Yes.
House of Commons photoWon his last election, in 2008, with 64% of the vote.
The Budget March 2nd, 1999
Yes.
The Budget March 2nd, 1999
Mr. Speaker, I wish I could say it was a great pleasure for me to rise today to address this budget. This budget is a disaster, as every Canadian is learning. I am sure hon. members opposite will be riveted by the speech I am about to deliver. Maybe they will be quiet enough to hear it.
I start this afternoon by focusing on the beginning of the finance minister's rather lengthy budget speech: “A budget always brings its own special vocabulary. We talk in the language of rates and ratios, of percentages and decimals, of accounting methods and measures. What all this obscures is what budgets should be about. It is to make the lives of Canadians better. It is to improve their standard of living”.
What the finance minister is obscuring is that the rates, ratios and numbers do not lie. The numbers are his undoing. His accounting practices are unorthodox and are not even supported by the auditor general. The numbers show clearly that increases in payroll taxes and bracket creep have not been offset by his minuscule tax cut.
In short, this is what budgets should be all about. They should be about being straight with Canadians. They should be about telling them the whole story or, as Paul Harvey says, at least the rest of the story.
Do not take my word for it. Neville Nankivell calls this budget “a clunker, disappointing and miserly in its approach to reducing what are the highest overall taxes of any major economy”.
According to Diane Francis of the National Post : “The latest budget is a big con job designed to hoodwink Canadians into believing that health care costs are why they cannot get the dramatic tax cuts they deserve. The fact is Canadian taxes are excessive due to unbridled public spending on non-health items. Canadians are being taxed to death and this budget is insulting to taxpayers by perpetuating myths”.
The Canadian Federation of Independent Business calls the budget “disappointing and a missed opportunity”.
The government is spending a lot of money advertising this budget, as my colleague just pointed out, but it is not being straight with Canadians. My constituents voted to re-elect me because I call them as I see them. I would like to clarify for Canadians facts and fiction, or the myths and realities of this budget.
The finance minister made choices in his budget and the consequences of those choices need to be explained to Canadian families.
Myth number one is that the Liberals have not increased taxes. In fact, we are to believe we just got a tax cut. Unfortunately even Canadian Airlines is perpetuating this myth.
Reality number one is that Canadian taxpayers will pay $2,020 more in taxes in 1999 than they did in 1993. That is $42 billion more, 42 thousand million dollars more. That is a tax hike of 34%, the highest tax increase in the world. That is the reality.
That is a five year period but even if a comparison with 1999 to last year is made, Canadians will still be paying more in taxes due to mammoth increases in CPP premiums and of course because of bracket creep.
Myth number two is that Canadians' taxes are higher in order to pay for universal health care. Reality number two is the latest OECD health data report reveals that the United States spends 90% more on each citizen on public health care than Canada does. Even with the so-called reinvestment in health care, Canadians are getting $4.3 billion less in health care spending from these Liberals.
When we take health care spending out of the picture Canadian taxes are double the rate of the Americans. The reality is that health care has nothing to do with the exorbitant taxes being charged by this bunch of Liberals across the way.
We have to love myth number three, that excessive taxes do not harm Canadian businesses or the economy. Just ask the industry minister. According to him, high taxes are good for business. Reality number three is Canada's taxes are double that of the U.S. and, surprise, our unemployment rate is nearly double that of the United States. Coincidence? I think not. Payroll taxes and user fees have taxed small businesses, the engine of job creation, out of prosperity into a daily struggle just to survive.
One small example of this government's lame brain policies is the recent change to T-4 slips. It used to fit four forms on a page which could be sent out in a standard letter sized envelope. The geniuses at Revenue Canada decided to change that format. Now only three forms fit to a page and due to their new and improved size, they require larger envelopes. Members are probably saying big deal, so they need new envelopes. The postage for these new envelopes is 90 cents instead of the 46 cents it cost for the old form. That is just one small example of how this government nickels and dimes small business people.
Myth number four is that the finance minister says his budget will give substantial tax relief to low income Canadians, in fact it will more than cover bracket creep for all Canadians. Reality number four is the minuscule tax cut given to low income Canadians is only half the amount of money they would receive if the finance minister would index personal income taxes. In 1980 a person making $10,505 paid no income tax. Now that same person pays taxes on only $6,496. Britain does not start taxing until $9,000 and the U.S. not until $9,500. No wonder our best and brightest are fleeing the country. Is there a pattern developing with this?
Myth number five is that the Liberals have been prudent—they love that word—and have balanced the budget by cutting costs and responsible priorizing. Reality number five is the single largest expenditure in this budget is interest on the national debt, which has grown by over $130 billion since 1993. The Liberals reduced 70% of the deficit by raising taxes while only cutting costs by 2%. The finance minister also got a break from lower international interest rates. The reality is this budget was balanced by charging Canadians more taxes and giving them less in return. That is neither prudent nor responsible. It is shameful.
Myth number six is that Canadians are better off today than they were before the Liberals took over in 1993. Reality number six is Canadians are worse off today than they were in 1993. I take no joy in saying that. There is no victory for the official opposition in that statement. This government has failed Canadians. It uses smoke and mirrors to manipulate the truth so Canadians will feel better about themselves and blindly spend more money so government revenues will climb even higher.
The numbers the finance minister says obscure what is important about a budget are all that is important about a budget. I will list them so members can see for themselves why the finance minister wants to avoid them. Canadians are paying $900 million more in income tax through bracket creep. Canadians are paying $1.14 billion more in CPP premiums just to receive less in benefits when they retire; in simpler terms, paying more, getting less. Canadians are paying $42 billion more in taxes in 1999 than they were in 1993.
The national debt has risen by $130 billion since 1993. Balanced budgets are the result of excessive tax hikes and onerous cost recovery schemes. Canadians are receiving $4.3 billion less in federal health care in 1999 than in 1993; paying more, getting less.
This budget was supposed to make the lives of Canadians better. It was supposed to increase their standard of living. These are the finance minister's own words so he must admit that he has failed, for Canadians are being forced to pay more and get less. We pay more taxes and get less health care. This is obviously reversed.
I quote once again Diane Francis who hits the nail right on the head, despite the cries of protest from the other side, when she says: “Ottawa should be forced to work backward. Taxpayers should demand back the billions Ottawa has over collected since 1993 in the form of pro rata tax cuts, to repay the unfair deindexing in an era of non inflation. After all, working backward while paying for essentials is exactly how Canadian households and business must conduct their financial affairs. Canadians struggle to pay escalating taxes, rents, food and other expenses. Why hasn't Ottawa ever suffered? Because it does not have to. That's why this budget is a national insult”.
Justice March 1st, 1999
Mr. Speaker, that legalistic mumbo-jumbo might cut it with Liberal backbenchers, but the facts are that it will not cut it with parents in British Columbia.
Glen Kelly knew he was guilty. He knew he did wrong. He should have been punished for his perversion. Yet in British Columbia judges cannot even accept a guilty plea for this disgusting crime.
Why should police continue to investigate and crown prosecutors prosecute if a guilty verdict will not be allowed by judges in B.C.?
Justice March 1st, 1999
Mr. Speaker, according to the justice minister child porn is not a problem in British Columbia. She says “police are investigating, charges are being laid and prosecutions are taking place as they always have”. Wrong.
Just last week a judge in Vernon, B.C. refused to accept a guilty plea from a man charged with possession of child porn because she said the charges were unconstitutional pending the April court appeal.
Why did the justice minister tell British Columbians that everything is okay when in fact it is not?
National Revenue February 16th, 1999
Mr. Speaker, it is now the middle of February, less than two weeks away from the deadline for employers to file T-4s with Revenue Canada.
Due to a strike at a warehouse in Vancouver, T-4s, the northern residents deduction and other tax forms are unavailable to British Columbia businesses.
My question is for the revenue minister. Last year a filing extension was given to the victims of the ice storm. Will he extend the same courtesy to western Canadians who have been adversely affected through no fault of their own by this work stoppage?
Taxation February 12th, 1999
Mr. Speaker, the truth is that this government decided long ago that health care was not its number one priority. Total government taxes are at an all time high and, of course, it continues to steamroll $1,800 more in income tax out of each and every one of us. Despite this record breaking tax collection, it has gutted hospital spending by $1,150 per person.
With taxes at a record high and health care funding at a record low, why does the government continue its pay more, get less policy?
Taxation February 12th, 1999
Mr. Speaker, if the government's intention was to cut taxes, it missed its target. The government's tax policy is like Zeller's in reverse: pay more, get less. Pay more taxes, get less health care and other services.
This year the Liberals are squeezing $1,800 more in taxes from each taxpayer than they did five years ago. But during the same period they cut social program spending by $1,150 per person. When tax revenue is at an all time high, why is health care funding at an all time low?
Taxation February 12th, 1999
Mr. Speaker, this government is now collecting $1,800 more from every Canadian taxpayer than when it came to power in 1993. That is just the increase in personal income tax alone. When we pile on the Prime Minister's much loved GST and PST, and payroll taxes like CPP and EI, the tax load is simply staggering. Yet over this same five year period the government has contributed $1,150 less per taxpayer for health care. Why?
Supply February 11th, 1999
Mr. Speaker, I cannot understand how the hon. member across the way can stand in her place and talk about this government, her government, governing by frugality. If it were not so serious, it would be laughable.
Her government took power back in 1993. The present Liberal administration has had close to one and a half mandates and it has yet to hit its budgeted target for spending. And she has the audacity to stand in her place and talk about governing with frugality.
The facts are that last year in the budget the finance minister estimated the spending to be about $104.5 billion. He is over that by an estimated $3 billion already. And he is talking about another $2.5 billion for health care that he is going to retroactively put back into last year's budget which will put him somewhere around $6 billion or $7 billion over budget. How is that governing with frugality?
Criminal Code February 10th, 1999
Mr. Speaker, this is very succinct. Not all murderers deserve the death penalty, but in the most heinous cases the punishment must match the crime.
(Motions deemed adopted, bill read the first time and printed)