House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Code Of Conduct May 1st, 1995

Mr. Speaker, it is a delight to be here this morning to address the motion before us. The question of ethics and conduct of members of Parliament and the Senate is a very important issue to Canadians.

I regret that almost immediately after I became a member of Parliament people began attributing to me characteristics I did not possess. Immediately they said because I was now in politics I must be such and such. They made all sorts of allegations and accusations which are not true. I like to think that having become a member of Parliament has not immediately blighted my character. The question of how we deal with perception of Canadians on ethical matters is of great importance.

I applaud the government for at least having the courage to begin the debate. I also have a fear that in this debate as in others we may have more smoke and mirrors, more symbolism than substance. We must have a mechanism which will satisfy the anxieties of Canadians when they feel their politicians are not behaving correctly.

The Order Paper indicated the committee producing this code of conduct is comprised of eight members of the Senate and fourteen members of the House of Commons. The solicitor general indicated there were to be seven members of the Senate. I presume seven is the correct number since that is what he said and the Order Paper must have been changed. Perhaps we could get clarification on that in the future. Whether there are seven or eight is irrelevant to my debate, and so I do not need that answer immediately. We will want to get that clarified.

In my previous profession I was a mathematics teacher in high school for four years and then at a technical institute for 27 years. Very early in my teaching career at high school some 30 years ago I had a debate with my students. The question was why should they respect me.

I still remember the essence of that debate. It helped me then to solidify a principle which I have kept all my life up to this point. I appealed to my students. I said let us start off with the premise that because of my position I am worthy of respect, instead of the one that I am not worthy of respect.

Then I said: "Let us not leave it there. As you get to know me better as I work as your teacher I hope I will be able to earn your respect. You will find I know my subject well, am able to communicate it and that I am fair in my marking". In all these different aspects of a teacher's life there would be a development of a respect which was earned.

With all due respect to the government's intention of having a joint committee to form a code of conduct the bottom line is, has been and will continue to be that those of us elected to public office will have to earn that respect. To a large degree that is an individual effort.

Some people, whether there is a code of conduct and/or a code of ethics which is greatly detailed, will not live up to it. They will lose the respect of the voters in their constituencies and probably throughout the country. Others, whether there is a code of conduct or a code of ethics or not, will generally behave in an honourable way. I like to think that will be the majority of us.

Allegations of dishonesty and others against politicians are the attribution I believe of the characteristics of very few to the greater number. In a way that is most regrettable, but it is an opportunity for us to take some action to correct the misperceptions and incorrect behaviour.

The purpose of the committee is to produce a code of conduct to guide senators and members of the House of Commons in reconciling their official responsibilities with their personal interests, including their dealings with lobbyists. The motion has come out of Bill C-43 to amend the Lobbyists Registration Act. These items are tied together.

I have a substantial question. How did it ever happen that we need to address this question? Most lobbyists do not waste too much time with members of Parliament; they go to the the loop of power. They will go to deputy ministers and cabinet ministers. They will try to influence the Prime Minister. They will probably try to influence anybody who has the power or the authority to make decisions.

We now have need for a code of conduct that will address the question of what kind of activity or what kind of dialogue is morally acceptable between a lobbyist and a person in a position of power.

Our democracy has gone awry. If these matters were working correctly we would have each member of Parliament faithfully and dutifully representing the wishes of his or her constituents. There would be open debate in this place and in committees. There would be freedom from coercion from the party. As a member of Parliament I would have freedom to express in both the debate and in the vote the wishes and aspirations of my constituents.

We have lobbyists who try to influence public policy, which is an aberration of the democratic process. I applaud the process. It is necessary given the way things work around here. It should be unnecessary because we would not even contemplate permitting special interest groups and lobby groups to be the sole determiners of public policy.

We also have the question of procurement, which is probably the larger one. The government is the largest doer of business in the country. To be successful in an enterprise often means being successful in gaining government contracts. In some instances individuals basically get set up for life because they were successful in that regard. To be able to get a government contract we have the scenario of lobbyists affecting the decision maker.

It seems there are two levels of lobbying. I may be wrong. I am relatively new here but I have done some study of it and I have kept my eyes and ears open. There are two levels on a continuum. At one end end of the spectrum we have totally legitimate representation of what a firm or company can do. We have its track record in producing what it contracted to produce and the quality of the product or the service. It is straight information gathering. If procurement in government were handled correctly, they would be part of the conditions of contracts when bids are let, and I believe they are. That information goes on the public record as part of the decision making in letting a contract.

Another kind of lobbying is the one we need to address. It has people, and rightly so, greatly upset. I am referring to the mechanism whereby the subtle pressure or influence is probably not deep enough to warrant a judicial investigation: "You are my friend" or a friend of a friend "and we would like to be given special consideration because of that".

I do not think it happens a great deal, but there are certainly a lot of suspicions about it happening too often when we consider the reaction of Canadians and talk about the issues with them. I cannot help but think of some specific instances in the area for which I am critic. It is very negative that allegations are even made.

We always get the message that the situation has been misunderstood, that we do not have the facts and that the allegations are false. We have not had it in the past and I regret that with the changes in Bill C-43 and with the motion we are not likely to have a mechanism with the authenticity to satisfy the questions Canadians have.

As I said in my speech on Bill C-43, we have two kinds of problems. One is where there are allegations of wrongdoing and the allegations are accurate. We need to have a mechanism to identify the allegations and bring the responsible people to accountability. I do not believe Bill C-43, the present Lobbyists

Registration Act or the motion and the possible outcome of the committee's work will actually answer that question. It should but I do not think it will. I ask the House to pardon my scepticism.

Then we have the other problem which is just as important. It has to do with the basic principles of law. I have had a lot of opportunity to discuss matters of government and related issues with students, especially with respect to the Young Offenders Act. We often get quite distinct overreactions to how harsh the law should be.

I had a discussion with some students not long ago. We came to the conclusion that the law had two functions in which it must be very accurate. It must accurately declare innocent the people who are truly innocent. It is not acceptable in our legal system to declare people guilty who are truly innocent. We must declare them innocent if they are. That is mostly done and is an aspect of the motion that I think is being missed. If an allegation is made that has no basis in fact, we do not have the mechanism to declare in a persuasive way that things are well. That is the missing element.

I have already mentioned the other part: if an allegation is made and there is guilt, the process of law, if it is court or this process here, should accurately declare guilty the guilty people. I am more concerned about allegations toward innocent people.

There have been cries from the government in the last several weeks on the issues we have brought forward. Allegations are being made and the government keeps saying there is nothing wrong and that nothing has gone bad. Can we believe that? We do not have an independent person, an independent ethics counsellor who can be trusted because he is at a reasonable distance from the government.

I would like to say something peripherally. Last weekend I was talking to some constituents back home. Their concerns have to do with much broader issues than even the points I have been making so far. The Solicitor General mentioned one of the concerns in his intervention. He wants to remove from people's perception that public office holders are able to use their offices for their own advantage.

With great concern several people in my constituency raised the issue of the MP pension plan. That is probably the greatest private interest exercised by members of the government. It is an instance where every one of them benefits from his or her position. They are in positions as members of Parliament to vote themselves an outrageously excessive pension plan compared to private industry. It is outrageously excessive compared to what is allowed in the Income Tax Act for private citizens. If that is not conflict of interest I do not know what is, but we have no mechanism to deal with it. That is a little aside from the main thrust of what I am speaking about today.

I have another concern with regard to the committee. It has a fair number of members. It is directed to consult broadly and review the approaches taken with respect to the issues in Canada and in other jurisdictions with comparable systems of government.

I am to be asked by my party to be one of the representatives on the committee. Frankly I have a bit of fear that for some 20 members plus staff this spells travel all over the world. The committee will probably want to go to Australia to see how it is done there. Maybe it will want to go to Singapore to see how it is done there. Maybe it will want to go to Thailand, England, Germany, France, Spain and Italy. It will go on and on; it will have to travel to a number of the states of the United States to investigate fully and consult broadly.

I am prejudging but it has happened so often that when a committee is struck its travel and expenses escalate right out of sight. I do not think Canadian taxpayers have the stomach to foot $20 million or $30 million for the study of something so self-evident that it should not be necessary. Here we are doing it and giving broad ranging rights or commitments to the committee that it have all these powers.

I urge the government at some stage before we are asked to vote to say that it will limit the expenditures of the committee to a stated figure. Why do committees not have a budget they have to live within? That is a missing element.

Other clerical points are stated. I would comment on them but I am running out of time. I want to state one more issue with respect to whom we will hear from. I am afraid the committee will listen primarily to us, that is we shall listen to ourselves. Once again we will have the fox proclaiming he did not eat the chicken. We need to ensure the witnesses at the committee present broad points of view and not just listen to MPs and senators who are primarily affected by the rules and the code to be produced.

We need to listen to Canadians. We need to listen to the taxpayers and wage earners. For example, this past weekend I talked to one young couple who are on UI. They have no reasonable hopes for a job. They are paying the bills. Those are the people we should be listening to on this matter, to see what expectations they have of public office holders.

It is mandatory that we have input from ordinary Canadians on issues such as this. They are continually left out of having influence on these decisions. They are not asked. They are given

no choice. They are told to pay the bills and are coerced to do it through taxation.

I strongly recommend that if the committee does its work and does it well and there could be an independent ethics counsellor to enforce it, then there would be some gains. This committee should do its work very thoroughly. Because of the lack of an independent ethics counsellor, the work of this committee is ever so much more important.

It is pivotal that this committee do good work to come up with a very clear, well defined code of conduct. I would like to see it get into some of the ethical matters as well. It helps to deteriorate the respect of government when members of Parliament and senators break laws which are part of the Criminal Code with increasing frequency. That issue is not being addressed. We need to address it in a very emphatic and strong way.

Lobbyists Registration Act April 28th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I really appreciate this.

The member indicated that there were no amendments to remove the tiers. I want to inform him that in fact one of our amendments at report stage dealt with exactly that issue, and it was turned down. That has happened here.

The member did not adequately explain how the independence of the ethics counsellor is achieved through the present system. When we compare it to the independence of the auditor general, there is quite a difference. Certainly in the perception of the people there is a large problem if the ethics counsellor is investigating an issue that deals with the registrar general. In that instance, the ethics counsellor would be doing an investigation and reporting to the very member he is investigating and then through him to the House. There is a perception of not having adequate independence. I want the hon. member's response to that. This is not adequate.

Lobbyists Registration Act April 28th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. May I ask that you seek unanimous consent to simply continue the debate with the present member? I would appreciate that. I think it would be useful because of his experience and wisdom in this.

Lobbyists Registration Act April 28th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I will be very brief. I will simply say that I appreciate the work the hon. member did with respect to lobbyists during the time he was in opposition. He was a good, hard working member and he said a lot of wise things. I wish that his government had followed some of his advice.

I would like to refer to what I call the Liberals' red ink book of broken promises. At page 94 of the red book, under "The Public Trust", it says: "Nine years of Conservative government have brought our political process into disrepute. A Liberal government will restore public trust and confidence in government." Wonderful. Those are nice words. "We will regulate the activities of lobbyists by appointing an ethics counsellor". They have done it. Great. It continues: "We will reform the pension plan of members of Parliament". For everybody who was here before 1988 it is the same old trough. "We will give more power to individual MPs by providing more free votes and more authority for parliamentary committees". That is not happening. "And we will establish strict guidelines for merit in government

appointments". We have lists and lists of appointments on everything other than merit.

I would like to ask the hon. member to respond to this, because this is very serious. I believe that their commitment is honourable, but they are not following through. I would like the hon. member to explain it. He was involved in the reports in the past that made this recommendation. I am reading from page 95: "In particular, a Liberal government will appoint an independent ethics counsellor". He referred to that in his speech. I would ask him to describe how the present appointment mechanism established in Bill C-43 via the Prime Minister and the submission of reports via the registrar general to the House reflects an independence, which is so necessary.

It continues: "The ethics counsellor will be appointed after consultation". Great. But it says here explicitly: "-will report directly to Parliament". That is not happening. The hon. member needs to explain that.

The Liberal government says that it will implement the unanimous June 1993 report; that is the Holtmann report. I cannot give the House the details, but if I had the time I would list two specifics in the Holtmann report that were not implemented. The removal of the tiers was an explicit Holtmann report recommendation. That is not in this bill. The anti-avoidance schemes were specific in the Holtmann report, but not in here.

I would like the hon. member to respond as to why the government is not doing those things.

Lobbyists Registration Act April 28th, 1995

I read enough to get the gist of it. However, I do remember reading this part. I was afraid that perhaps we would not win the election. If the Liberals had as their platform a greater role for the MPs and limiting lobbyists and so on, they were stealing our platform and maybe the people would believe them and elect them and then we would not win.

Well it so happens that despite that, I did in fact win in the Elk Island constituency. When I was asked to be on this committee it was great. It was something I really believed in and would be able to work on.

The minister this morning made reference to the specific statement that there would be a greater role for MPs. Frankly I have not observed it. I observe that decisions are still made mostly in the offices of upper level government officials in the departments, the top bureaucrats, in consort with deputy ministers and ministers. For ordinary people, including members of Parliament, to break into that loop is difficult. I understand it is almost as difficult for members on the government side as it is for those in opposition.

We all have influence. I am aware that Liberal members have influence in their caucus. However there would be no lobbyists if the people were able to successfully promote their views of what kind of country they would like and what our public policies should be. Their MPs are free. Well, they are not free. Taxpayers pay very handsomely for them, including the MPs' pension plan to which the government so eagerly hangs on. There is no additional or incremental cost to someone who wants to send a message to government if they do it via their member of Parliament.

That lobbyists exist is mute testimony to the fact that many people, being pragmatic, recognize that if they want to have their issues heard, they know that is how they have to do it.

I would like to say a few words about the changes we have produced to the bill. It was a good experience in the committee to propose amendments and to talk about them. Many of them were done before there ever were any clauses.

The final clauses were done quite unofficially without formal amendments. Then we began the process of formal amendments. You must remember, Mr. Speaker, as in the House, the committee is made up of a majority of members from the government side. The member for the Bloc and myself representing the opposition were, shall we say, considerably outnumbered.

I will say to the credit of the government members there that we did have an open discussion. We were heard. For the most part there was a high level of respect. I really appreciate the relationship that developed and the ease with which we were able to discuss things.

Then my hon. colleague from the Bloc, as he mentioned in his speech, proposed a large number of amendments. Those amendments were uniformly declined by the members on the government side. I was very disappointed. The House has already heard the member for the Bloc speak today. He described his amendments and their justification. Certainly there was justification for that. The government lost a great deal because it failed to put those into the bill and therefore they will not become law. That was very frustrating.

Then I brought in a number of amendments. As you know, Madam Speaker, we voted on those several evenings ago. I felt badly about it. It was due to the many amendments we brought forward from our party that all of us had to sit here for about an hour doing all of those votes. In order to maintain my integrity I had to bring those forward. I had to make sure that the government would go on record as saying "yes, we want these" or "no, we do not", just so the lines could be clearly defined.

I am pleased. As far as I know it is a record that two opposition amendments were accepted. I believe it is the first time that opposition amendments at report stage in this Parliament have been accepted. They were very good amendments, not because I brought them but because they were well supported. It shows they were logical and represented the wishes of the people. It was very gratifying to have those amendments passed.

A number of the amendments we made were declined by the government. Unfortunately this is going to be the proof of the pudding. This is going to be the Achilles heel of the government, where given an opportunity to really increase openness and transparency it declined the opportunity.

I do not want to be only negative. I said when I was elected a member of the opposition, not only would I criticize when things were wrong but that I would also try to give accolades when things were good.

Some things in the Lobbyists Registration Act are fairly positive, for instance, the increase in the disclosure requirements. If people now want to know who is lobbying who, they will know more than before Bill C-43 is passed. I presume it will be passed next week because of the Liberal majority.

The Reform Party thinks it is important for members of coalitions to be represented and registered so that if there is an association, its registration indicates all its member organizations.

We believe it is important, and this was our amendment, a very significant one, that when a lobbyist or association or corporation they represent receives direct government funding it also be disclosed.

I was asked about that not long ago by a member of the media. I said it really is stage one. Once Canadians find out that they are funding groups whose business it is to step in front of ordinary citizens in order to try to influence government, that funding will soon cease because of public pressure. Obviously there has not been the political will to stop funding lobby groups at this stage. Now that will be disclosed and people will be able to know exactly how much the government is spending on funding these various organizations.

When people know I am sure they will start sending their politicians a message that says stop funding them. That is our goal. There is no doubt in my mind that a lobbyist group should be funded by the people they purport to represent. If they do, they have full legitimacy.

A group whose first lobbying function is to lobby the government for its own funding so that it can continue to exist and then purport to represent a whole bunch of people is just not authentic. It totally minimizes its effectiveness and is a waste of money, besides being an aberration in the democratic process.

I am very pleased that the bill provides for the electronic filing of returns. One of the things we heard is that more and more government is intruding on our lives. It is making report filing more difficult. Certainly Canadians are very aware of that at this time of the year.

Under the Lobbyists Registration Act lobbyists can register and complete their information electronically so it is less onerous. It was a very fine idea to have the time of registration extended. Most of the time it is not urgent for these registrations be filed immediately, when the activity is taking place.

To ask for a final disclosure does two things. It is now required that every six months they bring their file up to date. What makes this good is knowing that it has to be disclosed is in itself a form of control. I think of it the same as when I do my work as a member of Parliament. I try to keep in the back of my mind the objective that we need to write and behave in such a way that anything ever made public will not bring us into disrepute. If we adopt that attitude, ultimately the people of Canada will be the judges. Then we will have a good process.

I need to criticize a little bit. The minister took the occasion in his speech this morning to deal at length with the question of restoring trust and confidence. He talked a bit about some of the current issues. I asked a question and he made a comment that: "The member for Elk Island cannot wait to have his say". It is true. I was trying to get his attention. He was talking about the current problem and giving the government's point of view.

I was trying to get something from the minister but unfortunately he did not respond. How does Bill C-34 solve the problem? I was not heckling him. I was simply trying to get his attention. The minister ignored that and proceeded with his statement, which is fine. In his speech time he is entitled to finish what he has to say.

The reason he could not answer is because Bill C-34 will not solve the problems that come before the House from time to time, including the current questions before the House. We all know what they are.

Issues that are important here are openness and accountability, showing that things are being done right. We could have a situation where things are not being done right and if people never find out about it, they will continue to be done in the wrong way. If we have an openness, a transparency-that is a word which means we can see through things, we can see right to the back of it-then these kinds of problems and issues could be put to rest reasonably quickly.

I do not believe there is sufficient meat in Bill C-34 to achieve the goal. That is regrettable because it was an opportunity for all members of the House to assure the Canadian people that, in fact, their government is honest. I am not implying it is not. I am talking about the assurance part of it. Even if it is honest and if the people perceive differently, then the battle has not been won. It needs to be correctly communicated in such a way that it has credibility.

Bill C-34 fails to do that for a few reasons. I will only have time to state a few of them. I want to use my time to talk later on about the big issue.

First I would like to point out that the red book promised in the 1993 election that the Holtmann report on lobbyists would be enacted. There are a number of areas where that has not been done. One explicit recommendation of the Holtmann report on lobbying, which was a couple of years ago, was that there should be an elimination of the tiers.

I suppose a lobbyist is a lobbyist is a lobbyist. If the purpose is to either procure a government contract or to influence government policy, then they are lobbyists. From the taxpayers' and voters' point of view, it really does not matter whether the association hires an external lobbyist who goes to government or whether the association or organization sends one of their own. That tier distinction for most groups is irrelevant. In every instance a lobbyist is out to influence a government decision. We felt very strongly that the distinction between the tiers should be removed.

I will admit again that I went through a metamorphosis here. At one stage I thought that very strongly, and then for a while I was thinking there is some justification for having a differentiation and perhaps less onerous reporting requirements. However, with further reflection, thought, and analysis, I came back to the conclusion that indeed there should be open and full disclosure of all of them equally.

Another problem is the definition of lobbyists. It is quite clear for association lobbyists and is included in the act that if they do lobbying for pay they are lobbyists and are required to register. However, the way C-34 is written for tier two lobbyists, the association ones, those who represent an organization from

within are only required to register if the lobbying activity, by some undefined definition, is significant.

We think the word "significant" leaves it wide open. In fact, people could be lobbying for a fair amount of time, but if they do very much other work then this two or three day amount of lobbying could be interpreted as insignificant. But if that lobbying is done by a person who has high government contacts, perhaps just a one-hour or two-hour luncheon meeting could have tremendous impact on a government decision. For that not to be disclosed is again a breach of the confidence that Canadian taxpayers are expecting.

Another issue we thought was very important is that there be a disclosure of political ties. This always comes up: So-and-so talked to so-and-so and got this achieved. Who did he or she know? What was the connection?

I know we also attract a large number of people. Just as the Liberals have a large number of supporters, party members, people who work on campaigns, so do we. Anticipating that not long from now we are going to be on the government side, I welcome the disclosure; I welcome the fact that if some time we are over there, there should be a total disclosure of someone who has worked on our campaigns. What's to hide? Why should we try to deceive the Canadian people on an issue like that? That should have been included in this bill.

We also believe that significant political contributions should be registered. We just pegged $1,000 as an arbitrary amount; that could be changed from time to time. But usually, if someone will put down a cheque for $1,000 they are more than just a casual supporter; they are usually people who are highly influential, or at least more influential in the party.

We can see that following the election it could happen that those same people want to try to influence the government. I would like to recommend very strongly that this should be disclosed. Again, what's to hide?

It has been a while since I have conducted 55-minute classes, so my voice is getting a little raspy. The difference is that when I used to teach at the technical institute my students paid attention and learned something. Now that was an unkind statement.

There is one more flaw to discuss before getting to the next section. Another considerable flaw in this bill is that there is no requirement to disclose the name of the government official being lobbied. We require the name of the lobbyist; we require the name of the groups or associations that are represented. But all that needs to be said is that, for example, in the Pearson airport deal the Department of Transport was being lobbied, and I think it would be very useful for Canadian people who judge matters like this if they could have a clear indication of who in the department was being influenced.

I want to talk a little about the ethics counsellor. There are other issues, but I am going to run out of time.

To me, the ethics counsellor is the pivotal point of this whole bill. I would like to begin by commending the government for bringing in the position of an ethics counsellor. It was long overdue. I suppose we could applaud that and say to the Prime Minister and to the government that this is a step forward. Unfortunately, the position of the ethics counsellor will end up being the weakest point of the bill, and it did not have to be. This is most regrettable.

The only time the ethics counsellor is needed is if there is a suspicion. Normally, if there are good relationships between companies or between associations and government, and there is no allegation of wrongdoing, the ethics counsellor can just sit in his office and go about his usual duties.

I would reflect on what the minister spoke about this morning. He talked about the deal with the minister of heritage. He mentioned it at length this morning. When I was trying to get his attention as to what Bill C-43 would do about it, I was hoping he would say that the ethics counsellor will investigate and put the matter at rest. I was trying to give him an out, and he did not bite at the bait; he ignored it.

That is a demonstration of the flaw in this bill. The minister did not recognize that in this particular case, where he claims over and over again that the minister did nothing wrong, the government did nothing wrong and the Prime Minister did nothing wrong, it is not convincing. It is the fox declaring loudly, "I did not eat the chicken", while the feathers are dangling from his mouth. Even if it is right, it requires independence to have credibility.

When we form the government I will welcome an independent ethics counsellor. I want one. If there are allegations that are untrue, I want an ethics counsellor to be able to investigate and to declare to the Canadian people beyond a shadow of a doubt that there was not any kind of influence or pressure and that he has investigated and has found nothing wrong in order to clear the name.

Under this bill the ethics counsellor is appointed by the Prime Minister, he answers to the Prime Minister, and he reports to this House through the registrar general. Everything is done through the government. Usually the allegations are of wrongdoing between a member of the government or a member of the bureaucracy. Any thinking person can see that if the ethics counsellor is appointed by and answerable to and through the government, any minister or the Prime Minister, he is basically unable to do his job. That is most unfortunate. It is most regrettable. That is the greatest missed opportunity in this bill, and it is the one I emphasize the most.

I would like to talk about both sides of this issue. When there is an allegation of wrongdoing there are really only two possibilities, with perhaps some interpretation along the spectrum in between. Let us consider the current issue that is before us in these dealings we have had during question period and in all of our debates this week. Either there is nothing wrong, as everybody over there keeps saying, or there is something wrong.

First, I would like to deal with a supposition. Here is a hypothesis. Let us suppose that in fact there was something that was not right. I want to have an ethics commissioner who has total freedom to investigate and to declare to the public via this House directly that he has investigated and this and this and this is wrong.

The other hypothesis is that there is no wrongdoing. Under our present system and under the one proposed by this bill, if the ethnics counsellor investigates and then says there is nothing wrong, the people of Canada will say we are not really sure we can trust him. It is not because he has not done his job. The current person who holds that office is a person of high esteem and honour. I have no reason to be suspicious of him. However, the man is hampered in his ability to convince the people simply because he lacks the independence of being able to give an independent report. Even if he has done his very best, he is still seen by the people as possibly having been pressured or organized by the Prime Minister, because he is appointed by him and is answerable to him.

We have had a number of cases in which we have asked for the ethics counsellor to investigate. The answer has been no, I am not going to ask him. We have gone on several occasions to the ethnics counsellor directly: "Were you consulted? Have you investigated?" The answer was "No, I have not been asked".

It is true that right now the counsellor is somewhat inhibited because this act has not yet been proclaimed. When it is, I believe that his role will be somewhat strengthened. He will then be empowered to investigate, so that will strengthen his role compared to what it is right now. There is a plus, and once again I applaud the government for that plus.

The negative end of it is that he is still required to table his reports, both the annual report and the reports as a result of an investigation, through the minister, the registrar general. This is ironic. I just point out a possible future flaw, a trap that will catch us. What happens if the registrar general, who is a member of this House, becomes the object of a suspicion and if the ethics counsellor does an investigation of that and then presents his report to the very minister he is investigating? Who will believe him? It does not matter what he says. He could say that everything is okay and no one will believe him. If he says that there is such and such a problem, of course that would be great. Then he would be believed. But it would have greater authenticity if he could have the freedom to answer both ways.

When I plead for the defeat of this bill based largely on the fact that the ethnics counsellor lacks independence, it is because I am looking forward to the day when I want him to have total freedom to convince the Canadian people that the allegations of wrongdoing are false. That is the motivation. There is nothing that is more important than that.

We need to do everything possible to strengthen the legitimacy of the role of the ethics counsellor. I would like to add that the annual reports also should be given directly to this House.

I think of a perfect analogy. When I go across the country-and I have not done too much of that, I have done most of my work in my Elk Island constituency-I visit other people in Saskatchewan and also in Manitoba. When I talk to them, one government official who has almost universal recognition and respect is the auditor general. The auditor general, because of the way he is appointed and the way he reports, is believed. There is no doubt that the flaw in this bill is that the ethnics counsellor will be hampered in his ability to provide believable reports simply because he lacks that independence.

I would like to conclude my statements, Mr. Speaker, by saying simply that this to me is a broken promise. It is an opportunity missed. It is regrettable because, among other things, the red book stated it explicitly. On page 95 it states the ethics counsellor will report directly to Parliament. Had the government fulfilled its red book promise in this legislation it would have been a good response.

I know I cannot comment on votes. Therefore I will not say I regret my amendment was not passed. However, I really commend the positive parts of this bill but I regret we will not be able to support it because of these tremendously important flaws in it.

Lobbyists Registration Act April 28th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, it is indeed an honour to be able to rise in this esteemed House, the one to which all of us were elected to represent the people of Canada, to address the question of lobbyists.

I will begin by commending my colleague from the Bloc who just spoke. He presented a very good case and I very much appreciate the points which he raised.

I would also like to comment briefly on the process we went through. As most members know, this was the first bill that went through the new process of going to committee after first reading. As I have said previously in this House, I found that experience both frustrating and rewarding.

It was rewarding in the sense that we had a very amiable chairman. I have said that before and he usually grins when I say that, and I give him that compliment again. I also got to know and to like all of the members on the committee. It was a very good, free and easy exchange.

We were assured during that process that we could think out loud. We could bring out ideas which perhaps we did not really espouse but we wanted to raise as questions. What would happen if we did this or what would happen if we did that? Being a neophyte, I thought that was a wonderful way of discussing and debating. I thought that we were going to get a really good bill out of this process and I was very enthused for most of it.

We had excellent witnesses. Again, I would like to go on record as commending them. They did a good job in presenting their cases.

Underlying all if it, I always wondered whether we really needed the lobbyists. As a matter of fact, if I can express my naivety, I came to Ottawa as a new MP in the fall of 1993 thinking that strictly speaking lobbyists are redundant and they should not be here. To a large degree I still think that way.

That reminds me of a story my assistant shared with me about a problem with some ravens that apparently had pretty well taken over the city of Ottawa. The ravens were becoming a real nuisance. They not only messed up cars, they occasionally attacked children and on occasion even, shall we say, bombed some public officials. That is when action had to be taken.

The mayor of this esteemed city put out a call saying that there would be a $5,000 reward for anyone who could get rid of all of the ravens. Lo and behold someone from the country said to the mayor: "I will solve your problem but it will cost you $5,000". The mayor said that very well, it was worth it because when that last official got bombed by one of the ravens that was the end of it.

The young man had a cage which contained a blue raven. He went to where all of the other ravens were, opened the door and let the blue raven out. That blue raven somehow attracted all of the other ravens and they flew together out of town and were never seen again.

The mayor said to the person: "Here is your $5,000, but I have a question for you: Do you have any blue lobbyists?"

That is a question. Should we get rid of all of the lobbyists? Should we get one of them to take the rest of them out of town?

I will admit that I underwent a minor change in my thinking during the work on this committee. I met different people and different groups and particularly, certain professional associations, business and industry associations which came to make presentations before us. In fact, they were quite successful in convincing us of their importance. I will not mention any of them specifically by name.

Certainly, just as what happens in this place deeply affects citizens, it also affects groups of citizens, businesses and different professions. Therefore, for the government to have some kind of an interface with an association of all of the dentists in the country instead of having to deal with each one individually probably has some merit.

Another one that comes to mind is a presentation that we had from an association of the forestry industry. In this particular instance public policy measures of taxation, environment protection and so on impact greatly not only on the industry's ability to do business in this country but also on its ability to compete worldwide, a factor which is ever more present with us.

Consequently, I came to the conclusion after thinking about this that there probably was some justification for these people to be represented by a smaller association which would specialize in making their views known to the government.

I still think though that for the bulk of public policy issues, lobbyists should be unnecessary. As a matter of fact, as a member of Parliament I am frequently asked whether I will meet with this or that group. I have several rules. One rule is that I usually respond by saying that I do not meet with lobbyists. My constituents, the people who elected me, are my lobbyists. They are the ones I am here to represent.

I have a few little subrules as well. If a lobbyist group comes to see me and one of the delegation members comes from my constituency, I do not care what their issue or cause is, they automatically have an in. I will never refuse to talk to any member of the Elk Island constituency for any reason.

I also have a couple of other little subrules. Occasionally there are groups that have done a lot of research and are specialists in their field. If they can increase my understanding from a technical point of view or from the government impact point of view on the wider population not just in my constituency but throughout the whole country and I have an opportunity to learn something, I will not deny that opportunity.

Therefore, I have had the opportunity to deal with a number of lobbyists directly. In most instances I have appreciated this.

We need to talk about this bill because it seems to be a foregone conclusion that the work of the MP is not effective. I hate to stand up and say this. I know that in a way I am impugning all of my colleagues, myself included, and certainly all of the backbenchers on the government side. It is true that our access to the decision making loop really is limited.

I was interested and paid close attention to the minister's speech this morning. I am going to respond to a few things he said. Among other things, he indicated that it was the government's goal to give MPs a greater role. I wrote that down. I remember reading that in the red book during the election campaign. I must confess that I never did read the whole book.

Lobbyists Registration Act April 28th, 1995

How does C-43 fix this?

Seagram April 27th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, during the campaign the Liberals said that they wanted to rebuild trust. We would like them to do it.

The way to do it is to have an independent investigator make an investigation and rule on the matter. Why does the Prime Minister resist having the ethics counsellor apply his skills to resolving the problem?

Seagram April 27th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, yesterday during question period the Prime Minister admitted that he consulted no government officials in regard to the Power Corp. deal.

In an interview the heritage minister indicated that there was no reason to consult. The Prime Minister has just now repeated again that there was no need to consult.

In view of the fact that in these affairs Liberal insiders stand to gain millions and maybe billions of dollars, why not ask the ethics counsellor to put the thing to rest, to have a free and open investigation?

Legal Recognition Of Same Sex Spouses April 26th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to enter into the debate on the motion that the government should take the necessary measures for the legal recognition of same sex spouses.

It is the role of Parliament to give leadership in providing the rules and laws that reflect the needs, wishes and aspirations of Canadians. In a democracy it is important for us to represent the views of the majority. If we did that carefully we would most likely end up with the best proportion of good laws for the benefit of all the people in this magnificent country.

I was elected to represent the will of the people who elected me in Elk Island. One could perhaps argue there is such a thing as the tyranny of the majority. However, in a well educated, well informed society such as ours if there is a really good idea, one that bears recognition, there should be absolutely no difficulty in gaining the majority consent for that.

I think of many different examples. We have rules of taxation. There was a big hue and cry when the GST was introduced and the majority of Canadians objected to it.

The Liberal Party ran on the platform of eliminating the GST because subsequently it found the majority of the people were against this and it was not a good tax. We are still waiting for that to happen.

In the context of this bill I find an overwhelming degree of support for the maintenance and development of the traditional family. I share what probably most MPs share in the receipt of letters and petitions given to us that by far the majority, an overwhelming number, indicate they would prefer not to recognize same sex relationships. They do not want to include homosexuality as part of the fabric of our society.

This could be viewed as the tyranny of the majority but we should look at it as a very clear and strong understanding of what is best. I say this with all due regard to those who think the other way.

With all due regard to my hon. colleague moving the motion today, I understand what he is saying but I want to very clearly communicate that we do not in any way wish him or other people who have the sexual orientation which he has admitted to any ill. We really do not.

We need to ask seriously the question whether this is best.