House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was conservatives.

Last in Parliament April 2025, as NDP MP for New Westminster—Burnaby (B.C.)

Lost his last election, in 2025, with 32% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Privilege March 21st, 2019

Madam Speaker, I rise on a question of privilege. We have now been sitting for over 36 hours, and I want to start by paying tribute to the table, the pages, the support workers and the security guards, who have been working just as hard as we have, inside and outside the House, providing support for the House of Commons and for our democracy.

I rise this evening on a question of privilege concerning what happened during the vote on Motion No. 126 of the opposed votes in the supplementary estimates.

As all my colleagues will remember, the Chair began reading the question concerning Motion No. 126 and then many Liberal members entered the chamber and took their seats. The Chair then stopped reading the question and recognized the member for Winnipeg North on a point of order.

During the long discussion that ensued, the Speaker explained that members must be in the House when he or she begins reading the question in order for their vote to count. After this explanation, some members acknowledged that they had arrived late and withdrew their vote, including the Minister of Official Languages , the Minister of National Defence and the member for Avignon—La Mitis—Matane—Matapédia. There is no point in naming them all.

However, many other members voted even though we all saw that they arrived late. The integrity of the vote on Motion No. 126 is in doubt not just because of the conventions that govern the House, but also because of precedents and rules.

This issue has come up before, Madam Speaker. On May 11, 2016, you made the following ruling on the same issue:

I thank hon. members for their interventions on this. The rule is that members have to be in their seats, and by the way, stay in their seats until they vote, when the Speaker starts reading the motion. The important thing is that members hear what they are voting on, the whole thing. Therefore, members have to be in the chamber when the Speaker starts reading the motion.

Today, the Assistant Deputy Speaker had this to say on the matter:

“I am about to answer and make a ruling. The question was to clarify who has the right to vote and who had the right to vote. When I began the question the first time, members had to be in the chamber, not necessarily at their seats but in the chamber. I will leave it to the individual members and their honour to identify themselves.”

After the Speaker began reading the question, several witnesses indicated that dozens of members may not have had the right to vote based on the criteria mentioned by the Speaker. Some members abstained from voting because of those instructions, but others voted anyway.

In his remarks as to why he was withdrawing his vote, the member for Avignon—La Mitis—Matane—Matapédia admitted that he and several other members had entered the House after the reading of the motion had already begun. He said, “If you say that you did not repeat the question, then I will be happy to withdraw my vote because I was not here the first time you asked.”

What is more, we asked the Clerk what the final count was for the vote on Motion No. 126, and he told members of the NDP, via our lobby general, that there was too much confusion to give the final count but that the government had won the vote.

On its own, the actions of the dozens of members who made the conscious decision to vote after missing the start of the question is clear contempt of the House and its rules. The Speaker rightly said that it was a question of honour, and by choosing to do the wrong thing, those members have not distinguished themselves, and they have not distinguished the House.

It is troubling that the House has been left in doubt about the integrity of the vote on Motion No. 126. First, the validity of the votes of several Liberal members was called into question by witnesses in the House. Second, we had to resume voting without knowing the final count for the vote on Motion No. 126. Third, it was impossible for us to know whether the vote on Motion No. 126 was valid.

Votes that have been subject to the errors of members have been revised after the fact. Madam Speaker, you yourself did that during the most recently completed sitting of the House, on March 19, when, in response to the chief opposition whip, who had several members vote in error, you said:

I thank the hon. member for raising what is an important point. In fact, the results were adjusted accordingly, and the motion was defeated.

I submit that the very same thing may happen for the vote being questioned today.

What happened with the vote on Motion No. 126 could create a serious precedent in terms of allowing the reading of the question to be interrupted and restarted as well as letting members come into the House and vote even though they were not here when the Speaker started reading the question. If members refuse to follow clear instructions from the Chair and to continue the work of the House without knowing the result of a vote, they are jeopardizing the integrity of our votes and our work and breaching the privilege of all parliamentarians.

We have all been here for a long time, and in order for us to continue our deliberations in an orderly fashion, I think you should find a prima facie breach of the privilege of all members of the House and refer these matters to the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs.

All the evidence is available. The cameras caught it all on tape. It would be very easy to check who entered the House on time and who was not present when the questions were read out. It would not be the first time that such a procedure is used. On June 12, 2014, former Deputy Speaker of the House of Commons Joe Comartin checked the tape so he could rule on whether the House had adopted a motion. I will quote what he said before suspending the House.

He said the following:

I am going to suspend the House for a few minutes to look at the tape. The government House leader has raised a valid point. My observations are the same as his, and I think it is a valid point that he has raised.

The House will suspend.

Video evidence definitely helped the former deputy speaker make an informed decision, and I am sure that in the case before us today, the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs would benefit from the video evidence available and could attest to the validity and integrity of the vote on Motion No. 126.

I am prepared to move the appropriate motion.

Interim Estimates March 21st, 2019

Mr. Speaker, this is a pretty serious situation. In all the years that I have been in the House, we have always had integrity as the guiding element when it comes to votes.

I cannot recall a situation where we have had members who were clearly contradicting your very clear direction that they must be in the House to hear the question the first time. We have had members very clearly identified by a number of members of the opposition who were not in the House to hear the question the first time.

I suggest that in that situation, we need to have an evaluation of who actually was entitled to vote according to the very clear guidelines that you have always given us. You gave us good and solid guidelines, as we have in precedence here. We proceeded to the vote. A number of members who came late, fortunately, stayed in their seats, on both sides of the House. A number did not.

We need to clarify, through the video that is provided to us. All of these cameras are running throughout the period of our being in the House. Yes, there is one that is broadcast on national television, but all of these cameras are constantly working.

Through you, Mr. Speaker, we can evaluate who came late. Even if they have not functioned on the honour system by standing up and saying they were not entitled to vote, it is up to the Speaker to determine their eligibility in that case. I would ask you to do so.

Interim Estimates March 21st, 2019

Mr. Speaker, we are governed by two broad principles that you have enforced throughout this Parliament.

First, each member of Parliament has the responsibility to be in the House to hear the questions before he or she can vote. That precedent has existed throughout the term of this Parliament.

Second, once that question begins, effectively the Speaker continues. As you will recall, we saw that in the tie vote on Bill C-10, where there was an attempt to obstruct the vote by certain members of the government, but the Speaker proceeded to what ultimately was a tie vote, which you, as Speaker, broke.

Those are the two principles that govern this vote and this situation.

I have been in the House for 15 years. I have never had a situation, which appears to have happened this time, where members of Parliament, who are obviously late for the vote, who have obviously not heard the entire question, are not being honest and forthright in saying, “I should not be voting on this question.”

That is why it is incumbent upon you, Mr. Speaker, to suspend the vote so we can determine who has the right to vote on this important vote, Motion No. 126, and we can ensure the integrity of this Parliament and parliamentary proceedings are maintained.

Privilege March 21st, 2019

Mr. Speaker, I am citing precedents from previous Speakers who have raised this issue. I will not take a lot of time, since we have important votes to get back to, but time is of the essence in this case. With every vote that takes place, if it is true that these members have been intimidated in some way from voting, the severity of the issue is increased.

First, Speaker Fraser, citing the then member for Glengarry—Prescott—Russell, who raised an issue of privilege on behalf of the then member for Beauport—Montmorency—Orléans, stated:

If we consider the words that were reported we clearly have a prima facie case that affects the dignity of this House and our colleague, because our colleague is an officer of this House. As the hon. member for Glengarry—Prescott—Russell said earlier, like the Speaker he is an officer of this House and an attack against the integrity of a person in that position is an attack against this House.

Second, Mr. Mackay, who was the member of Parliament for Pictou—Antigonish—Guysborough, raised and was allowed to bring forward a motion of privilege, as the member for Calgary Nose Hill has stated she is prepared to do. Citing an incident that happened in March 1993, Speaker Parent ruled on March 9, 1998:

That certain statements attributed to Members of the House of Commons, appearing on page 7 of the March 8, 1998, Ottawa Sun, which may bring into question the integrity of the House of Commons and its servant the Speaker, be referred immediately to the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs.

Finally, the Minister of Public Safety will remember that back on March 24, 2014, he raised a question of privilege under Speaker Scheer. The House took action following that, but at the time, the now Minister of Public Safety rose on a question of privilege, stating that Russia had imposed sanctions against 13 Canadians, including several members of Parliament.

The precedents are very clear that members of this House can raise questions of privilege on behalf of other members of this House. The issue raised by the member for Calgary Nose Hill is extremely serious. The fact that we are voting now, I believe, means that a prima facie case certainly exists. It is up to you to decide, but she has indicated she is prepared to move the appropriate motion. I believe you should be seriously considering this, and in a timely fashion of course, because we are voting now and those privileges are being obstructed now.

Privilege March 21st, 2019

It is a real testament to their professionalism that they are able to do that. We will see how much longer they have to do it.

Thank you for the opportunity to add to the question of privilege that was raised by the member for Calgary Nose Hill earlier.

I will not reiterate the concerns that have been raised by the article that was cited. Rather, I want to raise precedent, because it was just a little while ago that the question of privilege was raised, and it did not take me long to find some precedents that apply in this case.

I will start off with Speaker Bosley in 1986, who noted:

If an Hon. Member is impeded or obstructed in the performance of his or her parliamentary duties through threats, intimidation, bribery attempts or other improper behaviour, such a case would fall within the limits of parliamentary privilege. Should an Hon. Member be able to say that something has happened which prevented him or her from performing functions, that he or she has been threatened, intimidated, or in any way unduly influenced, there would be a case for the Chair to consider.

As you know, prima facie means that at first glance there has been a case of instruction or intimidation of a member of Parliament. The member for Calgary Nose Hill cited very clear evidence that has come out in the public domain in that regard, with respect to both the member for Markham—Stouffville and the member for Vancouver Granville. She raised this on behalf of those members.

I want to cite three cases where members in this House have raised issues of parliamentary privilege and raised a question of privilege on behalf of other members. Therefore, the member for Calgary Nose Hill has the ability and the right to do so.

Privilege March 21st, 2019

Mr. Speaker, many of us who have been in this House for more than 24 hours, and I count myself among them, have difficulty remembering our own names. It is therefore extraordinary to us that those at the table are able to go through 338 members of Parliament with such incredible effectiveness over a 24-hour period.

Privilege March 21st, 2019

Yes, Mr. Speaker, it is on the same question.

These are very serious allegations that have been raised in the House. This is an extraordinarily important matter. The right of a member to vote on behalf of their constituents shall never be impeded in any way.

I reserve the right to come back in a very brief time period to add more comments on this matter. Reacting immediately to what the member for Calgary Nose Hill has just said, I cannot find a precedent for this kind of potential intimidation in the history of our Parliament. These are very serious allegations and should be taken seriously. I intend to come back as quickly as possible to add further comments.

Supplementary Estimates (B), 2018-19 March 20th, 2019

Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. The practice in the House is very clear that the mover or another minister acting in the name of the mover, and the seconder, need to be in the House of Commons. The Minister of Public Safety is not in the House right now.

Supplementary Estimates (B), 2018-19 March 20th, 2019

Madam Speaker, we talked about the food that government members had earlier. We also talked about posters. I would now like to remind the House that our rules require members to wear appropriate attire in the House of Commons out of respect for our national Parliament. It is not appropriate for government members to come here dressed in t-shirts and bodysuits.

Please ask members to respect the dignity of our House of Commons.

Supplementary Estimates (B), 2018-19 March 20th, 2019

Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order.

We understand that members will be voting all night, but we all have to maintain respect for Parliament. A few moments ago, some members of the government were eating. Also, putting up posters or props in the chamber is simply now allowed. The government should remove them, as the rules of the House are very clear on this.

It is going to be a long night. We all have to respect the rules of the House and respect this chamber.