House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was debate.

Last in Parliament October 2010, as Conservative MP for Prince George—Peace River (B.C.)

Won his last election, in 2008, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Points Of Order March 24th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, my point of order is with regard to Bill C-206 and the fact that it has been dropped to the bottom of the order of precedence.

Mr. Speaker, as you are aware, the status of the bill was challenged by the member for Athabasca, resulting in a committee study by the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs.

The Speaker ruled on the complaint of the member for Athabasca and based his ruling on the recommendation from the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs, which recommended:

That the Speaker require (the Member for Wentworth—Burlington) to demonstrate that Bill C-206 has the current support of at least 100 Members, including at least 10 Members each from a majority of the recognized parties in the House, by filing with the Clerk a list, in accordance with Standing Order 87(6)(a), prior to Bill C-206 being set down for the first hour of debate at second reading. For these purposes only, and without prejudice to any future cases or recommendations, “support” shall mean support that the item be added to the Order of Precedence. If (the Member for Wentworth—Burlington) is unable to demonstrate such support within the specified period of time, the Speaker should order that Bill C-206 be dropped from the Order of Precedence and replaced by the next eligible item under Standing Order 87(6)(b). Any such removal of Bill C-206 would not affect in any way (the Member for Wentworth—Burlington's) use of this procedure for Bill C-206 in the future.

During the discussions at committee, it was suggested that the member for Wentworth—Burlington be apprised of the intentions of the committee before the committee actually finalized its report, in order to allow him time to seek the recommended support for his bill. The reason for this urgency was because the committee intended the deadline to be the first opportunity for the bill to be considered for its first hour of debate. That should have been today.

By arranging to prevent his bill from being considered today, the member for Wentworth—Burlington has gone against the intentions of the committee and the spirit of the Speaker's ruling. His procedural manoeuvre blocks the next eligible bill from making it on the order paper pursuant to Standing Order 87(6)(b).

No other member enjoys the advantage of securing a position on the order of precedence until such time as he or she can obtain 100 signatures. All other members are now required to wait while the member dithers.

The House has been patient enough and it is unfair to all members to delay this any further. In the Chair's ruling of March 21, 2000, the Speaker said:

Failing the filing of the necessary list with the Journals Branch prior to Bill C-206 being set down for the first hour of debate at second reading, the item will be removed from the order of precedence. It will, of course, remain eligible to be returned to the order of precedence through a later filing of such a list or by the normal process of the draw.

The member for Wentworth—Burlington rose after the Speaker's ruling and sought further clarification. He clarified with the Chair that if he could secure 100 signatures by Friday, March 24, 2000, today, his bill could remain on the order paper. It is obvious that the member did not obtain the required support in time.

The member had his chance. He should now proceed as suggested in the Speaker's ruling. He should file through the normal process and stop tying up a position on the order of precedence that would allow other members to take advantage of Standing Order 87(6)(b).

Human Resources Development March 24th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, we have always fully supported the auditor general. It is the Liberal government that only uses his words when it suits its needs.

It does not matter how many points there are in the minister's plan. As long as the very first point is political interference the plan is doomed to failure. With the Shawinigan fountain king staying on as leader, HRDC has no hope of fixing itself.

The minister and her predecessors have been warned for years that HRDC was rife with waste and they chose to do nothing about it.

Why should Canadians believe that the patronage and the political meddling is about to stop?

Human Resources Development March 24th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, every Canadian knows that the minister actually began to address the problem two days after receiving an access to information request to release the audit.

Let us consider the HRD minister's, by now, infamous six point plan that will supposedly clean up her mess. She stumbled, she stammered and she stifled, and then she stalled and stuttered before stonewalling. If she had spent more time addressing the problems and less time with her image consultant, perhaps taxpayers would take her plan seriously.

If the minister was serious about cleaning up her own department, why did she have to get caught before she did something about it?

Human Resources Development March 24th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, the auditor general slammed the human resources department yesterday. He said that he had never seen mismanagement on the scale of this giant fiasco.

However, the internal audit that uncovered the billion dollar bungle was only the latest in a long series of warnings that this and previous HRD ministers have received over the past two decades. The Liberals ignored those warnings because it allowed them to continue using taxpayers' money for partisan political purposes.

If the minister were sincere in wanting to clean up her department, why did she wait until she was caught before implementing a plan?

Conservative Party March 24th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, today's National Post describes Joe Clark's recent nomination meeting:

Joe Clark...played to an embarrassingly small crowd on Wednesday night...in Calgary Centre. About 300, by generous estimates, turned out in a...room that could have held 1,000.

The event got off to a disastrous start when Jim Silye called 30 representatives from community organizations up to the stage. Nobody came forward. While waiting Mr. Silye said “Does anybody know any good jokes while I wait for these people?” He then left the podium, telling the crowd: “Have another drink; I think I will”.

Facing the grim reality of the evening, Mr. Clark stated “We have a lot of work to do. I need your help, I need your prayers—”

Elections are usually run on memberships and money. Seeing as Joe has neither, I can see why he is relying on prayers.

The editorial concluded:

If 300 supporters is all (his) party can muster at a nominating meeting of its leader in a riding that many say Mr. Clark cannot win, it appears Mr. Clark may need all the prayer he can get.

I guess Joe Who has now become Joe Boo Hoo.

Division No. 1217 March 22nd, 2000

Mr. Speaker, we still do not like it and we will still vote no.

Division No. 1216 March 22nd, 2000

Mr. Speaker, I have been instructed that this is getting repetitious. Therefore I would like it to be noted that Reform Party members do not like this motion and will vote no.

Interim Supply March 22nd, 2000

Mr. Speaker, members of the official opposition who are present wish their vote to be recorded as nay.

Division No. 1214 March 22nd, 2000

We are in agreement with that, Mr. Speaker, but everyone else is not and that is unfortunate. Therefore I will state that members of the official opposition present this evening wish to be recorded as voting nay to this motion.

Division No. 1213 March 22nd, 2000

Mr. Speaker, members of the official opposition present wish their vote to be recorded as nay to this motion. I would note that the hon. members for Selkirk—Interlake and Vancouver Island North are now absent from the House.