House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was debate.

Last in Parliament October 2010, as Conservative MP for Prince George—Peace River (B.C.)

Won his last election, in 2008, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

House Of Commons March 16th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, if the hon. member across the way had been listening to my remarks he would know the answer before he made his intervention.

I do not take this lightly at all and I do not think the House does. This is not a normal proceeding. This is something that comes up very seldom, as well it should.

I stand by my words. I believe that different members at different times vote on different things in the House in different ways. However, it is up to each of us to decide what is meant by our vote and defend that to our constituents when called upon to do so.

I reject the fact that all we can do with this particular motion is focus strictly on the motion. If we were to do that, if we were to judge this solely on the basis of the motion in front of us, in my estimation what we would be doing is disavowing everything and every rule that you have ever made, Mr. Speaker, and our feelings about that, whether we support those rulings or not.

I do not want to see a case where every time we turn around someone is bringing forward a motion like this; a different party or a different member. This is serious business. This is not something where every time the Chair rules on a point of privilege or a point of order and we get upset about it because we did not get our own way, that we will bring forward a motion to censure the Speaker. This is much too serious for that.

I think everyone knows that because, to my understanding, the last time this happened was in 1956, a long time ago. That is why in my presentation I said that it was up to each and every one of us to decide what we will base our vote on tonight, to take it very seriously and to very clearly understand in our own minds why we will be voting the way we will and to be prepared to defend that to our colleagues, and, if it is a true free vote, to our colleagues in our own party, to our colleagues in this chamber from all parties and, most importantly, to defend it to our constituents.

House Of Commons March 16th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, I rise today to address this historic debate. It is not a debate that I take joy in addressing. However it is one that I believe is crucial to the future of this very institution. As I have stated many times in this place, one of the main reasons I was motivated to run for office was the need for parliamentary reform.

The motion brought forward by the Bloc today strikes at the very heart of the democratic foundation the House is built upon. In the six years I have been in this place, I have witnessed the rights and power of individual members of parliament systematically eroded. This power grab is especially troubling in this parliament where the government has a mere 38% of the popular vote. In an effort to protect its slim majority and to impose its legislative agenda upon Canadians, the government has put its agenda ahead of democracy.

It is your job, Mr. Speaker, to ensure that this does not happen. You have been entrusted with upholding the traditions and practices of the House of Commons, and I say with all due respect that these traditions have eroded under your watch.

Points of privilege have been raised on numerous occasions by members of the opposition. Few have ever been recognized as such by the Chair. A great number of these grievances have been made regarding the government leaking information to the media that is meant for the House and the government implementing measures in legislation before that legislation is even passed. This mocks and misrepresents the role of parliament.

The defence against this attack on the institution of parliament began in 1989, long before you occupied the chair, Mr. Speaker. On October 10, 1989, over the GST controversy, the hon. member for Windsor West, now the Deputy Prime Minister, was quoted in Speaker Fraser's ruling as saying that it was clearly contempt of parliament to misrepresent the role of this House. Speaker Fraser went on to say:

I want the House to understand very clearly that if your Speaker ever has to consider a situation like this again, the Chair will not be as generous.

On November 6, 1997 the present Speaker, when ruling on the controversy surrounding the government's setting up the Canada Pension Plan Board before the legislation was passed authorizing the government to do so, said:

—the Chair acknowledges that it is a matter of potential importance since it touches the role of members as legislators, a role which should not be trivialized. The dismissive view of the legislative process, repeated often enough, makes a mockery of our parliamentary conventions and practices. I trust that today's decision at this early stage of the 36th Parliament will not be forgotten by the minister and his officials and that the department and agencies will be guided by it.

I personally raised the matter regarding the Canadian Wheat Board on February 3, 1998. Nothing was done.

We had the naming of the head of the Canadian Millennium Scholarship Foundation before there was legislation setting up the foundation. It was raised in a question of privilege by the hon. member for Calgary—Nose Hill, and the Speaker did nothing.

It was not that long ago when the Minister for International Trade on March 30, 1998 sent out a press release entitled “Marchi Meets with Chinese Leaders in Beijing and Announces Canada-China Interparliamentary Group”. At that time there was no Canada-China interparliamentary group. The minister gave the impression to some one billion people in China that the association existed when parliament had not as yet approved it. Again this was raised and the Speaker's ruling on November 6, 1997 was referred to. Nothing was done.

On April 20, 1999 the matter of the government leaking a government response to a report of the Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs was raised in the House. The next day the government House leader apologized for the leak and assured the House that it would not happen again.

The very next day after the apology the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development stood in the House and quoted from an in camera meeting. There is a litany of cases of leaked committee reports that goes unchecked and unchallenged.

The Prime Minister announced the date of this year's budget outside the chamber. As far as I know this has never been done. It has always been announced in the House.

The most recent case is the leaking of Bill C-23. The act to modernize benefits was given to EGALE before being tabled in the House, allowing an interest group time to release a detailed analysis of the bill before the critic of my party could even see the bill. The member raised it and the Speaker, in my opinion, ignored it.

A number of my colleagues from all parties spoke today of their frustration with the way in which the government operates. I think that is what is being expressed today in this motion.

In all of these cases, the Speaker made speeches on the integrity of parliament yet never took action to protect it. Only on two occasions did the Speaker find it necessary to recognize the severity of a point of privilege; one, involving the former member for Charlesbourg regarding the formation of a Quebec militia, and the other was to censure two members of the official opposition who criticized the Speaker in public.

On numerous occasions the Speaker was called on to defend the integrity of the House and, in my opinion, did not do so.

Each member who is present tonight will be called on to make a very personal decision. First, whether to vote strictly on the basis of the motion or whether to vote based on their perceived opinion of whether or not the Speaker has ruled in an impartial and neutral manner during his tenure.

Second, individual members, if they decide the vote is not limited to the actual motion before the House, will be called on to wrestle with their own conscience as to whether they should vote to censure the Speaker, support him or abstain.

Third, members will have to decide for themselves, should they choose to vote in favour of censuring the Speaker, if their dissatisfaction is more with the Speaker or the government's abuse of power and the Speaker's inability to deal with that abuse.

As I said earlier during my interventions on this debate, I urge all members to consider this matter to be of the utmost importance. I am sure they do. I urge all members in all parties to consider this a real free vote of conscience. Each member will have to grapple with their own conscience because this is an issue of paramount importance to this place.

House Of Commons March 16th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, I will be splitting my time with my hon. colleague from Edmonton North.

House Of Commons March 16th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, I would like to direct my hon. colleague the government House leader to this issue.

The Reform Party of Canada as Her Majesty's official opposition feels that this particular issue is one of the most important issues that can ever be brought before this Chamber. We have already heard a number of members refer to the need for the impartiality of the Chair. Debating this issue is of supreme importance. The Speaker of this place is tasked with the job of upholding the rights and privileges of each and every member equally.

In debating this issue among Reform Party members it soon became apparent that the only way to address this was to have a free vote. If there was ever a reason to have a free vote on an issue, this one would be it, rather than taking a caucus position as we often do when we debate other issues, because of the importance that we have placed upon the Speaker's position.

The Speaker is tasked with upholding the rights and privileges of each and every one of us. Each and every one of us should be called upon to grapple with his or her conscience, with his or her projection of whether you, Mr. Speaker, have always acted in an impartial manner over the past number of years. We came to the conclusion that each member would have to make that choice for himself or herself.

I would ask the government House leader if it is his understanding that the Liberal members in this Chamber will be doing likewise.

Government Response To Petitions March 16th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, I will be very brief with my remarks. To reinforce what my hon. colleague from St. Albert has just said, what we are debating, this particular point of order, strikes to the very essence of this Chamber itself.

Nothing could be more serious than when a political party brings a motion of non-confidence in the Speaker. I cannot imagine what could be more serious. Whether I, my colleagues or other colleagues in the House from whatever party agree with that particular motion is irrelevant. How could the House continue to do its business as long as that black cloud hangs over this place? We must deal with it.

For the government to move to bypass, to circumvent Routine Proceedings in the manner in which it has and to crack the whip on its backbenchers to get them to fall in line and to basically turn their backs on their own rights and privileges just to support their party and the government, is despicable, to be quite blunt.

If this were allowed to continue, as it did yesterday and as the government has moved to do today, I suggest that there is room for each and every member in this Chamber to rise on a point of privilege. It is our privileges that are being usurped by the government trying to wipe Routine Proceedings off the orders of the day and move to its agenda.

Curling March 13th, 2000

Mr. Speaker, on behalf of the people of British Columbia I would like to declare that B.C. now stands for “Best Curlers”.

Yesterday skip Greg McAulay of New Westminster completed the trillium of champions by capturing his first Brier championship against the formidable Russ Howard.

British Columbia will be representing Canada at the World Curling Championships in three categories: men's, featuring Greg McAulay's rink of Brent Pierce, Brian Miki, Jody Svestrup and Darin Fenton; women's, featuring Richmond's Kelley Law's rink of Julie Skinner, Georgina Wheatcroft, Diane Nelson and Elaine Dagg-Jackson; and junior men's, featuring Kelowna's Brad Kuhn's team of Kevin Folk, Ryan Kuhn and Hugh Bennett.

I would also like to take this opportunity to thank the people of Saskatoon who organized and supported the Year 2000 Brier, setting a new attendance record.

Curling has long been one of Canada's favourite sports and now British Columbia leads the way. Congratulations and good luck to all at the world championships.

Points Of Order March 3rd, 2000

Mr. Speaker, my point of order arising from question period today deals with some confusion arising from the official opposition's assertion of a $10 million line of credit from the Export Development Corporation that we believe benefited Earth Canada.

I have documents that would back up our assertion and I would like permission to table them today.

Scotia Rainbow March 3rd, 2000

Mr. Speaker, my particular point of order arises from question period today and it could be dealt with just in a few seconds, but it is not the one that was raised by my hon. colleague.

Scotia Rainbow March 3rd, 2000

On a point of order, Mr. Speaker.

Human Resources Development March 3rd, 2000

Mr. Speaker, it is just inconceivable that the minister did not know about this so-called draft report until November.

The department was engaged in an internal strategic debate about when to release these documents. There was a communications plan in place. Senior officials were engaged in these discussions. In January, however, Reform sniffed out the audit.

Why will the minister not just admit that she was waiting as long as possible to tell Canadians about her billion dollar bungle?