House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Petitions May 12th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I have three petitions today pursuant to Standing Order 36.

The first one bears 39 signatures. It indicates that since Canadians believe that all Canadians should enjoy the same protection in law by virtue of being Canadians, the petitioners pray that Parliament not amend the Criminal Code in such a way that sentencing be less severe for crimes against persons who are not in an especially protected category.

Mr. Speaker, the second petition bears 280 signatures. It is similar to the other but is more specific.

The petitioners pray that Parliament not amend the human rights code, the Canadian Human Rights Act or the charter of rights and freedoms in any way which would indicate societal approval of same sex relationships or of homosexuality, including amending the human rights code to include the phrase of sexual orientation and including amending the Criminal Code in such a way that sentencing would be less severe for crimes against persons who are not homosexuals.

Auditor General's Report May 12th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, there is a great difference between filibustering and promoting a logical solution to a problem. We want the ethics counsellor to be independent. That was my question; that is what I was talking about. That is why my question is again directed to the Deputy Prime Minister.

We noticed that in the last few days no one has questioned the authenticity of the report of the auditor general. No one questions his findings as being inaccurate. No one questions that he is not thorough. We all find him trustworthy and believable. Why? It is because he is independent. That is the reason.

I ask again, again and again until finally I hope the logic gets through: When will we have the assurance that the ethics counsellor will enjoy the same independence as the auditor general has? That is what we are asking and we want an answer to that.

Auditor General's Report May 12th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Deputy Prime Minister.

Yesterday's auditor general report stated that even the best codes of conduct or conflict of interest guidelines could not protect Canadians from a government that was not fundamentally honest. The report made clear that we could not expect ethical behaviour from public servants if we do not have it from their leadership, the cabinet.

After appointing an ethics counsellor that is completely beholden to the office so that he will forever be able to hide all ethics scandals, how could the Prime Minister expect his public servants to behave ethically even when they know they cannot get caught?

Multiple Sclerosis May 12th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, yesterday I knelt while a wonderful woman in a wheelchair pinned this flower on my jacket. When I got up, I had to fight back tears because I was so aware of the ease with which I could get up and walk to my destination.

People who suffer from multiple sclerosis and other debilitating diseases display the highest courage as they live from day to day. I have a profound respect and love for them.

I think of people struggling with MS; Mark, Joanne and others in my Elk Island constituency and hundreds throughout our country. They deserve every possible support and encouragement from the rest of us.

I urge everyone to give generously to its fundraising efforts. Let us do all we can to promote research to find a cure and to help make their lives more tolerable.

Auditor General's Report May 11th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I think it is despicable that any senior manager would even consider undermining the competitive process. But then whose example are they following? We have the backroom José Perez deals, the Power Corp. deals, the Canada Communication Group deals, the Seagram MCA takeover.

Ministers and deputies should lead by example. The best way to assure that they are would be to make the ethics counsellor directly responsible to Parliament and not to the Prime Minister.

My question is for the Deputy Prime Minister: For the umpteenth time, will the Prime Minister honour the explicit red book promise and make the position of the ethics counsellor report directly to Parliament?

Auditor General's Report May 11th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, in news reports released today the auditor general disclosed that 12 per cent of senior managers believe it is appropriate to undermine competition for a contract at the request of a supervisor. Furthermore one in three public servants would not intervene to stop it. Nor would they report it.

My question is for the President of the Treasury Board. How widespread is the undermining of the open bidding process? What checks are in place, if any, to prevent such unethical behaviour?

Members Of Parliament Retiring Allowances Act May 10th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, the member for Capilano-Howe Sound has very important things to say and I think there should be more than two Liberals present to hear it. I call quorum.

Members Of Parliament Retiring Allowances Act May 9th, 1995

On a point of order, Mr. Speaker. I know it is difficult to keep the relevance rule going, but I think instead of the hon. member talking about the Reform Party we should be discussing Bill C-85. I would like the member to describe for us the wonderful aspects of Bill C-85 and how it solves the problems.

Members Of Parliament Retiring Allowances Act May 9th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I appreciate your encouraging the people to hear my words because I do speak them sincerely and hope they fall on sympathetic and understanding ears.

When I came here I was very sad to see the MP pension plan, knowing also the public perception of it as being excessive. There were many different terms used to describe it. The words obscene and excessive are often used. Being a mathematician I did some work on the MP pension plan from a mathematical, actuarial point of view. It was with great regret.

I am a family man with a wife and children. I am getting old; not very old, I am still young and energetic in thought. I am approaching that age when I need to think seriously of my pension. My wife was always a full time mom and so we have always lived on my income. The pension plan I had where I worked before accrued at the rate of 2 per cent per year. In terms of a possible pension benefit that means when I reach the age of 65 my deferred pension from my previous institute will give me 54 per cent of my best years in that place, which means I will get a pension of approximately $30,000 per year.

So there is no question as to whether I am double dipping, I am not now receiving a pension. I will be receiving it as a deferred pension when I reach age 65. Those are the rules. Had I not come here I would have reached my full pensionable age at 61 and I would have had 70 per cent by then.

However, having left my other employment I no longer am able to accrue pension benefits there. I came here and realized immediately I could not with integrity face the electors who elected me and participate in this pension plan.

At the time of our election in the fall of 1993 when I went to do all of the book work and fill in all the forms that we had to do as new employees of the House, I asked if I could opt out of the pension plan. I was told by a very kind person I could not because it was controlled by legislation and until the law was changed I had no choice.

Therefore, against my wishes I was registered into the MPs pension plan. I was being forced to pay into the plan approximately $590 per month. I do not object to paying $590 per month as long as I receive a fair pension on retirement, but there is a real problem with that pension plan because not only do I put in $590 a month but presumably the employers, in our case the taxpayers of Canada almost directly, are matching it.

What is wrong is this pension plan permits me as a member of Parliament to accrue pension benefits at a rate not available to other Canadians. The Income Tax Act does not permit the rate of accrual even if the person is willing to make those payments into a registered pension plan at that rate.

However, and this is critical, in the Income Tax Act self-employed persons have higher limits for RRSPs. If we as members of Parliament were able to get out of the MP pension plan and put our investment into an RRSP like other Canadians with the same rules and limits we would be able to provide for ourselves a pension which would surely be adequate.

I have observed most people who serve in the House do so at mid-age as opposed to an early age. There are some young members here and I commend them for their early entry into the parliamentary process. Most already have RRSPs or other pension plans started. They will not be dependent totally on their earnings from the House of Commons.

It seemed to me very unfortunate the pension plan here was inadequate because I would like to have finished my pensionable years either by staying at my other place of employment or by being able to do a comparable program here so that the two of them tied together would give me a reasonable pension and look after my needs as I enter those years of non-productive work, although for me hopefully that will be many years hence. That was not available. Hence we began to call strongly for the ability to opt out of the plan.

I want to address primarily and specifically that aspect of the plan. I do not know what words to use because I do not want to be unkind. I saw the proposal in Bill C-85 on the retirement allowances act for members of Parliament a one time provision which states that after it is brought into force all members will

have 60 days in which to indicate their willingness to continue in the plan, which is simply a spin on allowing opting out.

I thought this was particularly politically vindictive. There are people on this side the House elected by the electors who have as much respect for them as every Liberal elected to the House. I promise that. Those people are now being told: "You do not have the same rights and benefits as others. We will give you back your money and you will have to pay taxes on it". They are basically saying those of us who want to stand on principle will pay a very high price.

I am not backing down. I am doing this on a matter of principle. Frankly, my Reform colleagues and I are taking a tremendous economic hit on this. We are doing it on principle because it is right. We understand we will receive a little interest. Meanwhile members not opting out are telling the public their service here, as far as the pension portion is concerned, is worth two and half times as much or more.

When we calculate this we find if we were to make even reasonable assumptions on interest rates and inflation it would require an additional deposit of about $2,500 per month per member in order to provide the kind of pension these people are asking for. Clearly it is a vindictive, very malicious attack on those who want to stand on principle. I object strongly.

The rules of the House should apply equally to everyone. The fault of the government is that it divides people by saying some are in this class, some are in that class and some are in another class. Consequently there is an increasing amount of rancour and bitterness which could be avoided if we were fair with each other.

I am sorry my time has expired. I would like to speak for another half hour given permission. Should I ask for unanimous consent?

Members Of Parliament Retiring Allowances Act May 9th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I have a difficult act to follow.

One thought that occurred to me is that perhaps the hon. member should consult with the minister of Indian affairs, who has an inside track to a bishop. He often quotes letters from the bishop. Maybe the hon. member could get clarification on some of the scriptures.

It is with some remorse that I stand to debate this issue today. That is because I represent the point of view of ordinary Canadians who are fed up with the type of thing that has been happening with the MPs' pension plan for the last number of years. I regret this, because I have a lot of respect for members of the House. I believe that all of us, when we decided to run for election, did so with high motivation and because we wanted to serve our country.

I have never been involved politically before. I was an ordinary Canadian who dutifully voted, but I had never belonged to a political party and I had never participated in an election process. It was all new to me. One of the reasons I joined the Reform Party, and there were many of them, was because of the fact that it was promising integrity in government. It was promising integrity, openness, and accountability.

That appealed to me. When I joined I sent a donation never contemplating I would ever run for this office; that came later. I was attracted to the party because it believes governments should live within their means just like all other businesses and all other Canadians. Reformers said back in 1988 in a brochure that they believe MPs should be representing their constituents,

not to be told here how to vote but to represent and to reflect the wishes and aspirations of those who elected them.

I was also attracted because they indicated a member of Parliament should represent and promote the well-being of the country and the constituents, not his or her own well-being. When I came here and found the pension plan available to members of Parliament-