian of 44 cents per year as a counterbalance to the statement of the parliamentary secretary. I think I wrote down the quotation correctly. He said: "This will be a big load off the debt". With all due respect, I think not.

I will indicate some other reasons for the temporary statement that we are going to be resisting the bill. I have already indicated that to the individual Canadian it may not be nearly as big a saving as is being touted. I want to find out before I vote in favour of the bill whether it actually is economically feasible. I am not certain. I have not had sufficient data on it to convince me.

Also I somehow feel that we ought to be presenting Canadians with more than just this option. We now have a $1 coin and we are jumping now to a $2 coin and then a $5 coin. The $2 coin is the one in question.

To my knowledge no studies have been done on the viability and feasibility of dropping the $2 bill and going from the $1 to the $5. I cannot use props here, but I could hold up four coins and show that those four loonies would represent two $2 bills. After we pass the $4 dollar mark we could then use a $5 bill. You do not ever need more than two $2 bills. That means we would never need more than two $2 coins. Which means that if we did not have a $2 coin we would have to have up to four loonies.

I looked at the spec sheet. The loonie weighs 7 grams. The new proposed $2 coin is going to weigh 7.3 grams, just slightly heavier. Canadians are going to say: "If I have to have yet another coin, then there is going to more weight in my pocket". Well, this is what it is: four loonies weigh 28 grams. My generation likes to hear it in the old British system, which is about an ounce. If you had two $2 coins they would weigh 14.6 grams, which for all intents and purposes is about half an ounce.

We are asking Canadians to approve the introduction of a new $2 coin with huge costs to all the vending industries and all the coin operated machines in order to save, at maximum, the necessity of carrying an extra one-half ounce in their pockets. I suppose that could be justified. I am interested in studying it further. I am certainly interested in hearing from Canadians to find out whether they are really going to say: "Yes, let us go for the $2 coin because I walk lopsided if I have an extra half ounce on that side". I am being facetious. My apologizes. That was supposed to be a joke to wake up members opposite.

Too many questions of this type remain unanswered. In fact, there are some problems with the bill itself. Consequently, our initial response is that we respectfully submit that we are going to oppose the bill, with the option that if proper answers are given to our questions, then we will show that we are willing to support the bill.

One thing the government has done based on the data we received from it, was a poll which found that Canadians support the $2 coin. We actually question the accuracy of the poll. The difficulty with the poll is that the only option given was whether they liked the $2 coin or not. They were not given the option of not having the $2 denomination at all. Therefore, Canadians were not given a number of choices, but a very narrow choice.

I was also told, and I hope this is correct, that the first poll taken was not supportive. The question was changed in order to get a positive poll so that the proposal for the $2 coin could be advertised as having the support of Canadians. When I found out that this was done, I wondered about the motivation behind it.

Another question we definitely want answered is: Who will actually benefit from the introduction of the coin? I am making no allegations, but it is a question which we will always and carefully ask on this side of the House. I am not going to say which Liberal supporter, but we will ask who is going to benefit from this. Who has the contract? Which are the businesses that change the machines? If there are any problems with that, we are

going to try to find that out and make sure that the motivations are all above board.

I will also talk a little bit about the retailers. I am sure a lot of Canadians are not aware that when a purchase is made with currency there is almost always change. Very seldom does the customer present the exact change. In any case, every merchant has the option of having the facility to accept a credit card. We understand that a great deal of merchandising is done via credit cards. The mechanism for processing credit card and debit card purchases has been refined to a great extent. That system is fairly efficient, but we still have a coinage system. We still have the rules of currency and legal tender. Therefore, the merchants are required to have change.

If you were ever to look into the till, you would see that there are different compartments for pennies, nickels, dimes, quarters and loonies. We have very few 50-cent pieces in circulation; I think most of them are hoarded by collectors. With the introduction of a new coin, every tray in every till in the whole country is going to be put on the garbage heap and replaced with a new tray with an extra compartment because of the new coin.

Another aspect to that which was indicated by the parliamentary secretary is when the $2 coin was introduced, the government said it was going to do the vendors a favour by changing the metal content and hence the weights of the other coins at the same time. The vendors could then build new coin recognition systems and do that change only once.

That is commendable, but the government is not going to instantly take all of the old coins out of circulation. Therefore, the job for the coin vendors is to have a coin recognition system that no longer recognizes nickels, dimes, quarters and loonies, which is a total of four coins, but they are going to need a total of eight coins recognized. There will be two different kinds of nickels, dimes, quarters, loonies and the $2 coin, doubloonies, I guess we will call it.

When that happens the mechanism is going to have to be much more sophisticated and undoubtedly more expensive. I read an estimate that the vending machine industry is probably going to have to lay out approximately $25 million to change the machines. Remember I did the division by 20 on the projected savings. I said that if the saving is $254 million in 20 years, it is $12.7 million in one year. By the lowest estimates, we will be spending twice the annual savings of the government in order to change the machines when we start out.

Hopefully if there is some stability to our currency system, that change should not have to be made again soon. It is interesting to note it was approximately eight years ago when all the machines in the country had to be changed. I do submit one of the things we would call for is a longer period to guarantee Canadian businessmen the coinage will not change. Eight years is really much too short a period.

I would also like answers to questions like these: What are the actual total costs to industry? What are the total costs to Canadians?

It would also be appropriate to talk about seigniorage, which is the difference between the value of the coin and what it costs to produce it. We are told that based on this component, we expect to have an input into the Canadian government coffers of $449 million in two and one-half years. I will admit I am a mathematician but I am not an economist, so I do not fully understand how that accrues to actual value to the Canadian government.

I stand to be corrected but it seems to me that if we can actually bring in $500 million in two and one-half years to the Canadian government wealth and if it is real wealth, not inflationary wealth, because of the introduction of the new currency-and I understand that part-we will presumably be taking the $2 bills out of circulation when we bring in the $2 coin. If there is an actual accrual to the government of $449 million of added value, then I ask a very elementary question: Why do we not just greatly increase the number of $1 and $2 coins? Let us produce them in sufficient numbers to pay off the debt. If it really works then we should do that.

Now I think I know enough about economics to know that would not work. Unfortunately that is not the kind of economic policy that would keep us as a country in good light with all of the other trading partners. Our currency would undoubtedly be devalued by that.

Another aspect of this is profit to the mint. I like the fact that our mint is a money maker. I am sure many people are aware that the Canadian mint not only produces Canadian currency, but also provides a sizeable import of dollars by producing and shipping coins to other countries.

I understand it is definitely economical for the mint to tool up to produce a new $2 coin. Like a car manufacturer tooling up to make a new model of car, it is always economical because that will be recouped in sales. It is undoubtedly correct for the mint to do this.

I would like to know the details of the mint's cash flow. How is this actually going to work out? We also need to recognize there are ramifications to moving from the printing of paper currency to the production of the coins. Initially there will be a large flurry of activity in producing the new coins, but what happens to productivity once we have saturated the Canadian currency with the required number of $2 coins? Those are simple questions.

With respect to the bill itself there needs to be a long term plan which is not present in this very short bill. All it says is that we are going to make a new $2 coin. That is basically all it says in

layman's language. What we really should have is some sort of coherent, long term currency plan Canadians can count on.

There is a really serious question we ought to be asking, whether we should keep the penny. The penny costs about 70 per cent more to produce than what it is worth. It costs about 1.7 cents to manufacture a penny. It does not make a great deal of sense to keep manufacturing pennies. Think of the savings we could incur if we stop doing that. We could presumably go for many years utilizing the pennies out there now because their rate of replacement is not great. They are very sturdy coins.

Has there been any study on replacing the $5 bill with a $5 coin? If it is so good for the two, could it also be done for the five? Should it be done at the same time? Obviously if we are to make a change, to do it at the same time makes a great deal more sense than making this change now and then five or eight years down the road saying introduce a new $5 coin requiring all the vendors and all of the businesses once again to adjust.

These are some of the questions I want to have answered before I can support this bill. It could be that we are missing an opportunity of being very efficient if that is the long term direction we are to go. We need to have studies. We need to have answers to those questions.

I appreciate the opportunity to be able to address this question. Obviously in my limited knowledge I will not have explored all aspects of it. Undoubtedly there are other things we must also take into account. We will certainly be watching and participating eagerly in the House and in committee, provided we are allowed to vote in our committee and other things.

We will pay close attention in committee and we will be eagerly asking for the answers to these questions. I want to reiterate the bottom line for us is not a saving to government but a saving to the taxpayer. If the taxpayer in total is to land up with a higher expense then we will be opposed to this bill.

I seriously doubt, based on the numbers I gave at the beginning of my intervention, the added costs of making the changes to the commodities sold through vending machines primarily will eat up the pockets of the taxpayers more than what will be saved for those taxpayers through this avenue of government.

I also want to make sure that before we give consent to this bill all of the costs have been anticipated. Too often in government we start on a project and hear the estimates. How often have we heard of overruns? Over and over; it happens with great frequency. We want to make sure there are very precise accounting and estimates of the total anticipated costs to the taxpayers. I want to make sure we have an open and honest discussion.

In my first year and a half in the House there have been times when I have really enjoyed the work. I have felt what I have been contributing has been very helpful to the Canadians I was sent here to represent, broader than the Elk Island constituency, all Canadians from sea to sea.

I hope in this bill, which is such an innocuous bill, we will be able to embark on a debate, a study in committee free from the acrimony and the bull headedness that has been displayed in some of the committees, particularly in the past several days.

It is so important that we as parliamentarians-in the committee we are backbenchers-have, as the Liberal Party promised in its red book, a more meaningful role. That role will have to be found in committee because of the sheer numbers.

Not many members have the privilege I have today to make a 40 minute speech. Members on the Liberal side almost never get that opportunity. When a bill is introduced either the minister or the parliamentary secretary takes that opportunity. All of the other backbenchers really do not have a role.

In committee we can have a real role provided it is permitted, encouraged and acknowledged and that there is a genuine and honest recognition that the recommendations of the committee are to be taken seriously. I look forward to working on this bill in the committee. Provided our answers can be forthcoming very quickly I am sure we can come up with a solution to this problem.

It is not a big problem for Canadians. It is a problem of some significance. We can come up with a solution that will be best for all Canadians. I am thinking of those ordinary Canadians who work from day to day struggling to pay their bills, struggling to pay their taxes. Those are the people we want to represent. We want to make sure they get very best possible shake out of this legislation and other legislation like it.

Privilege May 19th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I have two very important things.

First, the incident I reported which grieves me so seriously occurred after the member for Frazer Valley East came to you to give his intervention yesterday. It happened afterwards. That is very significant. It is also of a completely different nature.

Second, I was using the instruction as I understood it from Standing Order 48(1):

Whenever any matter of privileges arises, it shall be taken into consideration immediately.

This says to me I have the right to not wait until that committee gave me the permission to come here. That is why I took the initiative to come.

Privilege May 19th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, it has been over one and one-half years since I was elected as a new member to this most important Chamber in the country. I came here full of hope and anticipation of what the democratic process would be. The breach of privilege of which I speak today is such a severe aberration and breach of the most fundamental premises of democracy that I am really sorry I have to raise it.

I also recognize that what I am going to say is important. I realize your position, Mr. Speaker, is of tremendous importance here. In your office and in your person lies the ability to maintain the very basic premise of democracy and the rules under which it operates. I am asking today not only for your ruling, but also for your guidance because of my deep concerns.

I want to specifically give the reasons for my complaint. I was a substitute authorized member of the Standing Committee on Human Rights and the Status of Disabled Persons on Tuesday and Wednesday. I know, Mr. Speaker, you heard one question of privilege already and you ruled on that, but my problem is a different one and much more serious. It has to do with the conducting of a vote in that committee.

Specifically, this is what happened. Our party moved an amendment. When the chairman of the committee called for the vote, we said yea. There was not a single nay heard. The chairman ruled that the motion had been defeated. Now that is so fundamental it is not even in the rule book. It is assumed in a democracy that when everybody who casts a vote says yea and the chairman says that it has been defeated that it is a flagrant and violent abuse of democracy such as we cannot tolerate if we want to maintain our system.

The chairman declared that motion defeated and of course I immediately challenged the chair. When I did that, the chairman of the committee said that his ruling would stand. I objected and the chairman then invoked the rules of order which ask for the majority of the people in the committee to decide if the ruling of the chair stands. The Liberal majority woke up and they faithfully fell into line and supported the ruling of the chair. I could not accept that.

This was such a serious aberration that I told the chairman he could not do that. He said he could. I suppose I should have apologized at that stage for becoming a little upset, but to me this was such a violent attack on the democratic process. I then moved to report this incident to the Speaker because it was my understanding that such an issue could not come to you unless it was reported by the committee. I may be wrong here and I have some reasons for considering that I may be wrong, but that was my understanding at the time.

I moved the motion that this be reported, but the chairman would not accept the motion and ruled it out of order. I told the chairman it could not be out of order. He then proceeded to ask if the ruling of the chair was sustained and the majority of the members present said yes. Now that is unbelievable. I cannot accept that.

I appeal to you, Mr. Speaker, that this be corrected. There must be some things the committee does not have 100 per cent autonomy to do. It cannot by vote alter the truth. This is a democratic tradition that has been upheld for so long that an arbitrary rule of a motion defeated when in fact it has passed cannot be accepted.

If the majority of members were not paying attention and did not vote when they should have, just wishing that they would have been awake does not give them any justification for using their majority to override the previous vote. Only a person who voted on the side that won the vote can move a motion to reconsider. That was not done in this case. The chairman arbitrarily and incorrectly declared the vote lost and the members were not paying attention and chimed into his defence.

This is so serious, Mr. Speaker, that I appeal to you that some corrective action be taken. As I said in my preamble, I do require your assistance as well as your ruling because I want to know how to handle this. This cannot be accepted by this Parliament, the highest court of the land, as such a serious aberration of the democratic process.

Canada Elections Act May 16th, 1995

You wait, you'll see.

Ethics Counsellor May 16th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, the fact is that the ethics counsellor has given an investigation on very, very few matters of substantive importance.

The Liberal red ink book promises an independent ethics counsellor. The Reform Party has repeatedly called for an independent ethics counsellor. Seven of ten provinces have independent persons in this role. Now Gregory Evans, the independent conflict of interest commissioner in Ontario, is calling on the federal government to appoint an independent ethics counsellor.

What is the government hiding? Why does the Prime Minister insist on keeping the ethics counsellor totally accountable to him?

Ethics Counsellor May 16th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Prime Minister.

The auditor general's report reveals that an astonishing 58 per cent of public servants are unaware of the federal government's conflict of interest policy. The auditor general also noted that the best conflict of interest guidelines are useless without leadership from the top, the cabinet.

When will the Prime Minister take the initiative to lead by example and prove that he has nothing to hide by appointing an independent ethics counsellor?

Old Age Security Act May 15th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, again I rise on this question to try to persuade the government to make the right decision. Since the calls are made by the Liberals, with their majority whatever they decide will be, so I am going to try hard to persuade them in the correct way.

There has been considerable inconsistency from Bloc members, in the sense that with this amendment they are asking that we take away from the minister the discretion not to pay.

In other words, if the minister decides that somebody should not be entitled to some of these programs that are being dealt with in Bill C-54 and some administrative bureaucrat in the

system decides a person should not be receiving a benefit because the rules say he should no longer be receiving it, according to this amendment the minister would no longer have the right to stop the payments.

To me, this is ludicrous. On the one hand they move a subamendment to our motion, which would have the effect of not giving the minister the right to make payments when they are required, and here they are saying they do not want to have the minister have the right to not make payments when they are not required. That does not make sense to me.

As members opposite are thinking about this amendment, and I presume they will be opposed to it, I want to strongly urge them to be opposed to it. If the payments are not justifiable they are in breach of the rules, and the minister should be able to stop those payments.

Let us look at the scenario this sets up. A person receives money and the department says no more money. Then the person who is receiving appeals. During that appeal process, in which the wheels of government can take quite some time, these payments must be kept coming. If the person receiving them really wants to take the system for a ride, they will make sure that all of that money they receive is totally spent, so that if the appeal goes against them they will be able to say they cannot pay it back because they have no money. Then, on a compassionate ground or whatever, according to the previous rules that money would not be repayable.

It really means that the taxpayers are being totally dumped on in terms of accountability if this amendment is accepted. As I said, I urge the members opposite to pass the information on to their leadership so that the leadership gives the direction to them so they know how to vote and they will vote correctly in opposing this amendment.

Old Age Security Act May 15th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I am very pleased to be able to address this particular matter today. When I came here in the fall of 1993 one of the biggest promises I made to the constituents of Elk Island who elected me was to exert pressure on the government to be accountable for the way the taxpayers' hard earned dollars were being spent.

I remember very distinctly one of the things which shocked me when I arrived here. There was an orientation for new members. The individual making the presentation told us what our office budgets were and explained the formula. Then he said that it did not matter, that we could spend more, that we could spend any amount we wanted to. I was getting upset and as a brand new member I did not know what to do. Should I get up and say that is wrong and we should not do that? I was getting quite angry about this carte blanche that an MP had to spend any amount he wanted.

Then the presenter said that to remember, any amount we overextended or overspent on our budget or any category in it would simply be deducted from our salary. I immediately relaxed and was happy. He was obviously building it up. He said that as a member of Parliament I had a personal responsibility to be within my budget. If I am not trustworthy or not on the bit in terms of managing my budget, then it would come out of my own pocket.

When I left that meeting I remembered how my emotions went up with anger and down with great delight that there was one level of accountability. I then asked some of my colleagues if it would not be wonderful if we could require that same level of accountability from all members of the government, all of the bureaucrats. A deputy minister would be required to give up a portion of his salary for overspending the budget.

I have been watching the budget and we have been working in committee on the estimates for the year and I am appalled. Over and over we hear about cuts, cuts, cuts. Yet in every set of estimates I have looked at so far the spending is up. The people of Canada need to know that total government spending under this new, much touted cutting budget is actually $2 billion more than last year. The people of Canada and members of this House ought to know that we are spending more and more.

When the hon. member from the governing Liberal Party was speaking earlier, he made some comments about the Reformers. He said that here is this group of Reformers who want accountability and all they are doing is proposing something that will cost more money. The member then said that the amount of overspending is not really that much. Why, it is only five one-thousandths of one per cent.

Five one thousandths of one per cent is certainly not excessive if it is put that way. But if we look at the tens of millions of dollars which are overspent because of administrative errors, because of lack of accountability and lack of resolve, I think that maybe 100 taxpayers would be required to pay their total tax bills just to pay for the overpayment. If we got those 100 taxpayers, or 1,000 taxpayers or however many are needed to come up with the tax dollars to fund this administrative error, I think we would have howls of protest. Perhaps then we would have a greater cry for accountability.

The member said that it is an administrative hassle. It will cost money to ask the minister to be accountable for the overpayments. Yes, indeed, accounting for money is a cost item. As any person who has ever been in business will tell us, the money which is spent on reliable accountants and on acceptable accounting procedures is usually money well spent. Money which is spent in providing accountability usually provides a saving of an amount much greater than the amount which is required to deliver on that accountability.

I would speak against the Bloc amendment to the Reform motion. What we are doing is we are promoting accountability.

The cry from the other side was that these people do not care, that we want to cut people off. Another statement was that we want to prevent the minister from being able to do his job. Wrong on both counts.

We in the Reform Party believe it is time we managed our fiscal affairs in such a way that we do not go down the tubes, so that we do maintain the ability to help people who are truly in need. As long as we keep on wasting money because we are too lazy to account for it, we are diving headlong into a disaster. That will prevent us from doing anything for anyone because we will have either runaway inflation or increased taxes and probably both in order to try to bail us out of a fiscal problem which was generated by governments over the past 30 years. There is probably nothing more urgent than bringing accountability to the whole process.

There is a recommendation in our motion that the minister must include his recommendations in his report. In other words, we are not saying that the minister cannot do his job; we are telling the minister to do his job and to do it well. Where it can be improved, he should bring his recommendations to the House. We will then provide assistance, via the House or a committee, so that we can be more efficient and better stewards of the money which Canadian taxpayers entrust to us.

We are saying to the minister that if he is overspending because of administrative errors, if he is giving money to people to whom it is not due, that money should be recoverable. If there are mitigating circumstances which would recommend that on compassionate grounds or for whatever reason it will not be paid back, we want to know why that is so. We want to know what the minister is going to do about it. Many years a go a very wise

teacher of mine said: "If you set no goals, you will be sure to reach them. If you aim for nothing, you will be sure to hit it".

We are asking the minister to account for administrative errors in his department that cost the taxpayers money. We are asking the minister to come up with a plan that will save the taxpayers money. I do not think anyone would argue that when there is increasing competition for increasingly rare dollars from government, the money should go to people to whom it is intended. If someone receives money, whether it is OAS or CPP or UIC, to which they are not entitled it is actually a violation of the rights of the people who need it and it should be paid back unless there are very severe mitigating circumstances.

We want the minister to aim ever higher. We want the minister to say: "Last year this amount of unauthorized payments were made and we could not collect it back". We want the minister to stand in the House or table a report that will say what the amount was. He must be up front with the taxpayers who are footing the bill. Then he must also show his plan for reducing those costs. He must show what he is prepared to do in order to make the administration more efficient to reduce the number of people receiving payments to which they are not entitled. If the minister aims at nothing or says if we will have a certain amount of overpayment, so be it, we cannot improve, that is exactly what will happen. There will be no improvement.

However, as our amendment suggests, if the minister is required to give a report, stage his plans for doing better then we hopefully will find there will be improvement and fewer people will receive money to which they are not entitled. There will hopefully be fewer people required to pay back money they should not have received because the administrative procedures will be so honed to a fine art that people who are not entitled to receive money will not receive it. That is the ultimate goal for which we should strive and the goal which we should keep in mind and work toward until it is actually met.

We recognize it is not possible for a minister to micromanage his department. We say without equivocation that if the committees are to have any function in the House, as we were told by the so-called Liberal red book, we were to have more meaningful activities for MPs, let them work in the committees and deal with these recommendations.

Ontario Election May 15th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, the Minister of Finance has gone on the hustings for Lyn McLeod and the son of red book. In a speech to the Liberal faithful, the minister heaped praise on the Ontario Liberals for setting a four-year target for the elimination of the deficit, calling their so-called strategic spending cuts laudable and their tax cuts sensible. This is very ironic. In a classic case of Liberal doublespeak, it is another example of do as I say not as I do. It is just like their MP pension plan reform.

Despite constant Reform pressure, the minister has repeatedly refused to set a date to eliminate the deficit and has actually increased taxes by over $1.5 billion. Liberals love taxes so it is not surprising that they would tax logic along with everything else.

Not to worry. The son of red book will end up with the garbage with its federal parent. Ontario voters will have the sense to realize that it is only by the application of the sound Reform principles of deficit elimination, debt reduction and the resultant tax reductions which will ultimately work to-

Petitions May 12th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, the third and last petition I would like to present today bears 373 signatures, mostly of Elk Island constituents.

It is one in which the petitioners say they are already overburdened by taxes. They do not believe the expensive procedure of registering firearms will have any substantial effect on the reduction of the criminal use of firearms. They ask that Parliament not enact any laws which would require the registration of all firearms.