Five minutes.
House of Commons photoWon his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.
Lobbyists Registration Act April 25th, 1995
Five minutes.
Lobbyists Registration Act April 25th, 1995
Mr. Speaker, may I then ask for unanimous consent to have a few more minutes?
Lobbyists Registration Act April 25th, 1995
moved:
Motion No. 24
That Bill C-43, in Clause 5, be amended by replacing lines 32 and 33, on page 13, with the following:
"the activities described in subsection 5(1)."
Motion No. 26
That Bill C-43, in Clause 5, be amended by replacing lines 5 to 11, on page 14, with the following:
"10.3(1) Every individual who is required to file a return under subsection 5(1) shall comply with the Code."
Motion No. 27
That Bill C-43, in Clause 5, be amended by replacing lines 35 to 41, on page 14, with the following:
"5(1), in respect of any matter referred to in any of subparagraphs 5(1)( a )(i) to (vi); and''.
Motion No. 32
That Bill C-43, in Clause 5, be amended by replacing lines 44 to 48, on page 15 and line 1, on page 16, with the following:
"in respect of any matter referred to in any of subparagraphs 5(1)( a )(i) to (vi), if the Ethics''.
Motion No. 33
That Bill C-43, in Clause 7, be amended by replacing line 29, on page 16, with following:
"section 5, or for any service".
Mr. Speaker, I begin this section of my participation today by commenting briefly on the process we went through. When Bill C-43 was first introduced last June we were relatively new in the House. I did not understand the full impact of what it meant to go from first reading directly into committee. Consequently we had a very good open discussion, I guess because most of the members of the committee were first time members of the House. We actually operated like a group of co-operating individuals for the most part, especially at the beginning of the committee. We tried to come together on a number of issues.
I was really quite disappointed to find that some of the things we tried to do were subsequently defeated or were not accepted as ideas worthy of being put forward.
In this grouping I will talk specifically about some of the motions. It would have been nice if we could have spent a little more time on all of them, but I will not be able to cover them all in 10 minutes. It is important for us as the House to adopt this set of amendments. Obviously I believe that or I would not have brought mine forward. In this instance I am eagerly anticipating that we will come to an agreement to accept the amendments.
I will begin talking about Motion No. 2 because it is a very important one. We need to clearly define who a lobbyist is. This amendment very clearly specifies what a lobbying activity is and how it is defined so that there is no question.
The problem with Bill C-43 and indeed the old Lobbyists Registration Act is that they are not clear as to precisely who is
required to register. We have said a lobbyist is a person who is clearly a lobbyist and there should be no question.
This is the definition:
Every individual who, for payment, pursuant to a contract or other arrangement or as an employee, undertakes or as a part of the duties of employment is required to undertake, on behalf of any person or organization (in this section referred to as the "client"), or on behalf of the individual's employer or the employer's client-
We want to specifically add the activity:
(a) communicate with a public office holder or advise a client how to communicate with a public office holder.
That person would be defined as a lobbyist. This is a critical part of the bill.
If we fail to bring in a clear definition of who has to register, it does not matter what the requirements for disclosure are. The presumed lobbyist can ask whether or not he or she is required to register. If the conclusion is that he or she is not required to register then he or she will not register. The result will be no disclosure at all, which defeats the whole purpose of the bill. That would be a pivotal point in this group.
We also want to include advice on how to lobby. Sometimes in order to avoid disclosure we could have a lobbyist who simply trains someone else. He or she does not make the contacts but does everything else. He or she indicates by the connections with whom to get in contact and shows the tree to follow in terms of making the connections. In other words, basically he or she orchestrates all of the work of the lobbying effort without becoming personally involved. We would include that also in the definition as given here.
In the current definition there is a real loose word. It states: "Anybody who spends a significant of time lobbying". The word significant is really one that is open to interpretation. We could have some people who because of the nature of their jobs spend 50 per cent of their time lobbying. They could actually spend less time than other people who spend 10 per cent of their time lobbying. To leave significant in the definition leaves it open and there is no clarity. This has the added problem for those people who are involved in lobbying to know if they should lobby. Neither will the registrar know by the definition whether or not there is a breach of the law. We should fix that one up.
Turning to Motion No. 7, this amendment is also very important because it provides for disclosure of connections. This is one area where Canadians have taken the greatest offence. After a person has worked particularly in the higher echelons of government, and indeed in the higher echelons of the House as a cabinet minister, retires from the activity and becomes a lobbyist, there is a network which occasionally is very suspicious in the minds of the people. It could happen that what the people are thinking is not accurate. I admit that. However, if we provide for disclosure and openness, at least we can honestly say that we are not trying to hide anything: these are the facts and they stand for themselves.
In this motion we are simply asking that anybody who in their past has had employment with or been elected to office in the Government of Canada, a province or a municipality, because those are important networks as well, be required to disclose it. We are asking that people register by stating that they have held a position with a political party as an employee or have held an office with a political party. Let us not hide it.
Undoubtedly someone will say in debate that it is on the public record anyway. Yes, it is. Anybody who has been a cabinet minister is on the public record. However it should be clear and concise.
When a person looks up the registration of a particular lobbyist it takes little effort for the person to simply delineate it in the registration. People can then see there is nothing being hidden.
We are asking that even those who have been heavily involved in contributing to political parties disclose that. If an individual donated more than $1,000 in aggregate to political parties during the preceding year, then the amount being donated to each party should be disclosed. Again, this is a matter of public record. During an election campaign major contributors are made public. The lists are available to anyone who asks. All we are saying is this should be readily accessible. It is very important for us to consider these different parts.
Another element in this group has to do with the tiers. As we know there are different levels of lobbyists. There are those who are simply professional lobbyists and work in a professional and client relationship. They get paid. There should no longer be a distinction among the different tiers. In other words, anybody who is there to influence government should be able to and should be required to give disclosure. We would like to say that whoever does it, whatever their level, it should be open. It should not be anything that is withheld from the people of the country.
Another element which I think annoys many Canadians and that we can fix in this bill is the disclosure by companies or groups that receive direct government funding. It is really an enigma that we are elected as members of the House of Commons.
During the campaign I certainly emphasized, and members on the government side said the same thing, that we were proud to represent our constituents. In reading the maiden speeches in Hansard by the 200 members here for the first time in this Parliament, almost every one said: ``I am proud to have been elected by the people in my constituency to represent them
here". That is wonderful. That is the way democracy should work.
It annoys Canadians when the very people they send to represent them are not able to do the job, but their tax dollars go to fund lobby groups to influence high government officials to change government policy. Something is backward. They should use the MPs because they are paying a lot of money to run our offices and to have those people in place. Let them do their jobs or reduce the House of Commons to 20 people. They do not need us if we are not going to do our work.
If there are going to be lobbyists, why should the taxpayers be funding the MPs offices, salaries and pensions and at the same time funding the lobbyists? In our system it appears the lobbyists have a greater influence on government policy than do the members of Parliament.
Therefore, we are proposing as stage one that when funding is received from government it is going to be made public. If any lobbyist individually or through representation by an association or corporation receives direct government funding, that should be disclosed. That is step one.
Hopefully step two would be that when this was sufficiently known, the people of Canada would revolt, of course in a friendly manner, at election time. They will elect Reformers who will say it is the responsibility of the MPs and not the lobbyists to represent the constituents. Hopefully with this openness people will at least become aware and will be able to make a rational decision.
I would have a lot to say about some of the other amendments as well since I have been working on this for a year. However, I realize my time is up and I will yield the floor now to other colleagues who will speak on some other matters.
Lobbyists Registration Act April 25th, 1995
moved:
Motion No. 16
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended by adding after line 16, on page 7, the following: f .1) where the employer is funded in whole or in part by a government, the name of the government or government agency, as the case may be, and the amount of funding received by the employer from that government or government agency;''.
Motion No. 17
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended by adding after line 46, on page 7, the following: j .1) the name of every public office holder the employee has attempted to influence or expects to attempt to influence;''.
Motion No. 18
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended by adding after line 7, on page 11, the following: j .1) the name of every public office holder any such employee has attempted to influence or expects to attempt to influence;''.
Lobbyists Registration Act April 25th, 1995
moved:
Motion No. 8
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended by adding after line 44, on page 3, the following: e .1) where the individual is employed by an organization and the organization is funded in whole or in part by a government, the name of the government or government agency, as the case may be, and the amount of funding received by the organization from that government or government agency during the previous three years;''.
Motion No. 9
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended by adding after line 44, on page 3, the following: e .1) where the client is funded in whole or in part by a government, the name of the government or government agency, as the case may be, and the amount of funding received by the client from that government or government agency;''.
Motion No. 11
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended by adding after line 19, on page 4, the following: h .1) the name of every public office holder the individual has attempted to influence or expects to attempt to influence;''.
Motion No. 12
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended by adding after line 27, on page 5, the following:
"(6.1) Where the individual is employed by a corporation or an organization and carries out activities mentioned in subsection (1) in the course of the employment, the employer must a ) ensure that the individual complies with this section, or b ) make the returns and provide the information that the individual is required to make by this section.''
Motion No. 13
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended in the French version, by replacing line 20, on page 5, with the following:
"(7) Le lobbyiste qui s'engage à".
Motion No. 14
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended by deleting lines 36 to 47 on page 5, 1 to 46 on page 6, 1 to 46 on page 7, 1 to 45 on page 8, 1 to 48 on page 9, 1 to 47 on page 10 and 1 to 47 on page 11.
Lobbyists Registration Act April 25th, 1995
All these motions are on the Order Paper. If you were to read the exact motions we are dealing with in this group we could dispense with all of them in one fell swoop.
Lobbyists Registration Act April 25th, 1995
Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. Could you shorten things by just reading the sections. I would like you to read the sections themselves and then we could say we would dispense with them all in one sweep.
Lobbyists Registration Act April 25th, 1995
moved:
Motion No. 4
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended by replacing line 12, on page 3, with following:
"office holder and any other person or advise another how to arrange such a meeting,".
Motion No. 5
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended in the French version, by replacing line 14, on page 3, with the following:
"(2) Le lobbyiste est tenu, dans sa".
Motion No. 6
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended by replacing line 23, on page 3, with following:
"individual is engaged in business or employed;".
Motion No. 7
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended by adding after line 23, on page 3, the following:
"(a.1)
(i) any employment or appointed or elected office the individual has held with the government of Canada or a province or with a municipality;
(ii) any employment or office the individual has held with a political party, political party caucus, a member of Parliament or of the legislative assembly of a province or a minister of the Crown in right of Canada or a province;
(iii) if the individual donated more than one thousand dollars in aggregate to political parties during the preceding year, the amount donated to each party;".
Lobbyists Registration Act April 25th, 1995
moved:
Motion No. 2
That Bill C-43, in Clause 3, be amended by replacing lines 24 to 28, on page 2 with the following:
"5. (1) Every individual who, for payment, pursuant to a contract or other arrangement or as an employee, undertakes or as a part of the duties of employment is required to undertake, on behalf of any person or organization (in this section referred to as the "client"), or on behalf of the individual's employer or the employer's client, to a ) communicate with a public office holder or advise a client how to communicate with a public office holder''.
Lobbyists Registration Act April 25th, 1995
moved:
That Bill C-43, in clause 2, be amended by deleting lines 8 to 20, on page 2.
Mr. Speaker, it is distinct pleasure to address the questions before us today on the Lobbyists Registration Act.
One of the pledges of the Liberal government was to rebuild trust in government which has been eroded to a considerable extent over the last number of years under previous governments. I use the plural extending to more than two.
The amendment is very specific. The government labelled the report on this bill "rebuilding trust". Therefore our party has tried to come up with amendments-this will be true for the one before us now and for the others we are proposing-that work toward that goal.
In a way we are trying to help the government to achieve the goals it stated but for some reason has now become unwilling to follow through on.
We are moving an amendment to increase the openness, the accountability and the disclosure required under the Lobbyists Registration Act so citizens can see more clearly what is happening. In a very general sense hopefully the more they know the more we will move toward a true democracy since it seems we have lost the sense of true representative democracy.
MPs are elected and sent to the House to represent their constituents but sometimes are not allowed to vote according to the wishes of those they represent; the decisions being made in smaller rooms elsewhere and the results being orchestrated from here. Obviously if people want to have their input into how government works they will find out where the decisions are made and then proceed to use that particular approach.
How did lobbyists gain such a large force? The people have discovered that it is a way they can get to the root of where the decisions are made in government. It is not through the members of Parliament. They have essentially lost their representative function.
The way one influences government policy is by getting to the decision makers. The decision makers are the top bureaucrats, the deputy ministers, the ministers and the Prime Minister. Backbench MPs on the government side ultimately feel that pressure. I have spoken to some who have expressed some consternation about the fact that they are not free to express their views in the House because of the element of party discipline.
The amendment we are moving would require more openness and disclosure. Therefore when people become aware of how government is being influenced, hopefully the more they know the more they will dislike it and we will then be able to achieve a shift toward true representative government via members of Parliament.
I found the work in the committee on Bill C-43 for the most part very interesting. It was a good committee. Our chairman was very capable and very personable. Sometimes he tried to push things through too fast. We had a committee that worked together and pulled him back. For the most part things went very smoothly until we came the end. Suddenly there was a dramatic shift on the part of government members. They stopped listening to reason and suddenly it was orchestrated from the back rooms.
When the motion simply says to delete some lines and introduce new ones, it is not really clear to the average person or even to some members exactly what this motion proposes.
Presently the bill exempts from registration requirements any meetings initiated by public office holders. In other words, the Lobbyists Registration Act says if you lobby government, you are supposed to register. That is an acknowledgement that there is a lobby group, organization, a business, a firm or a corporation trying to influence government.
We found out that quite often the government makes an initiative to talk to lobbyists because it wants to find out something about a particular business sector or it has some other reason. It initiates the call.
If it is a straight transfer of information, information gathering and if all of our amendments are accepted, that would not be included in a registration requirement. Where the lobbyist is trying to influence the government, however the first contact is initiated it ought to be disclosed. Bill C-43 as proposed by the government does not include that.
We are saying there should not be an exemption from registration if a department official or the minister or anyone else in government initiates the communications. In other words, if there is communication taking place, the purpose of it is ultimately in order to influence government, however it was implemented.
We need to be careful because if we do not permit this amendment, we will provide a very easy loophole. If we are rebuilding trust, the last thing we want is to provide a number of escape routes from accountability. The present bill has that escape route because it says that if a government official initiates the meeting, then registration is not required. Therefore what happens in that meeting may be greatly directed toward
influencing government. A government official has asked for it but immediately the lobbyist is influencing government.
It would not be correct to provide a means whereby the person doing the lobbying is now exempted from registration just because he did not take the first motion.
I will quote a local columnist: "Any lobbyist who cannot finagle an invitation from a public office holder is not worth his retainer". That is true. If a lobbyist wants to influence government but wants to do it in such a way that is not disclosed all he has to do is, in the words of this columnist, finagle an invitation.
That is very easy to do if one has a good lobbyist network. That is what these guys are about. This is their business. Therefore members can see where the lobbyist would meet casually with the government official and say: "Invite me down, I would like to talk to you about some things". There is a delay of a couple of days. Then he gets an invitation and now he is not required to register.
There is some question as to whether this would inhibit government officials from genuinely seeking information. I need to have the members, when they are considering supporting us in this amendment, to remember that we are also proposing another amendment that really is necessary to understand in order to approve this one. We want to also change the definition of lobbying. Lobbying is not well defined in the present act. We would like to change it so that the element of influencing or attempting to influence government is an integral part of definition of lobbyist.
That way if there is a genuine request simply for information there would be no requirement at all to register in any case. That is not a lobbying function. That would be a very normal routine of talking to some sector of industry for absent association in order to find information.
This new definition, if we say it must include influencing or attempting to influence, would totally look after that. Therefore in supporting the amendment we are proposing the government would do well. It would be fulfilling its own red book promise of increasing transparency, increasing accountability, increasing the openness with which government operates so hopefully the result could be achieved. We want to make sure all aspects of government operations whether procurement or influencing of government policy be done in the open so people know what is happening. Hopefully they can renew their trust in the officials, in the MPs and in the cabinet ministers elected by them.