House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was debate.

Last in Parliament October 2010, as Conservative MP for Prince George—Peace River (B.C.)

Won his last election, in 2008, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Justice March 19th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, Paul Gervais is a twice convicted pedophile. Instead of being locked up for molesting nine boys this child predator was awarded a conditional sentence and sent home free. It is not bad enough that his victims suffered from his abuse but now they must endure the abuse of a failed justice system.

I met with five of these young men last night. They asked me some tough questions. On their behalf I ask the justice minister why she will not change the law so that rather than setting child molesters like Paul Gervais free, they go directly to jail.

Points Of Order March 18th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, in that same train of thought, I noticed during question period today that the hon. member for Ottawa—Vanier accused one of my colleagues in the Reform Party of being intolerant. Since he is here in the House, I would ask him to respectfully withdraw that statement.

Points Of Order March 18th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I would like to clear the record. My hon. colleague from Fraser Valley did not accuse any hon. member in this House of influence peddling. He said that there was an appearance that it was close to influence peddling.

Petitions March 17th, 1999

Madam Speaker, it is my pleasure to present a petition today containing almost 900 signatures from the residents of Fort Nelson, which is in the northern end of my riding.

These citizens are deeply troubled by the recent ruling of B.C. Justice Duncan Shaw declaring the possession of child pornography to be legal in British Columbia. They express their combined outrage toward both the provincial and federal governments for their failure to protect our children.

They call upon parliament to immediately invoke the notwithstanding clause in order to provide children with the protection they are so obviously entitled to.

This petition represents about 30% of the eligible voters of Fort Nelson. I therefore salute the organizers of this petition for the very fine job they did.

Supply March 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, the hon. member keeps hollering at the top of his lungs “Who do you trust?” We trust the wisdom of the general public, because they know that the justice system is failing.

I very calmly tried to bring forward during this debate today the very important issue of conditional sentencing and the abuse by the courts in the cases of applying it to violent offenders.

One statement the hon. member made which I will agree with, is he said that my comments were grating, that comments of Reformers were grating on him. We are the official opposition. I would hope that our comments are grating on the Liberal government. We are trying our very best on behalf of the Canadian public to hold this bloody government accountable.

Supply March 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, now he is intent on heckling when I try to address his ridiculous comments.

Yes, we do not trust certain legislators. We do not trust this Liberal government. That is obvious.

In this particular case we do not trust the judges to use conditional sentencing properly because they have proven themselves time and time again unworthy of that trust. That is part of the reason our justice system is falling into such serious disrepute with the general public.

If the hon. member would care to get out of this hallowed hall and go to where he is supposed to be, out west trying to rebuild the shattered shreds of his party's support in western Canada, he certainly would find out what the general public is thinking about the justice system.

Supply March 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, the hon. member did not fail us again did he? He can always be counted upon to get up and launch into some outrageous diatribe instead of addressing the questions that we have today.

Supply March 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I wish I could say it is a pleasure for me to rise to address these very serious concerns the Reform Party has brought forward today.

Unfortunately like so many Canadians, probably millions across the land, I am suffering a little from a cold and it is not very pleasurable to try to make a speech. If my voice fails me at some point during the speech members will understand why. Over the weekend I lost my voice completely. Some people would say that would be a good thing, in particular some members across the way who do not like to hear what I have to say from time to time in this place. It is bad news for a politician not to have a voice because it is the one essential tool of the trade, so to speak.

Today in the short time I have I will be addressing the issue of conditional sentencing. I should explain for viewers at home and those in the gallery what conditional sentencing is.

Conditional sentencing should not be confused with parole and conditional release. Conditional sentencing allows judges a tool whereby rather than sending a convicted or confessed criminal to jail or prison, they can divert that individual to conditional sentencing, to serving their time in the community or at home in many cases under certain conditions. Thus the term conditional sentencing. There are certain conditions imposed on that individual.

Conditional sentencing was established under legislation of Bill C-41 in the first session of the 35th parliament. That is the parliament immediately preceding the one that is under way at present. This bill made sweeping changes to Canada's sentencing laws, but in each case neglected to reflect the interests of Canadians. The majority of the debate when Bill C-41 was before the House was focused on classifying murder.

According to the Liberals, killing only one person is not so bad as long as you do not kill more than one, or murder out of hate. If either of those cases were prevalent in a particular conviction, either a multiple murder or a so-called hate crime, then the individual might have to serve their entire lenient sentence.

But I am digressing from my main point today which is conditional sentencing which was also contained in Bill C-41.

As far back as March 1995 the Reform Party has been pleading with this government to change the law to exclude violent crimes, but so far our cries have fallen on deaf ears. It has been four years since we first raised this very serious issue. It is some two and a half years now since this law has been put into force. On September 3, 1996 conditional sentencing actually came into place and began to be utilized by judges across the land.

In 1995 the Reform member for Crowfoot moved several amendments to Bill C-41 in committee which would have disqualified violent offences from conditional sentencing. It would have ensured that the sentences were to deter the offender and others from committing offences and that the sentences were to provide compensation to the victims and/or their families.

The Canadian Police Association and Victims of Violence echoed the concerns expressed by the member for Crowfoot, yet the Liberals did not support any of those measures. I find it ironic in light of that fact that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Justice rose in her place about an hour ago in questions and comments following her speech and said that she or her government would be willing to look at amendments to the newly announced changes to the young offenders legislation. Some of us on this side of the House and indeed all Canadians might be just a bit sceptical of how sincere she was. We might even have some reason to be cynical about it.

Conditional sentencing was meant to cut costs. Although it can be argued that some financial costs have been cut, the human costs of the victims of crime are mounting. The trauma one feels from an unjust sentence is immeasurable. I am sure one feels victimized all over again. The societal costs of conditional sentencing are mounting. Rapists, killers, child and spousal abusers and drug dealers are set free without deterrents or consequence. It is my firm belief that without proper punishment there is no deterrent.

Bill C-41 allows convicted criminals to serve their sentences at home in the community rather than in jail. It is my belief and the belief of many MPs including the justice minister that it was not parliament's intent that conditional sentencing be used in the cases of violent or sexual offences. In January 1998 the justice minister publicly stated that. She said, “There have been some circumstances in which I believe conditional sentences were used when it was not the intention of parliament to have them and those should be appealed”. The minister added that conditional sentencing was never intended to apply to violent or sexual offenders.

I am going to relate to the viewing public a few of the cases where I believe conditional sentencing was applied inappropriately.

In Montreal three men were given 18 month conditional sentences after raping a 16 year old pregnant woman and holding her upside down from a balcony. The judge thought that this was part of their culture.

In Winnipeg a youth previously convicted of theft and seven armed robberies and on temporary leave from a Manitoba youth centre received a one year conditional sentence and three year probation for the drive-by shooting death of a 13 year old.

In Nanaimo a 28 year old man received a one year conditional sentence for shooting his girlfriend with a crossbow.

In Edmonton a 57 year old man who swung a machete at a 21 year old male cutting his face and cutting a third of his ear off got 240 hours of community service and a curfew.

I raised this particularly appalling case during question period just last week. In Ottawa, Paul Gervais confessed to sexually assaulting nine boys, yet he got two years conditional sentence and a curfew. That is absolutely appalling. I think the general public has every reason to be outraged at these types of sentences.

Also in Ottawa, Robert Turcotte strangled his mother to death. He received a two year conditional sentence, 100 hours of community service and a midnight curfew.

Pay close attention to this one. In Vancouver, a person out on conditional sentence for two counts of theft and dangerous driving has been accused of killing an 83 year old woman during a home invasion.

While the justice minister prefers to allow the appeal courts to address the inappropriate use of conditional sentencing, the courts have indicated the opposite. The issue of conditional sentencing continues to become more and more of an ambiguous matter within the courts.

Despite the minister's belief about the intention of conditional sentencing, in August 1997 the B.C. Court of Appeal ruled that violent offenders are entitled to serve time in the community under conditional sentences. The B.C. appeal court ruling stated: “If parliament had intended to exclude certain offences from consideration under section 742.1, it could have done so in clear language”.

It is my contention that Canadian courts are already bogged down. We should not be using the courts to appeal these types of sentences. Indeed the general public is waking up to this more and more and is becoming justifiably outraged at some of these sentences.

Since the minister has not responded to this public outcry or to her own criticisms of the law, I have submitted two private member's motions, Motion No. 383 and Motion No. 577, to rectify the situation. Motion No. 577 is currently on the Order Paper and reads:

That in the opinion of this House, the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights be instructed, in accordance with Standing Order 68(4)(b), to prepare and bring in a bill to prevent the use of conditional sentencing in cases where someone is convicted of a dangerous crime including: murder, manslaughter, armed robbery, kidnapping, drug trafficking, sexual assault, and all other classifications of assault including child and spousal abuse.

If the government would act on a motion similar to that and bring forward amendments to this section of the Criminal Code, it would certainly stand itself well with the general public. It would address a serious inadequacy in our present law.

Supply March 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I listened to my hon. colleague's speech very carefully about impaired driving and the problems it is creating on an ongoing basis.

One of the proactive things I did as an independent member of parliament was to put forward a private member's bill dealing with the use of interlock devices for repeat offenders of impaired driving. Unfortunately I have not been lucky enough to have my name drawn so that we could debate that bill.

Can my hon. colleague talk a bit about the interlock device and whether he sees some merit in having that as part of a complete package that does adequately address the very serious concern of impaired driving in Canada?

Foreign Publishers Advertising Services Act March 12th, 1999

Madam Speaker, following up on that, I noticed that during his intervention the hon. member for Toronto Centre—Rosedale was trying to turn things around by suggesting that the Americans in retaliating in the so-called banana war against the Europeans are somehow putting the WTO at risk. I suggest what is putting the WTO at great risk is countries which do not adhere to rulings of the WTO, countries that go completely contrary to the thrust of a ruling.

We as the sovereign nation of Canada enter into trade agreements and a dispute arises. Then the dispute is taken to the WTO for a ruling, as it was in this particular case. The WTO ruled on it and now we try to do an end run around the ruling.

That is what is happening with the case of bananas in Europe and with the magazine issue here which is before the House again in Bill C-55. I suggest that what is really putting the World Trade Organization at risk is countries that do not adhere to the rulings.

Would the hon. member comment further on that?